User:Contribution/Successive superparticular complementary pair: Difference between revisions
Contribution (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
Contribution (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
||
| (15 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
== Context == | |||
Read this first: [[Equal-step_tuning#Alpha-beta-gamma_family_of_equal_divisions]] | |||
== The Alpha-Beta-Gamma family == | |||
{| class="wikitable" | {| class="wikitable" | ||
|+ | |+ | ||
|- | |- | ||
! colspan=" | ! colspan="3" | Tuning !! colspan="2" | Intervals !! colspan="2" | Mappings | ||
|- | |- | ||
! Name | |||
! Equal division | |||
! Steps per octave | |||
! Equave | ! Equave | ||
! | ! SSC pair | ||
! | ! Steps (Equave, SSC pair) | ||
! Errors (cent) | |||
! Errors | |||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Alpha 3/1]] | |||
| [[3edt|3ed3/1]] | |||
| 1.89278926071437 | |||
| rowspan="3" | 3/1 | | rowspan="3" | 3/1 | ||
| rowspan="3" | 2/1, 3/2 | | rowspan="3" | 2/1, 3/2 | ||
| 3\3<3/1>, 2\3<3/1>, 1\3<3/1> | | 3\3<3/1>, 2\3<3/1>, 1\3<3/1> | ||
| 0, 67.970, -67.970 | | 0, 67.970, -67.970 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Beta 3/1]] | |||
| [[5edt|5ed3/1]] | | [[5edt|5ed3/1]] | ||
| | | 3.15464876785729 | ||
| 5\5<3/1>, 3\5<3/1>, 2\5<3/1> | | 5\5<3/1>, 3\5<3/1>, 2\5<3/1> | ||
| 0, -58.827, 58.827 | | 0, -58.827, 58.827 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Gamma 3/1]] | |||
| [[8edt|8ed3/1]] | | [[8edt|8ed3/1]] | ||
| | | 5.04743802857166 | ||
| 8\8<3/1>, 5\8<3/1>, 3\8<3/1> | | 8\8<3/1>, 5\8<3/1>, 3\8<3/1> | ||
| 0, -11.278, 11.278 | | 0, -11.278, 11.278 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Alpha 2/1]] | |||
| [[5edo|5ed2/1]] | |||
| 5 | |||
| rowspan="3" | 2/1 | | rowspan="3" | 2/1 | ||
| rowspan="3" | 3/2, 4/3 | | rowspan="3" | 3/2, 4/3 | ||
| 5\5<2/1>, 3\5<2/1>, 2\5<2/1> | | 5\5<2/1>, 3\5<2/1>, 2\5<2/1> | ||
| 0, 18.045, -18.045 | | 0, 18.045, -18.045 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Beta 2/1]] | |||
| [[7edo|7ed2/1]] | | [[7edo|7ed2/1]] | ||
| | | 7 | ||
| 7\7<2/1>, 4\7<2/1>, 3\7<2/1> | | 7\7<2/1>, 4\7<2/1>, 3\7<2/1> | ||
| 0, -16.241, 16.241 | | 0, -16.241, 16.241 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Gamma 2/1]] | |||
| [[12edo|12ed2/1]] | | [[12edo|12ed2/1]] | ||
| | | 12 | ||
| 12\12<2/1>, 7\12<2/1>, 5\12<2/1> | | 12\12<2/1>, 7\12<2/1>, 5\12<2/1> | ||
| 0, -1.955, 1.955 | | 0, -1.955, 1.955 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Alpha 5/3]] | |||
| [[7ed5/3]] | |||
| 9.49840814199707 | |||
| rowspan="3" | 5/3 | | rowspan="3" | 5/3 | ||
| rowspan="3" | 4/3, 5/4 | | rowspan="3" | 4/3, 5/4 | ||
| 7\7<5/3>, 4\7<5/3>, 3\7<5/3> | | 7\7<5/3>, 4\7<5/3>, 3\7<5/3> | ||
| 0, 7.303, -7.303 | | 0, 7.303, -7.303 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Beta 5/3]] | |||
| [[9ed5/3]] | | [[9ed5/3]] | ||
| | | 12.2122390397105 | ||
| 9\9<5/3>, 5\9<5/3>, 4\9<5/3> | | 9\9<5/3>, 5\9<5/3>, 4\9<5/3> | ||
| 0, -6.735, 6.735 | | 0, -6.735, 6.735 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Gamma 5/3]] | |||
| [[16ed5/3]] | | [[16ed5/3]] | ||
| | | 21.7106471817076 | ||
| 16\16<5/3>, 9\16<5/3>, 7\16<5/3> | | 16\16<5/3>, 9\16<5/3>, 7\16<5/3> | ||
| 0, -0.593, 0.593 | | 0, -0.593, 0.593 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Carlos Alpha|Alpha 3/2]] | |||
| [[9edf|9ed3/2]] | |||
| 15.3856016221631 | |||
| rowspan="3" | 3/2 | | rowspan="3" | 3/2 | ||
| rowspan="3" | 5/4, 6/5 | | rowspan="3" | 5/4, 6/5 | ||
| 9\9<3/2>, 5\9<3/2>, 4\9<3/2> | | 9\9<3/2>, 5\9<3/2>, 4\9<3/2> | ||
| 0, 3.661, -3.661 | | 0, 3.661, -3.661 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Carlos Beta|Beta 3/2]] | |||
| [[11edf|11ed3/2]] | | [[11edf|11ed3/2]] | ||
| | | 18.8046242048660 | ||
| 11\11<3/2>, 6\11<3/2>, 5\11<3/2> | | 11\11<3/2>, 6\11<3/2>, 5\11<3/2> | ||
| 0, -3.429, 3.429 | | 0, -3.429, 3.429 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Carlos Gamma|Gamma 3/2]] | |||
| [[20edf|20ed3/2]] | | [[20edf|20ed3/2]] | ||
| | | 34.1902258270291 | ||
| 20\20<3/2>, 11\20<3/2>, 9\20<3/2> | | 20\20<3/2>, 11\20<3/2>, 9\20<3/2> | ||
| 0, -0.238, 0.238 | | 0, -0.238, 0.238 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Alpha 7/5]] | |||
| [[11ed7/5]] | |||
| 22.6604698881676 | |||
| rowspan="3" | 7/5 | | rowspan="3" | 7/5 | ||
| rowspan="3" | 6/5, 7/6 | | rowspan="3" | 6/5, 7/6 | ||
| 11\11<7/5>, 6\11<7/5>, 5\11<7/5> | | 11\11<7/5>, 6\11<7/5>, 5\11<7/5> | ||
| 0, 2.093, -2.093 | | 0, 2.093, -2.093 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Beta 7/5]] | |||
| [[13ed7/5]] | | [[13ed7/5]] | ||
| | | 26.7805553223799 | ||
| 13\13<7/5>, 7\13<7/5>, 6\13<7/5> | | 13\13<7/5>, 7\13<7/5>, 6\13<7/5> | ||
| 0, -1.981, 1.981 | | 0, -1.981, 1.981 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Gamma 7/5]] | |||
| [[24ed7/5]] | | [[24ed7/5]] | ||
| | | 49.4410252105475 | ||
| 24\24<7/5>, 13\24<7/5>, 11\24<7/5> | | 24\24<7/5>, 13\24<7/5>, 11\24<7/5> | ||
| 0, -0.114, 0.114 | | 0, -0.114, 0.114 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Alpha 4/3]] | |||
| [[13ed4/3]] | |||
| 31.3224709154917 | |||
| rowspan="3" | 4/3 | | rowspan="3" | 4/3 | ||
| rowspan="3" | 7/6, 8/7 | | rowspan="3" | 7/6, 8/7 | ||
| 13\13<4/3>, 7\13<4/3>, 6\13<4/3> | | 13\13<4/3>, 7\13<4/3>, 6\13<4/3> | ||
| 0, 1.307, -1.307 | | 0, 1.307, -1.307 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Beta 4/3]] | |||
| [[15ed4/3]] | | [[15ed4/3]] | ||
| | | 36.1413125947981 | ||
| 15\15<4/3>, 8\15<4/3>, 7\15<4/3> | | 15\15<4/3>, 8\15<4/3>, 7\15<4/3> | ||
| 0, -1.247, 1.247 | | 0, -1.247, 1.247 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Gamma 4/3]] | |||
| [[28ed4/3]] | | [[28ed4/3]] | ||
| | | 67.4637835102899 | ||
| 28\28<4/3>, 15\28<4/3>, 13\28<4/3> | | 28\28<4/3>, 15\28<4/3>, 13\28<4/3> | ||
| 0, -0.061, 0.061 | | 0, -0.061, 0.061 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Alpha 9/7]] | |||
| [[15ed9/7]] | |||
| 41.3713123417559 | |||
| rowspan="3" | 9/7 | | rowspan="3" | 9/7 | ||
| rowspan="3" | 8/7, 9/8 | | rowspan="3" | 8/7, 9/8 | ||
| 15\15<9/7>, 8\15<9/7>, 7\15<9/7> | | 15\15<9/7>, 8\15<9/7>, 7\15<9/7> | ||
| 0, 0.871, -0.871 | | 0, 0.871, -0.871 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Beta 9/7]] | |||
| [[17ed9/7]] | | [[17ed9/7]] | ||
| | | 46.8874873206567 | ||
| 17\17<9/7>, 9\17<9/7>, 8\17<9/7> | | 17\17<9/7>, 9\17<9/7>, 8\17<9/7> | ||
| 0, -0.835, 0.835 | | 0, -0.835, 0.835 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Gamma 9/7]] | |||
| [[32ed9/7]] | | [[32ed9/7]] | ||
| | | 88.2587996624126 | ||
| 32\32<9/7>, 17\32<9/7>, 15\32<9/7> | | 32\32<9/7>, 17\32<9/7>, 15\32<9/7> | ||
| 0, -0.036, 0.036 | | 0, -0.036, 0.036 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Alpha 5/4]] | |||
| [[17ed5/4]] | |||
| 52.8068232315916 | |||
| rowspan="3" | 5/4 | | rowspan="3" | 5/4 | ||
| rowspan="3" | 9/8, 10/9 | | rowspan="3" | 9/8, 10/9 | ||
| 17\17<5/4>, 9\17<5/4>, 8\17<5/4> | | 17\17<5/4>, 9\17<5/4>, 8\17<5/4> | ||
| 0, 0.609, -0.609 | | 0, 0.609, -0.609 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Beta 5/4]] | |||
| [[19ed5/4]] | | [[19ed5/4]] | ||
| | | 59.0193906706024 | ||
| 19\19<5/4>, 10\19<5/4>, 9\19<5/4> | | 19\19<5/4>, 10\19<5/4>, 9\19<5/4> | ||
| 0, -0.587, 0.587 | | 0, -0.587, 0.587 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Gamma 5/4]] | |||
| [[36ed5/4]] | | [[36ed5/4]] | ||
| | | 111.826213902194 | ||
| 36\36<5/4>, 19\36<5/4>, 17\36<5/4> | | 36\36<5/4>, 19\36<5/4>, 17\36<5/4> | ||
| 0, -0.022, 0.022 | | 0, -0.022, 0.022 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Alpha 11/9]] | |||
| [[19ed11/9]] | |||
| 65.6288971357202 | |||
| rowspan="3" | 11/9 | | rowspan="3" | 11/9 | ||
| rowspan="3" | 10/9, 11/10 | | rowspan="3" | 10/9, 11/10 | ||
| 19\19<11/9>, 10\19<11/9>, 9\19<11/9> | | 19\19<11/9>, 10\19<11/9>, 9\19<11/9> | ||
| 0, 0.443, -0.443 | | 0, 0.443, -0.443 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Beta 11/9]] | |||
| [[21ed11/9]] | | [[21ed11/9]] | ||
| | | 72.5372020973750 | ||
| 21\21<11/9>, 11\21<11/9>, 10\21<11/9> | | 21\21<11/9>, 11\21<11/9>, 10\21<11/9> | ||
| 0, -0.428, 0.428 | | 0, -0.428, 0.428 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Gamma 11/9]] | |||
| [[40ed11/9]] | | [[40ed11/9]] | ||
| | | 138.166099233095 | ||
| 40\40<11/9>, 21\40<11/9>, 19\40<11/9> | | 40\40<11/9>, 21\40<11/9>, 19\40<11/9> | ||
| 0, -0.015, 0.015 | | 0, -0.015, 0.015 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Alpha 6/5]] | |||
| [[21ed6/5]] | |||
| 79.8374643554025 | |||
| rowspan="3" | 6/5 | | rowspan="3" | 6/5 | ||
| rowspan="3" | 11/10, 12/11 | | rowspan="3" | 11/10, 12/11 | ||
| 21\21<6/5>, 11\21<6/5>, 10\21<6/5> | | 21\21<6/5>, 11\21<6/5>, 10\21<6/5> | ||
| 0, 0.332, -0.332 | | 0, 0.332, -0.332 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Beta 6/5]] | |||
| [[23ed6/5]] | | [[23ed6/5]] | ||
| | | 87.4410323892504 | ||
| 23\23<6/5>, 12\23<6/5>, 11\23<6/5> | | 23\23<6/5>, 12\23<6/5>, 11\23<6/5> | ||
| 0, -0.322, 0.322 | | 0, -0.322, 0.322 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Gamma 6/5]] | |||
| [[44ed6/5]] | | [[44ed6/5]] | ||
| | | 167.278496744653 | ||
| 44\44<6/5>, 23\44<6/5>, 21\44<6/5> | | 44\44<6/5>, 23\44<6/5>, 21\44<6/5> | ||
| 0, -0.010, 0.010 | | 0, -0.010, 0.010 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Alpha 13/11]] | |||
| [[23ed13/11]] | |||
| 95.4324773621886 | |||
| rowspan="3" | 13/11 | | rowspan="3" | 13/11 | ||
| rowspan="3" | 12/11, 13/12 | | rowspan="3" | 12/11, 13/12 | ||
| 23\23<13/11>, 12\23<13/11>, 11\23<13/11> | | 23\23<13/11>, 12\23<13/11>, 11\23<13/11> | ||
| 0, 0.255, -0.255 | | 0, 0.255, -0.255 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Beta 13/11]] | |||
| [[25ed13/11]] | | [[25ed13/11]] | ||
| | | 103.730953654553 | ||
| 25\25<13/11>, 13\25<13/11>, 12\25<13/11> | | 25\25<13/11>, 13\25<13/11>, 12\25<13/11> | ||
| 0, -0.248, 0.248 | | 0, -0.248, 0.248 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Gamma 13/11]] | |||
| [[48ed13/11]] | | [[48ed13/11]] | ||
| | | 199.163431016741 | ||
| 48\48<13/11>, 25\48<13/11>, 23\48<13/11> | | 48\48<13/11>, 25\48<13/11>, 23\48<13/11> | ||
| 0, -0.007, 0.007 | | 0, -0.007, 0.007 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Alpha 7/6]] | |||
| [[25ed7/6]] | |||
| 112.413902640048 | |||
| rowspan="3" | 7/6 | | rowspan="3" | 7/6 | ||
| rowspan="3" | 13/12, 14/13 | | rowspan="3" | 13/12, 14/13 | ||
| 25\25<7/6>, 13\25<7/6>, 12\25<7/6> | | 25\25<7/6>, 13\25<7/6>, 12\25<7/6> | ||
| 0, 0.200, -0.200 | | 0, 0.200, -0.200 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Beta 7/6]] | |||
| [[27ed7/6]] | | [[27ed7/6]] | ||
| | | 121.407014851252 | ||
| 27\27<7/6>, 14\27<7/6>, 13\27<7/6> | | 27\27<7/6>, 14\27<7/6>, 13\27<7/6> | ||
| 0, -0.195, 0.195 | | 0, -0.195, 0.195 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Gamma 7/6]] | |||
| [[52ed7/6]] | | [[52ed7/6]] | ||
| | | 233.820917491300 | ||
| 52\52<7/6>, 27\52<7/6>, 25\52<7/6> | | 52\52<7/6>, 27\52<7/6>, 25\52<7/6> | ||
| 0, -0.005, 0.005 | | 0, -0.005, 0.005 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Alpha 15/13]] | |||
| [[27ed15/13]] | |||
| 130.781715879411 | |||
| rowspan="3" | 15/13 | | rowspan="3" | 15/13 | ||
| rowspan="3" | 14/13, 15/14 | | rowspan="3" | 14/13, 15/14 | ||
| 27\27<15/13>, 14\27<15/13>, 13\27<15/13> | | 27\27<15/13>, 14\27<15/13>, 13\27<15/13> | ||
| 0, 0.160, -0.160 | | 0, 0.160, -0.160 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Beta 15/13]] | |||
| [[29ed15/13]] | | [[29ed15/13]] | ||
| | | 140.469250388997 | ||
| 29\29<15/13>, 15\29<15/13>, 14\29<15/13> | | 29\29<15/13>, 15\29<15/13>, 14\29<15/13> | ||
| 0, -0.156, 0.156 | | 0, -0.156, 0.156 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Gamma 15/13]] | |||
| [[56ed15/13]] | | [[56ed15/13]] | ||
| | | 271.250966268408 | ||
| 56\56<15/13>, 29\56<15/13>, 27\56<15/13> | | 56\56<15/13>, 29\56<15/13>, 27\56<15/13> | ||
| 0, -0.004, 0.004 | | 0, -0.004, 0.004 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Alpha 8/7]] | |||
| [[29ed8/7]] | |||
| 150.535899020849 | |||
| rowspan="3" | 8/7 | | rowspan="3" | 8/7 | ||
| rowspan="3" | 15/14, 16/15 | | rowspan="3" | 15/14, 16/15 | ||
| 29\29<8/7>, 15\29<8/7>, 14\29<8/7> | | 29\29<8/7>, 15\29<8/7>, 14\29<8/7> | ||
| 0, 0.130, -0.130 | | 0, 0.130, -0.130 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Beta 8/7]] | |||
| [[31ed8/7]] | | [[31ed8/7]] | ||
| | | 160.917685160217 | ||
| 31\31<8/7>, 16\31<8/7>, 15\31<8/7> | | 31\31<8/7>, 16\31<8/7>, 15\31<8/7> | ||
| 0, -0.127, 0.127 | | 0, -0.127, 0.127 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| [[Gamma 8/7]] | |||
| [[60ed8/7]] | | [[60ed8/7]] | ||
| | | 311.453584181066 | ||
| 60\60<8/7>, 31\60<8/7>, 29\60<8/7> | | 60\60<8/7>, 31\60<8/7>, 29\60<8/7> | ||
| 0, -0.003, 0.003 | | 0, -0.003, 0.003 | ||
|} | |} | ||
As a | == The converging Alpha-Beta-Gamma sequence == | ||
As a fact, for each <math>n\ge 2</math>, equal divisions of <math>R_n=\dfrac{n+1}{n-1}</math> where low errors appear for <math>S_n=\dfrac{n+1}{n}</math> and <math>B_n=\dfrac{n}{n-1}</math> forms a converging sequence and pattern, with the happy equal divisions of <math>R_n</math> being: | |||
* '''Alpha:''' <math>k_\alpha=2n-1</math> | |||
* '''Beta:''' <math>k_\beta=2n+1</math> | |||
* '''Gamma:''' <math>k_\gamma=4n=k_\alpha+k_\beta</math> | |||
In this sequence, the errors are lower and lower. | |||
{{todo|Why this pattern|inline=1|comment=Explain why divisions of ratios where low errors appear for successive superparticular complementary pair make this pattern appears.}} | |||
{| class="wikitable sortable right-1 left-2 right-3 left-4 right-5 left-6 right-7 left-8 right-9 left-10 right-11 left-12 right-13 left-14 right-15 left-16 right-17 left-18 right-19 left-20" | {| class="wikitable sortable right-1 left-2 right-3 left-4 right-5 left-6 right-7 left-8 right-9 left-10 right-11 left-12 right-13 left-14 right-15 left-16 right-17 left-18 right-19 left-20" | ||