Xenharmonic Wiki:Things to do
Hello there! This page is a place for various projects and minute things to do on this wiki. Please be welcome to help with any of them you like!
If you think something essential was forgotten and should be here, don’t be shy to add a new section here! If you don’t know if a project would be interesting to others, write at the talk page and let’s decide it together.
When the technical help is needed, please aid volunteers with a tool or two for being sure the details are easy to make right. For example, a template, a converter etc..
- See also Conventions, Wikifuture, Migration FAQ as well as Category:Todo and its subcategories.
Get rid of "alternative pages"
There are some pages that were mostly started out of frustration of on particular user not any more active in this wiki. The problem with diverging pages about the same topic is that linking to it tends to break or at least dissipate the consistency of the entire wiki. As normally would be the case with pages targeting the same topic but created by chance, the content should be merged into the (mostly obvious) main page. If there is noting valuable on it, the pages should be deleted. The pages are currently in the Category:Alternative pages. For discussing deletion etc, we should refrain from doing that on the respective discussion pages, because deletion will remove these as well. We'd better open an own page for discussion deletion. Xenwolf (talk) 14:55, 22 November 2020 (UTC)
- I took a look at these. The edo pages are a relic of a discussion on facebook about the proper format for edo pages. Sort of useful. I suggest deleting all but the 15edo-a page and Gareth's page. The 94-edo page might have some good stuff, but since it's 94edo and 15edo jumbled together, it's also really confusing. This is what I suggest, but I don't feel I have the authority to actually delete someone's page. --TallKite (talk) 03:05, 12 January 2021 (UTC)
- Mostly done, only User:Lhearne/15edo left, and since it's in the user namespace, it's not as problematic. Still waiting for a reply from Lillian, I might give a poke on Discord. Fredg999 (talk) 07:51, 26 July 2023 (UTC)
Place to discuss deletion requests
Sometimes it's not easy to decide if a page should be deleted or not, it has to be discussed first. The problem with discussing deletion requests on the discussion page of the page being questioned is that they both have the same future. If the deletion happens, normal users have no access to the reasoning any more. Most wikis use an extra page for this purpose.
The so-called project namespace (in this wiki it's indicated by the prefix Xenharmonic Wiki:) is dedicated to that purpose, see pages currently in the project namespace. Xenwolf (talk) 15:08, 22 November 2020 (UTC)
- Wikipedia needs to handle a lot of page deletions, and in particular a lot of page deletion discussions. For more modest needs like ours, maybe we could create the talk page of Category:Pages nominated for deletion (therefore Category talk:Pages nominated for deletion) and create a topic per request on that page. If the page has a long backlog over time, we can create archive pages to avoid cluttering the active page too much. Fredg999 (talk) 07:51, 26 July 2023 (UTC)
Disambiguation project
There is a project Xenharmonic Wiki:Disambiguation that aims to build the tools we need. Please join the work and discuss related issues. Xenwolf (talk) 11:38, 26 November 2020 (UTC)
- I created Template:About a while ago for disambiguation hatnotes. I'll try to work on a simple help page soon. Fredg999 (talk) 07:51, 26 July 2023 (UTC)
13-Limit, 17-Limit and 19-Limit Comma Pages
- todo
A project to reorganize 11-limit and 13-limit temperaments. That is still discussed.
Join the discussion Xenharmonic Wiki talk:Things to do#13-Limit, 17-Limit and 19-Limit Comma Pages!
Comma tables in EDO pages
We found (on User talk:FloraC #Fractions vs. names in interval lemmas) that the comma tables on EDO pages are overloaded with information already given elsewhere. This self-evolving "convention" makes it hard to provide consistent and correct information about, (alternative) names, corrections etc. The original information should eventually find place in a dedicated page for each comma; the overview pages about commas (Large comma, Medium comma, Small comma, Unnoticeable comma) should be seen as secondary source then. Currently we tend to reduce the comma tables on EDO pages to at most three columns:
- p-Limit
- linked name or fraction (depending) on the lemma of the link target
- Comments ← only if there really are useful comments
This can be discussed in Xenharmonic Wiki talk:Things to do#Comma tables in EDO pages
Improve accessibility of wiki and present info in a non-technical way
- (shortcut(s): Xenwiki:Accessibility, XenWiki:Accessibility)
Many newcomers to xen are daunted by the math-heavy presentation of tunings and basic MOS/temperament ideas on this wiki. Therefore we propose the following:
- Unfamiliar terms should be linked when they are first used in an article.
- Section off or subpage all the math-heavy parts of articles (for example to move Fokker block#Mathematical description to Fokker block/Math).
- Introductory articles and sections should assume at most high school algebra and should focus on practical knowledge for musicians and composers, such as musical examples, how to build a scale in Scala, or what intervals and chords 17edo has.
- EDO pages should follow the above rule too. They should present general information in a standardized format, like an encyclopedia article (Not making any particular suggestion on the format now).
- Explanations of abstract concepts should use visualizations and examples where possible (They help even in more mathy contexts).
- Scales of size 5 to 10 should be given extra attention on the wiki.
Collaborative work on the Practical RTT series for teaching regular temperament theory (RTT) while using linear algebra terms as little as possible. While Mike's lectures were no doubt valuable to some people, they would have effectively involved teaching a whole course on theoretical linear algebra.- Maybe there's no need to even teach people to use x31eq or read mapping matrices; see newer proposals above.
Further proposals coming.
Please join the discussion in Xenharmonic Wiki talk:Things to do#Improve accessibility of wiki and present info in a non-technical way!
- Template:Inaccessible can now be used to warn readers of pages that may be difficult to understand, while also reminding wiki editors that these pages need work by placing these pages in Category:Inaccessible pages. Fredg999 (talk) 07:51, 26 July 2023 (UTC)
Reorganize temperament pages
How should temperament pages be reorganized?
Inthar's take: IMO there are too many rank-2 temperaments on this wiki that are just variants of each other (have similar optimal tunings) and only differ in some high complexity interpretation for an extra harmonic. Ideally the most important (low-complexity) approximations and subgroups should be given first, and one way we can pin those down is look at what intervals are approximated in small EDO tunings (<=36edo) for the rank 2 temperament.
This suggests a scale-tree based format for temperament pages; each page would focus on a fixed MOS structure and possible temperaments for the generator chain that generates that MOS. The temperaments are ordered in increasing generator size, and more complex temperaments (i.e. approximating additional JI intervals with intervals further out in the generator chain) would be children of simpler temperaments. The new scale tree temperament pages need not replace current temperament pages (they could even be integrated into current MOS structure pages like 5L 2s), but I believe that this is the most intuitive format and should be what newcomers to RTT-based tunings should be directed to. See example of this format.
- Proposal: This organization for temperament pages should be integrated into current MOS structure pages.
Please join the discussion in Xenharmonic Wiki talk:Things to do#Reorganize temperament pages!
New format for temperament entries
Present regular temperament tunings on temperament pages in a new concrete, easy-to-read format.
We are canceling it because it turns out suboptimal.
Please join the discussion in Xenharmonic Wiki talk:Things to do#New format for temperament entries!
General-audience temperament pages
Create table of interval pages for large edos you’re familiar with
If you are familiar with a large edo (100edo or higher), please create a “Table of #edo intervals” page for it, along the lines of Table of 99edo intervals or Table of 198edo intervals.
Please only do this if you are familiar with the edo, though: i.e. you have made music with the edo, or the edo falls within your sphere of expertise as a theorist.
FloraC and Budjarn Lambeth, 21 January 2024.
Comma pump examples
Add audio comma pump examples for commas.
A lot of comma pages have no examples demonstrating how commas can be used to build chord progressions, scales, etc., so please add comma pump examples! A good example is frameshift comma.