5/4: Difference between revisions

From Xenharmonic Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Plumtree (talk | contribs)
m Normalising usage of Infobox Interval
Names and references
Line 6: Line 6:
}}
}}
{{Infobox Interval
{{Infobox Interval
| Name = classic/just major third
| Name = just major third, classic(al) major third, ptolemaic major third
| Color name = y3, yo 3rd
| Color name = y3, yo 3rd
| Sound = jid_5_4_pluck_adu_dr220.mp3
| Sound = jid_5_4_pluck_adu_dr220.mp3
Line 12: Line 12:
{{Wikipedia|Major third}}
{{Wikipedia|Major third}}


In [[5-limit]] [[just intonation]], '''5/4''' is the [[frequency ratio]] between the 5th and 4th [[harmonic]]s. It has been called the '''just major third''' or '''classic major third''' to distinguish it from other intervals in that neighborhood. Measuring about 386.3 [[cent|¢]], it is about 13.7 ¢ away from [[12edo]]'s major third of 400 ¢. It has a distinctive "sweet" sound, and has been described as more "laid back" than its 12edo counterpart. Providing a novel consonance after 3, it is the basis for [[5-limit]] harmony. It is distinguished from the [[Pythagorean]] major third of [[81/64]] by the syntonic comma of [[81/80]], which measures about 21.5 ¢. 81/64 and 5/4 are both just intonation "major thirds", 81/64 having a more active and discordant quality, 5/4 sounding more "restful".
In [[5-limit]] [[just intonation]], '''5/4''' is the [[frequency ratio]] between the 5th and 4th [[harmonic]]s. It has been called the '''just major third'''<ref>[https://marsbat.space/pdfs/HEJI2_legend+series.pdf ''The Helmholtz-Ellis JI Pitch Notation (HEJI)''] by [[Marc Sabat]] and [[Thomas Nicholson]] from Plainsound Music Edition</ref>, '''classic(al) major third'''<ref>[https://dkeenan.com/Music/IntervalNaming.htm ''A note on the naming of musical intervals''] by [[Dave Keenan]]</ref>, or '''ptolemaic major third'''<ref>[https://marsbat.space/pdfs/JI.pdf ''Fundamental Principles of Just Intonation and Microtonal Composition''] by Thomas Nicholson and Marc Sabat —"'Ptolemaic' refers to intervals combining only the primes 2, 3, and 5."</ref> to distinguish it from other intervals in that neighborhood. Measuring about 386.3 [[cent|¢]], it is about 13.7 ¢ away from [[12edo]]'s major third of 400 ¢. It has a distinctive "sweet" sound, and has been described as more "laid back" than its 12edo counterpart. Providing a novel consonance after 3, it is the basis for [[5-limit]] harmony. It is distinguished from the [[Pythagorean]] major third of [[81/64]] by the syntonic comma of [[81/80]], which measures about 21.5 ¢. 81/64 and 5/4 are both just intonation "major thirds", 81/64 having a more active and discordant quality, 5/4 sounding more "restful".


In the context of the harmonic series, 5/4 can be heard between the 4th and 5th member of the series, demonstrated here melodically in singing into a resonant [[udderbot]] (from the fundamental up to 5 and then noodling between 5 and 4).
In the context of the harmonic series, 5/4 can be heard between the 4th and 5th member of the series, demonstrated here melodically in singing into a resonant [[udderbot]] (from the fundamental up to 5 and then noodling between 5 and 4).


== Approximations by EDOs ==
== Approximations by edos ==
Following [[EDO]]s (up to 200, and also 643) contain good approximations<ref>error magnitude below 7, both, absolute (in ¢) and relative (in r¢)</ref> of the interval 5/4. Errors are given by magnitude, the arrows in the table show if the EDO representation is sharp (&uarr;) or flat (&darr;).
Following [[edo]]s (up to 200, and also 643) contain good approximations<ref>error magnitude below 7, both, absolute (in ¢) and relative (in r¢)</ref> of the interval 5/4. Errors are given by magnitude, the arrows in the table show if the edo representation is sharp (&uarr;) or flat (&darr;).


{| class="wikitable sortable right-1 center-2 right-3 right-4 center-5"
{| class="wikitable sortable right-1 center-2 right-3 right-4 center-5"
|-
|-
! [[EDO]]
! [[Edo]]
! class="unsortable" | deg\edo
! class="unsortable" | deg\edo
! Absolute <br> error ([[Cent|¢]])
! Absolute <br> error ([[Cent|¢]])
! Relative <br> error ([[Relative cent|r¢]])
! Relative <br> error ([[Relative cent|r¢]])
! &#8597;
! &#8597;
! class="unsortable" | Equally acceptable multiples <ref>Super EDOs up to 200 within the same error tolerance</ref>
! class="unsortable" | Equally acceptable multiples <ref>Super-edos up to 200 within the same error tolerance</ref>
|-
|-
|  [[25edo|25]]  ||  8\25  || 2.3137 || 4.8202 || &darr; ||
|  [[25edo|25]]  ||  8\25  || 2.3137 || 4.8202 || &darr; ||
Line 62: Line 62:
| [[643edo|643]] || 207\643 || 0.0004 || 0.0235 || &uarr; ||
| [[643edo|643]] || 207\643 || 0.0004 || 0.0235 || &uarr; ||
|}
|}
<references/>


== See also ==
== See also ==
Line 73: Line 71:
* [[List of superparticular intervals]]
* [[List of superparticular intervals]]
* [[:File:5-4.mp3]] – sound sample that illustrates 5/4 as the interval between sung overtones
* [[:File:5-4.mp3]] – sound sample that illustrates 5/4 as the interval between sung overtones
== Notes ==
<references/>


[[Category:Third]]
[[Category:Third]]
[[Category:Major third]]
[[Category:Major third]]

Revision as of 11:47, 12 January 2023

Interval information
Ratio 5/4
Factorization 2-2 × 5
Monzo [-2 0 1⟩
Size in cents 386.3137 ¢
Names just major third,
classic(al) major third,
ptolemaic major third
Color name y3, yo 3rd
FJS name [math]\displaystyle{ \text{M3}^{5} }[/math]
Special properties superparticular,
reduced,
reduced harmonic
Tenney norm (log2 nd) 4.32193
Weil norm (log2 max(n, d)) 4.64386
Wilson norm (sopfr(nd)) 9

[sound info]
Open this interval in xen-calc
English Wikipedia has an article on:

In 5-limit just intonation, 5/4 is the frequency ratio between the 5th and 4th harmonics. It has been called the just major third[1], classic(al) major third[2], or ptolemaic major third[3] to distinguish it from other intervals in that neighborhood. Measuring about 386.3 ¢, it is about 13.7 ¢ away from 12edo's major third of 400 ¢. It has a distinctive "sweet" sound, and has been described as more "laid back" than its 12edo counterpart. Providing a novel consonance after 3, it is the basis for 5-limit harmony. It is distinguished from the Pythagorean major third of 81/64 by the syntonic comma of 81/80, which measures about 21.5 ¢. 81/64 and 5/4 are both just intonation "major thirds", 81/64 having a more active and discordant quality, 5/4 sounding more "restful".

In the context of the harmonic series, 5/4 can be heard between the 4th and 5th member of the series, demonstrated here melodically in singing into a resonant udderbot (from the fundamental up to 5 and then noodling between 5 and 4).

Approximations by edos

Following edos (up to 200, and also 643) contain good approximations[4] of the interval 5/4. Errors are given by magnitude, the arrows in the table show if the edo representation is sharp (↑) or flat (↓).

Edo deg\edo Absolute
error (¢)
Relative
error (r¢)
↕ Equally acceptable multiples [5]
25 8\25 2.3137 4.8202 ↓
28 9\28 0.5994 1.3987 ↓ 18\56, 27\84, 36\112, 45\140
31 10\31 0.7831 2.0229 ↑ 20\62, 30\93
34 11\34 1.9216 5.4445 ↑
53 17\53 1.4081 6.2189 ↓
59 19\59 0.1270 0.6242 ↑ 38\118, 57\177
87 28\87 0.1068 0.7744 ↓ 56\174
90 29\90 0.3530 2.6471 ↑ 58\180
115 37\115 0.2268 2.1731 ↓
121 39\121 0.4631 4.6701 ↑
143 46\143 0.2997 3.5718 ↓
146 47\146 0.0123 0.1502 ↓
149 48\149 0.2635 3.2714 ↑
152 49\152 0.5284 6.6930 ↑
171 55\171 0.3488 4.9704 ↓
199 64\199 0.3841 6.3691 ↓
643 207\643 0.0004 0.0235 ↑

See also

Notes

  1. ↑ The Helmholtz-Ellis JI Pitch Notation (HEJI) by Marc Sabat and Thomas Nicholson from Plainsound Music Edition
  2. ↑ A note on the naming of musical intervals by Dave Keenan
  3. ↑ Fundamental Principles of Just Intonation and Microtonal Composition by Thomas Nicholson and Marc Sabat —"'Ptolemaic' refers to intervals combining only the primes 2, 3, and 5."
  4. ↑ error magnitude below 7, both, absolute (in ¢) and relative (in r¢)
  5. ↑ Super-edos up to 200 within the same error tolerance