Major second (interval region)

From Xenharmonic Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
← Neutral second Interval region Minor third →
Name Major second, whole tone
Lower bound 160¢ – 180¢
Upper bound 240¢ – 260¢
Generated MOSes 1L 6s, 7L 1s, 6L 1s, 1L 5s, 5L 1s, 5L 4s
Example JI intervals
Intervals 8/7 (231.2¢)
9/8 (203.9¢)
10/9 (182.4¢)
Related regions
Complement Minor seventh

A major second (M2) is the larger of two "seconds" - intervals spanning 2 degrees or 1 scale step in the diatonic scale. It is found on the 1st note of the major scale, hence its name. Because it is one step, it is also called a "whole tone". Another diatonic interval around the same size is the diminished third.

More generally, an interval close to 200 cents can be called a major second.

The major second is also called the tone, or whole tone for clarity (as distinct from the semitone).

As an interval region

As a concrete interval region, a major second is typically near 200 ¢ in size, distinct from the semitone of roughly 100 ¢ and the neutral second of roughly 150 ¢. A rough tuning range for the major second is about 180 to 240 ¢ according to Margo Schulter's theory of interval regions.

This article covers intervals between 160 and 260 ¢. The outer range of this might be too extreme to call "major seconds", but this is done so that one can find what they are looking for easily.

In MOS scales

Being a small interval, major seconds generate a number of monosmall and monolarge MOS scales.

These tables start from the last monolarge MOS generated by the interval range.

Scales with more than 12 notes are not included.

Range MOS
150–171 ¢ 1L 6s 7L 1s
171–200 ¢ 1L 5s 6L 1s
200–218 ¢ 1L 4s 5L 1s 6L 5s
218–240 ¢ 5L 6s
240–267 ¢ 1L 3s 4L 1s 5L 4s

As a diatonic interval category

Diatonic major second
MOS 5L 2s
Other names Major 1-diastep
Generator span +2 generators
Tuning range 171–240 ¢
Basic tuning 200 ¢
Function on root Supertonic
Interval regions Major second
Associated just intervals 10/9, 9/8
Octave complement Minor seventh

As a diatonic interval category, a major second is an interval that spans one scale step in the diatonic scale with the major (wider) quality. It is generated by stacking 2 fifths octave reduced, and depending on the specific tuning, it ranges from 171 to 240 ¢ (1\7 to 1\5). It can be considered the large step of the diatonic scale.

In just intonation, an interval may be classified as a major second if it is reasonably mapped to 2 steps of the chromatic scale - formally, this is 4\24, which is used as opposed to 12edo's 2\12 to better capture the characteristics of many intervals in the 11- and 13-limit - and 1 step of the diatonic scale. Diminished thirds are mapped to 2 steps of the chromatic scale and 2 steps of the diatonic scale.

In TAMNAMS, the major second is called the major 1-diastep.

Given its role as the large step, it can be used to construct other diatonic intervals, along with the minor second: two major seconds make a major third, a major second and a minor second make a minor third, and three major seconds result in an augmented fourth, also called a tritone for that reason.

Scale info

The diatonic scale contains five major seconds. In the Ionian mode, major seconds are found on the 1st, 2nd, 4th, 5th, and 6th degrees of the scale; the other two degrees have minor seconds. The large number of major seconds compared to minor seconds ensures that thirds that include minor seconds (that is, minor thirds) are roughly evenly distributed with major thirds; in a scale with three small steps and four large steps, for example, six out of the seven thirds are minor.

Tunings

Being an abstract mos degree, and not a specific interval, the diatonic major third does not have a fixed tuning, but instead has a range of ways it can be tuned, based on the tuning of the generator used in making the scale.

The tuning range of the diatonic major second ranges from 342.8 to 480 ¢. The generator for a given tuning in cents, n, for the diatonic major second can be found by {{nowrap| (n + 1200)/2. For example, the third 192 ¢ gives us (192 + 1200)/2 = 1392/2 = 696 ¢, corresponding to 50edo.

Several example tunings are provided below:

Tuning Step ratio Edo Cents
Equalized 1:1 7 171 ¢
Supersoft 4:3 26 184 ¢
Soft 3:2 19 189 ¢
Semisoft 5:3 31 194 ¢
Basic 2:1 12 200 ¢
Semihard 5:2 29 207 ¢
Hard 3:1 17 212 ¢
Superhard 4:1 22 218 ¢
Collapsed 1:0 5 240 ¢

In just intonation

By prime limit

The Pythagorean (3-limit) major second is 9/8, which is 204 ¢ in size and corresponds to the mos-based interval category of the diatonic major second. It is generated by stacking two just perfect fifths of 3/2. There is also a Pythagorean diminished third of 65536/59049, which is about 180 cents in size. While called a "third", it is within the range of major seconds.

Other major seconds exist in higher limits, however, for example:

  • The 5-limit ptolemaic major second is a ratio of 10/9, however in 5-limit harmony it is used alongside 9/8. It is about 182 ¢.
  • The 7-limit (septimal) supermajor second is a ratio of 8/7, and is about 231 ¢.
  • The 11-limit (undecimal) submajor second is a ratio of 11/10, and is about 165 ¢, though it can also be analyzed as a neutral second. Despite that, it is also here for completeness.
  • The 13-limit (tridecimal) ultramajor second is a ratio of 15/13, and is about 248 ¢, though it can also be analyzed as an inframinor third. Despite that, it is also here for completeness.

By delta

See Delta-N ratio. Ratios that are marginal within the interval category and ambiguous with an adjoining one are marked with an asterisk.

Delta-1 Delta-2 Delta-3
8/7 231 ¢ 15/13* 248 ¢ 22/19* 253 ¢
9/8 204 ¢ 17/15 217 ¢ 23/20* 242 ¢
10/9 182 ¢ 19/17 193 ¢ 25/22 221 ¢
11/10* 165 ¢ 21/19 173 ¢ 26/23 212 ¢
28/25 196 ¢
29/26 189 ¢
31/28 176 ¢
32/29* 170 ¢

In edos

The following table lists the best tuning of 10/9, 9/8, and 8/7, as well as other major seconds if present, in various significant edos.

Edo 10/9 9/8 8/7 Other major seconds
5 240 ¢
7 171 ¢
12 200 ¢
15 160 ¢ 240 ¢
16 * 225 ¢
17 212 ¢
19 189 ¢ 253 ¢
22 164 ¢ 218 ¢
24 200 ¢ 250 ¢
25 192 ¢ 240 ¢
26 185 ¢ 231c
27 178 ¢ 222 ¢
29 166 ¢ 207 ¢ 248 ¢
31 194 ¢ 232 ¢
34 176 ¢ 212 ¢ 247 ¢
41 176 ¢ 205 ¢ 234 ¢
53 181 ¢ 204 ¢ 226 ¢ 249 ¢ ≈ 15/13

In regular temperaments

The three simplest major second ratios are 10/9, 9/8, and 8/7, and these along with other more complex interpretations serve as generators for a variety of regular temperaments.

  • The generator of the 7L 1s scale can be interpreted as a 10/9 major second, that is equated to 11/10 and 12/11 neutral seconds by porcupine, so that three generators reach 4/3. Its tuning range is therefore somewhat ambiguous between major and neutral second.
  • The generator of the 6L 1s and 7L 6s scales can be interpreted as a 10/9 major second in tetracot (which is sometimes equated to 11/10), where four of these seconds reach 3/2.
  • The generator of the 6L 1s and 6L 7s scales can be interpreted in terms of 2.5.7 didacus, whose generator represents 28/25 and which splits the septimal tritone 7/5 in three, with one step making the generator 28/25 and two making 5/4. This generator can also stand in for 10/9 and 9/8 in the 2.9.5.7 subgroup, if it is treated as an index-2 restriction of septimal meantone.
  • The generator of the 5L 6s scale can be interpreted as 8/7 in 2.3.7 slendric, where three of them are equated to 3/2.
  • The generator of the 5L 4s scale can be interpreted in terms of 2.3.7 semaphore, where 8/7 is equated to the subminor third 7/6 so that two generators reach 4/3, or more accurately as 2.3.13/5 barbados if 8/7 is eschewed in favor of 15/13. Either way, it is tuned as an interseptimal ambiguous between a major second and minor third.
Todo: complete list

Due to the 9/8 major second being closely related to the perfect fifth, it is often useful to detune the fifth to approach other intervals with the diatonic major second. If the diatonic perfect fifth is treated as 3/2, approximating various intervals with the diatonic major second leads to the following temperaments:

Just

interval

Cents Temperament Vanishing

comma

Generator

(eigenmonzo tuning)

21/19 173 ¢ Surprise 57/56 687 ¢
10/9 182 ¢ Meantone 81/80 691 ¢
19/17 193 ¢ Little ganassi 153/152 696 ¢
9/8 204 ¢ Pythagorean 1/1 702 ¢
17/15 217 ¢ Fiventeen 136/135 708 ¢
8/7 231 ¢ Archy 64/63 716 ¢


ViewTalkEditInterval classification
Seconds and thirds UnisonComma and diesisSemitoneNeutral secondMajor second • (Interseptimal second-third) • Minor thirdNeutral thirdMajor third
Fourths and fifths (Interseptimal third-fourth) • Perfect fourthSuperfourthTritoneSubfifthPerfect fifth • (Interseptimal fifth-sixth)
Sixths and sevenths Minor sixthNeutral sixthMajor sixth • (Interseptimal sixth-seventh) • Minor seventhNeutral seventhMajor seventhOctave
Diatonic qualities DiminishedMinorPerfectMajorAugmented
Tuning ranges Neutral (interval quality)Submajor and supraminorPental major and minorNovamajor and novaminorNeogothic major and minorSupermajor and subminorUltramajor and inframinor