Syntonic-diatonic equivalence continuum
The syntonic-diatonic equivalence continuum is a continuum of temperaments which equate a number of syntonic commas (81/80) with the limma (256/243). This continuum is theoretically interesting in that these are all 5-limit temperaments supported by 5edo.
All temperaments in the continuum satisfy (81/80)n ~ 256/243. Varying n results in different temperaments listed in the table below. It converges to meantone as n approaches infinity. If we allow non-integer and infinite n, the continuum describes the set of all 5-limit temperaments supported by 5edo due to it being the unique equal temperament that tempers out both commas and thus tempers out all combinations of them. The just value of n is 4.1952…, and temperaments near this tend to be the most accurate ones.
256/243 is the characteristic 3-limit comma tempered out in 5edo, and has many advantages as a target. In each case, n equals the order of harmonic 5 in the corresponding comma, and equals the number of generators to obtain a harmonic 3 in the generator chain. For example:
- Superpyth (n = 1) is generated by a fifth;
- Immunity (n = 2) splits its twelfth in two;
- Rodan (n = 3) splits its fifth in three;
- Etc.
At n = 5, the corresponding temperament splits the octave into five instead, as after a stack of five syntonic commas, both the orders of 3 and 5 are multiples of 5 again.
If we let k = n + 1 so that k = 0 means n = −1, k = 1 means n = 0, etc. then the continuum corresponds to (81/80)k = 16/15. Some prefer this way of conceptualising it because:
- 16/15 is the classic diatonic semitone, notable in the 5-limit as the difference between 4/3 and 5/4, so this shifted continuum could also logically be termed the "syntonic-diatonic equivalence continuum". This means that at k = 0, 4/3 and 5/4 are mapped to the same interval while 81/80 becomes independent of 16/15 (meaning 81/80 may or may not be tempered) because the relation becomes (81/80)0 ~ 1/1 ~ 16/15.
- k = 1 and upwards (up to a point) represent temperaments with (the potential for) reasonably good accuracy as equating at least one 81/80 with 16/15 seems like a good lower bound for a temperament intended to model JI. A good upper bound might be rodan (k = 4), with the only exception being meantone (n = k = ∞). (Temperaments corresponding to k = 0, −1, −2... are comparatively low-accuracy to the point of developing various intriguing structures and consequences.)
- 16/15 is the simplest ratio to be tempered in the continuum.
k | n | Temperament | Comma | |
---|---|---|---|---|
Ratio | Monzo | |||
−3 | −4 | Laquadgu (5 & 28) | 177147/160000 | [-8 11 -4⟩ |
−2 | −3 | Laconic | 2187/2000 | [-4 7 -3⟩ |
−1 | −2 | Bug | 27/25 | [0 3 -2⟩ |
0 | −1 | Father | 16/15 | [4 -1 -1⟩ |
1 | 0 | Blackwood | 256/243 | [8 -5⟩ |
2 | 1 | Superpyth | 20480/19683 | [12 -9 1⟩ |
3 | 2 | Immunity | 1638400/1594323 | [16 -13 2⟩ |
4 | 3 | Rodan | 131072000/129140163 | [20 -17 3⟩ |
5 | 4 | Vulture | 10485760000/10460353203 | [24 -21 4⟩ |
6 | 5 | Pental | 847288609443/838860800000 | [-28 25 -5⟩ |
7 | 6 | Hemiseven | 68630377364883/67108864000000 | [-32 29 -6⟩ |
… | … | … | … | |
∞ | ∞ | Meantone | 81/80 | [-4 4 -1⟩ |
We may invert the continuum by setting m such that 1/m + 1/n = 1. This may be called the superpyth-diatonic equivalence continuum, which is essentially the same thing. The just value of m is 1.3130… The superpyth comma is both larger and more complex than the syntonic comma. As such, this continuum does not contain as many useful temperaments, but still interesting nonetheless.
m | Temperament | Comma | |
---|---|---|---|
Ratio | Monzo | ||
−1 | Ultrapyth | 5242880/4782969 | [20 -14 1⟩ |
0 | Blackwood | 256/243 | [8 -5⟩ |
1 | Meantone | 81/80 | [-4 4 -1⟩ |
2 | Immunity | 1638400/1594323 | [16 -13 2⟩ |
3 | 5 & 56 | 33554432000/31381059609 | [28 -22 3⟩ |
… | … | … | … |
∞ | Superpyth | 20480/19683 | [12 -9 1⟩ |
n | m | Temperament | Comma |
---|---|---|---|
−3/2 = −1.5 | 3/5 = 0.6 | University | [4 2 -3⟩ |
−1/2 = −0.5 | 1/3 = 0.3 | Uncle | [12 -6 -1⟩ |
5/2 = 2.5 | 5/3 = 1.6 | Counterpental | [36 -30 5⟩ |
7/2 = 3.5 | 7/5 = 1.4 | Septiquarter | [44 -38 7⟩ |
21/5 = 4.2 | 21/16 = 1.3125 | 559 & 2513 | [-124 109 -21⟩ |
9/2 = 4.5 | 9/7 = 1.285714 | 5 & 118 | [-52 46 -9⟩ |
11/2 = 5.5 | 11/9 = 1.2 | 5 & 137 | [-60 54 -11⟩ |
Hemiseven
Subgroup: 2.3.5
Comma list: [32 -29 6⟩
Mapping: [⟨1 4 14], ⟨0 -6 -29]]
- mapping generators: ~2, ~320/243
- POTE: ~2 = 1200.0000, ~320/243 = 483.2474
Optimal ET sequence: 5, 62c, 67c, 72, 149, 221, 370, 591b, 961bb
Badness: 0.720465
Ultrapyth
Subgroup: 2.3.5
Comma list: 5242880/4782969
Mapping: [⟨1 0 -20], ⟨0 -1 -14]]
- mapping generators: ~2, ~3
- POTE: ~2 = 1200.0000, ~3/2 = 713.8287
Optimal ET sequence: 5, 27c, 32, 37, 79bc, 116bbc
Badness: 0.795243
Trisatriyo (5 & 56)
Subgroup: 2.3.5
Comma list: [28 -22 3⟩ = 33554432000/31381059609
Mapping: [⟨1 1 -2], ⟨0 3 22]]
- mapping generators: ~2, ~2560/2187
- POTE: ~2 = 1200.0000, ~2560/2187 = 235.8673
Optimal ET sequence: 5, …, 51, 56, 117b, 173b
Badness: 1.323443
The temperament finder - 5-limit 5 & 56
Counterpental
Subgroup: 2.3.5
Comma list: [36 -30 5⟩
Mapping: [⟨5 0 -36], ⟨0 1 6]]
- mapping generators: ~729/640, ~3
- POTE: ~2 = 1200.0000, ~3/2 = 704.5722
Optimal ET sequence: 5, …, 75, 80, 155, 390b, 545bbc
Badness: 1.500224
Septiquarter
Subgroup: 2.3.5
Comma list: [44 -38 7⟩
Mapping: [⟨1 3 10], ⟨0 -7 -38]]
- mapping generators: ~2, ~204800/177147
- POTE: ~2 = 1200.0000, ~204800/177147 = 242.4567
Optimal ET sequence: 5, 89c, 94, 99, 193, 292, 391
Badness: 0.971284
559 & 2513
Subgroup: 2.3.5
Comma list: [-124 109 -21⟩
Mapping: [⟨1 10 46], ⟨0 -21 -109]]
- mapping generators: ~2, ~3355443200000/2541865828329
- POTE: ~2 = 1200.0000, ~3355443200000/2541865828329 = 480.8595
Optimal ET sequence: 5, 267c, 272c, 277, 559, 1395, 1954, 2513, 40767, 43280, 45793, 48306, 50819, 53332, 55845, 58358, 60871, 63384, 65897, 68410, 70923, 73436, 75949, 78462
Badness: 0.134523
The temperament finder - 5-limit 2513 & 559
Quinla-tritrigu (5 & 118)
Subgroup: 2.3.5
Comma list: [-52 46 -9⟩
Mapping: [⟨1 -2 -16], ⟨0 9 46]]
- mapping generators: ~2, ~320/243
- POTE: ~2 = 1200.0000, ~320/243 = 477.9609
Optimal ET sequence: 5, 108c, 113, 118, 1057, 1175, 1293, 1411, 1529, 1647, 1765, 1883, 2001b, 3884b
Badness: 0.617683
Tribilalegu (5 & 137)
Subgroup: 2.3.5
Comma list: [-60 54 -11⟩
Mapping: [⟨1 6 24], ⟨0 -11 -54]]
- mapping generators: ~2, ~320/243
- POTE: ~2 = 1200.0000, ~320/243 = 481.7421
Optimal ET sequence: 5, 127c, 132, 137, 553, 690b, 827b, 964b
Badness: 3.620981