Ploidacot: Difference between revisions
No edit summary Tags: Mobile edit Mobile web edit |
Removed pointless table. Renaming numbers is silly. Tags: Reverted Visual edit: Switched |
||
| Line 12: | Line 12: | ||
Temperaments where the image of 3/2 is a whole number of ploids are called '''acot'''. | Temperaments where the image of 3/2 is a whole number of ploids are called '''acot'''. | ||
== Properties == | == Properties == | ||
Revision as of 22:48, 12 May 2026
The ploidacot system is a classification of rank-2 temperaments based on how a temperament can be thought of as a union of copies of Pythagorean tuning. It is similar to the pergen, and is a canonical naming scheme for pergens of rank-2 temperaments of the 2.3.… subgroup in that every such pergen corresponds to a unique name in the ploidacot system.
The ploidacot system was developed by Praveen Venkataramana.
Specification
Ploids
Any rank-2 temperament of the 2.3.… subgroup has an octave, and it may split the octave into a number of parts, or periods, called ploids. The temperament's number of ploids per octave is specified by a Greek numeral prefix (di-, tri-, etc.) and -ploid. For instance, pajara divides the octave into two, so it is diploid. Temperaments that do not divide the octave are called haploid (not *monoploid), which can be omitted.
Cots
If 3/2 is represented by a linearly independent element to the ploid, there is a number of ploids which when added to 3/2 gives the interval which is split into the largest number of parts, namely generators, by the temperament. Each of these parts is called a cot or cotyledon. The ploidacot system uses Greek letters (alpha-, beta-, etc.) to describe the smallest nonnegative number of ploids that should be added to 3/2 to form a whole number of cots. If the number is zero, it is left empty. The number of cots is then indicated by a Greek numeral prefix. Temperaments that do not divide the fifth are called monocot (not *haplocot). The full specification of cots is thus a (possibly empty) Greek letter prefix, followed by a Greek numeral prefix, and -cot.
Temperaments where the image of 3/2 is a whole number of ploids are called acot.
Properties
- For n-cot systems there are exactly n settings of shear, or number of ploids to add to the step that represents the interval class of 3. The possible values of shear are 0, 1, 2, …, (n − 1). For example, the tricot systems are tricot (0-sheared), alpha-tricot (1-sheared), and beta-tricot (2-sheared). There is not a *gamma-tricot since that would be equivalent to tricot.
Extensions
Omega extension
The Greek letter omega, proposed by Godtone, is used for −1. ("Contra" has also been used in place of omega.) This simplifies the classification of certain temperaments, e.g. porcupine, which instead of beta-tricot can be omega-tricot, as splitting the interval 4/3 into three is arguably more intuitive than splitting the interval 6. This effectively shifts the possible values of shear to -1, 0, 1, …, (n − 2) if n ≥ 3.
Note that omega should only be used with n ≥ 3. When n = 1, there is only monocot. When n = 2, alpha-dicot is preferred over omega-dicot. Omega-based names are also not preferred when dealing with temperaments that split the octave, as they may be confusing - for instance, diploid alpha-tricot splits 4/3 in three while diploid beta-tricot splits 3/1 in three.
No-twos or no-threes temperaments
The ploidacot system, similarly to pergens, relies on the presence of a 3-limit, i.e. 2.3 subgroup, spine, but its defining principles can be easily applied to a 2.5, 3.5, 3.7, etc. spine instead, and in the case of ploidacot, the "cot" suffix is simply replaced with a different suffix indicating the family of intervals being cloven. The existing extensions are "seph" for 5/4 with octave equivalence, and "gem" for 7/3 with tritave equivalence (note that 3.7 is preferred over 3.5 since 9/7 and 7/3 generate a much more commonly used structure in tritave systems, i.e. Lambda, than 5/3 and 9/5).
For instance, in the 2.5.7 subgroup, didacus can be labeled as "diseph", because its generator divides 5/4 in two, and llywelyn can be labeled as "alpha-heptaseph" because seven generators make up 5/2. In the tritave world, BPS (3.5.7) is "monogem" as its generator is 9/7, while mintaka (3.7.11) is alpha-trigem as its generator (of ~21/11) splits 7/1 in three.
Even if 3 is included in a given temperament, the ploidaseph framework may occasionally be more useful than the ploidacot framework, in cases where the mapping of 3 is very complex and the structure of the temperament therefore deprioritizes prime 3. Hemiwürschmidt, a strong extension of the aforementioned didacus, has a ploidacot of beta-hexadecacot as it divides 6/1 into sixteen generators; while trismegistus has a ploidacot of epsilon-pentadecacot as it maps 96/1 to fifteen generators. Each of these has a more intuitizable expression in terms of 2.5 intervals, which are much simpler in the respective temperaments: hemiwürschmidt is diseph and trismegistus is alpha-triseph (one-third 5/2).
Combining ploidacots and ploidasephs determines its 5-limit properties; for instance, meantone can be labeled as "monocot beta-tetraseph" because four generators make up 5/1 while the generator represents 3/2, and valentine can be labeled as "enneacot pentaseph" because five generators make up 5/4 and nine of them make up 3/2.
Examples
The ploidacots of most common temperaments can be intuitively derived from a basic understanding of its mapping. Meantone and helmholtz are monocot since they have a period of a whole octave and are generated by the perfect fifth. Dicot is dicot since it has a period of a whole octave and splits the perfect fifth in two. Semaphore has a period of a whole octave and splits the perfect twelfth in two. It requires one period to add to the fifth to make it a twelfth, and one is alpha. So it is alpha-dicot.
For a more complex example, let us consider sensi and its weak extension bison. Sensi splits 6/1 in seven. It requires two periods to the fifth to reach 6/1, and two is beta. So it is beta-heptacot. Bison splits the period of sensi in two. As a result, it now requires four periods to the fifth to reach 6/1, and four is delta. So it is diploid delta-heptacot.
Below is a list of ploidacots for common temperaments
- Meantone and helmholtz are haploid monocot
- Mohajira and dicot are dicot
- Bug and semaphore are alpha-dicot
- Shrutar is diploid alpha-dicot
- Ennealimmal is enneaploid dicot
- Hemiennealimmal is octodecaploid (18-ploid) dicot
- Slendric, mothra, and rodan are tricot
- Alphatricot is alpha-tricot
- Porcupine is beta-tricot
- Hedgehog is diploid alpha-tricot
- Tetracot is tetracot
- Squares is beta-tetracot
- Bleu is pentacot
- Magic is alpha-pentacot
- Amity is gamma-pentacot
- Miracle is hexacot
- Hanson is alpha-hexacot
- Harry is diploid delta-hexacot
- Orwell is alpha-heptacot
- Sensi is beta-heptacot
- Vishnu is diploid epsilon-heptacot
- Octacot is octacot
- Würschmidt is beta-octacot
- Valentine is enneacot
- Sycamore is hendecacot
- Chromo is tridecacot
- Pajara and injera are diploid
- Antitonic is diploid acot
- Augene is triploid
- Diminished is tetraploid
- Blackwood is pentaploid acot
- Whitewood is heptaploid acot
- Compton is dodecaploid acot
Notation
- TODO: Come up with canonical ups and downs notation systems for pergen squares
List of ploidacots
Acot
- Pentaploid acot (blackwood, 5edo)
- Heptaploid acot (whitewood, 7edo)
- Dodecaploid acot (compton, 12edo)
Monocot
- Monocot
- Diploid monocot
- Triploid monocot
- Tetraploid monocot
- Pentaploid monocot
- Hexaploid monocot
- Heptaploid monocot
Dicot
Tricot
- Tricot
- Alpha-tricot
- Omega-tricot
- Diploid tricot
- Diploid alpha-tricot
- Diploid beta-tricot
- Triploid tricot
Tetracot
Pentacot
Hexacot
Heptacot
Octacot
Enneacot
Decacot
>10 cots
See also
- Wedgie – a mathematical generalization of the concept of ploidacots that uniquely characterizes a temperament