Ploidacot/Alpha-dicot

From Xenharmonic Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Alpha-dicot is a temperament archetype where the generator is a semitwelfth, two of which make a perfect twelfth of 3/1, and the period is a 2/1 octave. Equivalently, the generator could be a semifourth, two of which make a 4/3, so omega-dicot means the same thing and is unused.

Alpha-dicot temperaments usually generate the 5L 4s MOS structure, named "semiquartal" after the semifourth generator, as well as the child scale 5L 9s. Alpha-dicot temperaments tend to involve interseptimal intervals, which are in between conventional diatonic intervals.

Intervals and notation

Alpha-dicot notation is complicated as it conventionally requires either the introduction of new "hemipythagorean" ordinals or the use of scales other than the standard diatonic scale. As such, there is no universally accepted convention. Note and interval names are provided where alpha-dicot intervals align with standard monocot intervals (which use Chain-of-fifths notation).

Alpha-dicot intervals (assuming pure octave and fifth)
# Cents Notation Name
-9 1041.2025
-8 792.18 Ab minor sixth
-7 543.1575
-6 294.135 Eb minor third
-5 45.1125
-4 996.09 Bb minor seventh
-3 747.0675
-2 498.045 F perfect fourth
-1 249.0225
0 0 C perfect unison
1 950.9775
2 701.955 G perfect fifth
3 452.9325
4 203.91 D major second
5 1154.8875
6 905.865 A major sixth
7 656.8425
8 407.82 E major third
9 158.7975

Temperament interpretations

By definition, alpha-dicot temperaments equate some interval to its twelfth complement, and so some other interval to its fourth complement.

In order of accuracy, we have bug (a clear exotemperament), semaphore (borderline) and barbados (awkward subgroup, but accurate).

Bug

Bug is an exotemperament, equating the semitwelfth generator to 5/3. This means that 9/5 is the same interval (tempering out 27/25), and the semifourth represents both 6/5 and 10/9. This is clearly badly inaccurate, but is probably the best 5-limit interpretation of this ploidacot.

The best tunings tend to be around 940 ¢ for the semitwelfth, with a somewhat flat twelfth. This sets the semifourth to 260 ¢, which is close to 7/6.

Semaphore

Given that bug sets the semifourth close to 7/6, what happens if it is set equal to 7/6 in the 2.3.7 subgroup? Then, it is equated to 8/7, and 49/48 is tempered out. The semitwelfth is equated to 12/7 and 7/4. This is still an inaccurate temperament, but is on the edge as to whether it counts as exo.

The best tunings tend to be around 950 ¢ here, with a far more accurate twelfth. But, just like how bug's semifourth generator was close to 7/6, this is close to 26/15.

Barbados

Here, the generator actually is 26/15, equated with 45/26. This is an accurate temperament, tempering out the unnoticeable comma of 676/675, but it is defined in the awkward 2.3.13/5 subgroup. The semifourth here is 15/13~52/45.

As the comma is so small, the best tunings are close to just. The semitwelfth is around 951 ¢, leading to a near-just twelfth.