Xenharmonic Wiki:Things to do: Difference between revisions

Line 165:

It seems the proposal for making the temperament material more accessible has failed. It might be better for pages intended for a general audience to be as isolated as possible from the temperament pages.

'''~~Proposals~~:'''

'''Proposal:''' On a page intended to be read by a general audience and those unfamiliar with RTT, such as pages about MOS patterns,

~~# Pages~~ intended to be read by a general audience and those unfamiliar with RTT, such as MOS ~~pages~~, should not ~~mention a temperament~~ at all, unless the temperament has been used in at least 20 compositions (for example, a 1L6s MOS in a porcupine tuning, or pumps the porcupine comma). Pages on which this temperament restriction policy is active should be clearly marked for editors.

# A temperament should not be mentioned at all, unless the temperament has been used in at least 20 compositions (for example, a 1L6s MOS in a porcupine tuning, or pumps the porcupine comma). Pages on which this temperament restriction policy is active should be clearly marked for editors.

#* When linking to a temperament name, it should link to a page describing the temperament for a general audience, not a technical temperament entry.

# When linking to a temperament name, it should link to a page describing the temperament for a general audience, not a technical temperament entry.

# <s>The same threshold should apply for creating a temperament page.</s>

@@ Line 165: / Line 165: @@
 It seems the proposal for making the temperament material more accessible has failed. It might be better for pages intended for a general audience to be as isolated as possible from the temperament pages.
-'''Proposals:'''
+'''Proposal:''' On a page intended to be read by a general audience and those unfamiliar with RTT, such as pages about MOS patterns,
-# Pages intended to be read by a general audience and those unfamiliar with RTT, such as MOS pages, should not mention a temperament at all, unless the temperament has been used in at least 20 compositions (for example, a 1L6s MOS in a porcupine tuning, or pumps the porcupine comma). Pages on which this temperament restriction policy is active should be clearly marked for editors.
+# A temperament should not be mentioned at all, unless the temperament has been used in at least 20 compositions (for example, a 1L6s MOS in a porcupine tuning, or pumps the porcupine comma). Pages on which this temperament restriction policy is active should be clearly marked for editors.
-#* When linking to a temperament name, it should link to a page describing the temperament for a general audience, not a technical temperament entry.
+# When linking to a temperament name, it should link to a page describing the temperament for a general audience, not a technical temperament entry.
 # <s>The same threshold should apply for creating a temperament page.</s>