Odd prime sum limit: Difference between revisions
Cleanup; +category |
Comparison |
||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
This concept was noted by [[User:Tristanbay|Tristan Bay]] as a way to measure how accurately an [[edo]] approximates just intonation with lower primes weighted more heavily. Specifically, the idea is to use OPSLs as an alternative metric for [[consistency|consistency limit]] either instead of or alongside [[odd limit]]s. | This concept was noted by [[User:Tristanbay|Tristan Bay]] as a way to measure how accurately an [[edo]] approximates just intonation with lower primes weighted more heavily. Specifically, the idea is to use OPSLs as an alternative metric for [[consistency|consistency limit]] either instead of or alongside [[odd limit]]s. | ||
== Comparison with odd limit == | |||
The 1- and 2-odd-prime-sum-limit are equivalent to the [[1-odd-limit]], which only contains a single interval pair {[[1/1]], [[2/1]]}. The 3- and 4-odd-prime-sum-limit are equivalent to the [[3-odd-limit]], which adds {[[3/2]], [[4/3]]}. All edos are consistent in those limits. | |||
The 5-odd-prime-sum-limit adds {[[5/4]], [[8/5]]} without {[[5/3]], [[6/5]]} from the [[5-odd-limit]], so it is the first OPSL that differs from the corresponding odd limit. The 6-odd-prime-sum-limit adds {[[9/8]], [[16/9]]}. The 7-odd-prime-sum-limit adds {[[7/4]], [[8/7]]} without {[[7/6]], [[12/7]]}, and the 8-odd-prime-sum-limit adds {5/3, 6/5} as well as {[[15/8]], [[16/15]]}. The 9-odd-prime-sum-limit adds {[[27/16]], [[32/27]]}, and the 10-odd-prime-sum-limit adds {7/6, 12/7}, {[[21/16]], [[32/21]]}, and {[[25/16]], [[32/25]]}. The 11-odd-prime-sum-limit adds {[[11/8]], [[16/11]]}, {[[9/5]], [[10/9]]}, and {[[45/32]], [[64/45]]}. The 12-odd-prime-sum-limit adds {[[7/5]], [[10/7]]}, {[[35/32]], [[64/35]]} and {[[81/64]], [[128/81]]}. | |||
== Minimal OPSL-consistent edos == | == Minimal OPSL-consistent edos == | ||
Revision as of 07:31, 28 April 2024
The n-odd-prime-sum-limit (abbreviated n-OPSL) is the collection of all just ratios with a no-twos Wilson height that does not exceed the integer n.
This concept was noted by Tristan Bay as a way to measure how accurately an edo approximates just intonation with lower primes weighted more heavily. Specifically, the idea is to use OPSLs as an alternative metric for consistency limit either instead of or alongside odd limits.
Comparison with odd limit
The 1- and 2-odd-prime-sum-limit are equivalent to the 1-odd-limit, which only contains a single interval pair {1/1, 2/1}. The 3- and 4-odd-prime-sum-limit are equivalent to the 3-odd-limit, which adds {3/2, 4/3}. All edos are consistent in those limits.
The 5-odd-prime-sum-limit adds {5/4, 8/5} without {5/3, 6/5} from the 5-odd-limit, so it is the first OPSL that differs from the corresponding odd limit. The 6-odd-prime-sum-limit adds {9/8, 16/9}. The 7-odd-prime-sum-limit adds {7/4, 8/7} without {7/6, 12/7}, and the 8-odd-prime-sum-limit adds {5/3, 6/5} as well as {15/8, 16/15}. The 9-odd-prime-sum-limit adds {27/16, 32/27}, and the 10-odd-prime-sum-limit adds {7/6, 12/7}, {21/16, 32/21}, and {25/16, 32/25}. The 11-odd-prime-sum-limit adds {11/8, 16/11}, {9/5, 10/9}, and {45/32, 64/45}. The 12-odd-prime-sum-limit adds {7/5, 10/7}, {35/32, 64/35} and {81/64, 128/81}.
Minimal OPSL-consistent edos
| OPSL | Smallest Consistent Edo* |
|---|---|
| 1 | 1 |
| 2 | 1 |
| 3 | 1 |
| 4 | 1 |
| 5 | 3 |
| 6 | 3 |
| 7 | 5 |
| 8 | 12 |
| 9 | 12 |
| 10 | 12 |
| 11 | 31 |
| 12 | 72 |
| 13 | 72 |
| 14 | 130 |
| 15 | 270 |
| 16 | 270 |
| 17 | 954 |
| 18 | 1236 |
| 19 | 1578 |
| 20 | 1578 |
| 21 | 3395 |
| 22 | 3395 |
| 23 | 6079 |
| 24 | 8539 |
| 25 | 8539 |
| 26 | 8539 |
| 27 | 8539 |
| 28 | 102557 |
| 29 | 102557 |
| 30 | 102557 |
| 31 | 102557 |
| 32 | 102557 |
| 33 | 258008 |
| 34 | 258008 |
| 35 | 258008 |
| 36 | 258008 |
*apart from 0edo