Xenharmonic Wiki:Cross-platform dialogue: Difference between revisions

Line 210:

::: I'd just like to note I'm very happy with KE, my feeling is that for low-accuracy temperaments CTE doesn't weight p/q over pq enough but POTE seems to overdo it, so it's very favourable that KE seems to be close to POTE but slightly in the CTE direction. Hopefully KE will continue this trend upon analysis in higher limits with various subgroups. (Not that I don't like CTE, I personally have generally liked the CTE tuning a lot for mid-to-high-accuracy temperaments, EG I think its tuning of meantone as ~2/9-comma (between 1/4 and 1/5) makes sense.) --[[User:Godtone|Godtone]] ([[User talk:Godtone|talk]]) 21:08, 19 March 2024 (UTC)

:::: I have made a table comparing some high-limit temperaments (specifically the ones Mike named) as well as some subgroup temperaments in POTE, KE and CTE. The same trend seems to continue, as all the tunings are in between POTE and CTE, and most of them lean closer to POTE.

:::: I have made a table comparing some high-limit temperaments (specifically the ones Mike named) as well as some subgroup temperaments in POTE, KE and CTE. The same trend seems to continue, as all the KE tunings are in between POTE and CTE, and most of them lean closer to POTE.

OptimalTuningSubgroupAndHighLim.png|Comparison of POTE, KE, CTE generators for high limit & subgroup temperaments

@@ Line 210: / Line 210: @@
 ::: I'd just like to note I'm very happy with KE, my feeling is that for low-accuracy temperaments CTE doesn't weight p/q over pq enough but POTE seems to overdo it, so it's very favourable that KE seems to be close to POTE but slightly in the CTE direction. Hopefully KE will continue this trend upon analysis in higher limits with various subgroups. (Not that I don't like CTE, I personally have generally liked the CTE tuning a lot for mid-to-high-accuracy temperaments, EG I think its tuning of meantone as ~2/9-comma (between 1/4 and 1/5) makes sense.) --[[User:Godtone|Godtone]] ([[User talk:Godtone|talk]]) 21:08, 19 March 2024 (UTC)
-:::: I have made a table comparing some high-limit temperaments (specifically the ones Mike named) as well as some subgroup temperaments in POTE, KE and CTE. The same trend seems to continue, as all the tunings are in between POTE and CTE, and most of them lean closer to POTE.
+:::: I have made a table comparing some high-limit temperaments (specifically the ones Mike named) as well as some subgroup temperaments in POTE, KE and CTE. The same trend seems to continue, as all the KE tunings are in between POTE and CTE, and most of them lean closer to POTE.
 <gallery>
 OptimalTuningSubgroupAndHighLim.png|Comparison of POTE, KE, CTE generators for high limit & subgroup temperaments