9edo: Difference between revisions

Line 33:

Here the characterizations are taken from [[Scala]], which also describes the scale itself as "Pelog Nawanada: Sunda". Chords such as {{dash|1/1, 7/6, 49/36, 12/7|med}} are therefore natural ones for 9edo. The above scale generates the [[just intonation subgroup]] 2.27/25.7/3, which is closely related to 9edo.

9edo has very little to offer in terms of accuracy for harmonics. Most other systems that lack good perfect fifths such as [[6edo]], [[11edo]], [[13edo]] and [[18edo]] at least contain a reasonable approximation of 9/8 (or (3/2)<sup>2</sup>), so they can be viewed as temperaments in subgroups like 2.9.5 and 2.9.7. 9edo, on the other hand, completely misses both 3/2 and 9/8. You could then try to treat 9edo as an entirely no-threes system without any 3/2 or 9/8, in a subgroup like 2.5.7.11, but even here 9edo performs somewhat poorly, because its best [[7/4]] is much closer to 12/7 and is off by 36 cents, while its best [[11/8]] is off by 18 cents. The 13th harmonic is also entirely missed by 9edo~~. This being said, 9edo does approximate [[47/32]] to within about 1.2 cents~~.

9edo has very little to offer in terms of accuracy for harmonics. Most other systems that lack good perfect fifths such as [[6edo]], [[11edo]], [[13edo]] and [[18edo]] at least contain a reasonable approximation of 9/8 (or (3/2)<sup>2</sup>), so they can be viewed as temperaments in subgroups like 2.9.5 and 2.9.7. 9edo, on the other hand, completely misses both 3/2 and 9/8. You could then try to treat 9edo as an entirely no-threes system without any 3/2 or 9/8, in a subgroup like 2.5.7.11, but even here 9edo performs somewhat poorly, because its best [[7/4]] is much closer to 12/7 and is off by 36 cents, while its best [[11/8]] is off by 18 cents. The 13th harmonic is also entirely missed by 9edo.

9edo's fifth ~~of 5\9 is~~ near the boundary of "perfect fifth" and "subfifth" so it sounds quite dirty but still recognizable.

This being said, 9edo's fifth does approximate [[47/32]] to within about 1.2 cents, and remains near enough the boundary of [[perfect fifth]] and [[subfifth]], so it sounds quite dirty but still recognizable. 9 is the first edo to include the [[2L 5s|antidiatonic (2L 5s)]] scale, which this fifth generates as well.

=== Odd harmonics ===

@@ Line 33: / Line 33: @@
 Here the characterizations are taken from [[Scala]], which also describes the scale itself as "Pelog Nawanada: Sunda". Chords such as {{dash|1/1, 7/6, 49/36, 12/7|med}} are therefore natural ones for 9edo. The above scale generates the [[just intonation subgroup]] 2.27/25.7/3, which is closely related to 9edo.
-edo has very little to offer in terms of accuracy for harmonics. Most other systems that lack good perfect fifths such as [[6edo]], [[11edo]], [[13edo]] and [[18edo]] at least contain a reasonable approximation of 9/8 (or (3/2)<sup>2</sup>), so they can be viewed as temperaments in subgroups like 2.9.5 and 2.9.7. 9edo, on the other hand, completely misses both 3/2 and 9/8. You could then try to treat 9edo as an entirely no-threes system without any 3/2 or 9/8, in a subgroup like 2.5.7.11, but even here 9edo performs somewhat poorly, because its best [[7/4]] is much closer to 12/7 and is off by 36 cents, while its best [[11/8]] is off by 18 cents. The 13th harmonic is also entirely missed by 9edo. This being said, 9edo does approximate [[47/32]] to within about 1.2 cents.
+edo has very little to offer in terms of accuracy for harmonics. Most other systems that lack good perfect fifths such as [[6edo]], [[11edo]], [[13edo]] and [[18edo]] at least contain a reasonable approximation of 9/8 (or (3/2)<sup>2</sup>), so they can be viewed as temperaments in subgroups like 2.9.5 and 2.9.7. 9edo, on the other hand, completely misses both 3/2 and 9/8. You could then try to treat 9edo as an entirely no-threes system without any 3/2 or 9/8, in a subgroup like 2.5.7.11, but even here 9edo performs somewhat poorly, because its best [[7/4]] is much closer to 12/7 and is off by 36 cents, while its best [[11/8]] is off by 18 cents. The 13th harmonic is also entirely missed by 9edo.
-edo's fifth of 5\9 is near the boundary of "perfect fifth" and "subfifth" so it sounds quite dirty but still recognizable.
+This being said, 9edo's fifth does approximate [[47/32]] to within about 1.2 cents, and remains near enough the boundary of [[perfect fifth]] and [[subfifth]], so it sounds quite dirty but still recognizable. 9 is the first edo to include the [[2L 5s|antidiatonic (2L 5s)]] scale, which this fifth generates as well.
 === Odd harmonics ===