5L 5s: Difference between revisions

From Xenharmonic Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
← Older editNewer edit →
VisualWikitext
Inthar (talk | contribs)
autopatrolled, emailconfirmed
15,004 edits
mNo edit summary
Inthar (talk | contribs)
autopatrolled, emailconfirmed
15,004 edits
mNo edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
{{User:IlL/Template:RTT restriction}}
{{Infobox MOS
{{Infobox MOS
| Name = pentasymmetric
| Name = blackwood, pentasymmetric
| Periods = 5
| Periods = 5
| nLargeSteps = 5
| nLargeSteps = 5
Line 8: Line 10:
| Pattern = LsLsLsLsLs
| Pattern = LsLsLsLsLs
}}
}}
'''5L 5s''' refers to the structure of octave-equivalent [[MOS]] scales with period 1\5 (one degree of [[5edo]] = 240¢) and generators ranging from 1\10 (one degree of [[10edo]] = 120¢) to 1\5 (240¢). In the case of 10edo, L and s are the same size; in the case of 5edo, s becomes so small it disappears (and all that remains are the five equal L's). There is only one significant harmonic entropy minimum with this MOS pattern: [[Archytas_clan|blackwood]], in which intervals of the prime numbers 3 and 7 are all represented using steps of [[5edo|5edo]], and the generator gets you to intervals of 5 like 6/5, 5/4, or 7/5. Hence from a regular temperament perspective, this MOS pattern is essentially synonymous with blackwood.
'''5L 5s''', '''blackwood''' or '''pentasymmetric''' refers to the structure of octave-equivalent [[MOS]] scales with period 1\5 (one degree of [[5edo]] = 240¢) and generators ranging from 1\10 (one degree of [[10edo]] = 120¢) to 1\5 (240¢). In the case of 10edo, L and s are the same size; in the case of 5edo, s becomes so small it disappears (and all that remains are the five equal L's).
 
The true MOS, LsLsLsLsLs, is always proper because there is only one small step per period, but because there are 5 periods in an octave, there are a wealth of near-MOSes in which multiples of the period (that is, intervals of an even number of steps) are the only generic intervals that come in more than two different flavors. Specifically, there are 6 others: LLssLsLsLs, LLssLLssLs, LLsLssLsLs, LLsLssLLss, LLsLsLssLs, LLsLsLsLss. [[15edo]] is right on the boundary of being [[Rothenberg_propriety|proper]].
 
== Intervals ==
 
{| class="wikitable"
|-
| | Step of 15edo
| | Cent Value
| | Interval Class
| | Guitar Notation
| | Decimal Notation
| | Approximated Ratios
| | Pseudo-Diatonic Category
|-
| | 0
| | 0
| | Unison
| | E
| | 1
| | 1/1
| | Unison
|-
| | 1
| | 80
| | Minor 2nd, Augmented Unison*
| | E#, Gbb
| | 2b, 1#
| | 16/15, 21/20, 22/21, 25/24
| | Minor 2nd
|-
| | 2
| | 160
| | Major 2nd, Diminished 3rd
| | Gb, Ex
| | 2, 3b
| | 10/9, 11/10, 12/11, 15/14
| | Flat Major 2nd
|-
| | 3
| | 240
| | Perfect 3rd, Augmented 2nd, Diminished 4th
| | G
| | 3, 2#, 4bb
| | 7/6, 8/7, 9/8
| | Major 2nd/Subminor 3rd
|-
| | 4
| | 320
| | Minor 4th, Augmented 3rd
| | G#, Abb
| | 4b, 3#
| | 6/5, 11/9
| | Minor 3rd
|-
| | 5
| | 400
| | Major 4th, Diminished 5th
| | Ab, Gx
| | 4, 5b
| | 5/4, 14/11,
| | Major 3rd
|-
| | 6
| | 480
| | Perfect 5th, Augmented 4th, Diminished 6th
| | A
| | 5, 4#, 6bb
| | 4/3, 21/16, 9/7
| | Perfect Fourth
|-
| | 7
| | 560
| | Minor 6th, Augmented 5th
| | A#, Bbb
| | 6b, 5#
| | 7/5, 11/8,
| | Augmented Fourth
|-
| | 8
| | 640
| | Major 6th, Diminished 7th
| | Bb, Ax
| | 6, 7b
| | 10/7, 16/11
| | Diminished 5th
|-
| | 9
| | 720
| | Perfect 7th, Augmented 6th, Diminished 8th
| | B
| | 7, 6#, 8bb
| | 3/2, 32/21, 14/9
| | Perfect Fifth
|-
| | 10
| | 800
| | Minor 8th, Augmented 7th
| | B#, Dbb
| | 8b, 7#
| | 8/5, 11/7,
| | Minor 6th
|-
| | 11
| | 880
| | Major 8th, Diminished 9th
| | Db, Bx
| | 8, 9b
| | 5/3, 18/11
| | Major 6th
|-
| | 12
| | 960
| | Perfect 9th, Augmented 8th, Diminished 10th
| | D
| | 9, 8#, 0bb
| | 12/7, 7/4, 16/9
| | Minor 7th/Supermajor 6th
|-
| | 13
| | 1040
| | Minor 10th, Augmented 9th
| | D#, Ebb
| | 0b, 9#
| | 9/5, 20/11, 11/6, 28/15
| | Sharp Minor 7th
|-
| | 14
| | 1120
| | Major 10th, Diminished Undecave
| | Eb, Dx
| | 0, 1b
| | 15/8, 40/21, 48/25
| | Major 7th
|-
| | 15
| | 1200
| | Undecave ("Octave")
| | E
| | 1
| | 2/1
| | Octave
|}
*Augmented and diminished intervals do not occur in the 10-note MOS scale, but can occur in chromatically-altered MODMOSs.
 
== Chords ==
 
=== Basic Functional Chords ===
All of the familiar triads and tetrads of the diatonic scale are found plentifully in Blackwood[10], which is pretty obvious when you just look at the notes available in the major and minor modes:
 
{| class="wikitable"
|-
| |
| | 1st
| | 2nd
| | 3rd
| | 4th
| | 5th
| | 6th
| | 7th
| | 8th
| | 9th
| | 10th
| | 11-ave
|-
| | Major Mode (cents)
| | 0
| | 160
| | 240
| | 400
| | 480
| | 640
| | 720
| | 880
| | 960
| | 1120
| | 1200
|-
| | Minor Mode (cents)
| | 0
| | 80
| | 240
| | 320
| | 480
| | 560
| | 720
| | 800
| | 960
| | 1040
| | 1200
|}
Looking at this table, one can see approximations to all sorts of functional chords; if it's not immediately obvious, I'll spell it out in the following tables:
 
{| class="wikitable"
|-
| | Diatonic Chord Name
| | Decatonic Name
 
(if different)
| | Tuning (cents)
| | Spelling 1
| | Spelling 2
| | Degrees of Major Mode Found On:
| | Degrees of Minor Mode Found On:
|-
| | Major Triad
| | Same
| | 0-400-720
| | E-Ab-B
| | 1-4-7
| | Odd
| | Even
|-
| | Minor Triad
| | Same
| | 0-320-720
| | E-G#-B
| | 1-4b-7
| | Even
| | Odd
|-
| | Diminished
| | Same
| | 0-320-560
| | E-G#-A#
| | 1-4b-6b
| | Even
| | Odd
|-
| | Sus2
| | Sus3
| | 0-240-720
| | E-G-B
| | 1-3-7
| | All
| | All
|-
| | Sus4
| | Sus5
| | 0-480-720
| | E-A-B
| | 1-5-7
| | All
| | All
|-
| | Major 7th (maj7)
| | Major 10th
| | 0-400-720-1120
| | E-Ab-B-Eb
| | 1-4-7-0
| | Odd
| | Even
|-
| | Minor 7th (min7)
| | Minor 10th
| | 0-320-720-1040
| | E-G#-B-D#
| | 1-4b-7-0b
| | Even
| | Odd
|-
| | Dominant 7th (7)
| | Major 9th
| | 0-400-720-960
| | E-Ab-B-D
| | 1-4-7-9
| | Odd
| | Even
|-
| | Half-Diminished 7th (m7b5)
| | Diminished 10th
| | 0-320-560-1040
| | E-G#-A#-D#
| | 1-4b-6b-0b
| | Even
| | Odd
|-
| | Diminished 7th
| | Diminished 9th
| | 0-320-560-960
| | E-G#-A#-D
| | 1-4b-6b-9
| | Even
| | Odd
|}
 
=== Additional Functional Chords ===
 
{| class="wikitable"
|-
| | Diatonic Chord Name
| | Decatonic Name
 
(if different)
| | Tuning (cents)
| | Spelling 1
| | Spelling 2
| | Degrees of Major:
| | Degrees of Minor Mode:
|-
| | Major 6th (M6)
| | Major 8th
| | 0-400-720-880
| | E-Ab-B-Db
| | 1-4-7-8
| | Odd
| | Even
|-
| | Minor-Major 6th (m6)
| | Minor 9th
| | 0-320-720-960
| | E-G#-B-D
| | 1-4b-7-9
| | Even
| | Odd
|-
| | Diminished(bb3) (Dim(bb3))
| | Sus3-Maj6
| | 0-240-640
| | E-G-Bb
| | 1-3-6
| | Odd
| | Even
|-
| | Double-Diminished (Dim(bb3)(bb5))
| | Sus3-Min6
| | 0-240-560
| | E-G-A#
| | 1-3-6b
| | Even
| | Odd
|-
| | Major-Diminished (Maj(b5))
| | Major-Sus6
| | 0-400-640
| | E-Ab-Bb
| | 1-4-6
| | Odd
| | Even
|}
 
=== Approximate JI Chords ===
The dominant 7th and minor-major 6th are both 7-limit chords (4:5:6:7 and 1/(4:5:6:7), respectively). The diminished triad also approximates 5:6:7. There are no full otonal 11-limit hexads in the 10-note scale, but there are lots of smaller 11-limit chords (otonal and utonal) approximated:
 
{| class="wikitable"
|-
| | Otonal Harmonics
| | Utonal Harmonics
| | Tuning (cents)
| | Spelling 1
| | Spelling 2
| | Degrees of Major:
| | Degrees of Minor:
|-
| | 5:7:9
| | 1/(6:8:11)
| | 0-560-1040
| |
| |
| |
| |
|-
| | 6:7:11
| | 1/(5:8:9)
| | 0-240-1040
| |
| |
| |
| |
|-
| | 6:7:9:11
| |
| | 0-240-720-1040
| |
| |
| |
| |
|-
| | 6:8:11
| | 1/(5:7:9)
| | 0-480-1040
| |
| |
| |
| |
|-
| | 7:8:9, 6:7:8
| | 1/(7:8:9), 1/(6:7:8)
| | 0-240-480
| |
| |
| |
| |
|-
| | 7:10:12
| | 1/(9:11:16)
| | 0-640-960
| |
| |
| |
| |
|-
| | 8:9:11
| | 1/(5:6:7)
| | 0-240-560
| |
| |
| |
| |
|-
| | 8:9:11:14
| |
| | 0-240-560-960
| |
| |
| |
| |
|-
| | 8:11:14
| |
| | 0-560-960
| |
| |
| |
| |
|-
| | 9:10:12:14
| |
| | 0-160-480-720
| |
| |
| |
| |
|-
| | 9:11:16
| |
| | 0-320-960
| |
| |
| |
| |
|-
| | 11:14:16
| |
| | 0-400-640
| |
| |
| |
| |
|-
| | 11:14:16:18
| |
| | 0-400-640-880
| |
| |
| |
| |
|}


The true MOS, LsLsLsLsLs, is always proper because there is only one small step per period, but because there are 5 periods in an octave, there are a wealth of near-MOSes in which multiples of the period (that is, intervals of an even number of steps) are the only generic intervals that come in more than two different flavors. Specifically, there are 6 others: LLssLsLsLs, LLssLLssLs, LLsLssLsLs, LLsLssLLss, LLsLsLssLs, LLsLsLsLss. In the blackwood temperament, these are right on the boundary of being [[Rothenberg_propriety|proper]] (because 1\15 is in the middle of the range of good blackwood generators).
== Diatonic Modal Harmony in Blackwood[10] ==
Because 15edo is not a meantone temperament, and thus does not temper out the syntonic comma of 81/80, the usual 5L2s diatonic scale is not available. In fact, in 15edo the syntonic comma, which is normally only 21.51 cents, is tuned quite wide: it is mapped to one step of 15edo, and is thus 80 cents! However, one can approximate the diatonic scale (or rather, approximate the various untempered 5-limit JI versions of it) using 3 step-sizes—a large whole tone of 240 cents representing 9/8, a small whole tone of 160 cents representing 10/9, and a semitone of 80 cents representing 16/15. Since these non-MOS diatonic scales do not temper out the syntonic comma, they will only have at most five consonant 5-limit triads (unless an 8th note is included in the right place). They may have even fewer, depending on how the steps are permuted (for instance, if the step-pattern 240-240-80-240-160-160-80 is used, only two consonant 5-limit triads are available).
 
However, if one insists on using only the versions of the diatonic scale that have the maximum number of consonant triads available, then it turns out all of these scales will be 7-note subsets of Blackwood[10]. They will also be the most compact arrangement of those five consonant triads possible on the 5-limit triangular lattice, which is just a fancy way of saying those five chords will be maximally connected to each other by common tones. This suggests that one can approach melody in Blackwood[10] by treating it not as one 10-note scale, but as several related 7-note scales, each of which functions like a 5-limit untempered version of the diatonic scale.
 
This approach allows one to apply the usual principles of diatonic tonality and modality, with the caveat that each familiar mode of the diatonic scale will come in two flavors, depending which of the 7 notes one wants to build consonant triads on. The two flavors will share six notes in common, but one of the seven will differ by 81/80 (i.e. one step of 15edo). Interesting relationships do arise if one maintains the tonic but switches through its different modes (i.e. 1 mixolydian to 1 ionian to 1 lydian), and an "extra" mode appears, because of the fact that 256/243 is tempered out (a way to understand 256/243 vanishing in musical terms is that V/V/V/V = IV, unlike in meantone where V/V/V/V = iii). All together, there are 14 modes of the 7-note diatonic to be found in Blackwood[10] if we keep the same tonic, and 20 if we allow alterations of the tonic.
 
== MODMOSes ==
 
=== Single-alteration MODMOSes ===
<span style="line-height: 1.5;">0-160-240-400-480-</span><span style="color: #0000ff; line-height: 1.5;">560</span><span style="line-height: 1.5;">-720-880-960-1120-1200</span>
 
0-80-240-320-480-560-720-800-960-<span style="color: #ff0000;">1120</span>-1200
 
=== Double-alteration MODMOSes ===
<span style="line-height: 1.5;">0-160-240-400-480-</span><span style="color: #0000ff; line-height: 1.5;">560</span><span style="line-height: 1.5;">-720-</span><span style="color: #0000ff; line-height: 1.5;">800</span><span style="line-height: 1.5;">-960-1120-1200</span>
 
0-<span style="color: #ff0000;">160</span>-240-320-480-560-720-800-960-<span style="color: #ff0000; line-height: 1.5;">1120</span><span style="line-height: 1.5;">-1200</span>
 
0-160-240-<span style="color: #0000ff;">320</span>-480-640-720-<span style="color: #0000ff;">800</span>-960-1120-1200
 
0-<span style="color: #ff0000;">160</span>-240-320-480-<span style="color: #ff0000;">640</span>-720-800-960-1040-1200
 
== Scale tree ==


{| class="wikitable"
{| class="wikitable"
Line 156: Line 639:
| style="text-align:center;" |  
| style="text-align:center;" |  
|}
|}
=Music=
[http://micro.soonlabel.com/gene_ward_smith/Others/Roncevaux/Pocahontas_by_Roncevaux_on_SoundCloud___Hear_the_world_s_sounds.mp3 Pocahontas] by [https://soundcloud.com/lois-lancaster/pocahontas Roncevaux (Löis Lancaster)]; Blackwood[10] in 15edo


[[Category:Scales]]
[[Category:Scales]]
[[Category:MOS scales]]
[[Category:MOS scales]]
[[Category:Abstract MOS patterns]]
[[Category:Abstract MOS patterns]]

Revision as of 18:37, 27 March 2021

User:IlL/Template:RTT restriction

↖ 4L 4s ↑ 5L 4s 6L 4s ↗
← 4L 5s 5L 5s 6L 5s →
↙ 4L 6s ↓ 5L 6s 6L 6s ↘ 
┌╥┬╥┬╥┬╥┬╥┬┐
│║│║│║│║│║││
││││││││││││
└┴┴┴┴┴┴┴┴┴┴┘
Scale structure
Step pattern LsLsLsLsLs
sLsLsLsLsL
Equave 2/1 (1200.0 ¢)
Period 1\5 (240.0 ¢)
Generator size
Bright 1\10 to 1\5 (120.0 ¢ to 240.0 ¢)
Dark 0\5 to 1\10 (0.0 ¢ to 120.0 ¢)
TAMNAMS information
Name pentawood
Prefix pentawd-
Abbrev. pw
Related MOS scales
Parent none
Sister 5L 5s (self)
Daughters 10L 5s, 5L 10s
Neutralized 10edo
2-Flought 15L 5s, 5L 15s
Equal tunings
Equalized (L:s = 1:1) 1\10 (120.0 ¢)
Supersoft (L:s = 4:3) 4\35 (137.1 ¢)
Soft (L:s = 3:2) 3\25 (144.0 ¢)
Semisoft (L:s = 5:3) 5\40 (150.0 ¢)
Basic (L:s = 2:1) 2\15 (160.0 ¢)
Semihard (L:s = 5:2) 5\35 (171.4 ¢)
Hard (L:s = 3:1) 3\20 (180.0 ¢)
Superhard (L:s = 4:1) 4\25 (192.0 ¢)
Collapsed (L:s = 1:0) 1\5 (240.0 ¢)

5L 5s, blackwood or pentasymmetric refers to the structure of octave-equivalent MOS scales with period 1\5 (one degree of 5edo = 240¢) and generators ranging from 1\10 (one degree of 10edo = 120¢) to 1\5 (240¢). In the case of 10edo, L and s are the same size; in the case of 5edo, s becomes so small it disappears (and all that remains are the five equal L's).

The true MOS, LsLsLsLsLs, is always proper because there is only one small step per period, but because there are 5 periods in an octave, there are a wealth of near-MOSes in which multiples of the period (that is, intervals of an even number of steps) are the only generic intervals that come in more than two different flavors. Specifically, there are 6 others: LLssLsLsLs, LLssLLssLs, LLsLssLsLs, LLsLssLLss, LLsLsLssLs, LLsLsLsLss. 15edo is right on the boundary of being proper.

Intervals

Step of 15edo Cent Value Interval Class Guitar Notation Decimal Notation Approximated Ratios Pseudo-Diatonic Category
0 0 Unison E 1 1/1 Unison
1 80 Minor 2nd, Augmented Unison* E#, Gbb 2b, 1# 16/15, 21/20, 22/21, 25/24 Minor 2nd
2 160 Major 2nd, Diminished 3rd Gb, Ex 2, 3b 10/9, 11/10, 12/11, 15/14 Flat Major 2nd
3 240 Perfect 3rd, Augmented 2nd, Diminished 4th G 3, 2#, 4bb 7/6, 8/7, 9/8 Major 2nd/Subminor 3rd
4 320 Minor 4th, Augmented 3rd G#, Abb 4b, 3# 6/5, 11/9 Minor 3rd
5 400 Major 4th, Diminished 5th Ab, Gx 4, 5b 5/4, 14/11, Major 3rd
6 480 Perfect 5th, Augmented 4th, Diminished 6th A 5, 4#, 6bb 4/3, 21/16, 9/7 Perfect Fourth
7 560 Minor 6th, Augmented 5th A#, Bbb 6b, 5# 7/5, 11/8, Augmented Fourth
8 640 Major 6th, Diminished 7th Bb, Ax 6, 7b 10/7, 16/11 Diminished 5th
9 720 Perfect 7th, Augmented 6th, Diminished 8th B 7, 6#, 8bb 3/2, 32/21, 14/9 Perfect Fifth
10 800 Minor 8th, Augmented 7th B#, Dbb 8b, 7# 8/5, 11/7, Minor 6th
11 880 Major 8th, Diminished 9th Db, Bx 8, 9b 5/3, 18/11 Major 6th
12 960 Perfect 9th, Augmented 8th, Diminished 10th D 9, 8#, 0bb 12/7, 7/4, 16/9 Minor 7th/Supermajor 6th
13 1040 Minor 10th, Augmented 9th D#, Ebb 0b, 9# 9/5, 20/11, 11/6, 28/15 Sharp Minor 7th
14 1120 Major 10th, Diminished Undecave Eb, Dx 0, 1b 15/8, 40/21, 48/25 Major 7th
15 1200 Undecave ("Octave") E 1 2/1 Octave
  • Augmented and diminished intervals do not occur in the 10-note MOS scale, but can occur in chromatically-altered MODMOSs.

Chords

Basic Functional Chords

All of the familiar triads and tetrads of the diatonic scale are found plentifully in Blackwood[10], which is pretty obvious when you just look at the notes available in the major and minor modes:

1st 2nd 3rd 4th 5th 6th 7th 8th 9th 10th 11-ave
Major Mode (cents) 0 160 240 400 480 640 720 880 960 1120 1200
Minor Mode (cents) 0 80 240 320 480 560 720 800 960 1040 1200

Looking at this table, one can see approximations to all sorts of functional chords; if it's not immediately obvious, I'll spell it out in the following tables:

Diatonic Chord Name Decatonic Name

(if different)

Tuning (cents) Spelling 1 Spelling 2 Degrees of Major Mode Found On: Degrees of Minor Mode Found On:
Major Triad Same 0-400-720 E-Ab-B 1-4-7 Odd Even
Minor Triad Same 0-320-720 E-G#-B 1-4b-7 Even Odd
Diminished Same 0-320-560 E-G#-A# 1-4b-6b Even Odd
Sus2 Sus3 0-240-720 E-G-B 1-3-7 All All
Sus4 Sus5 0-480-720 E-A-B 1-5-7 All All
Major 7th (maj7) Major 10th 0-400-720-1120 E-Ab-B-Eb 1-4-7-0 Odd Even
Minor 7th (min7) Minor 10th 0-320-720-1040 E-G#-B-D# 1-4b-7-0b Even Odd
Dominant 7th (7) Major 9th 0-400-720-960 E-Ab-B-D 1-4-7-9 Odd Even
Half-Diminished 7th (m7b5) Diminished 10th 0-320-560-1040 E-G#-A#-D# 1-4b-6b-0b Even Odd
Diminished 7th Diminished 9th 0-320-560-960 E-G#-A#-D 1-4b-6b-9 Even Odd

Additional Functional Chords

Diatonic Chord Name Decatonic Name

(if different)

Tuning (cents) Spelling 1 Spelling 2 Degrees of Major: Degrees of Minor Mode:
Major 6th (M6) Major 8th 0-400-720-880 E-Ab-B-Db 1-4-7-8 Odd Even
Minor-Major 6th (m6) Minor 9th 0-320-720-960 E-G#-B-D 1-4b-7-9 Even Odd
Diminished(bb3) (Dim(bb3)) Sus3-Maj6 0-240-640 E-G-Bb 1-3-6 Odd Even
Double-Diminished (Dim(bb3)(bb5)) Sus3-Min6 0-240-560 E-G-A# 1-3-6b Even Odd
Major-Diminished (Maj(b5)) Major-Sus6 0-400-640 E-Ab-Bb 1-4-6 Odd Even

Approximate JI Chords

The dominant 7th and minor-major 6th are both 7-limit chords (4:5:6:7 and 1/(4:5:6:7), respectively). The diminished triad also approximates 5:6:7. There are no full otonal 11-limit hexads in the 10-note scale, but there are lots of smaller 11-limit chords (otonal and utonal) approximated:

Otonal Harmonics Utonal Harmonics Tuning (cents) Spelling 1 Spelling 2 Degrees of Major: Degrees of Minor:
5:7:9 1/(6:8:11) 0-560-1040
6:7:11 1/(5:8:9) 0-240-1040
6:7:9:11 0-240-720-1040
6:8:11 1/(5:7:9) 0-480-1040
7:8:9, 6:7:8 1/(7:8:9), 1/(6:7:8) 0-240-480
7:10:12 1/(9:11:16) 0-640-960
8:9:11 1/(5:6:7) 0-240-560
8:9:11:14 0-240-560-960
8:11:14 0-560-960
9:10:12:14 0-160-480-720
9:11:16 0-320-960
11:14:16 0-400-640
11:14:16:18 0-400-640-880

Diatonic Modal Harmony in Blackwood[10]

Because 15edo is not a meantone temperament, and thus does not temper out the syntonic comma of 81/80, the usual 5L2s diatonic scale is not available. In fact, in 15edo the syntonic comma, which is normally only 21.51 cents, is tuned quite wide: it is mapped to one step of 15edo, and is thus 80 cents! However, one can approximate the diatonic scale (or rather, approximate the various untempered 5-limit JI versions of it) using 3 step-sizes—a large whole tone of 240 cents representing 9/8, a small whole tone of 160 cents representing 10/9, and a semitone of 80 cents representing 16/15. Since these non-MOS diatonic scales do not temper out the syntonic comma, they will only have at most five consonant 5-limit triads (unless an 8th note is included in the right place). They may have even fewer, depending on how the steps are permuted (for instance, if the step-pattern 240-240-80-240-160-160-80 is used, only two consonant 5-limit triads are available).

However, if one insists on using only the versions of the diatonic scale that have the maximum number of consonant triads available, then it turns out all of these scales will be 7-note subsets of Blackwood[10]. They will also be the most compact arrangement of those five consonant triads possible on the 5-limit triangular lattice, which is just a fancy way of saying those five chords will be maximally connected to each other by common tones. This suggests that one can approach melody in Blackwood[10] by treating it not as one 10-note scale, but as several related 7-note scales, each of which functions like a 5-limit untempered version of the diatonic scale.

This approach allows one to apply the usual principles of diatonic tonality and modality, with the caveat that each familiar mode of the diatonic scale will come in two flavors, depending which of the 7 notes one wants to build consonant triads on. The two flavors will share six notes in common, but one of the seven will differ by 81/80 (i.e. one step of 15edo). Interesting relationships do arise if one maintains the tonic but switches through its different modes (i.e. 1 mixolydian to 1 ionian to 1 lydian), and an "extra" mode appears, because of the fact that 256/243 is tempered out (a way to understand 256/243 vanishing in musical terms is that V/V/V/V = IV, unlike in meantone where V/V/V/V = iii). All together, there are 14 modes of the 7-note diatonic to be found in Blackwood[10] if we keep the same tonic, and 20 if we allow alterations of the tonic.

MODMOSes

Single-alteration MODMOSes

0-160-240-400-480-560-720-880-960-1120-1200

0-80-240-320-480-560-720-800-960-1120-1200

Double-alteration MODMOSes

0-160-240-400-480-560-720-800-960-1120-1200

0-160-240-320-480-560-720-800-960-1120-1200

0-160-240-320-480-640-720-800-960-1120-1200

0-160-240-320-480-640-720-800-960-1040-1200

Scale tree

Generator Cents Comments
0\5 0
1\30 40
1\25 48
240/(1+pi)
1\20 60
240/(1+e)
2\35 68.57
3\50 72
1\15 80 Blackwood is around here

Optimum rank range (L/s=2/1) for MOS

240/(1+sqrt(3))
3\40 90
5\65 92.31 Golden blackwood
240/(1+pi/2)
2\25 96
3\35 102.86
4\45 103.33
1\10 120

Music

Pocahontas by Roncevaux (Löis Lancaster); Blackwood[10] in 15edo

Retrieved from "https://en.xen.wiki/index.php?title=5L_5s&oldid=64645"