MOS scale: Difference between revisions
ArrowHead294 (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
ArrowHead294 (talk | contribs) mNo edit summary |
||
| Line 76: | Line 76: | ||
Every MOS scale can be ''generated'' by stacking a certain interval called the [[generator]] and octave-reducing (or more generally, [[period]]-reducing). For example, the diatonic scale is generated by stacking 6 fifths (or equivalently, 6 fourths) and octave-reducing to get a 7 note scale. Another example, 2L 3s is generated by stacking 4 fifths to get 5 notes. However, stacking 5 fifths to get a hexatonic scale such as {{nowrap|C D E F G A C}} does not produces a MOS, because there are more than 2 sizes of each interval class. | Every MOS scale can be ''generated'' by stacking a certain interval called the [[generator]] and octave-reducing (or more generally, [[period]]-reducing). For example, the diatonic scale is generated by stacking 6 fifths (or equivalently, 6 fourths) and octave-reducing to get a 7 note scale. Another example, 2L 3s is generated by stacking 4 fifths to get 5 notes. However, stacking 5 fifths to get a hexatonic scale such as {{nowrap|C D E F G A C}} does not produces a MOS, because there are more than 2 sizes of each interval class. | ||
The amount of stacking that produces a MOS scale depends only on the size of the generator relative to the size to the period. For a just fifth and a just octave, the valid scale sizes are 2, 3, 5, 7, 12, 17, 29, 41, 53 | The amount of stacking that produces a MOS scale depends only on the size of the generator relative to the size to the period. For a just fifth and a just octave, the valid scale sizes are 2, 3, 5, 7, 12, 17, 29, 41, 53… However for a quarter-comma meantone fifth, the valid sizes are 2, 3, 5, 7, 12, 19, 31, 50… | ||
== Step ratio spectrum == | == Step ratio spectrum == | ||
| Line 132: | Line 132: | ||
== Properties == | == Properties == | ||
=== Basic properties === | === Basic properties === | ||
* For every MOS scale with an [[octave]] period (which is usually the [[octave]]), if ''x''-[[edo]] is the [[collapsed]] tuning (where the small step vanishes) and ''y''-[[edo]] is the [[equalized]] tuning (where the large (''L'') step and small (''s'') step are the same size), then by definition it is an {{nowrap|''x''L (''y'' − ''x'')s}} MOS scale, and the [[basic]] tuning where {{nowrap|''L'' {{=}} 2''s''}} is thus {{nowrap|(''x'' + ''y'')}}-[[edo]]. This is also true if the period is 1\''p'', that is, 1 step of ''p''-[[edo]], which implies that ''x'' and ''y'' are divisible by ''p'', though note that in that case (if {{nowrap|''p'' > 1}}) you are considering a "multiperiod" MOS scale. | * For every MOS scale with an [[octave]] period (which is usually the [[octave]]), if ''x''-[[edo]] is the [[collapsed]] tuning (where the small step vanishes) and ''y''-[[edo]] is the [[equalized]] tuning (where the large (''L'') step and small (''s'') step are the same size), then by definition it is an {{nowrap|''x''L (''y'' − ''x'')s}} MOS scale, and the [[basic]] tuning where {{nowrap|''L'' {{=}} 2''s''}} is thus {{nowrap|(''x'' + ''y'')}}-[[edo]]. This is also true if the period is 1\''p'', that is, 1 step of ''p''-[[edo]], which implies that ''x'' and ''y'' are divisible by ''p'', though note that in that case (if {{nowrap|''p'' > 1}}) you are considering a "multiperiod" MOS scale. | ||
* More generally, whenever ''px''-[[edo]] and ''py''-[[edo]] are used to define two [[Val|vals]] (usually but not necessarily through taking the [[Patent val|patent vals]]) while simultaneously also being used to define the {{nowrap|''px''L (''py'' − ''px'')s}} MOS scale (where ''p'' is the number of periods per octave), then the ''px'' & ''py'' temperament corresponds to that MOS scale, and adding ''x'' and/or ''y'' corresponds to tuning closer to ''x''-[[edo]] and/or ''y''-[[edo]] respectively. (Optionally, see the below more precise statement for the mathematically-inclined.) | * More generally, whenever ''px''-[[edo]] and ''py''-[[edo]] are used to define two [[Val|vals]] (usually but not necessarily through taking the [[Patent val|patent vals]]) while simultaneously also being used to define the {{nowrap|''px''L (''py'' − ''px'')s}} MOS scale (where ''p'' is the number of periods per octave), then the ''px'' & ''py'' temperament corresponds to that MOS scale, and adding ''x'' and/or ''y'' corresponds to tuning closer to ''x''-[[edo]] and/or ''y''-[[edo]] respectively. (Optionally, see the below more precise statement for the mathematically-inclined.) | ||
* For the mathematically-inclined, we can say that whenever we consider a MOS with ''X''/''p'' notes per period in the [[collapsed]] tuning and ''Y''/''p'' notes per period in the [[equalized]] tuning and ''p'' periods per [[Octave stretching|tempered octave]] (or more generally tempered [[equave]]), and whenever we want to associate that MOS with the {{nowrap|''X'' & ''Y''}} rank 2 temperament'''*''', we can say that any {{w|natural number|natural}}-coefficient {{w|linear combination}} of vals {{val|''X'' | * For the mathematically-inclined, we can say that whenever we consider a MOS with ''X''/''p'' notes per period in the [[collapsed]] tuning and ''Y''/''p'' notes per period in the [[equalized]] tuning and ''p'' periods per [[Octave stretching|tempered octave]] (or more generally tempered [[equave]]), and whenever we want to associate that MOS with the {{nowrap|''X'' & ''Y''}} rank 2 temperament'''*''', we can say that any {{w|natural number|natural}}-coefficient {{w|linear combination}} of vals {{val|''X'' …}} and {{val|''Y'' …}} (where {{nowrap|''X'' < ''Y''}}) corresponds uniquely to a tuning of the {{nowrap|''X'' & ''Y''}} rank 2 temperament between ''X''-[[ET]] and ''Y''-[[ET]] (inclusive) iff {{nowrap|gcd(''a'', ''b'') {{=}} 1}}, because if {{nowrap|''k'' {{=}} gcd(''a'', ''b'') > 1}} then the val {{nowrap|''a''{{val| ''X'' …}} + ''b''{{val| ''Y'' …}}}} has a common factor ''k'' in all of its terms, meaning it is guaranteed to be [[contorted]]. The tuning corresponding to the [[wikipedia:Rational number|rational]] ''a''/''b'' is technically only unique up to (discarding of) [[octave stretching]] (or more generally [[equave]]-tempering). | ||
: The period of this temperament is {{nowrap|1\gcd(''X'', ''Y'')}}, and the rational ''a''/''b'' is very closely related to the [[step ratio]] of the corresponding MOS scale, because {{nowrap|1{{val| ''X'' | : The period of this temperament is {{nowrap|1\gcd(''X'', ''Y'')}}, and the rational ''a''/''b'' is very closely related to the [[step ratio]] of the corresponding MOS scale, because {{nowrap|1{{val| ''X'' …}} + 0{{val| ''Y'' …}}}} is the {{nowrap|''L'' {{=}} 1|''s'' {{=}} 0}} tuning while {{nowrap|0{{val| ''X'' …}} + 1{{val| ''Y'' …}}}} is the {{nowrap|''L'' {{=}} 1|''s'' {{=}} 1}} tuning and {{nowrap|1{{val| ''X'' …}} + 1{{val| ''Y'' …}}}} is the {{nowrap|''L'' {{=}} 2|''s'' {{=}} 1}} tuning, so that {{nowrap|''L'' {{=}} ''a'' + ''b''}} and {{nowrap|''s'' {{=}} ''b''}} and therefore: | ||
: {{nowrap|1/([[step ratio]]) {{=}} ''s''/''L''}} {{nowrap|{{=}} ''b''/(''a'' + ''b'')}} implying {{nowrap|[[step ratio]] {{=}} (''a'' + ''b'')/''b'' ≥ 1}} for [[wikipedia:Natural number|natural]] ''a'' and ''b'', where if {{nowrap|''b'' {{=}} 0}} then the step ratio is infinite, corresponding to the [[collapsed]] tuning.<ref group="note">It is '''important to note''' that the correspondence to the {{nowrap|''X'' & ''Y''}} rank 2 temperament only works in all cases if we allow the temperament to be [[contorted]] on its [[subgroup]]; alternatively, it works if we exclude cases where {{nowrap|''X'' & ''Y''}} describe a contorted temperament on the subgroup given. An example is the {{nowrap|5 & 19}} temperament is contorted in the [[5-limit]] (having a generator of a semifourth, corresponding to [[5L 14s]]), so we either need to consider the temperament itself to be contorted (generated by something lacking an interpretation in the subgroup given, two of which yielding a meantone-tempered [[~]][[4/3]]) or we exclude it because of its contortion.</ref> | : {{nowrap|1/([[step ratio]]) {{=}} ''s''/''L''}} {{nowrap|{{=}} ''b''/(''a'' + ''b'')}} implying {{nowrap|[[step ratio]] {{=}} (''a'' + ''b'')/''b'' ≥ 1}} for [[wikipedia:Natural number|natural]] ''a'' and ''b'', where if {{nowrap|''b'' {{=}} 0}} then the step ratio is infinite, corresponding to the [[collapsed]] tuning.<ref group="note">It is '''important to note''' that the correspondence to the {{nowrap|''X'' & ''Y''}} rank 2 temperament only works in all cases if we allow the temperament to be [[contorted]] on its [[subgroup]]; alternatively, it works if we exclude cases where {{nowrap|''X'' & ''Y''}} describe a contorted temperament on the subgroup given. An example is the {{nowrap|5 & 19}} temperament is contorted in the [[5-limit]] (having a generator of a semifourth, corresponding to [[5L 14s]]), so we either need to consider the temperament itself to be contorted (generated by something lacking an interpretation in the subgroup given, two of which yielding a meantone-tempered [[~]][[4/3]]) or we exclude it because of its contortion.</ref> | ||