Whitewood: Difference between revisions

Line 120:

While blackwood fifths are sharp and thus necessitate the tuning as a whole to be sharp-leaning, whitewood fifths are flat and thus this tuning is generally flat-leaning – targeting individually the [[5-limit|2.3.5-]] or [[2.3.7 subgroup|2.3.7-subgroup]]. Septimal whitewood entails a rather different tuning profile, as the vanishing of 36/35 means 5 and 7 should be tuned somewhat sharp.

Any multiple of [[7edo]], up until [[35edo]], contains 7edo's [[perfect fifth]], and thus supports whitewood, with all but 35edo supporting the canonical 7-limit extension by [[patent val]]. The most extreme tuning is [[14edo]], where up seconds and down thirds are equated, and every interval is either a 7edo interval or halfway between two 7edo intervals. While the 14edo tuning poorly approximates 5-limit intervals, it does approximate the [[6:7:9]] subminor and [[14:18:21|1/(9:7:6)]] supermajor triads fairly well. A less extreme tuning is [[21edo]], tuning [[7/4]] close to just and tuning [[5/4]] to the same 400{{c}} major third as in [[12edo]], though [[6/5]] is still about 30 cents flat. The [[28edo]] tuning has a near-just 5/4, and tunes whitewood about as best as it can be tuned.

Any multiple of [[7edo]], up until [[35edo]], contains 7edo's [[perfect fifth]], and thus supports whitewood, with all but 35edo supporting the canonical 7-limit extension by [[patent val]]. The most extreme tuning is [[14edo]], where up seconds and down thirds are equated, and every interval is either a 7edo interval or halfway between two 7edo intervals. While the 14edo tuning poorly approximates 5-limit intervals, it does approximate the [[6:7:9]] subminor and [[14:18:21|1/(9:7:6)]] supermajor triads fairly well. A less extreme tuning is [[21edo]], tuning [[7/4]] close to just and tuning [[5/4]] to the same 400{{c}} major third as in [[12edo]], though [[6/5]] is still about 30 cents flat. The [[28edo]] tuning has a near-just 5/4, and tunes whitewood about the best it can be tuned harmonically, though the small step of Whitewood[14] shrinks to just 42.9 cents, thus becoming less melodically viable.

=== Norm-based tunings ===

@@ Line 120: / Line 120: @@
 While blackwood fifths are sharp and thus necessitate the tuning as a whole to be sharp-leaning, whitewood fifths are flat and thus this tuning is generally flat-leaning – targeting individually the [[5-limit|2.3.5-]] or [[2.3.7 subgroup|2.3.7-subgroup]]. Septimal whitewood entails a rather different tuning profile, as the vanishing of 36/35 means 5 and 7 should be tuned somewhat sharp.
-Any multiple of [[7edo]], up until [[35edo]], contains 7edo's [[perfect fifth]], and thus supports whitewood, with all but 35edo supporting the canonical 7-limit extension by [[patent val]]. The most extreme tuning is [[14edo]], where up seconds and down thirds are equated, and every interval is either a 7edo interval or halfway between two 7edo intervals. While the 14edo tuning poorly approximates 5-limit intervals, it does approximate the [[6:7:9]] subminor and [[14:18:21|1/(9:7:6)]] supermajor triads fairly well. A less extreme tuning is [[21edo]], tuning [[7/4]] close to just and tuning [[5/4]] to the same 400{{c}} major third as in [[12edo]], though [[6/5]] is still about 30 cents flat. The [[28edo]] tuning has a near-just 5/4, and tunes whitewood about as best as it can be tuned.
+Any multiple of [[7edo]], up until [[35edo]], contains 7edo's [[perfect fifth]], and thus supports whitewood, with all but 35edo supporting the canonical 7-limit extension by [[patent val]]. The most extreme tuning is [[14edo]], where up seconds and down thirds are equated, and every interval is either a 7edo interval or halfway between two 7edo intervals. While the 14edo tuning poorly approximates 5-limit intervals, it does approximate the [[6:7:9]] subminor and [[14:18:21|1/(9:7:6)]] supermajor triads fairly well. A less extreme tuning is [[21edo]], tuning [[7/4]] close to just and tuning [[5/4]] to the same 400{{c}} major third as in [[12edo]], though [[6/5]] is still about 30 cents flat. The [[28edo]] tuning has a near-just 5/4, and tunes whitewood about the best it can be tuned harmonically, though the small step of Whitewood[14] shrinks to just 42.9 cents, thus becoming less melodically viable.
 === Norm-based tunings ===