User talk:Francium: Difference between revisions

Line 53:

* In the hemischis EP did you use more than 53 notes or is it essentially a detuning of 53- or 24-edo? Did you use [[hemischis|hemischis's]] 7-limit intervals or other ones of the 11, 13 and 17 limit and the schismic major third, or did you essentially use some other [[Schismatic family|schismatic]] or [[Semaphoresmic clan|semaphore]] temperament?

Sorry for the disturbance and the hard and potentially disrespectful questions. I don't mean to insult or disrespect you, just to make sure that the temperaments listed at the EP titles indeed represent the music in them. Thanks! [[User:Roeesi|Roeesi]] ([[User talk:Roeesi|talk]]) 13:55, 23 February 2026 (UTC)

: Hello Roeesi, first of all, I have moved your question into a new topic, since I haven't found it immediately and because you were asking about all temperament exploration EPs, not just the tibrepyt one (which in fact is rather a rank-2 tuning than a temperament). I must check all the MOS scales and how exactly I used them, since I don't remember what I did almost three years ago, since my style kinda evolved since then. Plus I can't respond your question all at once, I have to break this huge chunk up into little pieces (I hope that I have the energy to respond for one EP), thus I may need days to fully respond to your catalogue of questions.

: * Gross Temperament EP:

: ** In "I Made A Gross Mistake" I used a 27-tone scale, the 3/2 approximation and the 5/4 approximation are rather bad (with 722.213 cents and 366.136 cents respectively). It sounds like I used a major scale, the intervals I gravitated to, were (in cents) 91.534, 173.009, 366.136, 447.611, 722.212 (which changes to 732.272 cents in the middle of the song for whatever reason in the strings, I guess I didn't realize that I made a mistake at that point), 905.281, 1200.000. Plus passing tones: 183.068, 356.077, 457.670, 539.145, 549.204, 630.679, 640.738, 1006.873, 1088.349, 1098.407. I tried to use a major scale, the underlying chords are C A Dm.

: ** In "Gross Pattern" I used a 13-tone scale, so the approximation of 3/2 is even worse at 742.337 cents, the approximation of 5/4 stays the same at 366.130 cents. Plus I wrote the piece in C minor which the superminor third at 274.598 cents. [[User:Francium|Francium]] ([[User talk:Francium|talk]]) 14:06, 24 February 2026 (UTC)

@@ Line 53: / Line 53: @@
 * In the hemischis EP did you use more than 53 notes or is it essentially a detuning of 53- or 24-edo? Did you use [[hemischis|hemischis's]] 7-limit intervals or other ones of the 11, 13 and 17 limit and the schismic major third, or did you essentially use some other [[Schismatic family|schismatic]] or [[Semaphoresmic clan|semaphore]] temperament?
 Sorry for the disturbance and the hard and potentially disrespectful questions. I don't mean to insult or disrespect you, just to make sure that the temperaments listed at the EP titles indeed represent the music in them. Thanks! [[User:Roeesi|Roeesi]] ([[User talk:Roeesi|talk]]) 13:55, 23 February 2026 (UTC)
+: Hello Roeesi, first of all, I have moved your question into a new topic, since I haven't found it immediately and because you were asking about all temperament exploration EPs, not just the tibrepyt one (which in fact is rather a rank-2 tuning than a temperament). I must check all the MOS scales and how exactly I used them, since I don't remember what I did almost three years ago, since my style kinda evolved since then. Plus I can't respond your question all at once, I have to break this huge chunk up into little pieces (I hope that I have the energy to respond for one EP), thus I may need days to fully respond to your catalogue of questions.
+: * Gross Temperament EP:
+: ** In "I Made A Gross Mistake" I used a 27-tone scale, the 3/2 approximation and the 5/4 approximation are rather bad (with 722.213 cents and 366.136 cents respectively). It sounds like I used a major scale, the intervals I gravitated to, were (in cents) 91.534, 173.009, 366.136, 447.611, 722.212 (which changes to 732.272 cents in the middle of the song for whatever reason in the strings, I guess I didn't realize that I made a mistake at that point), 905.281, 1200.000. Plus passing tones: 183.068, 356.077, 457.670, 539.145, 549.204, 630.679, 640.738, 1006.873, 1088.349, 1098.407. I tried to use a major scale, the underlying chords are C A Dm.
+: ** In "Gross Pattern" I used a 13-tone scale, so the approximation of 3/2 is even worse at 742.337 cents, the approximation of 5/4 stays the same at 366.130 cents. Plus I wrote the piece in C minor which the superminor third at 274.598 cents. [[User:Francium|Francium]] ([[User talk:Francium|talk]]) 14:06, 24 February 2026 (UTC)