User talk:Francium: Difference between revisions

Line 32:

::::* In the helayo EP, does it make more sense to view the scale as a [[hemimeantone]] scale, with a heavy use of the major and minor thirds of -8 and 6 generators respectively and more complex even-generator-count intervals approximating 7- and possibly 11-limit ratios, and also possibly odd-generator-count harmonic intervals that can be interpreted as approximating higher limit ratios, does it make more sense viewing it as what is now called [[helayo]], with harmonic use of the generator as approximating 8/7, 7/6 or both, and with heavy use of the major and minor thirds of 11 and -13 generators respectively, or did you use some combination of the two e.g. using a -8-generator major third and a 1-generator 8/7 as in [[godzilla]], or both the -8 and 11 generator major thirds and what can be interpreted as several contradicting approximations of the 7th harmonic which looks more like a detuned 19-edo? Did you use a MOS with more than 19 notes?

::::* In the edson EP, did you avoid hinting at intervals that aren't in the 2.3.7/5.11/5.13/5 subgroup or is the music more easily interpreted as using a more intuitive tuning such as [[andromeda]] or some tuning from the [[meantone family]]? Did you use more than 29 notes or is it essentially a detuning of 29edo?

::::* In the hemischis EP did you use more than 53 notes or is it essentially a detuning of 53- or 24-edo? Did you use [[hemischis|hemischis's]] 7-limit intervals or other ones of the 11, 13 and 17 limit and the schismic major third, or did you essentially use some other schismic or ~~meantone~~ temperament?

::::* In the hemischis EP did you use more than 53 notes or is it essentially a detuning of 53- or 24-edo? Did you use [[hemischis|hemischis's]] 7-limit intervals or other ones of the 11, 13 and 17 limit and the schismic major third, or did you essentially use some other schismic or [[Semaphoresmic clan|semaphore]] temperament?

:::: Sorry for the disturbance and the hard and potentially disrespectful questions. I don't mean to insult or disrespect you, just to make sure that the temperaments listed at the EP titles indeed represent the music in them. Thanks! [[User:Roeesi|Roeesi]] ([[User talk:Roeesi|talk]]) 13:55, 23 February 2026 (UTC)

@@ Line 32: / Line 32: @@
 ::::* In the helayo EP, does it make more sense to view the scale as a [[hemimeantone]] scale, with a heavy use of the major and minor thirds of -8 and 6 generators respectively and more complex even-generator-count intervals approximating 7- and possibly 11-limit ratios, and also possibly odd-generator-count harmonic intervals that can be interpreted as approximating higher limit ratios, does it make more sense viewing it as what is now called [[helayo]], with harmonic use of the generator as approximating 8/7, 7/6 or both, and with heavy use of the major and minor thirds of 11 and -13 generators respectively, or did you use some combination of the two e.g. using a -8-generator major third and a 1-generator 8/7 as in [[godzilla]], or both the -8 and 11 generator major thirds and what can be interpreted as several contradicting approximations of the 7th harmonic which looks more like a detuned 19-edo? Did you use a MOS with more than 19 notes?
 ::::* In the edson EP, did you avoid hinting at intervals that aren't in the 2.3.7/5.11/5.13/5 subgroup or is the music more easily interpreted as using a more intuitive tuning such as [[andromeda]] or some tuning from the [[meantone family]]? Did you use more than 29 notes or is it essentially a detuning of 29edo?
-::::* In the hemischis EP did you use more than 53 notes or is it essentially a detuning of 53- or 24-edo? Did you use [[hemischis|hemischis's]] 7-limit intervals or other ones of the 11, 13 and 17 limit and the schismic major third, or did you essentially use some other schismic or meantone temperament?
+::::* In the hemischis EP did you use more than 53 notes or is it essentially a detuning of 53- or 24-edo? Did you use [[hemischis|hemischis's]] 7-limit intervals or other ones of the 11, 13 and 17 limit and the schismic major third, or did you essentially use some other schismic or [[Semaphoresmic clan|semaphore]] temperament?
 :::: Sorry for the disturbance and the hard and potentially disrespectful questions. I don't mean to insult or disrespect you, just to make sure that the temperaments listed at the EP titles indeed represent the music in them. Thanks! [[User:Roeesi|Roeesi]] ([[User talk:Roeesi|talk]]) 13:55, 23 February 2026 (UTC)