Harry Partch's 43-tone scale: Difference between revisions

From Xenharmonic Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Keenan Pepper (talk | contribs)
comparison with 41edo
Yourmusic Productions (talk | contribs)
More edo comparisons.
 
(12 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
[[File:Harry Partch Institute-3.jpg|thumb|right|250px|The [[Quadrangularis Reversum]], one of Partch's instruments featuring the 43-tone scale]]  
[[File:Harry Partch Institute-3.jpg|thumb|right|250px|The [[Quadrangularis Reversum]], one of Partch's instruments featuring the 43-tone scale]]  
The '''43-tone scale''' is a [[just intonation]] scale with 43 pitches in each [[octave]]. It is based on an eleven-limit tonality diamond, similar to the seven-limit diamond previously devised by [[Max Friedrich Meyer]]<ref>[http://www.chrysalis-foundation.org/Meyer-s_Diamond.htm "Musical Mathematics: Meyer's Diamond"], ''Chrysalis-Foundation.org''.</ref> and refined by [[Harry Partch]].<ref>Kassel, R. (2001, January 20). Partch, Harry. [https://www.oxfordmusiconline.com/grovemusic/ ''Grove Music Online''].</ref>
The '''43-tone scale''' is a [[just intonation]] scale with 43 pitches in each [[octave]]. It is based on an eleven-limit [[tonality diamond]], similar to the seven-limit diamond previously devised by [[Max Friedrich Meyer]]<ref>[http://www.chrysalis-foundation.org/Meyer-s_Diamond.htm "Musical Mathematics: Meyer's Diamond"], ''Chrysalis-Foundation.org''.</ref> and refined by [[Harry Partch]].<ref>Kassel, R. (2001, January 20). Partch, Harry. [https://www.oxfordmusiconline.com/grovemusic/ ''Grove Music Online''].</ref>


See [[Partch 43]] for the scale as a scala file.
See [[Partch 43]] for the scale as a scala file.


===Ratios of the 11 Limit===
==Ratios of the 11 Limit==
[[File:11-odd-limit_Tonality_Diamond.png|thumb|Circle Digram]]
Here are all the ratios within the [[octave]] with odd factors up to and including 11, known as the 11-limit [[tonality diamond]]. Note that the [[Inversion (interval)|inversion]] of every interval is also present, so the set is symmetric about the octave.
Here are all the ratios within the [[octave]] with odd factors up to and including 11, known as the 11-limit [[tonality diamond]]. Note that the [[Inversion (interval)|inversion]] of every interval is also present, so the set is symmetric about the octave.


Line 31: Line 32:
|}
|}


===Filling in the gaps===
==Filling in the gaps==
[[File:Partch%27s_43_Tone_Scale.png|thumb|Circle diagram. (complete)]]
There are two reasons why the 11-limit ratios by themselves would not make a good scale. First, the scale only contains a complete set of chords ([[otonalities]] and [[utonalities]]) based on one [[tonic (music)|tonic]] pitch. Second, it contains large gaps, between the tonic and the two pitches to either side, as well as several other places. Both problems can be solved by filling in the gaps with "multiple-number ratios", or intervals obtained from the product or quotient of other intervals within the 11 limit.
There are two reasons why the 11-limit ratios by themselves would not make a good scale. First, the scale only contains a complete set of chords ([[otonalities]] and [[utonalities]]) based on one [[tonic (music)|tonic]] pitch. Second, it contains large gaps, between the tonic and the two pitches to either side, as well as several other places. Both problems can be solved by filling in the gaps with "multiple-number ratios", or intervals obtained from the product or quotient of other intervals within the 11 limit.


Line 91: Line 93:


[[Erv Wilson]] who worked with Partch has pointed out that these added tones form a constant structure of 41 tones with two variables.<ref name="Anaphoria">"Letter to John from ERV Wilson, 19 October 1964 - SH 5 Chalmers" (PDF). Anaphoria.com. Retrieved 2016-10-28.page 11</ref> A constant structure giving one the property of anytime a ratio appears it will be subtended by the same number of steps. In this way Partch resolved his harmonic and melodic symmetry in one of the best ways possible.<ref name="Anaphoria" />
[[Erv Wilson]] who worked with Partch has pointed out that these added tones form a constant structure of 41 tones with two variables.<ref name="Anaphoria">"Letter to John from ERV Wilson, 19 October 1964 - SH 5 Chalmers" (PDF). Anaphoria.com. Retrieved 2016-10-28.page 11</ref> A constant structure giving one the property of anytime a ratio appears it will be subtended by the same number of steps. In this way Partch resolved his harmonic and melodic symmetry in one of the best ways possible.<ref name="Anaphoria" />
 
== Comparison with various equal tunings ==
===Comparison with 41edo===
===Comparison with 41edo===
The 43-note scale is almost [[epimorphic]] under the [[41edo]] [[patent val]]. The only exceptions are the pair {11/10, 10/9} and its octave complement {9/5, 20/11}, which are tempered together in [[41edo]]. Other than those, 41edo does a decent job of representing everything, for an EDO (although of course Partch himself would scoff at such a claim).
The 43-note scale is almost [[epimorphic]] under the [[41edo]] [[patent val]]. The only exceptions are the pair {11/10, 10/9} and its octave complement {9/5, 20/11}, which are tempered together in [[41edo]]. Other than those, 41edo does a decent job of representing everything, for an EDO (although of course Partch himself would scoff at such a claim).
Line 182: Line 184:
| 41 || 2/1 || 1200.00 || 1200.00 || 0.00
| 41 || 2/1 || 1200.00 || 1200.00 || 0.00
|}
|}
=== Comparison with 46edo ===
Like 41edo, [[46edo]] maps the 43 note scale to its patent val in a consistent way. However, this time, 12/11 and 11/10 (and their octave compliments) are tempered together rather than 11/10 and 10/9. In addition, several other intervals that are tempered closer together than JI in 41 edo are tempered further apart here, making the scale more uneven sounding in general.
The step sizes in this tuning are: 1 1 1 1 2 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 2 1 1 1 1
=== Comparison with 53edo ===
While [[53edo]] is excellently tuned in the [[5-limit]] and has more than enough steps to represent this scale without conflating any notes, it's poor representation of the 11th harmonic causes problems. Not only are 12/11 and 11/10 once again tempered together, but 14/11 is conflated with 9/7 in the patent val despite actually being closer to 81/64, which would mean only 39 of the scales notes can be cleanly defined under this system. Using the 53e val separates these notes, but now 11/10 and 10/9 are tempered together, which means it also does not cleanly map all 43 notes to different steps.
=== Comparison with 58edo ===
As the first edo that is distinctly consistent in the full [[11-odd-limit]], [[58edo]] is also the first edo that can clearly represent every interval in this scale with no conflations or discrepancies between the patent val and the direct mapping. However, it is strongly sharp trending, which means compound harmonics stack their error, with 33/32 and its octave compliment the worst tuned intervals at 8.8 cents out.
The step sizes in this tuning are: 1 2 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 2 2 1 1 2 1 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 1 2 1 1 2 2 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 2 1
=== Comparison with 72edo ===
Since [[72edo]] is [[distinctly consistent]] in the 11-limit and is a [[pepper ambiguity]] record in the 11-limit unsurpassed until 270, 72edo fits Harry Partch's 43-tone scale very well, with a maximum error of 5.9 cents, with the worst-tuned ratios the result of stacking the compound flatness of multiple 3/2's.
The step sizes in this tuning are: 1 2 2 2 2 1 1 1 2 2 2 1 2 2 2 1 2 2 1 2 2 2 2 2 1 2 2 1 2 2 2 1 2 2 2 1 1 1 2 2 2 2 1
=== Comparison with 270edo ===
In [[270edo]] the step sizes are somewhat more uneven, but far more accurate, with a maximum error of approximately 0.8 cents from JI.
The step sizes in this tuning are: 5 7 7 6 9 3 4 5 6 8 6 5 7 9 7 4 8 6 5 7 7 8 7 7 5 6 8 4 7 9 7 5 6 8 6 5 4 3 9 6 7 7 5
== Music ==
;[[Chris Ranier]]
* [https://chrisrainier.bandcamp.com/album/chris-rainier-sings-the-music-of-harry-partch ''Chris Ranier sings the music of Harry Partch](2024)
;[[The Rasa]]
* [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QwoOxiZRXFA ''Harry Partch's Rose Petal Jam''] (2020)


==References==
==References==
Line 189: Line 225:
*[http://www.chrysalis-foundation.org/Meyer-s_Diamond.htm "Musical Mathematics: Meyer's Diamond"] at ''Chrysalis-Foundation.org''
*[http://www.chrysalis-foundation.org/Meyer-s_Diamond.htm "Musical Mathematics: Meyer's Diamond"] at ''Chrysalis-Foundation.org''


[[Category:Just intonation scales]]
[[Category:Just intonation scales]] [[Category:Harry Partch]] [[Category:11-limit]]

Latest revision as of 11:11, 7 October 2026

The Quadrangularis Reversum, one of Partch's instruments featuring the 43-tone scale

The 43-tone scale is a just intonation scale with 43 pitches in each octave. It is based on an eleven-limit tonality diamond, similar to the seven-limit diamond previously devised by Max Friedrich Meyer[1] and refined by Harry Partch.[2]

See Partch 43 for the scale as a scala file.

Ratios of the 11 Limit

Circle Digram

Here are all the ratios within the octave with odd factors up to and including 11, known as the 11-limit tonality diamond. Note that the inversion of every interval is also present, so the set is symmetric about the octave.

Cents 0 150.6 165.0 182.4 203.9 231.2 266.9 315.6 347.4 386.3 417.5 435.1 498.0 551.3 582.5
Ratio 1/1 12/11 11/10 10/9 9/8 8/7 7/6 6/5 11/9 5/4 14/11 9/7 4/3 11/8 7/5
41edo 0.0 5.1 5.6 6.2 7.0 7.9 9.1 10.8 11.9 13.2 14.3 14.9 17.0 18.8 19.9
Cents 617.5 648.7 702.0 764.9 782.5 813.7 852.6 884.4 933.1 968.8 996.1 1017.6 1035.0 1049.4 1200
Ratio 10/7 16/11 3/2 14/9 11/7 8/5 18/11 5/3 12/7 7/4 16/9 9/5 20/11 11/6 2/1
41edo 21.1 22.2 24.0 26.1 26.7 27.8 29.1 30.2 31.9 33.1 34.0 34.8 35.4 35.9 41.0

Filling in the gaps

Circle diagram. (complete)

There are two reasons why the 11-limit ratios by themselves would not make a good scale. First, the scale only contains a complete set of chords (otonalities and utonalities) based on one tonic pitch. Second, it contains large gaps, between the tonic and the two pitches to either side, as well as several other places. Both problems can be solved by filling in the gaps with "multiple-number ratios", or intervals obtained from the product or quotient of other intervals within the 11 limit.

Cents 0 21.5 53.2 84.5 111.7 150.6
Ratio 1/1 81/80 33/32 21/20 16/15 12/11
Cents 266.9 294.1 315.6
Ratio 7/6 32/27 6/5
Cents 435.1 470.8 498.0 519.5 551.3
Ratio 9/7 21/16 4/3 27/20 11/8
Cents 648.7 680.5 702.0 729.2 764.9
Ratio 16/11 40/27 3/2 32/21 14/9
Cents 884.4 905.9 933.1
Ratio 5/3 27/16 12/7
Cents 1049.4 1088.3 1115.5 1146.8 1178.5 1200
Ratio 11/6 15/8 40/21 64/33 160/81 2/1

Together with the 29 ratios of the 11 limit, these 14 multiple-number ratios make up the full 43-tone scale.

Erv Wilson who worked with Partch has pointed out that these added tones form a constant structure of 41 tones with two variables.[3] A constant structure giving one the property of anytime a ratio appears it will be subtended by the same number of steps. In this way Partch resolved his harmonic and melodic symmetry in one of the best ways possible.[3]

Comparison with various equal tunings

Comparison with 41edo

The 43-note scale is almost epimorphic under the 41edo patent val. The only exceptions are the pair {11/10, 10/9} and its octave complement {9/5, 20/11}, which are tempered together in 41edo. Other than those, 41edo does a decent job of representing everything, for an EDO (although of course Partch himself would scoff at such a claim).

41edo steps Partch ratio(s) Partch cents EDO cents Error (cents)
0 1/1 0.00 0.00 0.00
1 81/80 21.51 29.27 +7.76
2 33/32 53.27 58.54 +5.26
3 21/20 84.47 87.80 +3.34
4 16/15 111.73 117.07 +5.34
5 12/11 150.64 146.34 -4.30
6 11/10, 10/9 165.00, 182.40 175.61 10.61, -6.79
7 9/8 203.91 204.88 +0.97
8 8/7 231.17 234.15 +2.97
9 7/6 266.87 263.41 -3.46
10 32/27 294.13 292.68 -1.45
11 6/5 315.64 321.95 +6.31
12 11/9 347.41 351.22 +3.81
13 5/4 386.31 380.49 -5.83
14 14/11 417.51 409.76 -7.75
15 9/7 435.08 439.02 +3.94
16 21/16 470.78 468.29 -2.49
17 4/3 498.04 497.56 -0.48
18 27/20 519.55 526.83 +7.28
19 11/8 551.32 556.10 +4.78
20 7/5 582.51 585.37 +2.85
21 10/7 617.49 614.63 -2.85
22 16/11 648.68 643.90 -4.78
23 40/27 680.45 673.17 -7.28
24 3/2 701.96 702.44 +0.48
25 32/21 729.22 731.71 +2.49
26 14/9 764.92 760.98 -3.94
27 11/7 782.49 790.24 +7.75
28 8/5 813.69 819.51 +5.83
29 18/11 852.59 848.78 -3.81
30 5/3 884.36 878.05 -6.31
31 27/16 905.87 907.32 +1.45
32 12/7 933.13 936.59 +3.46
33 7/4 968.83 965.85 -2.97
34 16/9 996.09 995.12 -0.97
35 9/5, 20/11 1017.60, 1035.00 1024.39 +6.79, -10.61
36 11/6 1049.36 1053.66 +4.30
37 15/8 1088.27 1082.93 -5.34
38 40/21 1115.53 1112.20 -3.34
39 64/33 1146.73 1141.46 -5.26
40 160/81 1178.49 1170.73 -7.76
41 2/1 1200.00 1200.00 0.00

Comparison with 46edo

Like 41edo, 46edo maps the 43 note scale to its patent val in a consistent way. However, this time, 12/11 and 11/10 (and their octave compliments) are tempered together rather than 11/10 and 10/9. In addition, several other intervals that are tempered closer together than JI in 41 edo are tempered further apart here, making the scale more uneven sounding in general.

The step sizes in this tuning are: 1 1 1 1 2 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 2 1 1 1 1

Comparison with 53edo

While 53edo is excellently tuned in the 5-limit and has more than enough steps to represent this scale without conflating any notes, it's poor representation of the 11th harmonic causes problems. Not only are 12/11 and 11/10 once again tempered together, but 14/11 is conflated with 9/7 in the patent val despite actually being closer to 81/64, which would mean only 39 of the scales notes can be cleanly defined under this system. Using the 53e val separates these notes, but now 11/10 and 10/9 are tempered together, which means it also does not cleanly map all 43 notes to different steps.

Comparison with 58edo

As the first edo that is distinctly consistent in the full 11-odd-limit, 58edo is also the first edo that can clearly represent every interval in this scale with no conflations or discrepancies between the patent val and the direct mapping. However, it is strongly sharp trending, which means compound harmonics stack their error, with 33/32 and its octave compliment the worst tuned intervals at 8.8 cents out.

The step sizes in this tuning are: 1 2 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 2 2 1 1 2 1 1 2 1 2 1 2 1 1 2 1 1 2 2 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 2 1

Comparison with 72edo

Since 72edo is distinctly consistent in the 11-limit and is a pepper ambiguity record in the 11-limit unsurpassed until 270, 72edo fits Harry Partch's 43-tone scale very well, with a maximum error of 5.9 cents, with the worst-tuned ratios the result of stacking the compound flatness of multiple 3/2's.

The step sizes in this tuning are: 1 2 2 2 2 1 1 1 2 2 2 1 2 2 2 1 2 2 1 2 2 2 2 2 1 2 2 1 2 2 2 1 2 2 2 1 1 1 2 2 2 2 1

Comparison with 270edo

In 270edo the step sizes are somewhat more uneven, but far more accurate, with a maximum error of approximately 0.8 cents from JI.

The step sizes in this tuning are: 5 7 7 6 9 3 4 5 6 8 6 5 7 9 7 4 8 6 5 7 7 8 7 7 5 6 8 4 7 9 7 5 6 8 6 5 4 3 9 6 7 7 5

Music

Chris Ranier
The Rasa

References

  1. ↑ "Musical Mathematics: Meyer's Diamond", Chrysalis-Foundation.org.
  2. ↑ Kassel, R. (2001, January 20). Partch, Harry. Grove Music Online.
  3. ↑ 3.0 3.1 "Letter to John from ERV Wilson, 19 October 1964 - SH 5 Chalmers" (PDF). Anaphoria.com. Retrieved 2016-10-28.page 11

Further reading