Lucy tuning: Difference between revisions

From Xenharmonic Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Fredg999 (talk | contribs)
External link
fixed temp links
Line 5: Line 5:
\def\val#1{\left\langle\begin{matrix}#1\end{matrix}\right]}
\def\val#1{\left\langle\begin{matrix}#1\end{matrix}\right]}
</math>
</math>
'''Lucy tuning''' is the [[meantone]] tuning advocated by [[Charles Lucy]], with a fifth of precisely 600 + 300/π = 695.493 [[cent]]s. This is close to the [[88edo]] fifth of 695.455 [[cent]]s, and shares its general characteristics such as being a good tuning for [[meantone family|mothra]] and [[Didymus rank three family|eupterpe]] temperaments, providing a mothra generator, an approximate [[8/7]], of 200+100/π cents, which extends [[5-limit]] meantone Lucy tuning to a version with a mothra (1/3 meantone fifth) generator. As a tuning for 5-limit meantone, it has the softer quality characteristic of the flatter fifth meantones between [[50edo]] and [[19edo]]. It has a major third of 1200/π cents, or 1/π of an octave, 381.972 cents, 4.342 cents flat of [[5/4]], but 2.827 cents sharp of [[1/3-comma meantone]]'s major third.
'''Lucy tuning''' is the [[meantone]] tuning advocated by [[Charles Lucy]], with a fifth of precisely 600 + 300/π = 695.493 [[cent]]s. This is close to the [[88edo]] fifth of 695.455 [[cent]]s, and shares its general characteristics such as being a good tuning for [[Gamelismic clan#Mothra|mothra]] and [[Didymus rank three family#Euterpe|euterpe]] temperaments, providing a mothra generator, an approximate [[8/7]], of 200+100/π cents, which extends [[5-limit]] meantone Lucy tuning to a version with a mothra (1/3 meantone fifth) generator. As a tuning for 5-limit meantone, it has the softer quality characteristic of the flatter fifth meantones between [[50edo]] and [[19edo]]. It has a major third of 1200/π cents, or 1/π of an octave, 381.972 cents, 4.342 cents flat of [[5/4]], but 2.827 cents sharp of [[1/3-comma meantone]]'s major third.


A reasonable mapping for [[11-limit]] extended Lucy tuning would be
A reasonable mapping for [[11-limit]] extended Lucy tuning would be

Revision as of 13:30, 26 March 2025

[math]\displaystyle{ \def\val#1{\left\langle\begin{matrix}#1\end{matrix}\right]} }[/math] Lucy tuning is the meantone tuning advocated by Charles Lucy, with a fifth of precisely 600 + 300/π = 695.493 cents. This is close to the 88edo fifth of 695.455 cents, and shares its general characteristics such as being a good tuning for mothra and euterpe temperaments, providing a mothra generator, an approximate 8/7, of 200+100/π cents, which extends 5-limit meantone Lucy tuning to a version with a mothra (1/3 meantone fifth) generator. As a tuning for 5-limit meantone, it has the softer quality characteristic of the flatter fifth meantones between 50edo and 19edo. It has a major third of 1200/π cents, or 1/π of an octave, 381.972 cents, 4.342 cents flat of 5/4, but 2.827 cents sharp of 1/3-comma meantone's major third.

A reasonable mapping for 11-limit extended Lucy tuning would be

[math]\displaystyle{ \val{1200 & 1800 + \frac{300}{π} & 2400 + \frac{1200}{π} & 3400 - \frac{100}{π} & 4400 - \frac{800}{π}} }[/math]

This tempers out the mothra commas of 81/80, 1029/1024, 99/98 and 385/384. While Charles Lucy himself does not seem to consider the possibility of extending Lucy tuning, it should be noted that the mothra mapping above gives a 7/4 of 1000-100/π, a mere 0.659 cents flat of a just 7/4. Another way to extend Lucy tuning is meanpop:

[math]\displaystyle{ \val{1200 & 1800 + \frac{300}{π} & 2400 + \frac{1200}{π} & 2400 + \frac{3000}{π} & 5400 - \frac{3900}{π}} }[/math]

Since this does not involve splitting the generator into thirds, it is closer to Lucy's 5-limit perspective.

External links