3.5 subgroup: Difference between revisions
CompactStar (talk | contribs) No edit summary Tag: Reverted |
CompactStar (talk | contribs) |
||
| (39 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
The 3.5 subgroup is a [[retraction]] of the [[5-limit]], obtained by removing prime 2. Its simplest [[expansion]] is the [[3.5.7 subgroup]], which adds prime [[7/1|7]]. | The 3.5 subgroup is a [[retraction]] of the [[5-limit]], obtained by removing prime 2. Its simplest [[expansion]] is the [[3.5.7 subgroup]], which adds prime [[7/1|7]]. | ||
If used with [[3/1|tritave]]-equivalence, it is an infinite chain of stacking the classical major sixth [[5/3]] with tritave-reduction, analogous to how [[Pythagorean tuning]] (also known as the 2.3 subgroup or 3-limit) involves stacking [[2 | If used with [[3/1|tritave]]-equivalence, it is an infinite chain of stacking the classical major sixth [[5/3]] with tritave-reduction, analogous to how [[Pythagorean tuning]] (also known as the 2.3 subgroup or 3-limit) involves stacking [[3/2]] with octave-reduction. It can be regarded as an application of the Pythagorean principle (stacking the smallest prime harmonic larger than the [[equave]]) to tritave-equivalence. The 3.5 subgroup is related to tritave-equivalent [[rank-2 temperament]]s generated by ~[[5/3]], such as 3.5.7 [[Arcturus]] and 3.5.11 [[Delta centauri]]. The famous rank 2 [[BPS]] temperament, however, is generated by [[7/3]]. | ||
== EDT approximation == | |||
[[EDT]]s which do relatively well at approximating 3.5 subgroup intervals can be found as the denominators of the convergents and semiconvergents of the {{w|continued fraction}} for the logarithm base 3 of 5. The sequence is equivalent to the numbers of notes per tritave in the [[mos scale]]s generated by a pure 3/1 period and pure 5/3 generator: {{EDTs| 2, 3, 5, 7, 9, 11, 13, 15, 28, 43, 71, 114, 157, 200, 357, 514, 671, 828, 985 … }} | |||
== MOS scales == | == MOS scales == | ||
As it is a [[rank-2]] system, stacking 5/3 with tritave-reduction can produce [[MOS scale]]s, just like how Pythagorean tuning famously produces | As it is a [[rank-2]] system, stacking 5/3 with tritave-reduction can produce [[MOS scale]]s, just like how Pythagorean tuning famously produces a version of the pentatonic, diatonic and chromatic scales. | ||
The non-trivial MOS scales that are produced are: [[2L 1s (3/1-equivalent)|2L 1s<3/1>]], [[2L 3s (3/1-equivalent)|2L 3s<3/1>]], [[2L 5s (3/1-equivalent))|2L 5s<3/1>]], [[2L 7s (3/1-equivalent)|2L 7s<3/1>]], [[2L 9s (3/1-equivalent)|2L 9s<3/1>]], [[2L 11s (3/1-equivalent)|2L 11s<3/1>]], [[13L 2s (3/1-equivalent)|13L 2s<3/1>]], [[15L 13s (3/1-equivalent)|15L 13s<3/1>]], [[28L 15s (3/1-equivalent)|28L 15s<3/1>]], etc. Probably the most practical scales are the 11-note (2L 9s), 13-note (2L 11s), and 15-note (13L 2s) scales. The reason for all of the 2L scales is because 5/3 (884 cents) is quite near √3 (951 cents) (incidentally, this fact is realized by the [[bug]] temperament, and removing octaves from bug results in a 3.5 [[equal temperament]] interpretation of [[2edt]]). All of the scales with less than 11 notes are very hard (lopsided L/s ratio) due to the proximity to 2edt, making them difficult to use melodically, so it's more practical to use an 11-note or higher scale. | |||
The 13-note MOS scale is also called [[Trithagorean]] by Jake Freivald (perhaps could be called Trithagorean[13] to specify, like saying Pythagorean[7] or Pythagorean[12]). | |||
== Generator chain == | |||
<div style="display: inline-grid; margin-right: 25px;"> | |||
{|class="wikitable" | |||
|- | |||
!Number of generators | |||
!Interval | |||
!Cents | |||
|- | |||
|0 | |||
|[[1/1]] | |||
|0.000 | |||
|- | |||
|1 | |||
|[[5/3]] | |||
|884.359 | |||
|- | |||
|2 | |||
|[[25/9]] | |||
|1768.717 | |||
|- | |||
|3 | |||
|[[125/81]] | |||
|751.121 | |||
|- | |||
|4 | |||
|[[625/243]] | |||
|1635.480 | |||
|- | |||
|5 | |||
|[[3125/2187]] | |||
|617.884 | |||
|- | |||
|6 | |||
|[[15625/6561]] | |||
|1502.242 | |||
|- | |||
|7 | |||
|[[78125/59049]] | |||
|484.646 | |||
|- | |||
|8 | |||
|[[390625/177147]] | |||
|1369.005 | |||
|- | |||
|9 | |||
|[[1953125/1594323]] | |||
|351.408 | |||
|- | |||
|10 | |||
|[[9765625/4782969]] | |||
|1235.767 | |||
|- | |||
|11 | |||
|[[48828125/43046721]] | |||
|218.171 | |||
|- | |||
|12 | |||
|[[244140625/129140163]] | |||
|1102.530 | |||
|- | |||
|13 | |||
|[[1220703125/1162261467]] | |||
|84.933 | |||
|- | |||
|14 | |||
|[[6103515625/3486784401]] | |||
|969.219 | |||
|- | |||
|15 | |||
|[[30517578125/10460353203]] | |||
|1853.651 | |||
|} | |||
</div> | |||
<div style="display: inline-grid; margin-right: 25px;"> | |||
{|class="wikitable" | |||
|- | |||
!Number of generators | |||
!Interval | |||
!Cents | |||
|- | |||
|0 | |||
|[[1/1]] | |||
|0.000 | |||
|- | |||
| -1 | |||
|[[9/5]] | |||
|1017.596 | |||
|- | |||
| -2 | |||
|[[27/25]] | |||
|133.238 | |||
|- | |||
| -3 | |||
|[[243/125]] | |||
|1150.834 | |||
|- | |||
| -4 | |||
|[[729/625]] | |||
|266.475 | |||
|- | |||
| -5 | |||
|[[6561/3125]] | |||
|1284.071 | |||
|- | |||
| -6 | |||
|[[19683/15625]] | |||
|399.713 | |||
|- | |||
| -7 | |||
|[[177147/78125]] | |||
|1417.309 | |||
|- | |||
| -8 | |||
|[[531441/390625]] | |||
|532.950 | |||
|- | |||
| -9 | |||
|[[4782969/1953125]] | |||
|1550.547 | |||
|- | |||
| -10 | |||
|[[14348907/9765625]] | |||
|666.188 | |||
|- | |||
| -11 | |||
|[[129140163/48828125]] | |||
|1683.784 | |||
|- | |||
| -12 | |||
|[[387420489/244140625]] | |||
|799.425 | |||
|- | |||
| -13 | |||
|[[3486784401/1220703125]] | |||
|1817.021 | |||
|- | |||
| -14 | |||
|[[10460353203/6103515625]] | |||
|932.663 | |||
|- | |||
| -15 | |||
|[[31381059609/30517578125]] | |||
|48.304 | |||
|} | |||
</div> | |||
== Relationship with the full 5-limit == | |||
The common visualization of the full [[5-limit]] as a 2-dimensional lattice with 3 and 5 as generators can be seen as "3.5 subgroup with octave-equivalence". Every full 5-limit interval has an octave-equivalent [[AOV|all-odd voicing]] which is always contained in the 3.5 subgroup–for example [[5/4]] is not in the 3.5 subgroup, but its all-odd voicing [[5/1]] is. | |||
[[Category:Just intonation subgroups|#]] | |||
[[Category:Rank-2 temperaments|#]] | |||
[[Category:5-limit|#]] | |||
Latest revision as of 07:50, 8 November 2026
The 3.5 subgroup is a non-octave just intonation subgroup consisting of rational intervals where 3 and 5 are the only allowable prime factors, so that every such interval may be written as a ratio of integers which are products of 3 and 5. This is an infinite set. Some examples of intervals in this subgroup are 5/3, 9/5, 27/25, and so on.
The 3.5 subgroup is a retraction of the 5-limit, obtained by removing prime 2. Its simplest expansion is the 3.5.7 subgroup, which adds prime 7.
If used with tritave-equivalence, it is an infinite chain of stacking the classical major sixth 5/3 with tritave-reduction, analogous to how Pythagorean tuning (also known as the 2.3 subgroup or 3-limit) involves stacking 3/2 with octave-reduction. It can be regarded as an application of the Pythagorean principle (stacking the smallest prime harmonic larger than the equave) to tritave-equivalence. The 3.5 subgroup is related to tritave-equivalent rank-2 temperaments generated by ~5/3, such as 3.5.7 Arcturus and 3.5.11 Delta centauri. The famous rank 2 BPS temperament, however, is generated by 7/3.
EDT approximation
EDTs which do relatively well at approximating 3.5 subgroup intervals can be found as the denominators of the convergents and semiconvergents of the continued fraction for the logarithm base 3 of 5. The sequence is equivalent to the numbers of notes per tritave in the mos scales generated by a pure 3/1 period and pure 5/3 generator: 2, 3, 5, 7, 9, 11, 13, 15, 28, 43, 71, 114, 157, 200, 357, 514, 671, 828, 985 …
MOS scales
As it is a rank-2 system, stacking 5/3 with tritave-reduction can produce MOS scales, just like how Pythagorean tuning famously produces a version of the pentatonic, diatonic and chromatic scales.
The non-trivial MOS scales that are produced are: 2L 1s<3/1>, 2L 3s<3/1>, 2L 5s<3/1>, 2L 7s<3/1>, 2L 9s<3/1>, 2L 11s<3/1>, 13L 2s<3/1>, 15L 13s<3/1>, 28L 15s<3/1>, etc. Probably the most practical scales are the 11-note (2L 9s), 13-note (2L 11s), and 15-note (13L 2s) scales. The reason for all of the 2L scales is because 5/3 (884 cents) is quite near √3 (951 cents) (incidentally, this fact is realized by the bug temperament, and removing octaves from bug results in a 3.5 equal temperament interpretation of 2edt). All of the scales with less than 11 notes are very hard (lopsided L/s ratio) due to the proximity to 2edt, making them difficult to use melodically, so it's more practical to use an 11-note or higher scale.
The 13-note MOS scale is also called Trithagorean by Jake Freivald (perhaps could be called Trithagorean[13] to specify, like saying Pythagorean[7] or Pythagorean[12]).
Generator chain
| Number of generators | Interval | Cents |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | 1/1 | 0.000 |
| 1 | 5/3 | 884.359 |
| 2 | 25/9 | 1768.717 |
| 3 | 125/81 | 751.121 |
| 4 | 625/243 | 1635.480 |
| 5 | 3125/2187 | 617.884 |
| 6 | 15625/6561 | 1502.242 |
| 7 | 78125/59049 | 484.646 |
| 8 | 390625/177147 | 1369.005 |
| 9 | 1953125/1594323 | 351.408 |
| 10 | 9765625/4782969 | 1235.767 |
| 11 | 48828125/43046721 | 218.171 |
| 12 | 244140625/129140163 | 1102.530 |
| 13 | 1220703125/1162261467 | 84.933 |
| 14 | 6103515625/3486784401 | 969.219 |
| 15 | 30517578125/10460353203 | 1853.651 |
| Number of generators | Interval | Cents |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | 1/1 | 0.000 |
| -1 | 9/5 | 1017.596 |
| -2 | 27/25 | 133.238 |
| -3 | 243/125 | 1150.834 |
| -4 | 729/625 | 266.475 |
| -5 | 6561/3125 | 1284.071 |
| -6 | 19683/15625 | 399.713 |
| -7 | 177147/78125 | 1417.309 |
| -8 | 531441/390625 | 532.950 |
| -9 | 4782969/1953125 | 1550.547 |
| -10 | 14348907/9765625 | 666.188 |
| -11 | 129140163/48828125 | 1683.784 |
| -12 | 387420489/244140625 | 799.425 |
| -13 | 3486784401/1220703125 | 1817.021 |
| -14 | 10460353203/6103515625 | 932.663 |
| -15 | 31381059609/30517578125 | 48.304 |
Relationship with the full 5-limit
The common visualization of the full 5-limit as a 2-dimensional lattice with 3 and 5 as generators can be seen as "3.5 subgroup with octave-equivalence". Every full 5-limit interval has an octave-equivalent all-odd voicing which is always contained in the 3.5 subgroup–for example 5/4 is not in the 3.5 subgroup, but its all-odd voicing 5/1 is.