User:BudjarnLambeth/Cultural appropriation-o-meter: Difference between revisions
| Line 181: | Line 181: | ||
The name could do a better job of making it clearer than this is not the original mavila tuning. "Avila temperament" does a good enough job of this to get a good star rating, but something that more overtly states that it's not real mavila, like "mavilesque temperament" or "almovila temperament" would push it up to 5 stars. | The name could do a better job of making it clearer than this is not the original mavila tuning. "Avila temperament" does a good enough job of this to get a good star rating, but something that more overtly states that it's not real mavila, like "mavilesque temperament" or "almovila temperament" would push it up to 5 stars. | ||
==== Kartvelian ==== | ==== Kartvelian^ ==== | ||
The inventor of the [[Kartvelian scale]] wrote a lot of dodgy stuff, claiming that his tuning was the exact same one that is actually used in [[Georgian|Georgia]], erasing all the nuances of how Georgian music is actually tuned. If I was rating based on all that, this entry would get 1 star. | The inventor of the [[Kartvelian scale]] wrote a lot of dodgy stuff, claiming that his tuning was the exact same one that is actually used in [[Georgian|Georgia]], erasing all the nuances of how Georgian music is actually tuned. If I was rating based on all that, this entry would get 1 star. | ||
| Line 187: | Line 187: | ||
So, everything else the inventor said about the Kartvelian scale, one star. But the name itself? Four stars! It’s great! | So, everything else the inventor said about the Kartvelian scale, one star. But the name itself? Four stars! It’s great! | ||
==== ^The name is 4 stars, other stuff written about it is 1 star ==== | |||
==== Migration ==== | ==== Migration ==== | ||