User talk:Eliora: Difference between revisions

Line 37:

::: Okay, I'll use the template and I'll monitor upcoming changes.

== About temperaments in edo pages ==

Reviewing your recent edits in the 298edo page, I find it necessary to help you clear up some misconceptions about temperaments.

First, it doesn't make sense to say an edo is "desolate" of temperaments. In fact, every val supports infinitely many temperaments. The only differences are whether they're named or unnamed, documented or undocumented, notable or not notable.

My other note is that you mentioned "31 & 118 & 298d". It should be pointed out that 31 & 118, 31 & 298d and 118 & 298d are the same temperament in the 7-limit but are three distinct temperaments in the 11-limit, with the first branch named as ''hemithirds''. So you should make it clear what you mean by that. If it's the rank-3 temperament 31 & 118 & 298d at least in the 11-limit, "variant" would be a vague choice of term. "Expansion" is a much clearer description for that relation.

Unrelated but FYI: to enter the cent symbol (¢) if you're in visual editor mode, click on the special character button, which depicts a "Ω", sitting on the same line as "save changes", and it should be in the "symbols" section.

[[User:FloraC|FloraC]] ([[User talk:FloraC|talk]]) 14:55, 10 August 2022 (UTC)

@@ Line 37: / Line 37: @@
 ::: Okay, I'll use the template and I'll monitor upcoming changes.
+== About temperaments in edo pages ==
+Reviewing your recent edits in the 298edo page, I find it necessary to help you clear up some misconceptions about temperaments.
+First, it doesn't make sense to say an edo is "desolate" of temperaments. In fact, every val supports infinitely many temperaments. The only differences are whether they're named or unnamed, documented or undocumented, notable or not notable.
+My other note is that you mentioned "31 & 118 & 298d". It should be pointed out that 31 & 118, 31 & 298d and 118 & 298d are the same temperament in the 7-limit but are three distinct temperaments in the 11-limit, with the first branch named as ''hemithirds''. So you should make it clear what you mean by that. If it's the rank-3 temperament 31 & 118 & 298d at least in the 11-limit, "variant" would be a vague choice of term. "Expansion" is a much clearer description for that relation.
+Unrelated but FYI: to enter the cent symbol (¢) if you're in visual editor mode, click on the special character button, which depicts a "Ω", sitting on the same line as "save changes", and it should be in the "symbols" section.
+[[User:FloraC|FloraC]] ([[User talk:FloraC|talk]]) 14:55, 10 August 2022 (UTC)