SN scale: Difference between revisions

(20 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)

Line 1:

~~== Definition ==~~

A '''step-nested scale''', '''SN scale''', or '''SNS''' is a scale generated through iteratively performing the following two moves:

A ~~Step~~-nested scale, or SN scale (or SNS) is a scale generated through iteratively ~~placing an instance of~~

a) A new smaller step at the top or bottom of every existing step, or

a) Add a new smaller step at the top or bottom of every existing step, or

b) ~~The~~ existing smallest step at the top or bottom of every larger step

b) Add the existing smallest step at the top or bottom of every larger step: i.e. replacing '''x''' with '''xs''' or '''sx''' for every occurrence of any step '''x''' such that '''x''' > '''s''' at the current stage, where '''s''' is the current smallest step.

Each iteration of a) ~~increasing~~ the rank of the scale by 1.

Each iteration of a) increases the rank of the scale by 1.

An SN scale of rank 2, a 2-SN scale, is a [[MOS scale]]. Accordingly, SN scales are a generalization of MOS scales into arbitrary rank. [[ET]]~~<nowiki/>~~s ~~can be considered to be~~ 1-SN scales, which can be generated by applying a) once, introducing a step of a single degree of the ET.

An SN scale of rank 2, a 2-SN scale, is a [[MOS scale]]. Accordingly, SN scales are a generalization of MOS scales into arbitrary rank. [[Equal division]]s are rank-1 SN scales, which can be generated by applying a) once, introducing a step of a single degree of the ET.

SN scales are [[chirality|mirror-symmetric]], and may be uniquely defined by a ''step signature'' - a generalization of the MOS signature into arbitrary rank.

==Examples ==

== Examples ==

The diatonic scale can be generated by iterating a) twice, introducing first the octave, then the perfect fifth, and then iterating b) 3 times. It has step signature 5L 2s, and in the symmetric mode, it has step arrangement LsLLLsL. No other arrangement of 5 large and 2 small step sizes results in a SN scale.

~~MET-24~~ can be generated ~~from the diatonic scale~~ by iterating b) ~~once more~~, and then ~~applying a~~)~~, introducing a quarter-tone type step~~. It has step signature ~~5L 12M 7s. A capital~~ 'M' ~~specifies that~~ the ~~size of the medium~~ step ~~is closer to the size~~ of ~~the~~ large ~~step than to the size of the~~ small step~~. A lower case 'm' would specify the converse. We may write the signature alternatively as (5,12,7)~~.

The diatonic scale can be generated by iterating a) twice, introducing first the octave, then the perfect fifth, and then iterating b) 3 times. It has step signature 5'''L'''2'''s''', and in the symmetric mode, it has step arrangement '''LsLLLsL'''. No other arrangement of 5 large and 2 small step sizes results in a SN scale.

The double harmonic scale can be generated by iterating a) three times, introducing first the octave, then the fifth, then the major third, leading to a major seven tetrad, and then applying b) once. It has step signature ~~2L 1M 4s~~, and in the symmetric mode, it has step arrangement sLsMsLs.

{| class="wikitable"

|+ Producing the diatonic MOS via the SNS procedure

|-

! Stage !! Move !! Scale (Cumulative form) !! Smallest step !! Step signature !! Word !! Visualization

|-

! 1

|| a): add '''a'''

|| {1/1, 2/1} || 2/1 = '''a''' || 1'''a''' || '''a''' || {{step vis|53 }}┤

|-

! 2

|| a): add '''b'''

|| {1/1, '''3/2''', 2/1} || 4/3 = '''a''' || 1'''a'''1'''b''' || '''ba''' || {{step vis|31 22}}

|-

! 3

|| b): '''b''' → '''ab'''

|| {1/1, '''4/3''', 3/2, 2/1} || 9/8 = '''b''' || 2'''a'''1'''b''' || '''aba''' || {{step vis|22 9 22}}

|-

! 4

|| b): '''a''' → '''ba'''

|| {1/1, '''9/8''', 4/3, 3/2, '''27/16''', 2/1} || 9/8 = '''b''' || 2'''a'''3'''b''' || '''babba''' || {{Step vis|9 13 9 9 13}}

|-

! 5

|| b): '''a''' → '''ba'''

|| {1/1, 9/8, '''81/64''', 4/3, 3/2, 27/16, '''243/128''', 2/1} || 256/243 = '''a''' || 2'''a'''5'''b''' || '''bbabbba''' || {{Step vis|9 9 4 9 9 9 4}}

|}

MET-24 can be generated from the diatonic scale by iterating b) once more, and then applying a), introducing a quarter-tone type step. It has step signature 5'''L'''12'''M'''7'''s'''. A capital '''M''' specifies that the size of the medium step is closer to the size of the large step than to the size of the small step. A lower case '''m''' would specify the opposite. We may write the signature alternatively as (5,12,7).

The double harmonic scale can be generated by iterating a) three times, introducing first the octave, then the fifth, then the major third, leading to a major seven tetrad, and then applying b) once. It has step signature 2'''L'''1'''M'''4'''s''', and in the symmetric mode, it has step arrangement '''sLsMsLs'''.

For more examples of 3-SN scales, see [[Gallery of 3-SN scales]].

The simplest 4-SN scale is generated by iterating a) 4 times, leading to the scale abacabad. If we map the intervals introduced with a) as 2/1, 3/2, 7/6, and 15/14, we get the scale 15/14 7/6 5/4 3/2 45/28 7/4 15/8 2/1, with step signature (1,2,4,1), mapped to (6/5, 7/6, 15/14, 16/15).

==~~Labeling~~==

== Denoting SN scales ==

Where the [[Meantone]] tempered diatonic scale can be ~~labelled as~~ Meantone[7], we may instead describe it through its derivation as an SN scale through ~~labeling~~ it (2/1, 3/2: 81/80)[7], which specifies that a) introduces the intervals 2/1 and 3/2, and then b) is applied until a 7-note scale is reached, and that 81/80 is tempered out in the scale.

Where the [[Meantone]] tempered diatonic scale can be denoted Meantone[7], we may instead describe it through its derivation as an SN scale through denoting it (2/1, 3/2: 81/80)[7], which specifies that a) introduces the intervals 2/1 and 3/2, and then b) is applied until a 7-note scale is reached, and that 81/80 is tempered out in the scale.

The scale SNS (2/1, 3/2, 5/4: 225/224)[7] describes a [[Marvel]] tempered double harmonic scale, with step signatures (2,1,4) mapped to (~7/6, ~9/8, 16/15~15/14).

MET-24, as a (2.3.7.11.13) Parapyth tempered scale can be ~~labelled~~ ((2/1, 3/2)[12], 28/27~33/32: 352/351, 364/363))[24] (the simplest basis set for commas tempered out is chosen to specify the temperament), with step signatures (5, 12, 7) mapped to (~27/26, 28/27~33/32, ~64/63).

MET-24, as a (2.3.7.11.13) Parapyth tempered scale can be denoted ((2/1, 3/2)[12], 28/27~33/32: 352/351, 364/363))[24] (the simplest basis set for commas tempered out is chosen to specify the temperament), with step signatures (5, 12, 7) mapped to (~27/26, 28/27~33/32, ~64/63).

==~~Further definition~~ ==

== Algorithm ==

The above scales all have a period of an octave - and therefore a) first introduces the interval of an octave, however, the period of an SN scale, as with the mapping of any new smallest step introduced, is arbitrary.

Line 37:

Line 63:

SN scales are based on epi-Christoffel words form combinatorics, which generalize finite Sturmian words. Finite Sturmian words are equivalent to well-formed scales, and equivalently equivalent to MOS scales that are not ''Multi-MOS'' scales, wich are MOS scales of more than one period, typically with a period that divides the octave evenly. The algorithm for generating SN scales introduced above is equivalent to the two epi-Sturmian morphisms that generate epi-Christoffel words.

To find the step arrangement of an ''r''-SN scale for arbitrary step sizes treated as letters of alphabet size ''r'', we iteratively apply the epi-Sturmian moprhism M in which a particular letter from the alphabet is added before each incidence of a different letter. To uncover the order of letters associated with the iterated application of the morphism we follow an algorithm T in which, from incidences (''X''1, ''X''2, ..., ''Xr'' ) of arbitrary letters ''S''1, ''S''2, ..., and ''~~Sr,~~'' respectively, we subtract from the highest incidence value the sum of all other incidence values:

To find the step arrangement of an ''r''-SN scale for arbitrary step sizes treated as letters of alphabet size ''r'', we iteratively apply the epi-Sturmian moprhism ''M'' in which a particular letter from the alphabet is added before each incidence of a different letter. To uncover the order of letters associated with the iterated application of the morphism we follow an algorithm T in which, from incidences (''X''1, ''X''2, ..., ''X''r ) of arbitrary letters '''S1''', '''S2''', ..., and '''Sr''' respectively, we subtract from the highest incidence value the sum of all other incidence values:

Iteratively applying T to (10,5,2) as an example:

Line 43:

Line 69:

(10,5,2)->(3,5,2)->(3,0,2)->(1,0,2)->(1,0,1)->(0,0,1)

~~We list in order the letter with~~ the ~~highest incidence in each~~ step ~~(relabeling~~ ''S''1, ''S''~~2, and~~ ''S''3 as ''a'', ~~''b''~~, ~~and~~ ''~~c'' respectively): ''abacac'' (we arbitrarily treated~~ ''a'' ~~as the largest step in (1,0,1) when we wrote (0,0,1) as the next step~~)

In the last step, since both '''S1''' and '''S3''' have the same incidence value, we can pick either of them to subtract from (in this case, '''S1''').

~~To generate~~ the ~~word~~, ~~we apply M~~''~~abaca~~''(''c'')~~, as in~~

We list in order the letter with the highest incidence in each step (relabeling '''S1''', '''S2''', and '''S3''' as '''a''', '''b''', and '''c''' respectively): '''abacac'''

M''abaca''(''c'') = M''abac''(''ac'') = M''aba''(''cac'') = M''ab''(''acaac'') = M''a''(''babcbababc'') = ''abaabacabaabaabac''.

To generate the word, we apply ''M'''''abaca'''('''c'''). We proceed:

''M'''''abaca'''('''c''') = ''M'''''abac'''('''ac''') = ''M'''''aba'''('''cac''') = ''M'''''ab'''('''acaac''') = ''M'''''a'''('''babcbababc''') = '''abaabacabaabaabac'''.

We can then apply mappings to the step sizes to defined the word as a scale.

If at any point in the application of T a negative number is reached, that combination of step incidences does not correspond to an SN scale. Accordingly, though for rank-2, any possible step signature corresponds to an SN scale, for higher ranks only a small portion of possible step signatures correspond to SN scales. The step signature (2,2,3), for example, does not correspond to an SN scale, as the iterative application of T leads to a negative number, i.e., (2,2,3)->(2,2,-1).

TODO: Prove that this algorithm yields the same result as the first definition given.

== Step-nested differential scales ==

Line 84:

Line 114:

SNDS ((2/1, 3/2)[5], ''x''))[10] - (2/1, 3/2)[5] = SNS (2/1, 3/2)[5] (dipentatonic SNS)

[[Category:~~Step-nested scales|~~ ]] ~~~~

[[Category:Scale]]

[[Category:MOS scale]]

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-== Definition ==
+A '''step-nested scale''', '''SN scale''', or '''SNS''' is a scale generated through iteratively performing the following two moves:
-A Step-nested scale, or SN scale (or SNS) is a scale generated through iteratively placing an instance of
-a) A new smaller step at the top or bottom of every existing step, or
+a) Add a new smaller step at the top or bottom of every existing step, or
-b) The existing smallest step at the top or bottom of every larger step
+b) Add the existing smallest step at the top or bottom of every larger step: i.e. replacing '''x''' with '''xs''' or '''sx''' for every occurrence of any step '''x''' such that '''x''' > '''s''' at the current stage, where '''s''' is the current smallest step.
-Each iteration of a) increasing the rank of the scale by 1.
+Each iteration of a) increases the rank of the scale by 1. <!-- In any of the steps, "bottom" may be replaced with "top", but the choice of "bottom" and "top" must be consistent. Todo: Prove this or find relevant literature on episturmian words to clarify this.-->
-An SN scale of rank 2, a 2-SN scale, is a [[MOS scale]]. Accordingly, SN scales are a generalization of MOS scales into arbitrary rank. [[ET]]<nowiki/>s can be considered to be 1-SN scales, which can be generated by applying a) once, introducing a step of a single degree of the ET.
+An SN scale of rank 2, a 2-SN scale, is a [[MOS scale]]. Accordingly, SN scales are a generalization of MOS scales into arbitrary rank. [[Equal division]]s are rank-1 SN scales, which can be generated by applying a) once, introducing a step of a single degree of the ET.
 SN scales are [[chirality|mirror-symmetric]], and may be uniquely defined by a ''step signature'' - a generalization of the MOS signature into arbitrary rank.
-==Examples ==
+== Examples ==
-The diatonic scale can be generated by iterating a) twice, introducing first the octave, then the perfect fifth, and then iterating b) 3 times. It has step signature 5L 2s, and in the symmetric mode, it has step arrangement LsLLLsL. No other arrangement of 5 large and 2 small step sizes results in a SN scale.
-MET-24 can be generated from the diatonic scale by iterating b) once more, and then applying a), introducing a quarter-tone type step. It has step signature 5L 12M 7s. A capital 'M' specifies that the size of the medium step is closer to the size of the large step than to the size of the small step. A lower case 'm' would specify the converse. We may write the signature alternatively as (5,12,7).
+The diatonic scale can be generated by iterating a) twice, introducing first the octave, then the perfect fifth, and then iterating b) 3 times. It has step signature 5'''L'''2'''s''', and in the symmetric mode, it has step arrangement '''LsLLLsL'''. No other arrangement of 5 large and 2 small step sizes results in a SN scale.
-The double harmonic scale can be generated by iterating a) three times, introducing first the octave, then the fifth, then the major third, leading to a major seven tetrad, and then applying b) once. It has step signature 2L 1M 4s, and in the symmetric mode, it has step arrangement sLsMsLs.
+{| class="wikitable"
+|+ Producing the diatonic MOS via the SNS procedure
+|-
+! Stage !! Move !! Scale (Cumulative form) !! Smallest step !! Step signature !! Word !! Visualization
+|-
+! 1
+|| a): add '''a'''
+|| {1/1, 2/1} || 2/1 = '''a''' || 1'''a''' || '''a''' || {{step vis|53 }}┤
+|-
+! 2
+|| a): add '''b'''
+|| {1/1, '''3/2''', 2/1} || 4/3 = '''a''' || 1'''a'''1'''b''' || '''ba''' || {{step vis|31 22}}
+|-
+! 3
+|| b): '''b''' → '''ab'''
+|| {1/1, '''4/3''', 3/2, 2/1} || 9/8 = '''b''' || 2'''a'''1'''b''' || '''aba''' || {{step vis|22 9 22}}
+|-
+! 4
+|| b): '''a''' → '''ba'''
+|| {1/1, '''9/8''', 4/3, 3/2, '''27/16''', 2/1} || 9/8 = '''b''' || 2'''a'''3'''b''' || '''babba''' || {{Step vis|9 13 9 9 13}}
+|-
+! 5
+|| b): '''a''' → '''ba'''
+|| {1/1, 9/8, '''81/64''', 4/3, 3/2, 27/16, '''243/128''', 2/1} || 256/243 = '''a''' || 2'''a'''5'''b''' || '''bbabbba''' || {{Step vis|9 9 4 9 9 9 4}}
+|}
+MET-24 can be generated from the diatonic scale by iterating b) once more, and then applying a), introducing a quarter-tone type step. It has step signature 5'''L'''12'''M'''7'''s'''. A capital '''M''' specifies that the size of the medium step is closer to the size of the large step than to the size of the small step. A lower case '''m''' would specify the opposite. We may write the signature alternatively as (5,12,7).
+The double harmonic scale can be generated by iterating a) three times, introducing first the octave, then the fifth, then the major third, leading to a major seven tetrad, and then applying b) once. It has step signature 2'''L'''1'''M'''4'''s''', and in the symmetric mode, it has step arrangement '''sLsMsLs'''.
 For more examples of 3-SN scales, see [[Gallery of 3-SN scales]].
 The simplest 4-SN scale is generated by iterating a) 4 times, leading to the scale abacabad. If we map the intervals introduced with a) as 2/1, 3/2, 7/6, and 15/14, we get the scale 15/14 7/6 5/4 3/2 45/28 7/4 15/8 2/1, with step signature (1,2,4,1), mapped to (6/5, 7/6, 15/14, 16/15).
-==Labeling==
+== Denoting SN scales ==
-Where the [[Meantone]] tempered diatonic scale can be labelled as Meantone[7], we may instead describe it through its derivation as an SN scale through labeling it (2/1, 3/2: 81/80)[7], which specifies that a) introduces the intervals 2/1 and 3/2, and then b) is applied until a 7-note scale is reached, and that 81/80 is tempered out in the scale.
+Where the [[Meantone]] tempered diatonic scale can be denoted Meantone[7], we may instead describe it through its derivation as an SN scale through denoting it (2/1, 3/2: 81/80)[7], which specifies that a) introduces the intervals 2/1 and 3/2, and then b) is applied until a 7-note scale is reached, and that 81/80 is tempered out in the scale.
 The scale SNS (2/1, 3/2, 5/4: 225/224)[7] describes a [[Marvel]] tempered double harmonic scale, with step signatures (2,1,4) mapped to (~7/6, ~9/8, 16/15~15/14).
-MET-24, as a (2.3.7.11.13) Parapyth tempered scale can be labelled ((2/1, 3/2)[12], 28/27~33/32: 352/351, 364/363))[24] (the simplest basis set for commas tempered out is chosen to specify the temperament), with step signatures (5, 12, 7) mapped to (~27/26, 28/27~33/32, ~64/63).
+MET-24, as a (2.3.7.11.13) Parapyth tempered scale can be denoted ((2/1, 3/2)[12], 28/27~33/32: 352/351, 364/363))[24] (the simplest basis set for commas tempered out is chosen to specify the temperament), with step signatures (5, 12, 7) mapped to (~27/26, 28/27~33/32, ~64/63).
-==Further definition ==
+== Algorithm ==
 The above scales all have a period of an octave - and therefore a) first introduces the interval of an octave, however, the period of an SN scale, as with the mapping of any new smallest step introduced, is arbitrary.
@@ Line 37: / Line 63: @@
 SN scales are based on epi-Christoffel words form combinatorics, which generalize finite Sturmian words. Finite Sturmian words are equivalent to well-formed scales, and equivalently equivalent to MOS scales that are not ''Multi-MOS'' scales, wich are MOS scales of more than one period, typically with a period that divides the octave evenly. The algorithm for generating SN scales introduced above is equivalent to the two epi-Sturmian morphisms that generate epi-Christoffel words.
-To find the step arrangement of an ''r''-SN scale for arbitrary step sizes treated as letters of alphabet size ''r'', we iteratively apply the epi-Sturmian moprhism M in which a particular letter from the alphabet is added before each incidence of a different letter. To uncover the order of letters associated with the iterated application of the morphism we follow an algorithm T in which, from incidences (''X''1, ''X''2, ..., ''Xr'' ) of arbitrary letters ''S''1, ''S''2, ..., and ''Sr,'' respectively, we subtract from the highest incidence value the sum of all other incidence values:
+To find the step arrangement of an ''r''-SN scale for arbitrary step sizes treated as letters of alphabet size ''r'', we iteratively apply the epi-Sturmian moprhism ''M'' in which a particular letter from the alphabet is added before each incidence of a different letter. To uncover the order of letters associated with the iterated application of the morphism we follow an algorithm T in which, from incidences (''X''<sub>1</sub>, ''X''<sub>2</sub>, ..., ''X''<sub>r</sub> ) of arbitrary letters '''S<sub>1</sub>''', '''S<sub>2</sub>''', ..., and '''S<sub>r</sub>''' respectively, we subtract from the highest incidence value the sum of all other incidence values:
 Iteratively applying T to (10,5,2) as an example:
@@ Line 43: / Line 69: @@
 (10,5,2)->(3,5,2)->(3,0,2)->(1,0,2)->(1,0,1)->(0,0,1)
-We list in order the letter with the highest incidence in each step (relabeling ''S''1, ''S''2, and ''S''3 as ''a'', ''b'', and ''c'' respectively): ''abacac'' (we arbitrarily treated ''a'' as the largest step in (1,0,1) when we wrote (0,0,1) as the next step)
+In the last step, since both '''S<sub>1</sub>''' and '''S<sub>3</sub>''' have the same incidence value, we can pick either of them to subtract from (in this case, '''S<sub>1</sub>''').
-To generate the word, we apply M''abaca''(''c''), as in
+We list in order the letter with the highest incidence in each step (relabeling '''S<sub>1</sub>''', '''S<sub>2</sub>''', and '''S<sub>3</sub>''' as '''a''', '''b''', and '''c''' respectively): '''abacac'''
-M''abaca''(''c'') = M''abac''(''ac'') = M''aba''(''cac'') = M''ab''(''acaac'') = M''a''(''babcbababc'') = ''abaabacabaabaabac''.
+To generate the word, we apply ''M''<sub>'''abaca'''</sub>('''c'''). We proceed:
+''M''<sub>'''abaca'''</sub>('''c''') = ''M''<sub>'''abac'''</sub>('''ac''') = ''M''<sub>'''aba'''</sub>('''cac''') = ''M''<sub>'''ab'''</sub>('''acaac''') = ''M''<sub>'''a'''</sub>('''babcbababc''') = '''abaabacabaabaabac'''.
 We can then apply mappings to the step sizes to defined the word as a scale.
 If at any point in the application of T a negative number is reached, that combination of step incidences does not correspond to an SN scale. Accordingly, though for rank-2, any possible step signature corresponds to an SN scale, for higher ranks only a small portion of possible step signatures correspond to SN scales. The step signature (2,2,3), for example, does not correspond to an SN scale, as the iterative application of T leads to a negative number, i.e., (2,2,3)->(2,2,-1).
+TODO: Prove that this algorithm yields the same result as the first definition given.
 == Step-nested differential scales ==
@@ Line 84: / Line 114: @@
 SNDS ((2/1, 3/2)[5], ''x''))[10] - (2/1, 3/2)[5] = SNS (2/1, 3/2)[5] (dipentatonic SNS)
-[[Category:Step-nested scales| ]] <!-- main article -->
+[[Category:Scale]]
 [[Category:MOS scale]]