Talk:The Riemann zeta function and tuning: Revision history

26 April 2025

• curprev 13:3013:30, 26 April 2025 Godtone talk contribs m 28,636 bytes −17 →Alternate list based on unmodified zeta function: (was thinking about signing again to indicate the small edit to this comment but decided against it but accidentally left in this remnant while editing)
• curprev 13:2913:29, 26 April 2025 Godtone talk contribs m 28,653 bytes +1 →Alternate list based on unmodified zeta function: missing bracket
• curprev 13:2813:28, 26 April 2025 Godtone talk contribs m 28,652 bytes +29 →Alternate list based on unmodified zeta function: nowrap
• curprev 13:2713:27, 26 April 2025 Godtone talk contribs m 28,623 bytes +114 →Alternate list based on unmodified zeta function: add invitation to share any findings/concerns
• curprev 13:2513:25, 26 April 2025 Godtone talk contribs m 28,509 bytes +8 →Alternate list based on unmodified zeta function: correction as per updating of list to top 10 and as per more stuff being added to that page

24 April 2025

• curprev 17:0617:06, 24 April 2025 Godtone talk contribs m 28,501 bytes +84 →Top 20 (and top 10) zeta edos: forgot to sign
• curprev 17:0617:06, 24 April 2025 Godtone talk contribs 28,417 bytes +268 top 20 (and top 10) zeta edos

19 April 2025

• curprev 15:2315:23, 19 April 2025 Fredg999 talk contribs 28,149 bytes +1,724 Move topic and WSArchiveLink from previous talk page (dating from before the main page was moved and the talk page didn't follow)

17 April 2025

• curprev 18:4218:42, 17 April 2025 Godtone talk contribs m 26,425 bytes +194 →Alternate list based on unmodified zeta function: add minor detail
• curprev 18:3918:39, 17 April 2025 Godtone talk contribs 26,231 bytes +1,646 →Criticisms of and possible improvements to new list: offer alternate list and optimal edo sequences
• curprev 15:4215:42, 17 April 2025 Godtone talk contribs 24,585 bytes +1,150 add extra explanation for why i believe the adjustment is correct

16 April 2025

• curprev 21:5221:52, 16 April 2025 Godtone talk contribs 23,435 bytes −76 correction
• curprev 21:3421:34, 16 April 2025 Godtone talk contribs m 23,511 bytes +152 clarify/make more intuitive (hopefully)
• curprev 21:2221:22, 16 April 2025 Godtone talk contribs m 23,359 bytes +9 missing words
• curprev 21:2121:21, 16 April 2025 Godtone talk contribs m 23,350 bytes +51 wording tweak
• curprev 21:1921:19, 16 April 2025 Godtone talk contribs 23,299 bytes +2,368 →Criticisms of and possible improvements to new list: reply/explanation
• curprev 20:0020:00, 16 April 2025 Sintel talk contribs 20,931 bytes +762 →Criticisms of and possible improvements to new list
• curprev 18:1318:13, 16 April 2025 Godtone talk contribs m 20,169 bytes +3 →Criticisms of and possible improvements to new list: grammar
• curprev 18:1318:13, 16 April 2025 Godtone talk contribs m 20,166 bytes −1 →Criticisms of and possible improvements to new list: typo
• curprev 18:1218:12, 16 April 2025 Godtone talk contribs m 20,167 bytes +35 →Criticisms of and possible improvements to new list: remove redundant part of list (the part where every EDO < 11 is included, therefore it makes sense to start at 12)
• curprev 18:1018:10, 16 April 2025 Godtone talk contribs m 20,132 bytes +2 →Criticisms of & possible improvements to new list: make title easier to link to (& -> and)
• curprev 18:1018:10, 16 April 2025 Godtone talk contribs 20,130 bytes +4,061 on improved lists

14 April 2025

• curprev 23:2123:21, 14 April 2025 Sintel talk contribs m 16,069 bytes +2 typos
• curprev 23:0423:04, 14 April 2025 Sintel talk contribs 16,067 bytes +287 →General concern about edit strategy
• curprev 22:5922:59, 14 April 2025 Lériendil talk contribs m 15,780 bytes +53 No edit summary
• curprev 22:5722:57, 14 April 2025 Lériendil talk contribs 15,727 bytes +992 No edit summary
• curprev 22:5322:53, 14 April 2025 Lériendil talk contribs 14,735 bytes +68 No edit summary
• curprev 22:5322:53, 14 April 2025 Lériendil talk contribs m 14,667 bytes +93 No edit summary
• curprev 22:5222:52, 14 April 2025 Lériendil talk contribs 14,574 bytes +87 No edit summary
• curprev 22:5222:52, 14 April 2025 Lériendil talk contribs 14,487 bytes +409 No edit summary
• curprev 22:5022:50, 14 April 2025 Lériendil talk contribs 14,078 bytes +252 →General concern about edit strategy
• curprev 22:4722:47, 14 April 2025 Sintel talk contribs 13,826 bytes +657 →General concern about edit strategy
• curprev 21:2821:28, 14 April 2025 Godtone talk contribs m 13,169 bytes +45 →General concern about edit strategy: clarify sense
• curprev 21:2721:27, 14 April 2025 Godtone talk contribs m 13,124 bytes −6 lessen severity of wording
• curprev 21:2721:27, 14 April 2025 Godtone talk contribs 13,130 bytes +2,462 concern about replacing the page
• curprev 20:2720:27, 14 April 2025 Godtone talk contribs m 10,668 bytes +538 →Reworking page: clarify what i meant about zeta integral being significant (or at least why i think it's significant)
• curprev 20:0820:08, 14 April 2025 Sintel talk contribs 10,130 bytes +795 →Reworking page
• curprev 19:0119:01, 14 April 2025 Godtone talk contribs m 9,335 bytes +799 →Reworking page: correct response and note concern about zeta integral
• curprev 18:5618:56, 14 April 2025 Godtone talk contribs m 8,536 bytes +971 →Reworking page: concern about wording in explanation

13 April 2025

• curprev 16:2316:23, 13 April 2025 Sintel talk contribs 7,565 bytes +227 Reworking page

10 April 2025

• curprev 17:1217:12, 10 April 2025 Fredg999 talk contribs m 7,338 bytes +18 Move high priority to talk page

9 April 2025

• curprev 10:2410:24, 9 April 2025 Sintel talk contribs 7,320 bytes +312 No edit summary

8 April 2025

• curprev 15:1115:11, 8 April 2025 Godtone talk contribs m 7,008 bytes +1,571 clarify purpose of the post as the title and address the only other genuine issue that im aware of that i forgot to address (but which for reasons explained i dont think is actually much of an issue)
• curprev 14:4014:40, 8 April 2025 Godtone talk contribs 5,437 bytes +3,701 defence of gene's derivation as the best one imo so that it deserves inclusion on the main page, and perhaps some mathematical motivations/details that might not be obvious to the reader could be added to make it more accessible

5 April 2025

• curprev 18:0218:02, 5 April 2025 Sintel talk contribs 1,736 bytes +35 No edit summary
• curprev 18:0118:01, 5 April 2025 Sintel talk contribs 1,701 bytes +1,701 Created page with "== Review needed == This page is linked from almost every important edo, and I would consider it "high priority". Despite the length of the page and numerous derivations, some questions and problems remain: * The construction itself remains largely unmotivated. Why the specific error functions? There is a large amount of handwaving and heuristics. We can use different cyclic error functions which will not lead to zeta, but they seem equally valid. If there is no specif..."