Talk:11edo

This page also contains archived Wikispaces discussion.

Please check mapping of 9-limit intervals

Someone private messaged me on Facebook because I'm a wiki editor, but I didn't feel confident dealing with the thing they talked about so I'm posting it here so someone more confident and experienced can deal with it:

"The wiki page for 11EDO might need brushing up in regards to consistency, since it keeps referring to the "correct" 9-limit intervals, but the listed val in 3-limit cannot produce those 🤔 Because the 3rd harmonic is so flat, it would put 9/8 at 1\11 edosteps, but the page keeps referring it to 2\11."

I don't really see the issue. Mapping 9/8 to 1\11 seems absurd, and the interval table does state that it's based on the 2.9 subgroup and not 2.3.

Maybe the confusion is because in the regular temperament properties the full 13-limit [11 17 26 31 38 41] is assumed (which is questionable for sure).

– Sintel🎏 (talk) 22:55, 13 February 2025 (UTC)