User:BudjarnLambeth/Table of stretched 42edo tunings: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
mNo edit summary |
mNo edit summary |
||
| Line 85: | Line 85: | ||
| −30.1% <br>(8.6¢) | | −30.1% <br>(8.6¢) | ||
|- | |- | ||
! 2/1 | ! 2/1 val <br>(& reduced) | ||
| 42 <br>(0) | | 42 <br>(0) | ||
| 42 <br>(0) | | 42 <br>(0) | ||
| Line 93: | Line 93: | ||
| 42 <br>(0) | | 42 <br>(0) | ||
|- | |- | ||
! 3/1 | ! 3/1 val | ||
| 66 <br>(24) | | 66 <br>(24) | ||
| 66 <br>(24) | | 66 <br>(24) | ||
| Line 101: | Line 101: | ||
| 67 <br>(25) | | 67 <br>(25) | ||
|- | |- | ||
! 5/1 | ! 5/1 val | ||
| 97 <br>(13) | | 97 <br>(13) | ||
| 97 <br>(13) | | 97 <br>(13) | ||
| Line 109: | Line 109: | ||
| 98 <br>(14) | | 98 <br>(14) | ||
|- | |- | ||
! 7/1 | ! 7/1 val | ||
| 117 <br>(33) | | 117 <br>(33) | ||
| 117 <br>(33) | | 117 <br>(33) | ||
| Line 117: | Line 117: | ||
| 118 <br>(34) | | 118 <br>(34) | ||
|- | |- | ||
! 11/1 | ! 11/1 val | ||
| 144 <br>(18) | | 144 <br>(18) | ||
| 145 <br>(19) | | 145 <br>(19) | ||
| Line 125: | Line 125: | ||
| 146 <br>(20) | | 146 <br>(20) | ||
|- | |- | ||
! 13/1 | ! 13/1 val | ||
| 155 <br>(29) | | 155 <br>(29) | ||
| 155 <br>(29) | | 155 <br>(29) | ||
Revision as of 09:26, 7 December 2024
42edo has almost 50% relative error on harmonics 3/1 and 5/1. This means that whether one stretches or compresses the octave, either way it will improve 42edo’s approximations of JI, but in opposite directions.
This table provides a detailed comparison of three stretched- and two compressed-octave tunings for 42edo.
| Tuning | 42ed257/128 | APS720jot | 189zpi | 42edo | 191zpi | 42ed255/128 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Steps / octave | ~41.77 | ~41.81 | ~41.83 | 42.00 | ~42.19 | ~42.24 |
| Step size | ~28.73¢ | ~28.70¢ | ~28.69¢ | ~28.57¢ | ~28.44¢ | ~28.41¢ |
| Overview | great: 5 good: 2, 3, 7 okay: bad: 11, 13 |
great: 5 good: 2, 3 okay: 7, 11, 13 bad: |
great: 5 good: 2, 13 okay: 3, 11 bad: 7 |
great: 2, 7 good: okay: 11 bad: 3, 5, 13 |
great: 5, 11, 13 good: 2, 3 okay: bad: 7 |
great: 3, 5, 11 good: 2 okay: 13 bad: 7 |
| 2/1 error | +23.5% (6.7¢) |
+19.0% (5.5¢) |
+17.2% (4.9¢) |
0.0% (0.0¢) |
−18.8% (5.3¢) |
−23.9% (6.8¢) |
| 3/1 error | −19.6% (5.6¢) |
−26.7% (7.7¢) |
−29.6% (8.5¢) |
+43.2% (12.3¢) |
+13.4% (3.8¢) |
+5.4% (1.5¢) |
| 5/1 error | +2.4% (0.7¢) |
−7.9% (2.3¢) |
−12.2% (3.5¢) |
+47.9% (13.7¢) |
+4.3% (1.2¢) |
−7.5% (2.1¢) |
| 7/1 error | −24.9% (7.2¢) |
−37.5% (10.8¢) |
−42.6% (12.2¢) |
+9.1% (2.6¢) |
−43.6% (12.4¢) |
+42.2% (12.0¢) |
| 11/1 error | −48.3% (13.9¢) |
+36.2% (10.4¢) |
+29.8% (8.6¢) |
−29.6% (8.5¢) |
+5.5% (1.6¢) |
−12.1% 3.4¢) |
| 13/1 error | +45.1% (13.0¢) |
+28.6% (8.2¢) |
+21.7% (6.2¢) |
−41.8% (12.0¢) |
−11.3% (3.2¢) |
−30.1% (8.6¢) |
| 2/1 val (& reduced) |
42 (0) |
42 (0) |
42 (0) |
42 (0) |
42 (0) |
42 (0) |
| 3/1 val | 66 (24) |
66 (24) |
66 (24) |
67 (25) |
67 (25) |
67 (25) |
| 5/1 val | 97 (13) |
97 (13) |
97 (13) |
98 (14) |
98 (14) |
98 (14) |
| 7/1 val | 117 (33) |
117 (33) |
117 (33) |
118 (34) |
118 (34) |
118 (34) |
| 11/1 val | 144 (18) |
145 (19) |
145 (19) |
145 (19) |
146 (20) |
146 (20) |
| 13/1 val | 155 (29) |
155 (29) |
155 (29) |
155 (29) |
156 (30) |
156 (30) |
“great” = 0-12.5% relative error • “good” = 12.5-27.5% • “okay” = 27.5-40% • “bad” = 40-50%
| ||||||