Xenharmonic Wiki:Deleted temperament entries: Difference between revisions

From Xenharmonic Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
← Older editNewer edit →
VisualWikitext
No edit summary
+ more general reasons
Line 9: Line 9:
|-
|-
| Oviminor
| Oviminor
| 5 to 7-limit
| 5- to 7-limit
| 19 & 1600
| 19 & 1600
| More complex than egads (which shares the same generator) at lower accuracy
| Pointless microtemperament: more complex than egads (which shares the same generator) at lower accuracy
|-
|-
| Maqamschismic
| Maqamschismic
| 11 to 13-limit
| 2.3.5.11.(13)
| 41 & 53
| 41 & 53
| Removes prime 7 from cassandra even though prime 11 has higher complexity and error
| Canonical restriction of cassandra, lack of unique value
|-
|-
| Quintapole
| Quintapole
| 7 to 11-limit
| 7- to 11-limit
| 12 & 85
| 12 & 85
| Medium accuracy is not worth the high complexity; could lead to confusion with similarly named "quintupole"
| Medium accuracy is not worth the high complexity; confusing name (could lead to confusion with similarly named "quintupole")
|-
|-
| Quintapole > Galeleic
| Quintapole > Galeleic
| 13 to 19-limit
| 13- to 19-limit
| 12f & 85fg
| 12f & 85fg
| Medium accuracy is not worth the high complexity; not even supported by any patent vals
| Medium accuracy is not worth the high complexity; not even supported by any patent vals
|-
|-
| Quintapole > Catagali
| Quintapole > Catagali
| 13 to 19-limit
| 13- to 19-limit
| 12f & 85g
| 12f & 85g
| Medium accuracy is not worth the high complexity; not even supported by any patent vals
| Medium accuracy is not worth the high complexity; not even supported by any patent vals
|-
|-
| Quintapole > Quintain
| Quintapole > Quintain
| 11 to 13-limit
| 11- to 13-limit
| 12 & 85e
| 12 & 85e
| Medium accuracy is not worth the high complexity
| Medium accuracy is not worth the high complexity
Line 41: Line 41:
| 5-limit
| 5-limit
| 1 & 1c
| 1 & 1c
| Too coarse even for detempering
| Extreme exotemperament: too coarse even for detempering
|-
|-
| Archon
| Archon
| 5-limit
| 5-limit
| 1 & 1b
| 1 & 1b
| Too coarse even for detempering
| Extreme exotemperament: too coarse even for detempering
|-
|-
| Seesaw
| Seesaw
| 2.3.5(.11)
| 2.3.5.(11)
| 1b & 2
| 1b & 2
| Too coarse even for detempering
| Extreme exotemperament: too coarse even for detempering
|-
|-
| Seesaw > Heavy windmill
| Seesaw > Heavy windmill
| 7 to 11-limit
| 7- to 11-limit
| 1bd & 2
| 1bd & 2
| Too coarse even for detempering
| Extreme exotemperament: too coarse even for detempering
|-
|-
| Seesaw > Light windmill
| Seesaw > Light windmill
| 7 to 11-limit
| 7- to 11-limit
| 1b & 2
| 1b & 2
| Too coarse even for detempering
| Extreme exotemperament: too coarse even for detempering
|-
|-
| Sixseven
| Sixseven
| 2.3.7(.13)
| 2.3.7.(13)
| 1 & 3
| 1 & 3
| Too coarse even for detempering
| Extreme exotemperament: too coarse even for detempering
|-
|-
| Sixseven > Heaven
| Sixseven > Heaven
| 2.3.7.11(.13)
| 2.3.7.11.(13)
| 1e & 3
| 1e & 3
| Too coarse even for detempering
| Extreme exotemperament: too coarse even for detempering
|-
|-
| Dog
| Dog
| 2.3.19
| 2.3.19
| 7 & 16
| 7 & 16
| No reason to interpret the resultant scales as dog rather than mavila / unenlightening restriction of armodog
| Pointless exotemperament: unenlightening restriction of armodue/armodog, lack of unique value
|-
|-
| Sept
| Sept
| 7 to 13-limit
| 7- to 13-limit
| 7 & 14de
| 7 & 14de
| No reason to leave prime 5 free in 7et rather than prime 7
| Pointless exotemperament: no reason to leave prime 5 free in 7et rather than prime 7
|-
|-
| Counterorson
| Counterorson
| 7-limit
| 7-limit
| 53 & 1718
| 53 & 1718
| High badness at all but unusable complexity
| Pointless microtemperament: high badness at all but unusable complexity
|-
| Counterquectismic
| 5-limit
| 359 & 665
| High badness at unusable complexity
|-
| Quectismic
| 5-limit
| 306 & 665
| High badness at unusable complexity
|-
|-
| Nanoquectismic
| Nanoquectismic
| 7-limit
| 7-limit
| 306 & 665
| 306 & 665
| High badness at unusable complexity
| Pointless microtemperament: high badness at unusable complexity
|-
|-
| Conanoquectismic
| Conanoquectismic
| 7-limit
| 7-limit
| 306d & 665
| 306d & 665
| Extremely high badness at unusable complexity
| Pointless microtemperament: extremely high badness at unusable complexity
|}
|}


[[Category:Xenharmonic Wiki guidelines]]
[[Category:Xenharmonic Wiki guidelines]]

Revision as of 11:25, 20 June 2026

This page collects deleted entries of regular temperaments from the Xenharmonic Wiki due to not meeting our notability guidelines, although other materials may still reference them. We recommend to refer to these temperaments with an ET join (e. g. "11-limit 12 & 85") or as a restriction of a different temperament (e. g. "no-7's cassandra").

Name Subgroup ET join Reason for deletion
Oviminor 5- to 7-limit 19 & 1600 Pointless microtemperament: more complex than egads (which shares the same generator) at lower accuracy
Maqamschismic 2.3.5.11.(13) 41 & 53 Canonical restriction of cassandra, lack of unique value
Quintapole 7- to 11-limit 12 & 85 Medium accuracy is not worth the high complexity; confusing name (could lead to confusion with similarly named "quintupole")
Quintapole > Galeleic 13- to 19-limit 12f & 85fg Medium accuracy is not worth the high complexity; not even supported by any patent vals
Quintapole > Catagali 13- to 19-limit 12f & 85g Medium accuracy is not worth the high complexity; not even supported by any patent vals
Quintapole > Quintain 11- to 13-limit 12 & 85e Medium accuracy is not worth the high complexity
Bixby 5-limit 1 & 1c Extreme exotemperament: too coarse even for detempering
Archon 5-limit 1 & 1b Extreme exotemperament: too coarse even for detempering
Seesaw 2.3.5.(11) 1b & 2 Extreme exotemperament: too coarse even for detempering
Seesaw > Heavy windmill 7- to 11-limit 1bd & 2 Extreme exotemperament: too coarse even for detempering
Seesaw > Light windmill 7- to 11-limit 1b & 2 Extreme exotemperament: too coarse even for detempering
Sixseven 2.3.7.(13) 1 & 3 Extreme exotemperament: too coarse even for detempering
Sixseven > Heaven 2.3.7.11.(13) 1e & 3 Extreme exotemperament: too coarse even for detempering
Dog 2.3.19 7 & 16 Pointless exotemperament: unenlightening restriction of armodue/armodog, lack of unique value
Sept 7- to 13-limit 7 & 14de Pointless exotemperament: no reason to leave prime 5 free in 7et rather than prime 7
Counterorson 7-limit 53 & 1718 Pointless microtemperament: high badness at all but unusable complexity
Nanoquectismic 7-limit 306 & 665 Pointless microtemperament: high badness at unusable complexity
Conanoquectismic 7-limit 306d & 665 Pointless microtemperament: extremely high badness at unusable complexity
Retrieved from "https://en.xen.wiki/index.php?title=Xenharmonic_Wiki:Deleted_temperament_entries&oldid=232473"