User:BudjarnLambeth/SimHue: Difference between revisions
mNo edit summary |
mNo edit summary |
||
| (5 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
'''SimHue 11''' is intended as a simple heuristic for comparing how good EDOs are relative to | {{Editable user page}} | ||
'''SimHue 11''' is intended as a simple heuristic for comparing how good [[Edo|EDOs (ed2s)]] are relative to their size at approximating the [[11-limit]]. | |||
It could be easily adapted into ''SimHue N'' for the N-prime-limit, or ''SimHue A.B.C'' for the subgroup A.B.C where A, B, C can be any harmonic or interval. | It could be easily adapted into ''SimHue N'' for the [[Prime-limit|N-prime-limit]], or ''SimHue A.B.C'' for the [[subgroup]] A.B.C where A, B, C can be any [[harmonic]] or [[interval]]. | ||
=== Definition === | === Definition === | ||
| Line 7: | Line 8: | ||
For each ed2, let N(ed2) be the number of steps that ed2 has. | For each ed2, let N(ed2) be the number of steps that ed2 has. | ||
Let N(ed3) be the number of steps its nearest ed3 has per 1200 cents. | Let N(ed3) be the number of steps its nearest [[ed3]] has per 1200 [[cents]]. | ||
Let N(ed5) be the number of steps its nearest ed5 has per 1200 cents. | Let N(ed5) be the number of steps its nearest [[ed5]] has per 1200 cents. | ||
And so on. | And so on. | ||
<math>S(\mathrm{ed2}) = \frac{\left|N(\mathrm{ed2}) - N(\mathrm{ed3})\right|}{3} + \frac{\left|N(\mathrm{ed2}) - N(\mathrm{ed5})\right|}{5} + \frac{\left|N(\mathrm{ed2}) - N(\mathrm{ed7})\right|}{7} + \frac{\left|N(\mathrm{ed2}) - N(\mathrm{ed11})\right|}{11}</math> | <math display="block"> | ||
\begin{aligned} | |||
S(\mathrm{ed2}) &= \frac{\left|N(\mathrm{ed2}) - N(\mathrm{ed3})\right|}{3} + \frac{\left|N(\mathrm{ed2}) - N(\mathrm{ed5})\right|}{5} + \frac{\left|N(\mathrm{ed2}) - N(\mathrm{ed7})\right|}{7} + \frac{\left|N(\mathrm{ed2}) - N(\mathrm{ed11})\right|}{11} \\ | |||
&\quad + \frac{\left|N(\mathrm{ed3}) - N(\mathrm{ed5})\right|}{5} + \frac{\left|N(\mathrm{ed3}) - N(\mathrm{ed7})\right|}{7} + \frac{\left|N(\mathrm{ed3}) - N(\mathrm{ed11})\right|}{11} \\ | |||
&\quad + \frac{\left|N(\mathrm{ed5}) - N(\mathrm{ed7})\right|}{7} + \frac{\left|N(\mathrm{ed5}) - N(\mathrm{ed11})\right|}{11} \\ | |||
&\quad + \frac{\left|N(\mathrm{ed7}) - N(\mathrm{ed11})\right|}{11} | |||
\end{aligned} | |||
</math> | |||
S(ed2) is the SimHue 11 score for the | S(ed2) is the SimHue 11 score for the ed2. Lower S(ed2) is better. | ||
=== SimHue 11 scores for every EDO 1-100 === | === SimHue 11 scores for every EDO 1-100 === | ||
{| class="wikitable sortable" | {| class="wikitable sortable" style="table-layout: fixed; width: 48em;" | ||
! ed2 !! S(ed2)!! Nearest ed3 !! Nearest ed5 !! Nearest ed7 !! Nearest ed11 | ! ed2 !! S(ed2) !! Nearest ed3 !! Nearest ed5 !! Nearest ed7 !! Nearest ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="1" | 1ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="1" | 1ed2 || 0.3289 || data-sort-value="2" | 2ed3 || data-sort-value="2" | 2ed5 || data-sort-value="3" | 3ed7 || data-sort-value="3" | 3ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="2" | 2ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="2" | 2ed2 || 0.2115 || data-sort-value="3" | 3ed3 || data-sort-value="5" | 5ed5 || data-sort-value="6" | 6ed7 || data-sort-value="7" | 7ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="3" | 3ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="3" | 3ed2 || 0.2201 || data-sort-value="5" | 5ed3 || data-sort-value="7" | 7ed5 || data-sort-value="8" | 8ed7 || data-sort-value="10" | 10ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="4" | 4ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="4" | 4ed2 || 0.2063 || data-sort-value="6" | 6ed3 || data-sort-value="9" | 9ed5 || data-sort-value="11" | 11ed7 || data-sort-value="14" | 14ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="5" | 5ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="5" | 5ed2 || 0.1596 || data-sort-value="8" | 8ed3 || data-sort-value="12" | 12ed5 || data-sort-value="14" | 14ed7 || data-sort-value="17" | 17ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="6" | 6ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="6" | 6ed2 || 0.2460 || data-sort-value="10" | 10ed3 || data-sort-value="14" | 14ed5 || data-sort-value="17" | 17ed7 || data-sort-value="21" | 21ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="7" | 7ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="7" | 7ed2 || 0.1561 || data-sort-value="11" | 11ed3 || data-sort-value="16" | 16ed5 || data-sort-value="20" | 20ed7 || data-sort-value="24" | 24ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="8" | 8ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="8" | 8ed2 || 0.2827 || data-sort-value="13" | 13ed3 || data-sort-value="19" | 19ed5 || data-sort-value="22" | 22ed7 || data-sort-value="28" | 28ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="9" | 9ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="9" | 9ed2 || 0.1783 || data-sort-value="14" | 14ed3 || data-sort-value="21" | 21ed5 || data-sort-value="25" | 25ed7 || data-sort-value="31" | 31ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="10" | 10ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="10" | 10ed2 || 0.1641 || data-sort-value="16" | 16ed3 || data-sort-value="23" | 23ed5 || data-sort-value="28" | 28ed7 || data-sort-value="35" | 35ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="11" | 11ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="11" | 11ed2 || 0.3483 || data-sort-value="17" | 17ed3 || data-sort-value="26" | 26ed5 || data-sort-value="31" | 31ed7 || data-sort-value="38" | 38ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="12" | 12ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="12" | 12ed2 || 0.1079 || data-sort-value="19" | 19ed3 || data-sort-value="28" | 28ed5 || data-sort-value="34" | 34ed7 || data-sort-value="42" | 42ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="13" | 13ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="13" | 13ed2 || 0.3123 || data-sort-value="21" | 21ed3 || data-sort-value="30" | 30ed5 || data-sort-value="36" | 36ed7 || data-sort-value="45" | 45ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="14" | 14ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="14" | 14ed2 || 0.2556 || data-sort-value="22" | 22ed3 || data-sort-value="33" | 33ed5 || data-sort-value="39" | 39ed7 || data-sort-value="48" | 48ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="15" | 15ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="15" | 15ed2 || 0.1468 || data-sort-value="24" | 24ed3 || data-sort-value="35" | 35ed5 || data-sort-value="42" | 42ed7 || data-sort-value="52" | 52ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="16" | 16ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="16" | 16ed2 || 0.2110 || data-sort-value="25" | 25ed3 || data-sort-value="37" | 37ed5 || data-sort-value="45" | 45ed7 || data-sort-value="55" | 55ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="17" | 17ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="17" | 17ed2 || 0.2004 || data-sort-value="27" | 27ed3 || data-sort-value="39" | 39ed5 || data-sort-value="48" | 48ed7 || data-sort-value="59" | 59ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="18" | 18ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="18" | 18ed2 || 0.2905 || data-sort-value="29" | 29ed3 || data-sort-value="42" | 42ed5 || data-sort-value="51" | 51ed7 || data-sort-value="62" | 62ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="19" | 19ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="19" | 19ed2 || 0.1234 || data-sort-value="30" | 30ed3 || data-sort-value="44" | 44ed5 || data-sort-value="53" | 53ed7 || data-sort-value="66" | 66ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="20" | 20ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="20" | 20ed2 || 0.2779 || data-sort-value="32" | 32ed3 || data-sort-value="46" | 46ed5 || data-sort-value="56" | 56ed7 || data-sort-value="69" | 69ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="21" | 21ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="21" | 21ed2 || 0.2223 || data-sort-value="33" | 33ed3 || data-sort-value="49" | 49ed5 || data-sort-value="59" | 59ed7 || data-sort-value="73" | 73ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="22" | 22ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="22" | 22ed2 || 0.1120 || data-sort-value="35" | 35ed3 || data-sort-value="51" | 51ed5 || data-sort-value="62" | 62ed7 || data-sort-value="76" | 76ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="23" | 23ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="23" | 23ed2 || 0.3630 || data-sort-value="36" | 36ed3 || data-sort-value="53" | 53ed5 || data-sort-value="65" | 65ed7 || data-sort-value="80" | 80ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="24" | 24ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="24" | 24ed2 || 0.1563 || data-sort-value="38" | 38ed3 || data-sort-value="56" | 56ed5 || data-sort-value="67" | 67ed7 || data-sort-value="83" | 83ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="25" | 25ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="25" | 25ed2 || 0.2586 || data-sort-value="40" | 40ed3 || data-sort-value="58" | 58ed5 || data-sort-value="70" | 70ed7 || data-sort-value="86" | 86ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="26" | 26ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="26" | 26ed2 || 0.1563 || data-sort-value="41" | 41ed3 || data-sort-value="60" | 60ed5 || data-sort-value="73" | 73ed7 || data-sort-value="90" | 90ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="27" | 27ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="27" | 27ed2 || 0.1706 || data-sort-value="43" | 43ed3 || data-sort-value="63" | 63ed5 || data-sort-value="76" | 76ed7 || data-sort-value="93" | 93ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="28" | 28ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="28" | 28ed2 || 0.2649 || data-sort-value="44" | 44ed3 || data-sort-value="65" | 65ed5 || data-sort-value="79" | 79ed7 || data-sort-value="97" | 97ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="29" | 29ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="29" | 29ed2 || 0.1443 || data-sort-value="46" | 46ed3 || data-sort-value="67" | 67ed5 || data-sort-value="81" | 81ed7 || data-sort-value="100" | 100ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="30" | 30ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="30" | 30ed2 || 0.2936 || data-sort-value="48" | 48ed3 || data-sort-value="70" | 70ed5 || data-sort-value="84" | 84ed7 || data-sort-value="104" | 104ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="31" | 31ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="31" | 31ed2 || 0.0836 || data-sort-value="49" | 49ed3 || data-sort-value="72" | 72ed5 || data-sort-value="87" | 87ed7 || data-sort-value="107" | 107ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="32" | 32ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="32" | 32ed2 || 0.2372 || data-sort-value="51" | 51ed3 || data-sort-value="74" | 74ed5 || data-sort-value="90" | 90ed7 || data-sort-value="111" | 111ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="33" | 33ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="33" | 33ed2 || 0.2880 || data-sort-value="52" | 52ed3 || data-sort-value="77" | 77ed5 || data-sort-value="93" | 93ed7 || data-sort-value="114" | 114ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="34" | 34ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="34" | 34ed2 || 0.1655 || data-sort-value="54" | 54ed3 || data-sort-value="79" | 79ed5 || data-sort-value="95" | 95ed7 || data-sort-value="118" | 118ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="35" | 35ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="35" | 35ed2 || 0.2472 || data-sort-value="55" | 55ed3 || data-sort-value="81" | 81ed5 || data-sort-value="98" | 98ed7 || data-sort-value="121" | 121ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="36" | 36ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="36" | 36ed2 || 0.1700 || data-sort-value="57" | 57ed3 || data-sort-value="84" | 84ed5 || data-sort-value="101" | 101ed7 || data-sort-value="125" | 125ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="37" | 37ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="37" | 37ed2 || 0.1811 || data-sort-value="59" | 59ed3 || data-sort-value="86" | 86ed5 || data-sort-value="104" | 104ed7 || data-sort-value="128" | 128ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="38" | 38ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="38" | 38ed2 || 0.1992 || data-sort-value="60" | 60ed3 || data-sort-value="88" | 88ed5 || data-sort-value="107" | 107ed7 || data-sort-value="131" | 131ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="39" | 39ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="39" | 39ed2 || 0.2547 || data-sort-value="62" | 62ed3 || data-sort-value="91" | 91ed5 || data-sort-value="109" | 109ed7 || data-sort-value="135" | 135ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="40" | 40ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="40" | 40ed2 || 0.2517 || data-sort-value="63" | 63ed3 || data-sort-value="93" | 93ed5 || data-sort-value="112" | 112ed7 || data-sort-value="138" | 138ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="41" | 41ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="41" | 41ed2 || 0.0861 || data-sort-value="65" | 65ed3 || data-sort-value="95" | 95ed5 || data-sort-value="115" | 115ed7 || data-sort-value="142" | 142ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="42" | 42ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="42" | 42ed2 || 0.2865 || data-sort-value="67" | 67ed3 || data-sort-value="98" | 98ed5 || data-sort-value="118" | 118ed7 || data-sort-value="145" | 145ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="43" | 43ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="43" | 43ed2 || 0.1508 || data-sort-value="68" | 68ed3 || data-sort-value="100" | 100ed5 || data-sort-value="121" | 121ed7 || data-sort-value="149" | 149ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="44" | 44ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="44" | 44ed2 || 0.2239 || data-sort-value="70" | 70ed3 || data-sort-value="102" | 102ed5 || data-sort-value="124" | 124ed7 || data-sort-value="152" | 152ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="45" | 45ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="45" | 45ed2 || 0.2358 || data-sort-value="71" | 71ed3 || data-sort-value="104" | 104ed5 || data-sort-value="126" | 126ed7 || data-sort-value="156" | 156ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="46" | 46ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="46" | 46ed2 || 0.1061 || data-sort-value="73" | 73ed3 || data-sort-value="107" | 107ed5 || data-sort-value="129" | 129ed7 || data-sort-value="159" | 159ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="47" | 47ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="47" | 47ed2 || 0.3012 || data-sort-value="74" | 74ed3 || data-sort-value="109" | 109ed5 || data-sort-value="132" | 132ed7 || data-sort-value="163" | 163ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="48" | 48ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="48" | 48ed2 || 0.1873 || data-sort-value="76" | 76ed3 || data-sort-value="111" | 111ed5 || data-sort-value="135" | 135ed7 || data-sort-value="166" | 166ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="49" | 49ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="49" | 49ed2 || 0.1769 || data-sort-value="78" | 78ed3 || data-sort-value="114" | 114ed5 || data-sort-value="138" | 138ed7 || data-sort-value="170" | 170ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="50" | 50ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="50" | 50ed2 || 0.1515 || data-sort-value="79" | 79ed3 || data-sort-value="116" | 116ed5 || data-sort-value="140" | 140ed7 || data-sort-value="173" | 173ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="51" | 51ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="51" | 51ed2 || 0.2209 || data-sort-value="81" | 81ed3 || data-sort-value="118" | 118ed5 || data-sort-value="143" | 143ed7 || data-sort-value="176" | 176ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="52" | 52ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="52" | 52ed2 || 0.2793 || data-sort-value="82" | 82ed3 || data-sort-value="121" | 121ed5 || data-sort-value="146" | 146ed7 || data-sort-value="180" | 180ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="53" | 53ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="53" | 53ed2 || 0.0881 || data-sort-value="84" | 84ed3 || data-sort-value="123" | 123ed5 || data-sort-value="149" | 149ed7 || data-sort-value="183" | 183ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="54" | 54ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="54" | 54ed2 || 0.3378 || data-sort-value="86" | 86ed3 || data-sort-value="125" | 125ed5 || data-sort-value="152" | 152ed7 || data-sort-value="187" | 187ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="55" | 55ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="55" | 55ed2 || 0.2076 || data-sort-value="87" | 87ed3 || data-sort-value="128" | 128ed5 || data-sort-value="154" | 154ed7 || data-sort-value="190" | 190ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="56" | 56ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="56" | 56ed2 || 0.1749 || data-sort-value="89" | 89ed3 || data-sort-value="130" | 130ed5 || data-sort-value="157" | 157ed7 || data-sort-value="194" | 194ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="57" | 57ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="57" | 57ed2 || 0.1996 || data-sort-value="90" | 90ed3 || data-sort-value="132" | 132ed5 || data-sort-value="160" | 160ed7 || data-sort-value="197" | 197ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="58" | 58ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="58" | 58ed2 || 0.1068 || data-sort-value="92" | 92ed3 || data-sort-value="135" | 135ed5 || data-sort-value="163" | 163ed7 || data-sort-value="201" | 201ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="59" | 59ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="59" | 59ed2 || 0.2773 || data-sort-value="94" | 94ed3 || data-sort-value="137" | 137ed5 || data-sort-value="166" | 166ed7 || data-sort-value="204" | 204ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="60" | 60ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="60" | 60ed2 || 0.1796 || data-sort-value="95" | 95ed3 || data-sort-value="139" | 139ed5 || data-sort-value="168" | 168ed7 || data-sort-value="208" | 208ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="61" | 61ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="61" | 61ed2 || 0.2374 || data-sort-value="97" | 97ed3 || data-sort-value="142" | 142ed5 || data-sort-value="171" | 171ed7 || data-sort-value="211" | 211ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="62" | 62ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="62" | 62ed2 || 0.1671 || data-sort-value="98" | 98ed3 || data-sort-value="144" | 144ed5 || data-sort-value="174" | 174ed7 || data-sort-value="214" | 214ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="63" | 63ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="63" | 63ed2 || 0.1595 || data-sort-value="100" | 100ed3 || data-sort-value="146" | 146ed5 || data-sort-value="177" | 177ed7 || data-sort-value="218" | 218ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="64" | 64ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="64" | 64ed2 || 0.3687 || data-sort-value="101" | 101ed3 || data-sort-value="149" | 149ed5 || data-sort-value="180" | 180ed7 || data-sort-value="221" | 221ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="65" | 65ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="65" | 65ed2 || 0.1242 || data-sort-value="103" | 103ed3 || data-sort-value="151" | 151ed5 || data-sort-value="182" | 182ed7 || data-sort-value="225" | 225ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="66" | 66ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="66" | 66ed2 || 0.2812 || data-sort-value="105" | 105ed3 || data-sort-value="153" | 153ed5 || data-sort-value="185" | 185ed7 || data-sort-value="228" | 228ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="67" | 67ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="67" | 67ed2 || 0.2299 || data-sort-value="106" | 106ed3 || data-sort-value="156" | 156ed5 || data-sort-value="188" | 188ed7 || data-sort-value="232" | 232ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="68" | 68ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="68" | 68ed2 || 0.1422 || data-sort-value="108" | 108ed3 || data-sort-value="158" | 158ed5 || data-sort-value="191" | 191ed7 || data-sort-value="235" | 235ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="69" | 69ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="69" | 69ed2 || 0.2667 || data-sort-value="109" | 109ed3 || data-sort-value="160" | 160ed5 || data-sort-value="194" | 194ed7 || data-sort-value="239" | 239ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="70" | 70ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="70" | 70ed2 || 0.1869 || data-sort-value="111" | 111ed3 || data-sort-value="163" | 163ed5 || data-sort-value="197" | 197ed7 || data-sort-value="242" | 242ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="71" | 71ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="71" | 71ed2 || 0.3092 || data-sort-value="113" | 113ed3 || data-sort-value="165" | 165ed5 || data-sort-value="199" | 199ed7 || data-sort-value="246" | 246ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="72" | 72ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="72" | 72ed2 || 0.0694 || data-sort-value="114" | 114ed3 || data-sort-value="167" | 167ed5 || data-sort-value="202" | 202ed7 || data-sort-value="249" | 249ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="73" | 73ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="73" | 73ed2 || 0.2000 || data-sort-value="116" | 116ed3 || data-sort-value="170" | 170ed5 || data-sort-value="205" | 205ed7 || data-sort-value="253" | 253ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="74" | 74ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="74" | 74ed2 || 0.2129 || data-sort-value="117" | 117ed3 || data-sort-value="172" | 172ed5 || data-sort-value="208" | 208ed7 || data-sort-value="256" | 256ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="75" | 75ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="75" | 75ed2 || 0.1980 || data-sort-value="119" | 119ed3 || data-sort-value="174" | 174ed5 || data-sort-value="211" | 211ed7 || data-sort-value="259" | 259ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="76" | 76ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="76" | 76ed2 || 0.2703 || data-sort-value="120" | 120ed3 || data-sort-value="176" | 176ed5 || data-sort-value="213" | 213ed7 || data-sort-value="263" | 263ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="77" | 77ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="77" | 77ed2 || 0.1253 || data-sort-value="122" | 122ed3 || data-sort-value="179" | 179ed5 || data-sort-value="216" | 216ed7 || data-sort-value="266" | 266ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="78" | 78ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="78" | 78ed2 || 0.2197 || data-sort-value="124" | 124ed3 || data-sort-value="181" | 181ed5 || data-sort-value="219" | 219ed7 || data-sort-value="270" | 270ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="79" | 79ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="79" | 79ed2 || 0.2076 || data-sort-value="125" | 125ed3 || data-sort-value="183" | 183ed5 || data-sort-value="222" | 222ed7 || data-sort-value="273" | 273ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="80" | 80ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="80" | 80ed2 || 0.1194 || data-sort-value="127" | 127ed3 || data-sort-value="186" | 186ed5 || data-sort-value="225" | 225ed7 || data-sort-value="277" | 277ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="81" | 81ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="81" | 81ed2 || 0.2101 || data-sort-value="128" | 128ed3 || data-sort-value="188" | 188ed5 || data-sort-value="227" | 227ed7 || data-sort-value="280" | 280ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="82" | 82ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="82" | 82ed2 || 0.1721 || data-sort-value="130" | 130ed3 || data-sort-value="190" | 190ed5 || data-sort-value="230" | 230ed7 || data-sort-value="284" | 284ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="83" | 83ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="83" | 83ed2 || 0.2603 || data-sort-value="132" | 132ed3 || data-sort-value="193" | 193ed5 || data-sort-value="233" | 233ed7 || data-sort-value="287" | 287ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="84" | 84ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="84" | 84ed2 || 0.1352 || data-sort-value="133" | 133ed3 || data-sort-value="195" | 195ed5 || data-sort-value="236" | 236ed7 || data-sort-value="291" | 291ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="85" | 85ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="85" | 85ed2 || 0.2679 || data-sort-value="135" | 135ed3 || data-sort-value="197" | 197ed5 || data-sort-value="239" | 239ed7 || data-sort-value="294" | 294ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="86" | 86ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="86" | 86ed2 || 0.2970 || data-sort-value="136" | 136ed3 || data-sort-value="200" | 200ed5 || data-sort-value="241" | 241ed7 || data-sort-value="298" | 298ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="87" | 87ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="87" | 87ed2 || 0.0995 || data-sort-value="138" | 138ed3 || data-sort-value="202" | 202ed5 || data-sort-value="244" | 244ed7 || data-sort-value="301" | 301ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="88" | 88ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="88" | 88ed2 || 0.2600 || data-sort-value="139" | 139ed3 || data-sort-value="204" | 204ed5 || data-sort-value="247" | 247ed7 || data-sort-value="304" | 304ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="89" | 89ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="89" | 89ed2 || 0.1370 || data-sort-value="141" | 141ed3 || data-sort-value="207" | 207ed5 || data-sort-value="250" | 250ed7 || data-sort-value="308" | 308ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="90" | 90ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="90" | 90ed2 || 0.2353 || data-sort-value="143" | 143ed3 || data-sort-value="209" | 209ed5 || data-sort-value="253" | 253ed7 || data-sort-value="311" | 311ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="91" | 91ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="91" | 91ed2 || 0.1707 || data-sort-value="144" | 144ed3 || data-sort-value="211" | 211ed5 || data-sort-value="255" | 255ed7 || data-sort-value="315" | 315ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="92" | 92ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="92" | 92ed2 || 0.2122 || data-sort-value="146" | 146ed3 || data-sort-value="214" | 214ed5 || data-sort-value="258" | 258ed7 || data-sort-value="318" | 318ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="93" | 93ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="93" | 93ed2 || 0.2418 || data-sort-value="147" | 147ed3 || data-sort-value="216" | 216ed5 || data-sort-value="261" | 261ed7 || data-sort-value="322" | 322ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="94" | 94ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="94" | 94ed2 || 0.1053 || data-sort-value="149" | 149ed3 || data-sort-value="218" | 218ed5 || data-sort-value="264" | 264ed7 || data-sort-value="325" | 325ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="95" | 95ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="95" | 95ed2 || 0.2252 || data-sort-value="151" | 151ed3 || data-sort-value="221" | 221ed5 || data-sort-value="267" | 267ed7 || data-sort-value="329" | 329ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="96" | 96ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="96" | 96ed2 || 0.1869 || data-sort-value="152" | 152ed3 || data-sort-value="223" | 223ed5 || data-sort-value="270" | 270ed7 || data-sort-value="332" | 332ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="97" | 97ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="97" | 97ed2 || 0.2401 || data-sort-value="154" | 154ed3 || data-sort-value="225" | 225ed5 || data-sort-value="272" | 272ed7 || data-sort-value="336" | 336ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="98" | 98ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="98" | 98ed2 || 0.2911 || data-sort-value="155" | 155ed3 || data-sort-value="228" | 228ed5 || data-sort-value="275" | 275ed7 || data-sort-value="339" | 339ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="99" | 99ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="99" | 99ed2 || 0.1055 || data-sort-value="157" | 157ed3 || data-sort-value="230" | 230ed5 || data-sort-value="278" | 278ed7 || data-sort-value="342" | 342ed11 | ||
|- | |- | ||
| data-sort-value="100" | 100ed2 || 0. | | data-sort-value="100" | 100ed2 || 0.3115 || data-sort-value="158" | 158ed3 || data-sort-value="232" | 232ed5 || data-sort-value="281" | 281ed7 || data-sort-value="346" | 346ed11 | ||
|} | |} | ||
Latest revision as of 22:04, 3 October 2026
| This user page is editable by any wiki editor.
As a general rule, most users expect their user space to be edited only by themselves, except for minor edits (e.g. maintenance), undoing obviously harmful edits such as vandalism or disruptive editing, and user talk pages. However, by including this message box, the author of this user page has indicated that this page is open to contributions from other users (e.g. content-related edits). |
SimHue 11 is intended as a simple heuristic for comparing how good EDOs (ed2s) are relative to their size at approximating the 11-limit.
It could be easily adapted into SimHue N for the N-prime-limit, or SimHue A.B.C for the subgroup A.B.C where A, B, C can be any harmonic or interval.
Definition
For each ed2, let N(ed2) be the number of steps that ed2 has.
Let N(ed3) be the number of steps its nearest ed3 has per 1200 cents.
Let N(ed5) be the number of steps its nearest ed5 has per 1200 cents.
And so on.
[math]\displaystyle{ \begin{aligned} S(\mathrm{ed2}) &= \frac{\left|N(\mathrm{ed2}) - N(\mathrm{ed3})\right|}{3} + \frac{\left|N(\mathrm{ed2}) - N(\mathrm{ed5})\right|}{5} + \frac{\left|N(\mathrm{ed2}) - N(\mathrm{ed7})\right|}{7} + \frac{\left|N(\mathrm{ed2}) - N(\mathrm{ed11})\right|}{11} \\ &\quad + \frac{\left|N(\mathrm{ed3}) - N(\mathrm{ed5})\right|}{5} + \frac{\left|N(\mathrm{ed3}) - N(\mathrm{ed7})\right|}{7} + \frac{\left|N(\mathrm{ed3}) - N(\mathrm{ed11})\right|}{11} \\ &\quad + \frac{\left|N(\mathrm{ed5}) - N(\mathrm{ed7})\right|}{7} + \frac{\left|N(\mathrm{ed5}) - N(\mathrm{ed11})\right|}{11} \\ &\quad + \frac{\left|N(\mathrm{ed7}) - N(\mathrm{ed11})\right|}{11} \end{aligned} }[/math]
S(ed2) is the SimHue 11 score for the ed2. Lower S(ed2) is better.
SimHue 11 scores for every EDO 1-100
| ed2 | S(ed2) | Nearest ed3 | Nearest ed5 | Nearest ed7 | Nearest ed11 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1ed2 | 0.3289 | 2ed3 | 2ed5 | 3ed7 | 3ed11 |
| 2ed2 | 0.2115 | 3ed3 | 5ed5 | 6ed7 | 7ed11 |
| 3ed2 | 0.2201 | 5ed3 | 7ed5 | 8ed7 | 10ed11 |
| 4ed2 | 0.2063 | 6ed3 | 9ed5 | 11ed7 | 14ed11 |
| 5ed2 | 0.1596 | 8ed3 | 12ed5 | 14ed7 | 17ed11 |
| 6ed2 | 0.2460 | 10ed3 | 14ed5 | 17ed7 | 21ed11 |
| 7ed2 | 0.1561 | 11ed3 | 16ed5 | 20ed7 | 24ed11 |
| 8ed2 | 0.2827 | 13ed3 | 19ed5 | 22ed7 | 28ed11 |
| 9ed2 | 0.1783 | 14ed3 | 21ed5 | 25ed7 | 31ed11 |
| 10ed2 | 0.1641 | 16ed3 | 23ed5 | 28ed7 | 35ed11 |
| 11ed2 | 0.3483 | 17ed3 | 26ed5 | 31ed7 | 38ed11 |
| 12ed2 | 0.1079 | 19ed3 | 28ed5 | 34ed7 | 42ed11 |
| 13ed2 | 0.3123 | 21ed3 | 30ed5 | 36ed7 | 45ed11 |
| 14ed2 | 0.2556 | 22ed3 | 33ed5 | 39ed7 | 48ed11 |
| 15ed2 | 0.1468 | 24ed3 | 35ed5 | 42ed7 | 52ed11 |
| 16ed2 | 0.2110 | 25ed3 | 37ed5 | 45ed7 | 55ed11 |
| 17ed2 | 0.2004 | 27ed3 | 39ed5 | 48ed7 | 59ed11 |
| 18ed2 | 0.2905 | 29ed3 | 42ed5 | 51ed7 | 62ed11 |
| 19ed2 | 0.1234 | 30ed3 | 44ed5 | 53ed7 | 66ed11 |
| 20ed2 | 0.2779 | 32ed3 | 46ed5 | 56ed7 | 69ed11 |
| 21ed2 | 0.2223 | 33ed3 | 49ed5 | 59ed7 | 73ed11 |
| 22ed2 | 0.1120 | 35ed3 | 51ed5 | 62ed7 | 76ed11 |
| 23ed2 | 0.3630 | 36ed3 | 53ed5 | 65ed7 | 80ed11 |
| 24ed2 | 0.1563 | 38ed3 | 56ed5 | 67ed7 | 83ed11 |
| 25ed2 | 0.2586 | 40ed3 | 58ed5 | 70ed7 | 86ed11 |
| 26ed2 | 0.1563 | 41ed3 | 60ed5 | 73ed7 | 90ed11 |
| 27ed2 | 0.1706 | 43ed3 | 63ed5 | 76ed7 | 93ed11 |
| 28ed2 | 0.2649 | 44ed3 | 65ed5 | 79ed7 | 97ed11 |
| 29ed2 | 0.1443 | 46ed3 | 67ed5 | 81ed7 | 100ed11 |
| 30ed2 | 0.2936 | 48ed3 | 70ed5 | 84ed7 | 104ed11 |
| 31ed2 | 0.0836 | 49ed3 | 72ed5 | 87ed7 | 107ed11 |
| 32ed2 | 0.2372 | 51ed3 | 74ed5 | 90ed7 | 111ed11 |
| 33ed2 | 0.2880 | 52ed3 | 77ed5 | 93ed7 | 114ed11 |
| 34ed2 | 0.1655 | 54ed3 | 79ed5 | 95ed7 | 118ed11 |
| 35ed2 | 0.2472 | 55ed3 | 81ed5 | 98ed7 | 121ed11 |
| 36ed2 | 0.1700 | 57ed3 | 84ed5 | 101ed7 | 125ed11 |
| 37ed2 | 0.1811 | 59ed3 | 86ed5 | 104ed7 | 128ed11 |
| 38ed2 | 0.1992 | 60ed3 | 88ed5 | 107ed7 | 131ed11 |
| 39ed2 | 0.2547 | 62ed3 | 91ed5 | 109ed7 | 135ed11 |
| 40ed2 | 0.2517 | 63ed3 | 93ed5 | 112ed7 | 138ed11 |
| 41ed2 | 0.0861 | 65ed3 | 95ed5 | 115ed7 | 142ed11 |
| 42ed2 | 0.2865 | 67ed3 | 98ed5 | 118ed7 | 145ed11 |
| 43ed2 | 0.1508 | 68ed3 | 100ed5 | 121ed7 | 149ed11 |
| 44ed2 | 0.2239 | 70ed3 | 102ed5 | 124ed7 | 152ed11 |
| 45ed2 | 0.2358 | 71ed3 | 104ed5 | 126ed7 | 156ed11 |
| 46ed2 | 0.1061 | 73ed3 | 107ed5 | 129ed7 | 159ed11 |
| 47ed2 | 0.3012 | 74ed3 | 109ed5 | 132ed7 | 163ed11 |
| 48ed2 | 0.1873 | 76ed3 | 111ed5 | 135ed7 | 166ed11 |
| 49ed2 | 0.1769 | 78ed3 | 114ed5 | 138ed7 | 170ed11 |
| 50ed2 | 0.1515 | 79ed3 | 116ed5 | 140ed7 | 173ed11 |
| 51ed2 | 0.2209 | 81ed3 | 118ed5 | 143ed7 | 176ed11 |
| 52ed2 | 0.2793 | 82ed3 | 121ed5 | 146ed7 | 180ed11 |
| 53ed2 | 0.0881 | 84ed3 | 123ed5 | 149ed7 | 183ed11 |
| 54ed2 | 0.3378 | 86ed3 | 125ed5 | 152ed7 | 187ed11 |
| 55ed2 | 0.2076 | 87ed3 | 128ed5 | 154ed7 | 190ed11 |
| 56ed2 | 0.1749 | 89ed3 | 130ed5 | 157ed7 | 194ed11 |
| 57ed2 | 0.1996 | 90ed3 | 132ed5 | 160ed7 | 197ed11 |
| 58ed2 | 0.1068 | 92ed3 | 135ed5 | 163ed7 | 201ed11 |
| 59ed2 | 0.2773 | 94ed3 | 137ed5 | 166ed7 | 204ed11 |
| 60ed2 | 0.1796 | 95ed3 | 139ed5 | 168ed7 | 208ed11 |
| 61ed2 | 0.2374 | 97ed3 | 142ed5 | 171ed7 | 211ed11 |
| 62ed2 | 0.1671 | 98ed3 | 144ed5 | 174ed7 | 214ed11 |
| 63ed2 | 0.1595 | 100ed3 | 146ed5 | 177ed7 | 218ed11 |
| 64ed2 | 0.3687 | 101ed3 | 149ed5 | 180ed7 | 221ed11 |
| 65ed2 | 0.1242 | 103ed3 | 151ed5 | 182ed7 | 225ed11 |
| 66ed2 | 0.2812 | 105ed3 | 153ed5 | 185ed7 | 228ed11 |
| 67ed2 | 0.2299 | 106ed3 | 156ed5 | 188ed7 | 232ed11 |
| 68ed2 | 0.1422 | 108ed3 | 158ed5 | 191ed7 | 235ed11 |
| 69ed2 | 0.2667 | 109ed3 | 160ed5 | 194ed7 | 239ed11 |
| 70ed2 | 0.1869 | 111ed3 | 163ed5 | 197ed7 | 242ed11 |
| 71ed2 | 0.3092 | 113ed3 | 165ed5 | 199ed7 | 246ed11 |
| 72ed2 | 0.0694 | 114ed3 | 167ed5 | 202ed7 | 249ed11 |
| 73ed2 | 0.2000 | 116ed3 | 170ed5 | 205ed7 | 253ed11 |
| 74ed2 | 0.2129 | 117ed3 | 172ed5 | 208ed7 | 256ed11 |
| 75ed2 | 0.1980 | 119ed3 | 174ed5 | 211ed7 | 259ed11 |
| 76ed2 | 0.2703 | 120ed3 | 176ed5 | 213ed7 | 263ed11 |
| 77ed2 | 0.1253 | 122ed3 | 179ed5 | 216ed7 | 266ed11 |
| 78ed2 | 0.2197 | 124ed3 | 181ed5 | 219ed7 | 270ed11 |
| 79ed2 | 0.2076 | 125ed3 | 183ed5 | 222ed7 | 273ed11 |
| 80ed2 | 0.1194 | 127ed3 | 186ed5 | 225ed7 | 277ed11 |
| 81ed2 | 0.2101 | 128ed3 | 188ed5 | 227ed7 | 280ed11 |
| 82ed2 | 0.1721 | 130ed3 | 190ed5 | 230ed7 | 284ed11 |
| 83ed2 | 0.2603 | 132ed3 | 193ed5 | 233ed7 | 287ed11 |
| 84ed2 | 0.1352 | 133ed3 | 195ed5 | 236ed7 | 291ed11 |
| 85ed2 | 0.2679 | 135ed3 | 197ed5 | 239ed7 | 294ed11 |
| 86ed2 | 0.2970 | 136ed3 | 200ed5 | 241ed7 | 298ed11 |
| 87ed2 | 0.0995 | 138ed3 | 202ed5 | 244ed7 | 301ed11 |
| 88ed2 | 0.2600 | 139ed3 | 204ed5 | 247ed7 | 304ed11 |
| 89ed2 | 0.1370 | 141ed3 | 207ed5 | 250ed7 | 308ed11 |
| 90ed2 | 0.2353 | 143ed3 | 209ed5 | 253ed7 | 311ed11 |
| 91ed2 | 0.1707 | 144ed3 | 211ed5 | 255ed7 | 315ed11 |
| 92ed2 | 0.2122 | 146ed3 | 214ed5 | 258ed7 | 318ed11 |
| 93ed2 | 0.2418 | 147ed3 | 216ed5 | 261ed7 | 322ed11 |
| 94ed2 | 0.1053 | 149ed3 | 218ed5 | 264ed7 | 325ed11 |
| 95ed2 | 0.2252 | 151ed3 | 221ed5 | 267ed7 | 329ed11 |
| 96ed2 | 0.1869 | 152ed3 | 223ed5 | 270ed7 | 332ed11 |
| 97ed2 | 0.2401 | 154ed3 | 225ed5 | 272ed7 | 336ed11 |
| 98ed2 | 0.2911 | 155ed3 | 228ed5 | 275ed7 | 339ed11 |
| 99ed2 | 0.1055 | 157ed3 | 230ed5 | 278ed7 | 342ed11 |
| 100ed2 | 0.3115 | 158ed3 | 232ed5 | 281ed7 | 346ed11 |