Tenney norm: Difference between revisions

From Xenharmonic Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Sintel (talk | contribs)
intro: remove HE mention
m - Wikipedia link. There's an article for James Tenney
 
(5 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Wikipedia| James Tenney }}
{{Texops}}
 
The '''Tenney norm''', otherwise known as '''harmonic distance''' ('''HD''') or '''Tenney height''', is commonly used as a measure of [[complexity]] for [[just interval]]s. If ''n''/''d'' is a positive rational number reduced to its lowest terms, then the [[Benedetti height]] is the integer ''nd''. Often it is more convenient instead to take the logarithm, usually base 2 ([[log2]]), of the Benedetti height, leading to the Tenney norm.  
The '''Tenney height''', '''Tenney norm''', or otherwise known as '''harmonic distance''' ('''HD'''), is widely used as a measure of [[complexity]] for [[just interval]]s. If ''n''/''d'' is a positive rational number reduced to its lowest terms, then the [[Benedetti height]] is the integer ''nd''. Often it is more convenient instead to take the logarithm, usually base 2 ([[log2]]), of the Benedetti height, leading to the Tenney height.  


== Computation ==
== Computation ==
=== Ratio form ===
=== Ratio form ===
The Tenney height of a ratio ''n''/''d'' is given by
The Tenney norm of a ratio ''n''/''d'' is given by


<math>\log_2 (nd)</math>
$$\log_2 (nd) $$


=== Vector form ===
=== Vector form ===
The Tenney height of a [[Harmonic limit|''p''-limit]] [[monzo]] '''m''' = {{monzo| ''m''<sub>1</sub> ''m''<sub>2</sub> … ''m''<sub>π (''p'')</sub> }} (π being the [[Wikipedia: prime-counting function|prime-counting function]]) is given by
The Tenney norm of a [[harmonic limit|''p''-limit]] [[monzo]] {{nowrap|'''m''' {{=}} {{monzo| ''m''<sub>1</sub> ''m''<sub>2</sub> … ''m''<sub>π (''p'')</sub> }}}} (π being the {{w|prime-counting function}}) is given by


<math>\lVert H \vec m \rVert_1 \\
$$
= \vert m_1 \vert + \vert m_2 \vert \log_2 (3) + \ldots + \vert m_{\pi (p)} \vert \log_2 (p) \\
\begin{align}
= \log_2 (2^{|m_1|} \cdot 3^{|m_2|} \cdot \ldots \cdot p^{|m_{\pi (p)}|})</math>
\norm{H \vec m}_1 &= \abs{m_1} + \abs{m_2} \log_2 (3) + \ldots + \abs{m_{\pi (p)}} \log_2 (p) \\
&= \log_2\left(2^{\abs{m_1}} \cdot 3^{\abs{m_2}} \cdot \ldots \cdot p^{\abs{m_{\pi (p)}}}\right)
\end{align}
$$


where ''H'' is the transformation matrix such that, for the prime basis ''Q'' = {{val| 2 3 5 … ''p'' }},  
where ''H'' is the transformation matrix such that, for the prime basis {{nowrap| ''Q'' {{=}} {{val| 2 3 5 … ''p'' }} }},  


<math>H = \operatorname {diag} (\log_2 (Q))</math>
$$ H = \operatorname {diag} (\log_2 (Q)) $$


== Examples ==
== Examples ==
{| class="wikitable center-2"
{| class="wikitable center-2"
! Interval Name
|-
! Interval name
! Ratio (''n''/''d'')
! Ratio (''n''/''d'')
! Monzo
! Monzo
! Tenney Height
! Tenney norm
|-
|-
| Unison
| Unison
Line 54: Line 57:


== History and terminology ==
== History and terminology ==
In general mathematics, this measurement is known as ''log-product complexity''. With respect to microtonal tuning, this measurement was first described by [[James Tenney]], who himself called it ''harmonic distance''.<ref>[https://www.plainsound.org/pdfs/JC&ToH.pdf ''John Cage and the Theory of Harmony'']. James Tenney. </ref><ref>[https://zh.booksc.eu/book/68954431/f87a1d ''On the Conception and Measure of Consonance'']. Alex Wand. </ref><ref>[https://scholar.sun.ac.za/bitstream/handle/10019.1/98644/brand_signal_2016.pdf?sequence=2&isAllowed=y ''A Signal-Based Model of Teleology in Tonal Music'']. Mark André Brand. p. 28. "Tenney's measure of ''harmonic distance'' (Hd) is thus singled out as perhaps his most 'crucial development', affording him the means towards 'compactness'. His is a Manhattan, rather than Euclidean metric, defined as Hd (''a''/''b'') = ''k''log(''ab''), with ''a''/''b'' the maximally reduced ratio representing the frequency difference, and ''k'' = 1 indicating measure in octaves."</ref> This terminology was also used in [[Paul Erlich]]'s paper [[A Middle Path]]<ref>Wherein Erlich writes: "This is why, in Tenney’s terminology, the taxicab distance an interval traverses in his lattice is the 'Harmonic Distance' of that interval."</ref>.   
In general mathematics, this measurement is known as ''log-product complexity''. With respect to microtonal tuning, this measurement was first described by [[James Tenney]], who himself called it ''harmonic distance''.<ref>[https://www.plainsound.org/pdfs/JC&ToH.pdf ''John Cage and the Theory of Harmony'']. James Tenney. </ref><ref>[https://zh.booksc.eu/book/68954431/f87a1d ''On the Conception and Measure of Consonance'']. Alex Wand. </ref><ref>[https://scholar.sun.ac.za/bitstream/handle/10019.1/98644/brand_signal_2016.pdf?sequence=2&isAllowed=y ''A Signal-Based Model of Teleology in Tonal Music'']. Mark André Brand. p. 28. "Tenney's measure of ''harmonic distance'' (Hd) is thus singled out as perhaps his most 'crucial development', affording him the means towards 'compactness'. His is a Manhattan, rather than Euclidean metric, defined as {{nowrap|Hd(''a''/''b'') {{=}} ''k'' log(''ab'')}}, with ''a''/''b'' the maximally reduced ratio representing the frequency difference, and {{nowrap|''k'' {{=}} 1}} indicating measure in octaves."</ref> This terminology was also used in [[Paul Erlich]]'s paper [[A Middle Path]]<ref>Wherein Erlich writes: "This is why, in Tenney’s terminology, the taxicab distance an interval traverses in his lattice is the 'Harmonic Distance' of that interval."</ref>.   


== See also ==
== See also ==
* [[Generalized Tenney norms and Tp interval space|Generalized Tenney norms and T<sub>''p''</sub> interval space]]
* [[Generalized Tenney norms and Tp interval space|Generalized Tenney norms and T<sub>''p''</sub> interval space]]


== Notes ==
== References ==
<references />


[[Category:Consonance and dissonance]]
[[Category:Consonance and dissonance]]

Latest revision as of 02:17, 3 September 2025

[math]\displaystyle{ \def\hs{\hspace{-3px}} \def\lvsp{{}\mkern-5.5mu}{} \def\rvsp{{}\mkern-2.5mu}{} \def\llangle{\left\langle\lvsp\left\langle} \def\lllangle{\left\langle\lvsp\left\langle\lvsp\left\langle} \def\llllangle{\left\langle\lvsp\left\langle\lvsp\left\langle\lvsp\left\langle} \def\llbrack{\left[\left[} \def\lllbrack{\left[\left[\left[} \def\llllbrack{\left[\left[\left[\left[} \def\llvert{\left\vert\left\vert} \def\lllvert{\left\vert\left\vert\left\vert} \def\llllvert{\left\vert\left\vert\left\vert\left\vert} \def\rrangle{\right\rangle\rvsp\right\rangle} \def\rrrangle{\right\rangle\rvsp\right\rangle\rvsp\right\rangle} \def\rrrrangle{\right\rangle\rvsp\right\rangle\rvsp\right\rangle\rvsp\right\rangle} \def\rrbrack{\right]\right]} \def\rrrbrack{\right]\right]\right]} \def\rrrrbrack{\right]\right]\right]\right]} \def\rrvert{\right\vert\right\vert} \def\rrrvert{\right\vert\right\vert\right\vert} \def\rrrrvert{\right\vert\right\vert\right\vert\right\vert} }[/math][math]\displaystyle{ \def\abs#1{\left|{#1}\right|} \def\norm#1{\left\|{#1}\right\|} \def\floor#1{\left\lfloor{#1}\right\rfloor} \def\ceil#1{\left\lceil{#1}\right\rceil} \def\round#1{\left\lceil{#1}\right\rfloor} \def\rround#1{\left\lfloor{#1}\right\rceil} }[/math] The Tenney norm, otherwise known as harmonic distance (HD) or Tenney height, is commonly used as a measure of complexity for just intervals. If n/d is a positive rational number reduced to its lowest terms, then the Benedetti height is the integer nd. Often it is more convenient instead to take the logarithm, usually base 2 (log2), of the Benedetti height, leading to the Tenney norm.

Computation

Ratio form

The Tenney norm of a ratio n/d is given by

$$\log_2 (nd) $$

Vector form

The Tenney norm of a p-limit monzo m = [m1 m2mπ (p) (π being the prime-counting function) is given by

$$ \begin{align} \norm{H \vec m}_1 &= \abs{m_1} + \abs{m_2} \log_2 (3) + \ldots + \abs{m_{\pi (p)}} \log_2 (p) \\ &= \log_2\left(2^{\abs{m_1}} \cdot 3^{\abs{m_2}} \cdot \ldots \cdot p^{\abs{m_{\pi (p)}}}\right) \end{align} $$

where H is the transformation matrix such that, for the prime basis Q = 2 3 5 … p],

$$ H = \operatorname {diag} (\log_2 (Q)) $$

Examples

Interval name Ratio (n/d) Monzo Tenney norm
Unison 1/1 [0 0
Octave 2/1 [1 1
Just perfect fifth 3/2 [-1 1 2.585
Just major third 5/4 [-2 0 1 4.322
Harmonic seventh 7/4 [-2 0 0 1 4.807

History and terminology

In general mathematics, this measurement is known as log-product complexity. With respect to microtonal tuning, this measurement was first described by James Tenney, who himself called it harmonic distance.[1][2][3] This terminology was also used in Paul Erlich's paper A Middle Path[4].

See also

References

  1. John Cage and the Theory of Harmony. James Tenney.
  2. On the Conception and Measure of Consonance. Alex Wand.
  3. A Signal-Based Model of Teleology in Tonal Music. Mark André Brand. p. 28. "Tenney's measure of harmonic distance (Hd) is thus singled out as perhaps his most 'crucial development', affording him the means towards 'compactness'. His is a Manhattan, rather than Euclidean metric, defined as Hd(a/b) = k log(ab), with a/b the maximally reduced ratio representing the frequency difference, and k = 1 indicating measure in octaves."
  4. Wherein Erlich writes: "This is why, in Tenney’s terminology, the taxicab distance an interval traverses in his lattice is the 'Harmonic Distance' of that interval."