Talk:11edo: Difference between revisions

Line 6:

"The wiki page for 11EDO might need brushing up in regards to consistency, since it keeps referring to the "correct" 9-limit intervals, but the listed val in 3-limit cannot produce those 🤔 Because the 3rd harmonic is so flat, it would put 9/8 at 1\11 edosteps, but the page keeps referring it to 2\11."

: I don't really see the issue. Mapping 9/8 to 1/11 seems absurd, and the interval table does state that it's based on the 2.9 subgroup and not 2.3.

: I don't really see the issue. Mapping 9/8 to 1\11 seems absurd, and the interval table does state that it's based on the 2.9 subgroup and not 2.3.

: Maybe the confusion is because in the regular temperament properties the full 13-limit [11 17 26 31 38 41] is assumed (which is questionable for sure).

: – [[User:Sintel|<span style="color:#965d99">Sintel</span>🎏]] ([[User_talk:Sintel|talk]]) 22:55, 13 February 2025 (UTC)

@@ Line 6: / Line 6: @@
 "The wiki page for 11EDO might need brushing up in regards to consistency, since it keeps referring to the "correct" 9-limit intervals, but the listed val in 3-limit cannot produce those 🤔 Because the 3rd harmonic is so flat, it would put 9/8 at 1\11 edosteps, but the page keeps referring it to 2\11."
-: I don't really see the issue. Mapping 9/8 to 1/11 seems absurd, and the interval table does state that it's based on the 2.9 subgroup and not 2.3.
+: I don't really see the issue. Mapping 9/8 to 1\11 seems absurd, and the interval table does state that it's based on the 2.9 subgroup and not 2.3.
 : Maybe the confusion is because in the regular temperament properties the full 13-limit [11 17 26 31 38 41] is assumed (which is questionable for sure).
 : – [[User:Sintel|<span style="color:#965d99">Sintel</span>🎏]] ([[User_talk:Sintel|talk]]) 22:55, 13 February 2025 (UTC)