Talk:29edo

This page also contains archived Wikispaces discussion.

Logarithmic mathematical constants vs acoustic mathematical constants

When we are hearing logarithmic phi, we are in fact hearing the number 2**(phi) = 3.070

Same thing for logarithmic pi, the number that comes to our ears is 2**(pi) = 8.825

While these intervals can still be used in a way or another as useful tones in a piece of music, they don't correspond to anything.

Moreover, music is fundamentally the art of numbers made audible. This is something that was already known in antiquity. That's why I believe that what is completely outside the "grid of numbers" and the "harmonic grids" that emerge from it does not truly correspond to what music is fundamentally nor to the actual functioning of hearing (for this reason, I believe that most of what was composed in the Second Viennese School does not truly correspond to what music is deeply about, although it is interesting to analyse intellectually).

This is why I say that logarithmic phi and pi are not musical.

When it comes to acoustic constants, we are truly hearing the mathematical constants phi = 1.6180 and pi = 3.1416

Acoustic constants are the only real musical ones.

--Contribution (talk) 15:51, 7 March 2023 (UTC)

I agree they are not of much harmonic value, but you seem to be the one who added them yourself.

Plz remember to sign your talk by leaving four tildes.

FloraC (talk) 13:30, 7 March 2023 (UTC)