User talk:Overthink: Difference between revisions

Line 5:

I see that you've done some pretty good work on updating temperament pages and infoboxes and the like. However, we have already been dealing with a glut of stubs - i.e. pages with very minimal content beyond what is automatically generated - created for large EDOs or impractical intervals. You have failed to demonstrate notability for these EDOs, which is a very high burden when dealing with systems in the thousands or even hundreds of thousands of notes.

One reason you might be making these pages is that you just want to look at the harmonics table. I do that on ~~a subpage of my userpage:~~ [[User:Lériendil/ET ~~harmonics~~ testing page]] for the sake of minimizing disruption to the wiki, and I advise that you do similar in the future. Consider this a warning; you seem to want to make useful contributions, so let us mutually assume good faith.

One reason you might be making these pages is that you just want to look at the harmonics table. I do that on [[User:Lériendil/ET harmonic testing page|a subpage of my userpage]] for the sake of minimizing disruption to the wiki, and I advise that you do similar in the future. Consider this a warning; you seem to want to make useful contributions, so let us mutually assume good faith.

Thanks,

- [[User:Lériendil|Lériendil]] ([[User talk:Lériendil|talk]]) 07:23, 22 September 2025 (UTC)

@@ Line 5: / Line 5: @@
 I see that you've done some pretty good work on updating temperament pages and infoboxes and the like. However, we have already been dealing with a glut of stubs - i.e. pages with very minimal content beyond what is automatically generated - created for large EDOs or impractical intervals. You have failed to demonstrate notability for these EDOs, which is a very high burden when dealing with systems in the thousands or even hundreds of thousands of notes.
-One reason you might be making these pages is that you just want to look at the harmonics table. I do that on a subpage of my userpage: [[User:Lériendil/ET harmonics testing page]] for the sake of minimizing disruption to the wiki, and I advise that you do similar in the future. Consider this a warning; you seem to want to make useful contributions, so let us mutually assume good faith.
+One reason you might be making these pages is that you just want to look at the harmonics table. I do that on [[User:Lériendil/ET harmonic testing page|a subpage of my userpage]] for the sake of minimizing disruption to the wiki, and I advise that you do similar in the future. Consider this a warning; you seem to want to make useful contributions, so let us mutually assume good faith.
 Thanks,
 - [[User:Lériendil|Lériendil]] ([[User talk:Lériendil|talk]]) 07:23, 22 September 2025 (UTC)