Xenharmonic Wiki:Things to do: Difference between revisions

Line 121:

I'm hoping for further discussion on how to deal with pages listing temperaments of various ranks that are all connected by the tempering if a single comma, such as the Archipelago, and even the Quartismic family page. Is it possible that these could be analyzed as types of "X family" or "X clan" pages depending on the nature of the comma? From the looks of things, how we handle the page on the Biosphere page in particular will determine how we handle the the current "Quartismic family" page going forward as there seem to be a lot of structural parallels. --[[User:Aura|Aura]] ([[User talk:Aura|talk]]) 17:46, 31 December 2020 (UTC)

== Comma tables in EDO pages ==

We found that the comma tables on EDO pages are overloaded with information already given elsewhere. This self-evolving "convention" makes it hard to provide consistent and correct information about, (alternative) names, corrections etc. The original information should eventually find place in a dedicated page for each comma; the overview pages about [[comma]]s ([[Large comma]], [[Medium comma]], [[Small comma]], [[Unnoticeable comma]]) should be seen as secondary source then. Currently we tend to reduce the comma tables on EDO pages to at most three columns:

* p-Limit

* linked name or fraction (depending) on the lemma of the link target

* Comments (this column should not be entirely empty)

@@ Line 121: / Line 121: @@
 I'm hoping for further discussion on how to deal with pages listing temperaments of various ranks that are all connected by the tempering if a single comma, such as the Archipelago, and even the Quartismic family page.  Is it possible that these could be analyzed as types of "X family" or "X clan" pages depending on the nature of the comma? From the looks of things, how we handle the page on the Biosphere page in particular will determine how we handle the the current "Quartismic family" page going forward as there seem to be a lot of structural parallels. --[[User:Aura|Aura]] ([[User talk:Aura|talk]]) 17:46, 31 December 2020 (UTC)
+== Comma tables in EDO pages ==
+We found that the comma tables on EDO pages are overloaded with information already given elsewhere. This self-evolving "convention" makes it hard to provide consistent and correct information about, (alternative) names, corrections etc. The original information should eventually find place in a dedicated page for each comma; the overview pages about [[comma]]s ([[Large comma]], [[Medium comma]], [[Small comma]], [[Unnoticeable comma]]) should be seen as secondary source then. Currently we tend to reduce the comma tables on EDO pages to at most three columns:
+* p-Limit
+* linked name or fraction (depending) on the lemma of the link target
+* Comments (this column should not be entirely empty)