|
|
| Line 21: |
Line 21: |
| === Path-based goodnesses and octave stretches for the equal temperaments 7-41: === | | === Path-based goodnesses and octave stretches for the equal temperaments 7-41: === |
| (these use target_score 0.02 instead of 0.002; the order remains mostly unchanged, but all the values here are smaller than they would be at the correct target_score.) | | (these use target_score 0.02 instead of 0.002; the order remains mostly unchanged, but all the values here are smaller than they would be at the correct target_score.) |
| 1. 41et: goodness 30.8. 2: 0.10. score <3, <6: 3.9%, 11.5%
| | {| class="wikitable" style="text-align: right;" |
| 2. 31et: goodness 28.2. 2: 0.33. score <3, <6: 4.2%, 13.0%
| | |+ Temperament Rankings |
| 3. 34et: goodness 26.0. 2: -1.06. score <3, <6: 4.6%, 13.9%
| | ! style="width: 25%;" | EDO |
| 4. 36et: goodness 26.0. 2: 0.44. score <3, <6: 4.5%, 13.2%
| | ! style="width: 25%;" | GPV |
| 5. 37et: goodness 24.3. 2: -0.68. score <3, <6: 4.6%, 13.0%
| | ! style="width: 25%;" | Goodness |
| 6. 38et: goodness 23.3. 2: 2.26. score <3, <6: 4.8%, 13.6% which is likely easy to navigate due to sharing features with 19edo
| | ! style="width: 25%;" | Octave stretch |
| 7. 24et: goodness 22.8. 2: 0.03. score <3, <6: 4.9%, 15.3%
| | |- |
| 8. 29et: goodness 22.8. 2: 2.45. score <3, <6: 4.6%, 14.0% Note that 29et is identical to 58et on the 2.3.7/5.11/5.13/5 subgroup
| | | 1 || 1.06 || 10.8 || +0.00 |
| 9. 40et: goodness 22.7. 2: 1.51. score <3, <6: 4.4%, 12.4% which is likely easy to navigate due to supporting orwell and diminished
| | |- |
| 10. 22et: goodness 22.5. 2: -0.51. score <3, <6: 4.8%, 15.1% the best temperament below 29
| | | 2 || 2.03 || 10.6 || +0.00 |
| 11. 26et: goodness 22.4. 2: 2.57. score <3, <6: 4.5%, 15.0%
| | |- |
| 12. 27et: goodness 22.4. 2: -2.56. score <3, <6: 5.0%, 14.4%
| | | 3 || 3.12 || 13.5 || -0.03 |
| 13. 19et: goodness 21.5. 2: 3.75. score <3, <6: 5.5%, 17.7% the best temperament below 22
| | |- |
| 14. 32et: goodness 20.2. 2: -0.45. score <3, <6: 4.9%, 14.3% which is likely easy to navigate due to supporting pajara
| | | 4 || 4.03 || 12.1 || +0.01 |
| 15. 39et: goodness 20.1. 2: -1.63. score <3, <6: 5.6%, 14.4%
| | |- |
| 16. 33et: goodness 19.2. 2: -0.02. score <3, <6: 4.9%, 13.3% which is likely placed so high due to higher-limit accuracy
| | | 5 || 5.06 || 13.7 || +0.11 |
| 17. 35et: goodness 18.7. 2: 1.97. score <3, <6: 5.2%, 14.7%
| | |- |
| 18. 17et: goodness 17.4. 2: -2.42. score <3, <6: 7.1%, 21.4%
| | | 6 || 6.03 || 12.6 || -0.47 |
| 19. 30et: goodness 16.9. 2: -2.47. score <3, <6: 5.4%, 14.8% which shares many features with 15et and lands close to it in badness
| | |- |
| 20. 28et: goodness 16.7. 2: -0.05. score <3, <6: 6.5%, 16.8%
| | | 7 || 7.03 || 14.1 || +10.58 |
| 21. 21et: goodness 16.5. 2: -0.21. score <3, <6: 5.8%, 17.6%
| | |- |
| 22. 12et: goodness 16.3. 2: 0.35. score <3, <6: 8.7%, 28.2% octave-stretched for an even worse 5/1 because it was never that good anyway
| | | 8 || 8.12 || 14.4 || -0.09 |
| 23. 25et: goodness 15.9. 2: 0.90. score <3, <6: 7.2%, 19.0%
| | |- |
| 24. 15et: goodness 15.8. 2: -3.91. score <3, <6: 5.9%, 19.6%
| | | 9 || 8.97 || 15.9 || -0.10 |
| 25. 20et: goodness 14.7. 2: 1.79. score <3, <6: 6.3%, 16.2%
| | |- |
| 26. 16et: goodness 14.6. 2: 4.64. score <3, <6: 6.3%, 18.1%
| | | 10 || 10.12 || 17.3 || +0.19 |
| 27. 14et: goodness 12.6. 2: 9.46. score <3, <6: 8.2%, 21.3% near 22edt even though we're using the wrong mapping for prime 5, thus ignoring it
| | |- |
| 28. 10et: goodness 12.6. 2: 3.35. score <3, <6: 6.7%, 15.6%
| | | 11 || 11.03 || 17.4 || -0.17 |
| 29. 23et: goodness 12.0. 2: 0.03. score <3, <6: 9.2%, 21.7%
| | |- |
| 30. 18et: goodness 11.4. 2: 1.48. score <3, <6: 8.4%, 18.0%
| | | 12 || 11.97 || 24.9 || +0.49 |
| 31. 13et: goodness 9.8. 2: 4.95. score <3, <6: 9.2%, 26.7%
| | |- |
| 32. 9et: goodness 9.7. 2: -0.26. score <3, <6: 13.1%, 38.8%
| | | 13 || 13.03 || 15.2 || +0.00 |
| 33. 7et: goodness 8.6. 2: 10.80. score <3, <6: 12.1%, 38.2% near 11edt
| | |- |
| 34. 8et: goodness 6.9. 2: -0.07. score <3, <6: 21.9%, 71.7%
| | | 14 || 13.91 || 21.1 || +9.93 |
| 35. 11et: goodness 6.9. 2: -0.28. score <3, <6: 21.9%, 83.5%
| | |- |
| | | | 15 || 15.12 || 22.6 || -3.43 |
| | |- |
| | | 16 || 16.00 || 20.2 || +4.52 |
| | |- |
| | | 17 || 17.12 || 26.2 || -2.36 |
| | |- |
| | | 18 || 18.09 || 19.7 || -8.70 |
| | |- |
| | | 19 || 18.97 || 29.5 || +3.64 |
| | |- |
| | | 20 || 19.94 || 19.9 || +2.01 |
| | |- |
| | | 21 || 21.00 || 23.1 || -0.71 |
| | |- |
| | | 22 || 22.06 || 30.3 || -1.04 |
| | |- |
| | | 23 || 22.91 || 21.5 || +9.07 |
| | |- |
| | | 24 || 24.00 || 30.7 || +0.13 |
| | |- |
| | | 25 || 25.06 || 23.7 || +0.87 |
| | |- |
| | | 26 || 25.94 || 30.6 || +3.03 |
| | |- |
| | | 27 || 27.12 || 32.8 || -4.21 |
| | |- |
| | | 28 || 27.94 || 24.3 || +0.04 |
| | |- |
| | | 29 || 28.94 || 31.8 || +3.28 |
| | |} |
| [[Category:Badness]] | | [[Category:Badness]] |