User:Hkm/Rankings: Difference between revisions

From Xenharmonic Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
← Older editNewer edit →
VisualWikitext
Hkm (talk | contribs)
934 edits
No edit summary
Hkm (talk | contribs)
934 edits
No edit summary
Line 19: Line 19:
| Nuorvala || [https://youtu.be/qMDfQZg-tRQ Violin sonata] || 22edo || Classical; violin and piano || 3.33 || 1
| Nuorvala || [https://youtu.be/qMDfQZg-tRQ Violin sonata] || 22edo || Classical; violin and piano || 3.33 || 1
|-
|-
| Harrison || [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yG69xptl1Bc From Ancient Worlds] || JI (2.3.7) || solo piano || 3.33 || 1
| Harrison || [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yG69xptl1Bc From Ancient Worlds] || JI (2.3.7) || full album; solo piano || 3.33 || 1
|-
|-
| Tapeworm Saga || [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QooiCwiouPM Languor Study] || 26edo || - || 3.33 || 2
| Tapeworm Saga || [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QooiCwiouPM Languor Study] || 26edo || - || 3.33 || 2
Line 25: Line 25:
| Blackwood || Etudes: 15edo || 15edo || Original version || 3.27 || 2
| Blackwood || Etudes: 15edo || 15edo || Original version || 3.27 || 2
|-
|-
| benyamind || A progression in 31-tone equal temperament: 31edo || ||  || 3.17 || 1
| benyamind || A progression in 31-tone equal temperament || 31edo
|  || 3.17 || 1
|-
|-
| Tapeworm Saga || A quick quintet, music for 5 EWIs in 17edo || 17edo ||  || 3.13 || 1
| Tapeworm Saga || A quick quintet, music for 5 EWIs in 17edo || 17edo ||  || 3.13 || 1
|-
|-
| Wrenharmonic || Larger Than The Oceans: 53edo || ||  || 3.13 || 1
| Wrenharmonic || Larger Than The Oceans || 53edo
|  || 3.13 || 1
|-
|-
| Grégoire Blanc || A microtonal teatime jam: 27edo || ||  || 3.13 || 1
| Grégoire Blanc || A microtonal teatime jam || 27edo
|  || 3.13 || 1
|-
|-
| Costa || [https://microtonalharmonyproject.bandcamp.com/track/debussy-syrinx-19-edo-flute-quartett Debussy's "Syrinx" arranged for flute quartet] || 17edo ||  || 3.12 || 2
| Costa || [https://microtonalharmonyproject.bandcamp.com/track/debussy-syrinx-19-edo-flute-quartett Debussy's "Syrinx" arranged for flute quartet] || 17edo ||  || 3.12 || 2
Line 37: Line 40:
| Johnston || String Quartet No 4 || JI ||  || 3.12 || 2
| Johnston || String Quartet No 4 || JI ||  || 3.12 || 2
|-
|-
| LΛMPLIGHT || Caftaphata: 41edo + JI + 12edo ||  ||  || 3.07 || 1
| LΛMPLIGHT || Caftaphata || Various
| 41edo, JI, 12edo || 3.07 || 1
|-
|-
| E8 Heterotic (Chris Simmons) || Glaukos Circuit: 29edo || ||  || 3.07 || 1
| E8 Heterotic (Chris Simmons) || Glaukos Circuit || 29edo
|  || 3.07 || 1
|-
|-
| SunScent || Mimicry Symdrome: 31edo || ||  || 3.07 || 1
| SunScent || Mimicry Symdrome || 31edo
|  || 3.07 || 1
|-
|-
| dotuXil || Enter Nil: 22edo || ||  || 3.07 || 1
| dotuXil || Collected Refractions: Enter Nil || 22edo
|  || 3.07 || 1
|-
|-
| Abnormality || Moondust: 26edo || ||  || 3.07 || 1
| Abnormality || Moondust || 26edo
| "Have to listen to it multiple times with openness."
| 3.07 || 1
|-
|-
| Abnormality || Stardust: 22edo || || || 3.03 || 1
| Abnormality || Stardust || 22edo || "Intense in a way I don't really see in 12edo music."
| 3.03 || 1
|-
|-
| dotuXil || Cheat Codes: 19edo || ||  || 3.03 || 1
| dotuXil || Cheat Codes || 19edo
|  || 3.03 || 1
|-
|-
| Xotla Music || Rive: 17edo || ||  || 3.03 || 1
| Xotla Music || Rive || 17edo
|  || 3.03 || 1
|-
|-
| Xotla Music || Equilibrate: 13edo || ||  || 3.03 || 1
| Xotla Music || Equilibrate || 13edo ||  || 3.03 || 1
|-
|-
| Blackwood || Etudes: 24edo || 24edo || Original version || 3.00 || 1
| Blackwood || Etudes: 24edo || 24edo || Original version || 3.00 || 1
Line 61: Line 73:
| Osmium || Heartbeat || 28edo || [[User:Godtone]] || 3.00 || 1
| Osmium || Heartbeat || 28edo || [[User:Godtone]] || 3.00 || 1
|-
|-
| SunScent || KYO/Punitive Life: 31edo || ||  || 3.00 || 1
| SunScent || KYO/Punitive Life || 31edo
|  || 3.00 || 1
|-
|-
| Uncreative Name || Isles of Despair: 15edo || ||  || 3.00 || 1
| Uncreative Name || Isles of Despair || 15edo
|  || 3.00 || 1
|-
|-
| E8 Heterotic (Chris Simmons) || No Threes For You: 34edo || ||  || 3.00 || 1
| E8 Heterotic (Chris Simmons) || No Threes For You || 34edo
|  || 3.00 || 1
|-
|-
| E8 Heterotic (Chris Simmons) || Ennead Dance: 17edo || ||  || 2.97 || 1
| E8 Heterotic (Chris Simmons) || Ennead Dance || 17edo
|  || 2.97 || 1
|-
|-
| Sintel || Diversion in 34: 34edo || ||  || 2.97 || 1
| Sintel || Diversion in 34 || 34edo
|  || 2.97 || 1
|-
|-
| Xotla Music || Brusselator Sprouts: 13edo || ||  || 2.97 || 1
| Xotla Music || Brusselator Sprouts || 13edo ||  || 2.97 || 1
|-
|-
| Costa || [https://microtonalharmonyproject.bandcamp.com/track/enharmonic-study-31-edo-2 Enharmonic Study (31edo version)] || 31edo ||  || 2.93 || 1
| Costa || [https://microtonalharmonyproject.bandcamp.com/track/enharmonic-study-31-edo-2 Enharmonic Study (31edo version)] || 31edo ||  || 2.93 || 1

Revision as of 01:52, 22 March 2025

Even though works should be analyzed and talked about in more nuanced terms than ratings, ratings are a valuable thing to keep track of. This is because compiled ratings can provide the best estimations of what music is the most worthwhile to listen to. By leaving a rating, you are contributing positively to people's ability to find enjoyable xen music.

Rate any xenharmonic work on the talk page from 0 to 5. You may rate both larger projects and songs from those projects. If a song is part of a larger project, we ask that you name it as [LARGER PROJECT]: [SONG]. If the creator is a person posting music under their real name, please use the last name only unless there is a need for disambiguation between people with the same last name. If the creator has a xen wiki account, do not link that account. Feel free to write it in the Notes section.

If you do not have an account, message me on the XA Discord @hyperbolekillsme with your ratings.

Write your ratings in the talk page in the same form as the examples there. If you want to provide a work's tuning, link, or notes if you are the first person to rate it, create a row at the bottom of the table without filling in the "R" or "#" columns. (If you're wondering how you can translate your thoughts about each work into ratings, the hypothetical ratings of all the xen music you've listened to, including music so bad it’s not worth rating, should follow a uniform distribution from 0 to 5. This means that a 3/5 is a good score. Alternatively, you can decide to not rate things this way--I wouldn't be able to tell)

Ratings are compiled once a day at least. Ratings displayed here are averaged with 0 and 5 as per this 3blue1brown video. The following table is created with this program. This should ideally be a bot, but I think I need permission to create those. Hopefully it's easily adaptable into a bot.

Creator Work Tuning Notes R #
Sintel Top Ten most Epic fish of all time Only movements "9. Hagfish," "6. Wobbegong," "5. Ghost Shark," and "1. Coelacanth" are xenharmonic. 3.45 2
Blackwood Etudes: 16edo 16edo Original version 3.38 2
Nuorvala Violin sonata 22edo Classical; violin and piano 3.33 1
Harrison From Ancient Worlds JI (2.3.7) full album; solo piano 3.33 1
Tapeworm Saga Languor Study 26edo - 3.33 2
Blackwood Etudes: 15edo 15edo Original version 3.27 2
benyamind A progression in 31-tone equal temperament 31edo 3.17 1
Tapeworm Saga A quick quintet, music for 5 EWIs in 17edo 17edo 3.13 1
Wrenharmonic Larger Than The Oceans 53edo 3.13 1
Grégoire Blanc A microtonal teatime jam 27edo 3.13 1
Costa Debussy's "Syrinx" arranged for flute quartet 17edo 3.12 2
Johnston String Quartet No 4 JI 3.12 2
LΛMPLIGHT Caftaphata Various 41edo, JI, 12edo 3.07 1
E8 Heterotic (Chris Simmons) Glaukos Circuit 29edo 3.07 1
SunScent Mimicry Symdrome 31edo 3.07 1
dotuXil Collected Refractions: Enter Nil 22edo 3.07 1
Abnormality Moondust 26edo "Have to listen to it multiple times with openness." 3.07 1
Abnormality Stardust 22edo "Intense in a way I don't really see in 12edo music." 3.03 1
dotuXil Cheat Codes 19edo 3.03 1
Xotla Music Rive 17edo 3.03 1
Xotla Music Equilibrate 13edo 3.03 1
Blackwood Etudes: 24edo 24edo Original version 3.00 1
Costa Arabesque 19edo 3.00 1
Osmium Heartbeat 28edo User:Godtone 3.00 1
SunScent KYO/Punitive Life 31edo 3.00 1
Uncreative Name Isles of Despair 15edo 3.00 1
E8 Heterotic (Chris Simmons) No Threes For You 34edo 3.00 1
E8 Heterotic (Chris Simmons) Ennead Dance 17edo 2.97 1
Sintel Diversion in 34 34edo 2.97 1
Xotla Music Brusselator Sprouts 13edo 2.97 1
Costa Enharmonic Study (31edo version) 31edo 2.93 1
vivi mouse fog 2.93 1
Blackwood Etudes: 20edo 20edo Original version 2.90 1
dogwithabome to have my bones be one with the river 18edo 2.90 1
Serafini Do Androids Dream of 18ed2? 18edo 2.87 1
Blackwood Etudes: 18edo 18edo Original version 2.83 1
Blackwood Etudes Various Original version 2.83 1
Costa Danse-Etude 17edo 2.83 1
Jumble Undiminished 84edo 2.83 1
DotuXil Collected Refractions: Odd Harmonic *13edt 2.77 2
Hunt Equal-Tempered Keyboard: Prelude in 14et 14edo 2.77 1
Jumble Azure 22edo Ambient 2.70 2
Groundfault A New Dusk Various 2.66 3
Blackwood Etudes: 17edo 17edo Original version 2.62 2
Blackwood Etudes: 22edo 22edo Original version 2.60 1
Blackwood Etudes: 14edo 14edo Original version 2.60 1
Costa Short piece 72edo 2.60 1
Costa Messaien's "O Sacrum Convivium" 19edo 2.60 1
Blackwood Etudes: 23edo 23edo Original version 2.57 1
Blackwood Etudes: 19edo 19edo Original version 2.53 1
DotuXil Collected Refractions: A Multitude of New Colors 2.53 1
Blackwood Etudes: 13edo 2.33 1
Blackwood Etudes: 21edo 21edo Original version 2.27 1

* this asterisk is included for edts so that when sorting by tuning they do not appear with edos

Retrieved from "https://en.xen.wiki/index.php?title=User:Hkm/Rankings&oldid=187637"