User:FloraC/Quick reference: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
-outdated stuff |
|||
| (6 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
** JI purism: this school recognizes that the acoustic quality of JI is of top importance. Some consider music as a platonic ideal object that cannot be approximated at all. Meanwhile, its weaker version is characterized by being maximally strict about JI approximation. | ** JI purism: this school recognizes that the acoustic quality of JI is of top importance. Some consider music as a platonic ideal object that cannot be approximated at all. Meanwhile, its weaker version is characterized by being maximally strict about JI approximation. | ||
*** Primodality: I don't feel entitled to define this. | *** Primodality: I don't feel entitled to define this. | ||
*** Stacking based | *** Stacking based a.k.a. lattice based: a more traditional approach to JI. They recognize both the acoustic quality and the algebraic structure of JI. | ||
** JI approximabilism: this school recognizes that the acoustic quality of JI and the algebraic structure of tuning systems are similarly important, and therefore accepts a tradeoff. | ** JI approximabilism: this school recognizes that the acoustic quality of JI and the algebraic structure of tuning systems are similarly important, and therefore accepts a tradeoff. | ||
*** RTT: this school encompasses stacking based JI and applies approximation for custom structures. | *** RTT: this school encompasses stacking based JI and applies approximation for custom structures. | ||
| Line 12: | Line 12: | ||
== Important prime limits == | == Important prime limits == | ||
; 2-limit (rank-1): | |||
* Essential equivalence | |||
* Completes the harmonic series for the first octave | |||
; 3-limit (rank-2): | ; 3-limit (rank-2): | ||
* Essential interval functions | * Essential interval functions | ||
* Completes the harmonic series for the first 2 octaves | |||
* Rank is a highly composite number | |||
; 5-limit (rank-3): | |||
* Completes the harmonic series for the first 2 octaves and a fifth | |||
; 7-limit (rank-4): | |||
* Tonality: tonal | |||
* Categorical characteristics: pivotal and semiambitonal | |||
* Completes the harmonic series for the first 3 octaves | |||
* Rank is a highly composite number | |||
; 11-limit (rank-5): | |||
* Completes the harmonic series for the first 3 octaves and a fifth | |||
; 13-limit (rank-6): | ; 13-limit (rank-6): | ||
* Essential interval colors | * Essential interval colors | ||
* Tonality: | * Tonality: microtonal | ||
* Categorical characteristics: | * Categorical characteristics: ambitonal and semiambitonal | ||
* | * Completes the harmonic series for the first 4 octaves | ||
* Rank is a highly composite number | |||
; 23-limit (rank-9): | ; 23-limit (rank-9): | ||
| Line 26: | Line 45: | ||
* Tonality: pseudotonal and pseudomicrotonal | * Tonality: pseudotonal and pseudomicrotonal | ||
* Categorical characteristics: pseudoambitonal | * Categorical characteristics: pseudoambitonal | ||
* | * Completes the harmonic series for the first 4 octaves and a fifth | ||
* Followed by a record prime gap | * Followed by a record prime gap | ||
; 31-limit (rank-11) | ; 31-limit (rank-11) | ||
* | * Completes the harmonic series for the first 5 octaves | ||
; 37-limit (rank-12) | ; 37-limit (rank-12) | ||
* Rank is a highly composite number | |||
; 47-limit (rank-15) | ; 47-limit (rank-15) | ||
* | * Completes the harmonic series for the first 5 octaves and a fifth | ||
; 61-limit (rank-18) | ; 61-limit (rank-18) | ||
* | * Completes the harmonic series for the first 6 octaves | ||
; 89-limit (rank-24) | ; 89-limit (rank-24) | ||
* | * Completes the harmonic series for the first 6 octaves and a fifth | ||
* Followed by a record prime gap | * Followed by a record prime gap | ||
* Rank is a highly composite number | |||
== Edo sizes == | |||
* Exo: 0–9 | |||
* Small: 10–38 | |||
** Semitonic: 10–14 | |||
** Subsemitonic: 15–26 | |||
** Dietic: 27–38 | |||
* Medium: 39–79 | |||
** Commatic: 39–67 | |||
** Subcommatic: 68–79 | |||
* Large: 80–190 | |||
** Hemicommatic: 80–132 | |||
** Codettic: 133–137 | |||
** Kleismatic: 138–190 | |||
* Mega: 191+ | |||
** Subkleismatic | |||
** Hemikleismatic | |||
** … | |||
Latest revision as of 10:06, 18 January 2026
Taxonomy of tuning approaches
- Tuning rationalism
- JI purism: this school recognizes that the acoustic quality of JI is of top importance. Some consider music as a platonic ideal object that cannot be approximated at all. Meanwhile, its weaker version is characterized by being maximally strict about JI approximation.
- Primodality: I don't feel entitled to define this.
- Stacking based a.k.a. lattice based: a more traditional approach to JI. They recognize both the acoustic quality and the algebraic structure of JI.
- JI approximabilism: this school recognizes that the acoustic quality of JI and the algebraic structure of tuning systems are similarly important, and therefore accepts a tradeoff.
- RTT: this school encompasses stacking based JI and applies approximation for custom structures.
- JI agnosticism: this school suspends the question whether the acoustic quality of JI is of importance. It tends to focus on algebraic structures such as mos scales and generalizations.
- JI indifferentism: this school does not believe the acoustic quality of JI is of importance. Practice in this school is orthogonal to the influence of JI.
- JI purism: this school recognizes that the acoustic quality of JI is of top importance. Some consider music as a platonic ideal object that cannot be approximated at all. Meanwhile, its weaker version is characterized by being maximally strict about JI approximation.
- Tuning empiricism
- Tuning stochasticism
Important prime limits
- 2-limit (rank-1)
- Essential equivalence
- Completes the harmonic series for the first octave
- 3-limit (rank-2)
- Essential interval functions
- Completes the harmonic series for the first 2 octaves
- Rank is a highly composite number
- 5-limit (rank-3)
- Completes the harmonic series for the first 2 octaves and a fifth
- 7-limit (rank-4)
- Tonality: tonal
- Categorical characteristics: pivotal and semiambitonal
- Completes the harmonic series for the first 3 octaves
- Rank is a highly composite number
- 11-limit (rank-5)
- Completes the harmonic series for the first 3 octaves and a fifth
- 13-limit (rank-6)
- Essential interval colors
- Tonality: microtonal
- Categorical characteristics: ambitonal and semiambitonal
- Completes the harmonic series for the first 4 octaves
- Rank is a highly composite number
- 23-limit (rank-9)
- Limit of classical functional harmony
- Limit of classical concordance
- Tonality: pseudotonal and pseudomicrotonal
- Categorical characteristics: pseudoambitonal
- Completes the harmonic series for the first 4 octaves and a fifth
- Followed by a record prime gap
- 31-limit (rank-11)
- Completes the harmonic series for the first 5 octaves
- 37-limit (rank-12)
- Rank is a highly composite number
- 47-limit (rank-15)
- Completes the harmonic series for the first 5 octaves and a fifth
- 61-limit (rank-18)
- Completes the harmonic series for the first 6 octaves
- 89-limit (rank-24)
- Completes the harmonic series for the first 6 octaves and a fifth
- Followed by a record prime gap
- Rank is a highly composite number
Edo sizes
- Exo: 0–9
- Small: 10–38
- Semitonic: 10–14
- Subsemitonic: 15–26
- Dietic: 27–38
- Medium: 39–79
- Commatic: 39–67
- Subcommatic: 68–79
- Large: 80–190
- Hemicommatic: 80–132
- Codettic: 133–137
- Kleismatic: 138–190
- Mega: 191+
- Subkleismatic
- Hemikleismatic
- …