Telicity: Difference between revisions

Inthar (talk | contribs)
Remove double negative
Tags: Mobile edit Mobile web edit
Aura (talk | contribs)
An attempt at describing why telicity is useful based on Sintel's work.
Line 1: Line 1:
'''Telicity''' is a property of both [[equal temperament]]s and [[comma]]s and how they relate to each other.  Specifically, for [[EDO]]s, it is the quality or state of being able to successfully stack a number of instances of a given prime's [[patent interval]] to connect with an interval belonging to a chain created by a lower prime's patent interval – designated as the '''telos''' – so that all of the tempered intervals on either prime's patent interval chain, and the tempered comma connecting the two prime chains in question, satisfy the following equation where ''N'' is the number of steps in a given EDO, ''r'' is the ratio of an interval in one of the two prime chains in question, and val (''N'') denotes the [[patent val]] of ''N''-EDO:
'''Telicity''' is a property of both [[equal temperament]]s and [[comma]]s and how they relate to each other.  Specifically, for [[EDO]]s, it is the quality or state of being able to successfully stack a number of instances of a given prime's [[direct approximation]] to connect with an interval belonging to a chain created by a lower prime's direct approximation – designated as the '''telos''' – so that all of the tempered intervals on either prime's approximation chain, and the tempered comma connecting the two prime chains in question, satisfy the following equation where ''N'' is the number of steps in a given EDO, ''r'' is the ratio of an interval in one of the two prime chains in question, and val (''N'') denotes the [[patent val]] or [[simple map]] of ''N''-EDO:


<math>\text{val} (N) \cdot \text{monzo} (r) = \text{round} (N \log_2 (r))</math>
<math>\text{val} (N) \cdot \text{monzo} (r) = \text{round} (N \log_2 (r))</math>


Commas and equal temperaments that demonstrate this property are referred to as as being '''telic'''.  When a given EDO is telic in a given multiprime relationship by more than one means, it can be said to be '''multitelic'''.
Commas and equal temperaments that demonstrate this property are referred to as as being '''telic'''.  When a given EDO is telic in a given multiprime relationship by more than one means, it can be said to be '''multitelic'''.
== Telicity and Mappings ==
In order to understand how and why telicity is useful, one must first realize that there are two ways of constructing a mapping for a given EDO. 
The first is the construct a [[regular temperament]], in which you first establish a set of approximations to prime intervals, putting the values into a [[temperament mapping matrix]] and, from there, just take the prime factorization and multiply to get other desired intervals.  For example, in creating a simple map for [[12edo]], mapping matrix 'M' of [12 19 28], from which we can calculate the following:
* M(5/4) = 4
* M(81/80) = 0
* M(81/80)^3 = 0
Now because M is linear, it satisfies the conditions:
* M(a) + M(b) = M(a * b)  (for two JI intervals a, b)
* n*M(a) = M (a^n)  (for some integer n)
The second way to construct a mapping is to just round, using the equation F(r) = round(N⋅log2(r)) in which 'N' is the number of EDO-steps and 'r' is the ratio in question.  For 12edo, this is F(r) = round(12⋅log2(r)), from which we can calculate the following:
* F(5/4) = 4
* F(81/80) = 0
* F((81/80)^3) = 1 (!)
Because F is not a linear function, it does not satisfy any of the conditions above. So even though rounding sometimes gives us better approximations, it doesn't conserve interval interval arithmetic, and conserving interval arithmetic is why we care about RTT in the first place.
However, people who care about 'both' good approximations 'and' conserving interval arithmetic are seemingly presented with a dilemma- either go with a linear map and risk bad approximations, or go with a non-linear map and risk inconsistent interval arithmetic.  This is why telicity is useful- when one is able to work with the section of the EDO's harmonic lattice in which both mapping methods lead to the same result and limit the harmonic lattice to this section, one has the best of both worlds, hence the equation described above.


== Telicity Range and Usable EDO Sizes ==
== Telicity Range and Usable EDO Sizes ==
Line 13: Line 37:
== Telicity Type Designations ==
== Telicity Type Designations ==


Different equal temperaments have different relationships among the various primes that are used to define their [[patent val]]s, and thus, there is a need to designate these relationships. Given that EDOs specifically are defined as equal divisions of the [[octave]], the 2-prime – which defines the octave – is always listed last, with the largest prime being listed first, and other primes being listed in the middle from largest to smallest thus, for example a '''telic connection''' between the 3-prime and the 2-prime is denoted as 3-2 telicity.  It should be noted that the only type of telicity available to the 3-prime is 3-2 telicity, as 2 is the only positive prime lower than 3, and since octave equivalency renders the unison as the only available target, that means that the 3-prime requires a complete [[circle of fifths]] without accumulating 50% relative error or more in order to achieve telicity.  However, higher primes have more options for achieving a form of telicity as there are multiple lower primes to chose from to potentially connect with.  For instance, the 5-prime has both 5-3 and 5-2 telicity available to it.  Not only that, but in cases where multiple overlapping telic relationships exist for a given EDO without the largest tempered comma failing to satisfy the telicity equation, one can express all of these telic relationships within a single designation.  For example, [[12edo]], which simultaneously demonstrates 3-2 telicity, 5-3 telicity, and 5-2 telicity, can be said to demonstrate 5-3-2 telicity.
Different equal temperaments have different relationships among the various primes that are used to define their [[patent val]]s, and thus, there is a need to designate these relationships. Given that EDOs specifically are defined as equal divisions of the [[octave]], the 2-prime – which defines the octave – is always listed last, with the largest prime being listed first, and other primes being listed in the middle from largest to smallest thus, for example a '''telic connection''' between the 3-prime and the 2-prime is denoted as 3-2 telicity.  It should be noted that the only type of telicity available to the 3-prime is 3-2 telicity, as 2 is the only positive prime lower than 3, and since octave equivalency renders the unison as the only available target, that means that the 3-prime requires a complete [[circle of fifths]] without accumulating 50% relative error or more in order to achieve telicity.  However, higher primes have more options for achieving a form of telicity as there are multiple lower primes to chose from to potentially connect with.  For instance, the 5-prime has both 5-3 and 5-2 telicity available to it.  Not only that, but in cases where multiple overlapping telic relationships exist for a given EDO without the largest tempered comma failing to satisfy the telicity equation, one can express all of these telic relationships within a single designation.  For example, 12edo, which simultaneously demonstrates 3-2 telicity, 5-3 telicity, and 5-2 telicity, can be said to demonstrate 5-3-2 telicity.


== k-Strong Telicity ==
== k-Strong Telicity ==
Line 23: Line 47:
Harmonics, and especially primes, are fairly simple as both [[equave]]s and [[generator]]s when it comes to telicity, and since all of these interval ratios are integers, this type of telicity can be referred to specifically as '''integer telicity'''.  However, when the equave and or the generator are a combination of primes, things are more complicated, leading to the broader term '''rational telicity''' as a descriptor for this second type of telicity.
Harmonics, and especially primes, are fairly simple as both [[equave]]s and [[generator]]s when it comes to telicity, and since all of these interval ratios are integers, this type of telicity can be referred to specifically as '''integer telicity'''.  However, when the equave and or the generator are a combination of primes, things are more complicated, leading to the broader term '''rational telicity''' as a descriptor for this second type of telicity.


== Telicity On Subgroups ==
== Telicity on Subgroups ==
Telicity is often most useful in the accurate modelling of subgroups of interest; it therefore makes sense to define senses of telicity for subgroups. This builds on the idea that a telic connection between two generators in a rank one temperament can be k-strong. Consider a set of generators. As we are generalising the notion, the generators need not necessarily prime, but ideally all generators are either harmonics (positive integers > 1) or at least (ideally low-complexity) intervals of significant musical interest. Then a subgroup (a set of rationals > 1 AKA a "set of generators") is '''k-strong pairwise telic''' if there is a k-strong telic connection between every pair of generators. If a subgroup is "almost" k-strong pairwise telic except for exactly '''n''' pairs of generators lacking a k-strong telic connection, then it is instead '''n-deficient k-strong pairwise-telic'''. (If a subgroup is "1-strong pairwise telic" it is simply '''pairwise telic'''.) This means that a subgroup can be both "pairwise telic" and "n-deficient k-strong pairwise-telic" simultaneously. This can be abbreviated as being '''n-weak k-strong pairwise-telic'''.
Telicity is often most useful in the accurate modelling of subgroups of interest; it therefore makes sense to define senses of telicity for subgroups. This builds on the idea that a telic connection between two generators in a rank one temperament can be k-strong. Consider a set of generators. As we are generalising the notion, the generators need not necessarily prime, but ideally all generators are either harmonics (positive integers > 1) or at least (ideally low-complexity) intervals of significant musical interest. Then a subgroup (a set of rationals > 1 AKA a "set of generators") is '''k-strong pairwise telic''' if there is a k-strong telic connection between every pair of generators. If a subgroup is "almost" k-strong pairwise telic except for exactly '''n''' pairs of generators lacking a k-strong telic connection, then it is instead '''n-deficient k-strong pairwise-telic'''. (If a subgroup is "1-strong pairwise telic" it is simply '''pairwise telic'''.) This means that a subgroup can be both "pairwise telic" and "n-deficient k-strong pairwise-telic" simultaneously. This can be abbreviated as being '''n-weak k-strong pairwise-telic'''.