User talk:Xenwolf: Difference between revisions

Line 895:

We (including [[User:SupahstarSaga]], [[User:Fredg999]] and I) would like to resurrect [[Xenharmonic_Wiki:Things_to_do#Odd_harmonics_table_instead_of_prime_harmonics_for_edos|an old suggestion of mine]], namely using odds instead of primes. This is because odd mappings give more information at a glance than primes: odd harmonic mappings don't always correspond to prime mappings (for example, a stack of two best 3's don't always make the best 9), and subgroup interpretations can sometimes care about ratios between odds harmonics, for example, 7/5 and 11/5. I made a template implementing this suggestion here: [[User:Inthar/Template:Harmonics_in_edo]]. We also want to do this with other equal-step tunings such as [[13edt]]. Tom Price also suggested an additional visual idea I really like. We could try implementing that with Lua, but in the meantime I think this will do.

I'd just like to reopen the discussion about this suggested change. Please let me know if you have any concerns.

I'd just like to reopen the discussion about this suggested change. Please let me know on the relevant discussion page if you have any concerns.

[[User:Inthar|Inthar]] ([[User talk:Inthar|talk]]) 21:15, 24 July 2021 (UTC)

@@ Line 895: / Line 895: @@
 We (including [[User:SupahstarSaga]], [[User:Fredg999]] and I) would like to resurrect [[Xenharmonic_Wiki:Things_to_do#Odd_harmonics_table_instead_of_prime_harmonics_for_edos|an old suggestion of mine]], namely using odds instead of primes. This is because odd mappings give more information at a glance than primes: odd harmonic mappings don't always correspond to prime mappings (for example, a stack of two best 3's don't always make the best 9), and subgroup interpretations can sometimes care about ratios between odds harmonics, for example, 7/5 and 11/5. I made a template implementing this suggestion here: [[User:Inthar/Template:Harmonics_in_edo]]. We also want to do this with other equal-step tunings such as [[13edt]]. Tom Price also suggested an additional visual idea I really like. We could try implementing that with Lua, but in the meantime I think this will do.
-I'd just like to reopen the discussion about this suggested change. Please let me know if you have any concerns.
+I'd just like to reopen the discussion about this suggested change. Please let me know on the relevant discussion page if you have any concerns.
 [[User:Inthar|Inthar]] ([[User talk:Inthar|talk]]) 21:15, 24 July 2021 (UTC)