Xenharmonic Wiki:Deleted temperament entries: Difference between revisions
m FloraC moved page Deleted temperaments to Xenharmonic Wiki:Deleted temperament entries: This is mainly a matter of Wiki management |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
This page collects deleted entries of [[regular temperament]]s from the Xenharmonic Wiki due to not meeting our [[Xenharmonic Wiki: Notability guidelines|notability guidelines]], although other materials may still reference them. We recommend to refer to these temperaments with an ET [[join]] (e. g. "11-limit 12 & 85") or as a [[restriction]] of a different temperament (e. g. "no-7's cassandra"). | |||
{| class="wikitable" style="margin: auto;" | {| class="wikitable" style="margin: auto;" | ||
|+ | |+ | ||
! | ! Name | ||
!Subgroup | ! Subgroup | ||
! | ! ET join | ||
!Reason for deletion | ! Reason for deletion | ||
|- | |- | ||
|Oviminor | | Oviminor | ||
|5 to 7-limit | | 5 to 7-limit | ||
|19 & 1600 | | 19 & 1600 | ||
|More complex than egads (which shares the same generator) at lower accuracy | | More complex than egads (which shares the same generator) at lower accuracy | ||
|- | |- | ||
|Maqamschismic | | Maqamschismic | ||
|11 to 13-limit | | 11 to 13-limit | ||
|41 & 53 | | 41 & 53 | ||
|Removes prime 7 from cassandra even though prime 11 has higher complexity and error | | Removes prime 7 from cassandra even though prime 11 has higher complexity and error | ||
|- | |- | ||
|Quintapole | | Quintapole | ||
|7 to 11-limit | | 7 to 11-limit | ||
|12 & 85 | | 12 & 85 | ||
|Medium accuracy is not worth the high complexity; could lead to confusion with similarly named "quintupole" | | Medium accuracy is not worth the high complexity; could lead to confusion with similarly named "quintupole" | ||
|- | |- | ||
|Quintapole > Galeleic | | Quintapole > Galeleic | ||
|13 to 19-limit | | 13 to 19-limit | ||
|12f & 85fg | | 12f & 85fg | ||
|Medium accuracy is not worth the high complexity; not even supported by any patent vals | | Medium accuracy is not worth the high complexity; not even supported by any patent vals | ||
|- | |- | ||
|Quintapole > Catagali | | Quintapole > Catagali | ||
|13 to 19-limit | | 13 to 19-limit | ||
|12f & 85g | | 12f & 85g | ||
|Medium accuracy is not worth the high complexity; not even supported by any patent vals | | Medium accuracy is not worth the high complexity; not even supported by any patent vals | ||
|- | |- | ||
|Quintapole > Quintain | | Quintapole > Quintain | ||
|11 to 13-limit | | 11 to 13-limit | ||
|12 & 85e | | 12 & 85e | ||
|Medium accuracy is not worth the high complexity | | Medium accuracy is not worth the high complexity | ||
|- | |- | ||
|Bixby | | Bixby | ||
|5-limit | | 5-limit | ||
|1 & 1c | | 1 & 1c | ||
|Too coarse even for detempering | | Too coarse even for detempering | ||
|- | |- | ||
|Archon | | Archon | ||
|5-limit | | 5-limit | ||
|1 & 1b | | 1 & 1b | ||
|Too coarse even for detempering | | Too coarse even for detempering | ||
|- | |- | ||
|Seesaw | | Seesaw | ||
|2.3.5(.11) | | 2.3.5(.11) | ||
|1b & 2 | | 1b & 2 | ||
|Too coarse even for detempering | | Too coarse even for detempering | ||
|- | |- | ||
|Seesaw > Heavy windmill | | Seesaw > Heavy windmill | ||
|7 to 11-limit | | 7 to 11-limit | ||
|1bd & 2 | | 1bd & 2 | ||
|Too coarse even for detempering | | Too coarse even for detempering | ||
|- | |- | ||
|Seesaw > Light windmill | | Seesaw > Light windmill | ||
|7 to 11-limit | | 7 to 11-limit | ||
|1b & 2 | | 1b & 2 | ||
|Too coarse even for detempering | | Too coarse even for detempering | ||
|- | |- | ||
|Sixseven | | Sixseven | ||
|2.3.7(.13) | | 2.3.7(.13) | ||
|1 & 3 | | 1 & 3 | ||
|Too coarse even for detempering | | Too coarse even for detempering | ||
|- | |- | ||
|Sixseven > Heaven | | Sixseven > Heaven | ||
|2.3.7.11(.13) | | 2.3.7.11(.13) | ||
|1e & 3 | | 1e & 3 | ||
|Too coarse even for detempering | | Too coarse even for detempering | ||
|- | |- | ||
|Dog | | Dog | ||
|2.3.19 | | 2.3.19 | ||
|7 & 16 | | 7 & 16 | ||
|No reason to interpret the resultant scales as dog rather than mavila / unenlightening restriction of armodog | | No reason to interpret the resultant scales as dog rather than mavila / unenlightening restriction of armodog | ||
|- | |- | ||
|Sept | | Sept | ||
|7 to 13-limit | | 7 to 13-limit | ||
|7 & 14de | | 7 & 14de | ||
|No reason to leave prime 5 free in 7et rather than prime 7 | | No reason to leave prime 5 free in 7et rather than prime 7 | ||
|- | |- | ||
|Counterorson | | Counterorson | ||
|7-limit | | 7-limit | ||
|53 & 1718 | | 53 & 1718 | ||
|High badness at all but unusable complexity | | High badness at all but unusable complexity | ||
|- | |- | ||
|Counterquectismic | | Counterquectismic | ||
|5-limit | | 5-limit | ||
|359 & 665 | | 359 & 665 | ||
|High badness at unusable complexity | | High badness at unusable complexity | ||
|- | |- | ||
|Quectismic | | Quectismic | ||
|5-limit | | 5-limit | ||
|306 & 665 | | 306 & 665 | ||
|High badness at unusable complexity | | High badness at unusable complexity | ||
|- | |- | ||
|Nanoquectismic | | Nanoquectismic | ||
|7-limit | | 7-limit | ||
|306 & 665 | | 306 & 665 | ||
|High badness at unusable complexity | | High badness at unusable complexity | ||
|- | |- | ||
|Conanoquectismic | | Conanoquectismic | ||
|7-limit | | 7-limit | ||
|306d & 665 | | 306d & 665 | ||
|Extremely high badness at unusable complexity | | Extremely high badness at unusable complexity | ||
|} | |} | ||
[[Category: | |||
[[Category:Xenharmonic Wiki guidelines]] | |||