User:FloraC/Temperament extension issues: Difference between revisions

Line 27:

: 7-limit → 11-limit → 13-limit

: 11-limit ennealimmal should be decanonicalized. Further, 13-limit ennealimmal should be decanonicalized with respect to the 11-limit to make way for the other extension to be canon. Compared to the absolute supremacy of the 7-limit temperament, the 11-limit is mid, and the 13-limit is just utterly wrong. This should be obvious from the badness values and the optimal GPV sequences, but also the Graham complexities: 225 for 99e & 171e vs 189 for 99ef & 171ef.

: The names of the ennealimmal extensions demonstrate an absolute devoidness of creativity. The same morpheme combination ''ennealimma'' is re-used again and again, making all the extension names almost undistinguishable. Therefore I believe in rectifying these names we should inject new morphemes into the scene, while keeping the ''ennea-'' part to remind users of their relations. 11-limit ennealimmal (99e & 171e) tempers out the symbiotic comma, so it can be called ''enneabiotic''. Further, since 13-limit 99e & 171e is the worse extension, it can be ''enneabio''. The other high-accuracy 11-limit extension, 99 & 171, tempers out the olympic comma, so it can be called ''ennealympic''.

: The names of the ennealimmal extensions demonstrate an absolute devoidness of creativity. The same morpheme combination ''ennealimma'' is re-used again and again, making all the extension names almost undistinguishable. Therefore I believe in rectifying these names we should inject new morphemes into the scene, while keeping the ''ennea-'' part to remind users of their relations. 11-limit ennealimmal (99e & 171e) tempers out the symbiotic comma, so it can be called ''enneabiotic''. Further, since 13-limit 99e & 171e is the worse extension, it can be ''enneabio''. The other high-accuracy 11-limit extension, 99 & 171, tempers out the olympic comma, so it can be called ''ennealympic''. Ennealimnic and ennealiminal were named earlier so I think they can stay.

: Ennealimnic and ennealiminal were named earlier so I think they can stay.

: ''Semiennealimmal'' is extremely misleading. It tempers out the pine comma so it can be ''ennealimmapine''. This name is a little long but the temp itself isn't very notable anyway.

: Proposed solution: 11-limit ennealimmal, 13-limit ennealimmalis → enneabiotic; 13-limit ennealimmal → enneabio; ennealimmia → ennealympic; semiennealimmal → ennealimmapine. Status: pending community reaction.

: Proposed solution: 11-limit ennealimmal, 13-limit ennealimmalis → enneabiotic; 13-, 17-, 19-limit ennealimmal → enneabio; ennealimmia → ennealympic; semiennealimmal → ennealimmapine. Status: pending community reaction.

; Keemun

@@ Line 27: / Line 27: @@
 : 7-limit → 11-limit → 13-limit
 : 11-limit ennealimmal should be decanonicalized. Further, 13-limit ennealimmal should be decanonicalized with respect to the 11-limit to make way for the other extension to be canon. Compared to the absolute supremacy of the 7-limit temperament, the 11-limit is mid, and the 13-limit is just utterly wrong. This should be obvious from the badness values and the optimal GPV sequences, but also the Graham complexities: 225 for 99e & 171e vs 189 for 99ef & 171ef.
-: The names of the ennealimmal extensions demonstrate an absolute devoidness of creativity. The same morpheme combination ''ennealimma'' is re-used again and again, making all the extension names almost undistinguishable. Therefore I believe in rectifying these names we should inject new morphemes into the scene, while keeping the ''ennea-'' part to remind users of their relations. 11-limit ennealimmal (99e & 171e) tempers out the symbiotic comma, so it can be called ''enneabiotic''. Further, since 13-limit 99e & 171e is the worse extension, it can be ''enneabio''. The other high-accuracy 11-limit extension, 99 & 171, tempers out the olympic comma, so it can be called ''ennealympic''.
+: The names of the ennealimmal extensions demonstrate an absolute devoidness of creativity. The same morpheme combination ''ennealimma'' is re-used again and again, making all the extension names almost undistinguishable. Therefore I believe in rectifying these names we should inject new morphemes into the scene, while keeping the ''ennea-'' part to remind users of their relations. 11-limit ennealimmal (99e & 171e) tempers out the symbiotic comma, so it can be called ''enneabiotic''. Further, since 13-limit 99e & 171e is the worse extension, it can be ''enneabio''. The other high-accuracy 11-limit extension, 99 & 171, tempers out the olympic comma, so it can be called ''ennealympic''. Ennealimnic and ennealiminal were named earlier so I think they can stay.
-: Ennealimnic and ennealiminal were named earlier so I think they can stay.
 : ''Semiennealimmal'' is extremely misleading. It tempers out the pine comma so it can be ''ennealimmapine''. This name is a little long but the temp itself isn't very notable anyway.
-: Proposed solution: 11-limit ennealimmal, 13-limit ennealimmalis → enneabiotic; 13-limit ennealimmal → enneabio; ennealimmia → ennealympic; semiennealimmal → ennealimmapine. Status: pending community reaction.
+: Proposed solution: 11-limit ennealimmal, 13-limit ennealimmalis → enneabiotic; 13-, 17-, 19-limit ennealimmal → enneabio; ennealimmia → ennealympic; semiennealimmal → ennealimmapine. Status: pending community reaction.
 ; Keemun