27edo: Difference between revisions
→Notation: added the modern (as opposed to the classical) version of the ups and downs accidentals, moved some text to two new sections for extended pyth notation and quartertone notation. |
ArrowHead294 (talk | contribs) mNo edit summary |
||
Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
== Theory == | == Theory == | ||
Assuming pure octaves, 27edo divides the [[octave]] in 27 equal parts each exactly 44{{frac|4|9}} [[cent]]s in size. Its fifth and harmonic seventh are both sharp by 9 | Assuming pure octaves, 27edo divides the [[octave]] in 27 equal parts each exactly 44{{frac|4|9}} [[cent]]s in size. Its fifth and harmonic seventh are both sharp by 9{{c}}, and the major third is the same 400-cent major third as [[12edo]], sharp by 13.7{{c}}. The result is that [[6/5]], [[7/5]], and especially [[7/6]] are all tuned more accurately than this. It can be considered the superpythagorean counterpart of [[19edo]], as its 5th is audibly indistinguishable from [[superpyth|1/3-septimal-comma superpyth]] in the same way that 19edo is audibly indistinguishable from [[1/3-comma meantone|1/3-syntonic-comma meantone]], where three fifths in 19edo reach a near-perfect [[6/5]] and [[5/3]] and three fifths in 27edo reaching a near-perfect [[7/6]] and [[12/7]]. | ||
Though 27edo's [[7-limit]] tuning is not highly accurate, it nonetheless is the smallest equal division to represent the [[7-odd-limit]] both [[consistent]]ly and | Though 27edo's [[7-limit]] tuning is not highly accurate, it nonetheless is the smallest equal division to represent the [[7-odd-limit]] both [[consistent]]ly and distinctly—that is, everything in the [[7-odd-limit]] [[tonality diamond]] is uniquely represented by a certain number of steps of 27edo. It also represents the 13th harmonic very well, and performs quite decently as a 2.3.5.7.13.19 (no-11's, no-17's 19-limit) temperament. It also approximates [[19/10]], [[19/12]], and [[19/14]], so {{dash|0, 7, 13, 25|med}} does quite well as a 10:12:14:19 chord, with the major seventh 25\27 being less than one cent off from 19/10. Octave-inverted, these also form a quite convincing approximation of the main Bohlen–Pierce triads, 3:5:7 and 5:7:9, making 27 the smallest edo that can simulate tritave harmony, although it rapidly becomes rough if extended to the 11 and above, unlike a true tritave based system. | ||
27edo, with its 400 | 27edo, with its 400{{c}} major third, [[tempering out|tempers out]] the lesser diesis, [[128/125]], and the septimal comma, [[64/63]], and hence [[126/125]] as well. These it shares with 12edo, making some relationships familiar, and they both support the [[augene]] temperament. It shares with [[22edo]] tempering out the sensamagic comma [[245/243]] as well as 64/63, so that they both support the [[superpyth]] temperament, with four quite sharp "superpythagorean" fifths giving a sharp [[9/7]] in place of meantone's 5/4. | ||
Its step, as well as the octave-inverted and octave-equivalent versions of it, has some of the highest [[harmonic entropy]] possible and thus is, in theory, one of the most dissonant intervals possible, assuming the relatively common values of {{nowrap|''a'' {{=}} 2}} and {{nowrap|''s'' {{=}} 1%}}. This property is shared with all edos between around 24 and 30. Intervals smaller than this tend to be perceived as unison and are more consonant as a result; intervals larger than this have less "tension" and thus are also more consonant. | Its step, as well as the octave-inverted and octave-equivalent versions of it, has some of the highest [[harmonic entropy]] possible and thus is, in theory, one of the most dissonant intervals possible, assuming the relatively common values of {{nowrap|''a'' {{=}} 2}} and {{nowrap|''s'' {{=}} 1%}}. This property is shared with all edos between around 24 and 30. Intervals smaller than this tend to be perceived as unison and are more consonant as a result; intervals larger than this have less "tension" and thus are also more consonant. | ||
Line 15: | Line 15: | ||
=== Octave stretch === | === Octave stretch === | ||
Since the harmonics whose intervals it approximates well (3, 5, 7, 13, and 19) are all tuned sharp of just, 27edo is a prime candidate for [[stretched and compressed tuning|octave compression]]. The local zeta peak around 27 is at 27.086614, which corresponds to a step size of 44.3023 | Since the harmonics whose intervals it approximates well (3, 5, 7, 13, and 19) are all tuned sharp of just, 27edo is a prime candidate for [[stretched and compressed tuning|octave compression]]. The local zeta peak around 27 is at 27.086614, which corresponds to a step size of 44.3023{{c}}. More generally, narrowing the steps to between 44.2 and 44.35{{c}} would be better in theory; [[43edt]], [[70ed6]], and [[97ed12]] are good options if octave compression is acceptable, and these narrow the octaves by 5.75, 3.53, and 2.55{{c}}, respectively. | ||
=== Subsets and supersets === | === Subsets and supersets === | ||
Line 411: | Line 411: | ||
|- style="white-space: nowrap;" | |- style="white-space: nowrap;" | ||
!Cents | !Cents | ||
! colspan="2" |Extended | ! colspan="2" | Extended<br />Pythagorean<br />notation | ||
! colspan="2" | Quartertone<br />notation | |||
! colspan="2" |Quartertone<br>notation | |||
|- | |- | ||
|0.0 | | 0.0 | ||
| colspan="2" |C | | colspan="2" | C | ||
| colspan="2" |A{{sesquisharp2}} | | colspan="2" | A{{sesquisharp2}} | ||
|- | |- | ||
|711.1 | | 711.1 | ||
| colspan="2" |G | | colspan="2" | G | ||
| colspan="2" |E{{sesquisharp2}} | | colspan="2" | E{{sesquisharp2}} | ||
|- | |- | ||
|222.2 | | 222.2 | ||
| colspan="2" |D | | colspan="2" | D | ||
|B{{sesquisharp2}} | | B{{sesquisharp2}} | ||
|F{{sesquiflat2}} | | F{{sesquiflat2}} | ||
|- | |- | ||
|933.3 | | 933.3 | ||
| colspan="2" |A | | colspan="2" | A | ||
| colspan="2" |C{{sesquiflat2}} | | colspan="2" | C{{sesquiflat2}} | ||
|- | |- | ||
|444.4 | | 444.4 | ||
| colspan="2" |E | | colspan="2" | E | ||
| colspan="2" |G{{sesquiflat2}} | | colspan="2" | G{{sesquiflat2}} | ||
|- | |- | ||
|1155.6 | | 1155.6 | ||
| colspan="2" |B | | colspan="2" | B | ||
| colspan="2" |D{{sesquiflat2}} | | colspan="2" | D{{sesquiflat2}} | ||
|- | |- | ||
|666.7 | | 666.7 | ||
| colspan="2" |F♯ | | colspan="2" | F♯ | ||
| colspan="2" |A{{sesquiflat2}} | | colspan="2" | A{{sesquiflat2}} | ||
|- | |- | ||
|177.8 | | 177.8 | ||
| colspan="2" |C♯ | | colspan="2" | C♯ | ||
| colspan="2" |E{{sesquiflat2}} | | colspan="2" | E{{sesquiflat2}} | ||
|- | |- | ||
|888.9 | | 888.9 | ||
| colspan="2" |G♯ | | colspan="2" | G♯ | ||
| colspan="2" |B{{sesquiflat2}} | | colspan="2" | B{{sesquiflat2}} | ||
|- | |- | ||
|400.0 | | 400.0 | ||
| colspan="2" |D♯ | | colspan="2" | D♯ | ||
| colspan="2" |F{{demiflat2}} | | colspan="2" | F{{demiflat2}} | ||
|- | |- | ||
|1111.1 | | 1111.1 | ||
| colspan="2" |A♯ | | colspan="2" | A♯ | ||
| colspan="2" |C{{demiflat2}} | | colspan="2" | C{{demiflat2}} | ||
|- | |- | ||
|622.2 | | 622.2 | ||
| colspan="2" |E♯ | | colspan="2" | E♯ | ||
| colspan="2" |G{{demiflat2}} | | colspan="2" | G{{demiflat2}} | ||
|- | |- | ||
|133.3 | | 133.3 | ||
|B♯ | | B♯ | ||
|F𝄫 | | F𝄫 | ||
| colspan="2" |D{{demiflat2}} | | colspan="2" | D{{demiflat2}} | ||
|- | |- | ||
|844.4 | | 844.4 | ||
|F𝄪 | | F𝄪 | ||
|C𝄫 | | C𝄫 | ||
| colspan="2" |A{{demiflat2}} | | colspan="2" | A{{demiflat2}} | ||
|- | |- | ||
|355.6 | | 355.6 | ||
|C𝄪 | | C𝄪 | ||
|G𝄫 | | G𝄫 | ||
| colspan="2" |E{{demiflat2}} | | colspan="2" | E{{demiflat2}} | ||
|- | |- | ||
|1066.7 | | 1066.7 | ||
|G𝄪 | | G𝄪 | ||
|D𝄫 | | D𝄫 | ||
| colspan="2" |B{{demiflat2}} | | colspan="2" | B{{demiflat2}} | ||
|- | |- | ||
|577.8 | | 577.8 | ||
|D𝄪 | | D𝄪 | ||
|A𝄫 | | A𝄫 | ||
| colspan="2" |F{{demisharp2}} | | colspan="2" | F{{demisharp2}} | ||
|- | |- | ||
|88.9 | | 88.9 | ||
|A𝄪 | | A𝄪 | ||
|E𝄫 | | E𝄫 | ||
| colspan="2" |C{{demisharp2}} | | colspan="2" | C{{demisharp2}} | ||
|- | |- | ||
|800.0 | | 800.0 | ||
|E𝄪 | | E𝄪 | ||
|B𝄫 | | B𝄫 | ||
| colspan="2" |G{{demisharp2}} | | colspan="2" | G{{demisharp2}} | ||
|- | |- | ||
|311.1 | | 311.1 | ||
|B𝄪 | | B𝄪 | ||
|F♭ | | F♭ | ||
| colspan="2" |D{{demisharp2}} | | colspan="2" | D{{demisharp2}} | ||
|- | |- | ||
|1022.2 | | 1022.2 | ||
| colspan="2" |C♭ | | colspan="2" | C♭ | ||
| colspan="2" |A{{demisharp2}} | | colspan="2" | A{{demisharp2}} | ||
|- | |- | ||
|533.3 | | 533.3 | ||
| colspan="2" |G♭ | | colspan="2" | G♭ | ||
| colspan="2" |E{{demisharp2}} | | colspan="2" | E{{demisharp2}} | ||
|- | |- | ||
|44.4 | | 44.4 | ||
| colspan="2" |D♭ | | colspan="2" | D♭ | ||
| colspan="2" |B{{demisharp2}} | | colspan="2" | B{{demisharp2}} | ||
|- | |- | ||
|755.6 | | 755.6 | ||
| colspan="2" |A♭ | | colspan="2" | A♭ | ||
| colspan="2" |F{{sesquisharp2}} | | colspan="2" | F{{sesquisharp2}} | ||
|- | |- | ||
|266.7 | | 266.7 | ||
| colspan="2" |E♭ | | colspan="2" | E♭ | ||
| colspan="2" |C{{sesquisharp2}} | | colspan="2" | C{{sesquisharp2}} | ||
|- | |- | ||
|977.8 | | 977.8 | ||
| colspan="2" |B♭ | | colspan="2" | B♭ | ||
| colspan="2" |G{{sesquisharp2}} | | colspan="2" | G{{sesquisharp2}} | ||
|- | |- | ||
|488.9 | | 488.9 | ||
| colspan="2" |F | | colspan="2" | F | ||
| colspan="2" |D | | colspan="2" | D{{sesquisharp2}} | ||
|- | |- | ||
| 0.0 | |||
| colspan="2" | C | |||
| colspan="2" | A{{sesquisharp2}} | |||
|} | |} | ||
=== Extended | === Extended Pythagorean notation === | ||
27edo being a superpythagorean system, the 5/4 major third present in the 4:5:6 chord is technically an augmented second, since (for example) C–E is a 9/7 supermajor third and so the note located 5/4 above C must be notated as D♯. Conversely, the 6/5 minor third of a 10:12:15 chord is actually reached by a diminished fourth, since (for example) D–F is a 7/6 subminor third and so the note located 6/5 above D must be notated as G♭. The diminished 2nd is a descending interval, thus A♯ is higher than B♭. Though here very exaggerated, this should be familiar to those working with the Pythagorean scale (see [[53edo]]), and also to many classically trained violinists. | 27edo being a superpythagorean system, the 5/4 major third present in the 4:5:6 chord is technically an augmented second, since (for example) C–E is a 9/7 supermajor third and so the note located 5/4 above C must be notated as D♯. Conversely, the 6/5 minor third of a 10:12:15 chord is actually reached by a diminished fourth, since (for example) D–F is a 7/6 subminor third and so the note located 6/5 above D must be notated as G♭. The diminished 2nd is a descending interval, thus A♯ is higher than B♭. Though here very exaggerated, this should be familiar to those working with the Pythagorean scale (see [[53edo]]), and also to many classically trained violinists. | ||