27edo: Difference between revisions

TallKite (talk | contribs)
Notation: added the modern (as opposed to the classical) version of the ups and downs accidentals, moved some text to two new sections for extended pyth notation and quartertone notation.
ArrowHead294 (talk | contribs)
mNo edit summary
Line 3: Line 3:


== Theory ==
== Theory ==
Assuming pure octaves, 27edo divides the [[octave]] in 27 equal parts each exactly 44{{frac|4|9}} [[cent]]s in size. Its fifth and harmonic seventh are both sharp by 9 cents, and the major third is the same 400-cent major third as [[12edo]], sharp by 13.7 cents. The result is that [[6/5]], [[7/5]], and especially [[7/6]] are all tuned more accurately than this. It can be considered the superpythagorean counterpart of [[19edo]], as its 5th is audibly indistinguishable from [[superpyth|1/3-septimal-comma superpyth]] in the same way that 19edo is audibly indistinguishable from [[1/3-comma meantone|1/3-syntonic-comma meantone]], where three fifths in 19edo reach a near-perfect [[6/5]] and [[5/3]] and three fifths in 27edo reaching a near-perfect [[7/6]] and [[12/7]].
Assuming pure octaves, 27edo divides the [[octave]] in 27 equal parts each exactly 44{{frac|4|9}} [[cent]]s in size. Its fifth and harmonic seventh are both sharp by 9{{c}}, and the major third is the same 400-cent major third as [[12edo]], sharp by 13.7{{c}}. The result is that [[6/5]], [[7/5]], and especially [[7/6]] are all tuned more accurately than this. It can be considered the superpythagorean counterpart of [[19edo]], as its 5th is audibly indistinguishable from [[superpyth|1/3-septimal-comma superpyth]] in the same way that 19edo is audibly indistinguishable from [[1/3-comma meantone|1/3-syntonic-comma meantone]], where three fifths in 19edo reach a near-perfect [[6/5]] and [[5/3]] and three fifths in 27edo reaching a near-perfect [[7/6]] and [[12/7]].


Though 27edo's [[7-limit]] tuning is not highly accurate, it nonetheless is the smallest equal division to represent the [[7-odd-limit]] both [[consistent]]ly and distinctly – that is, everything in the [[7-odd-limit]] [[tonality diamond]] is uniquely represented by a certain number of steps of 27edo. It also represents the 13th harmonic very well, and performs quite decently as a 2.3.5.7.13.19 (no-11's, no-17's 19-limit) temperament. It also approximates [[19/10]], [[19/12]], and [[19/14]], so {{dash|0, 7, 13, 25|med}} does quite well as a 10:12:14:19 chord, with the major seventh 25\27 being less than one cent off from 19/10. Octave-inverted, these also form a quite convincing approximation of the main Bohlen–Pierce triads, 3:5:7 and 5:7:9, making 27 the smallest edo that can simulate tritave harmony, although it rapidly becomes rough if extended to the 11 and above, unlike a true tritave based system.
Though 27edo's [[7-limit]] tuning is not highly accurate, it nonetheless is the smallest equal division to represent the [[7-odd-limit]] both [[consistent]]ly and distinctly—that is, everything in the [[7-odd-limit]] [[tonality diamond]] is uniquely represented by a certain number of steps of 27edo. It also represents the 13th harmonic very well, and performs quite decently as a 2.3.5.7.13.19 (no-11's, no-17's 19-limit) temperament. It also approximates [[19/10]], [[19/12]], and [[19/14]], so {{dash|0, 7, 13, 25|med}} does quite well as a 10:12:14:19 chord, with the major seventh 25\27 being less than one cent off from 19/10. Octave-inverted, these also form a quite convincing approximation of the main Bohlen–Pierce triads, 3:5:7 and 5:7:9, making 27 the smallest edo that can simulate tritave harmony, although it rapidly becomes rough if extended to the 11 and above, unlike a true tritave based system.


27edo, with its 400-cent major third, [[tempering out|tempers out]] the lesser diesis, [[128/125]], and the septimal comma, [[64/63]], and hence [[126/125]] as well. These it shares with 12edo, making some relationships familiar, and they both support the [[augene]] temperament. It shares with [[22edo]] tempering out the sensamagic comma [[245/243]] as well as 64/63, so that they both support the [[superpyth]] temperament, with four quite sharp "superpythagorean" fifths giving a sharp [[9/7]] in place of meantone's 5/4.
27edo, with its 400{{c}} major third, [[tempering out|tempers out]] the lesser diesis, [[128/125]], and the septimal comma, [[64/63]], and hence [[126/125]] as well. These it shares with 12edo, making some relationships familiar, and they both support the [[augene]] temperament. It shares with [[22edo]] tempering out the sensamagic comma [[245/243]] as well as 64/63, so that they both support the [[superpyth]] temperament, with four quite sharp "superpythagorean" fifths giving a sharp [[9/7]] in place of meantone's 5/4.


Its step, as well as the octave-inverted and octave-equivalent versions of it, has some of the highest [[harmonic entropy]] possible and thus is, in theory, one of the most dissonant intervals possible, assuming the relatively common values of {{nowrap|''a'' {{=}} 2}} and {{nowrap|''s'' {{=}} 1%}}. This property is shared with all edos between around 24 and 30. Intervals smaller than this tend to be perceived as unison and are more consonant as a result; intervals larger than this have less "tension" and thus are also more consonant.
Its step, as well as the octave-inverted and octave-equivalent versions of it, has some of the highest [[harmonic entropy]] possible and thus is, in theory, one of the most dissonant intervals possible, assuming the relatively common values of {{nowrap|''a'' {{=}} 2}} and {{nowrap|''s'' {{=}} 1%}}. This property is shared with all edos between around 24 and 30. Intervals smaller than this tend to be perceived as unison and are more consonant as a result; intervals larger than this have less "tension" and thus are also more consonant.
Line 15: Line 15:


=== Octave stretch ===
=== Octave stretch ===
Since the harmonics whose intervals it approximates well (3, 5, 7, 13, and 19) are all tuned sharp of just, 27edo is a prime candidate for [[stretched and compressed tuning|octave compression]]. The local zeta peak around 27 is at 27.086614, which corresponds to a step size of 44.3023 cents. More generally, narrowing the steps to between 44.2 and 44.35 cents would be better in theory; [[43edt]], [[70ed6]], and [[97ed12]] are good options if octave compression is acceptable, and these narrow the octaves by 5.75, 3.53, and 2.55 cents, respectively.
Since the harmonics whose intervals it approximates well (3, 5, 7, 13, and 19) are all tuned sharp of just, 27edo is a prime candidate for [[stretched and compressed tuning|octave compression]]. The local zeta peak around 27 is at 27.086614, which corresponds to a step size of 44.3023{{c}}. More generally, narrowing the steps to between 44.2 and 44.35{{c}} would be better in theory; [[43edt]], [[70ed6]], and [[97ed12]] are good options if octave compression is acceptable, and these narrow the octaves by 5.75, 3.53, and 2.55{{c}}, respectively.


=== Subsets and supersets ===
=== Subsets and supersets ===
Line 411: Line 411:
|- style="white-space: nowrap;"
|- style="white-space: nowrap;"
!Cents
!Cents
! colspan="2" |Extended
! colspan="2" | Extended<br />Pythagorean<br />notation
pythagorean<br>notation
! colspan="2" | Quartertone<br />notation
! colspan="2" |Quartertone<br>notation
|-
|-
|0.0
| 0.0
| colspan="2" |C
| colspan="2" | C
| colspan="2" |A{{sesquisharp2}}
| colspan="2" | A{{sesquisharp2}}
|-
|-
|711.1
| 711.1
| colspan="2" |G
| colspan="2" | G
| colspan="2" |E{{sesquisharp2}}
| colspan="2" | E{{sesquisharp2}}
|-
|-
|222.2
| 222.2
| colspan="2" |D
| colspan="2" | D
|B{{sesquisharp2}}
| B{{sesquisharp2}}
|F{{sesquiflat2}}
| F{{sesquiflat2}}
|-
|-
|933.3
| 933.3
| colspan="2" |A
| colspan="2" | A
| colspan="2" |C{{sesquiflat2}}
| colspan="2" | C{{sesquiflat2}}
|-
|-
|444.4
| 444.4
| colspan="2" |E
| colspan="2" | E
| colspan="2" |G{{sesquiflat2}}
| colspan="2" | G{{sesquiflat2}}
|-
|-
|1155.6
| 1155.6
| colspan="2" |B
| colspan="2" | B
| colspan="2" |D{{sesquiflat2}}
| colspan="2" | D{{sesquiflat2}}
|-
|-
|666.7
| 666.7
| colspan="2" |F♯
| colspan="2" | F♯
| colspan="2" |A{{sesquiflat2}}
| colspan="2" | A{{sesquiflat2}}
|-
|-
|177.8
| 177.8
| colspan="2" |C♯
| colspan="2" | C♯
| colspan="2" |E{{sesquiflat2}}
| colspan="2" | E{{sesquiflat2}}
|-
|-
|888.9
| 888.9
| colspan="2" |G♯
| colspan="2" | G♯
| colspan="2" |B{{sesquiflat2}}
| colspan="2" | B{{sesquiflat2}}
|-
|-
|400.0
| 400.0
| colspan="2" |D♯
| colspan="2" | D♯
| colspan="2" |F{{demiflat2}}
| colspan="2" | F{{demiflat2}}
|-
|-
|1111.1
| 1111.1
| colspan="2" |A♯
| colspan="2" | A♯
| colspan="2" |C{{demiflat2}}
| colspan="2" | C{{demiflat2}}
|-
|-
|622.2
| 622.2
| colspan="2" |E♯
| colspan="2" | E♯
| colspan="2" |G{{demiflat2}}
| colspan="2" | G{{demiflat2}}
|-
|-
|133.3
| 133.3
|B♯
| B♯
|F𝄫
| F𝄫
| colspan="2" |D{{demiflat2}}
| colspan="2" | D{{demiflat2}}
|-
|-
|844.4
| 844.4
|F𝄪
| F𝄪
|C𝄫
| C𝄫
| colspan="2" |A{{demiflat2}}
| colspan="2" | A{{demiflat2}}
|-
|-
|355.6
| 355.6
|C𝄪
| C𝄪
|G𝄫
| G𝄫
| colspan="2" |E{{demiflat2}}
| colspan="2" | E{{demiflat2}}
|-
|-
|1066.7
| 1066.7
|G𝄪
| G𝄪
|D𝄫
| D𝄫
| colspan="2" |B{{demiflat2}}
| colspan="2" | B{{demiflat2}}
|-
|-
|577.8
| 577.8
|D𝄪
| D𝄪
|A𝄫
| A𝄫
| colspan="2" |F{{demisharp2}}
| colspan="2" | F{{demisharp2}}
|-
|-
|88.9
| 88.9
|A𝄪
| A𝄪
|E𝄫
| E𝄫
| colspan="2" |C{{demisharp2}}
| colspan="2" | C{{demisharp2}}
|-
|-
|800.0
| 800.0
|E𝄪
| E𝄪
|B𝄫
| B𝄫
| colspan="2" |G{{demisharp2}}
| colspan="2" | G{{demisharp2}}
|-
|-
|311.1
| 311.1
|B𝄪
| B𝄪
|F♭
| F♭
| colspan="2" |D{{demisharp2}}
| colspan="2" | D{{demisharp2}}
|-
|-
|1022.2
| 1022.2
| colspan="2" |C♭
| colspan="2" | C♭
| colspan="2" |A{{demisharp2}}
| colspan="2" | A{{demisharp2}}
|-
|-
|533.3
| 533.3
| colspan="2" |G♭
| colspan="2" | G♭
| colspan="2" |E{{demisharp2}}
| colspan="2" | E{{demisharp2}}
|-
|-
|44.4
| 44.4
| colspan="2" |D♭
| colspan="2" | D♭
| colspan="2" |B{{demisharp2}}
| colspan="2" | B{{demisharp2}}
|-
|-
|755.6
| 755.6
| colspan="2" |A♭
| colspan="2" | A♭
| colspan="2" |F{{sesquisharp2}}
| colspan="2" | F{{sesquisharp2}}
|-
|-
|266.7
| 266.7
| colspan="2" |E♭
| colspan="2" | E♭
| colspan="2" |C{{sesquisharp2}}
| colspan="2" | C{{sesquisharp2}}
|-
|-
|977.8
| 977.8
| colspan="2" |B♭
| colspan="2" | B♭
| colspan="2" |G{{sesquisharp2}}
| colspan="2" | G{{sesquisharp2}}
|-
|-
|488.9
| 488.9
| colspan="2" |F
| colspan="2" | F
| colspan="2" |D{{sesquisharp2}}
| colspan="2" | D{{sesquisharp2}}
|-
|0.0
| colspan="2" |C
| colspan="2" |A{{sesquisharp2}}
|-
|-
| 0.0
| colspan="2" | C
| colspan="2" | A{{sesquisharp2}}
|}
|}


=== Extended pythagorean notation ===
=== Extended Pythagorean notation ===
27edo being a superpythagorean system, the 5/4 major third present in the 4:5:6 chord is technically an augmented second, since (for example) C–E is a 9/7 supermajor third and so the note located 5/4 above C must be notated as D♯. Conversely, the 6/5 minor third of a 10:12:15 chord is actually reached by a diminished fourth, since (for example) D–F is a 7/6 subminor third and so the note located 6/5 above D must be notated as G♭. The diminished 2nd is a descending interval, thus A♯ is higher than B♭. Though here very exaggerated, this should be familiar to those working with the Pythagorean scale (see [[53edo]]), and also to many classically trained violinists.
27edo being a superpythagorean system, the 5/4 major third present in the 4:5:6 chord is technically an augmented second, since (for example) C–E is a 9/7 supermajor third and so the note located 5/4 above C must be notated as D♯. Conversely, the 6/5 minor third of a 10:12:15 chord is actually reached by a diminished fourth, since (for example) D–F is a 7/6 subminor third and so the note located 6/5 above D must be notated as G♭. The diminished 2nd is a descending interval, thus A♯ is higher than B♭. Though here very exaggerated, this should be familiar to those working with the Pythagorean scale (see [[53edo]]), and also to many classically trained violinists.