@@ Line 2: / Line 2: @@
 == hkm ==
 <pre>
+Abnormality: Moondust. 3.75
-Abnormality: Moondust. 4
+Abnormality: towerjamcalm.mp3. 3.44
-Abnormality: towerjamcalm.mp3. 3.75
+Abnormality: towerjamfight.mp3. 4.6
-Blackwood: Etudes: 16edo. 4.38
+Blackwood: Etudes: 16edo. 4.22
-Blackwood: Etudes: 18edo. 3.75
+Blackwood: Etudes: 18edo. 3.44
-Blackwood: Etudes: 21edo. 1.62
+Blackwood: Etudes: 21edo. 0.78
-Blackwood: Etudes: 23edo. 2.75
+Blackwood: Etudes: 23edo. 2.19
 EDITED 2025.03.21
-Blackwood: Etudes: 13edo. 1.88
+Blackwood: Etudes: 13edo. 1.1
 EDITED 2025.03.21
-Blackwood: Etudes: 15edo. 3.88
+Blackwood: Etudes: 15edo. 3.6
 EDITED 2025.03.21
 you have to make it past the first six seconds
-Blackwood: Etudes: 17edo. 2.88
+Blackwood: Etudes: 17edo. 2.35
-Blackwood: Etudes: 22edo. 2.88
+Blackwood: Etudes: 22edo. 2.35
-Blackwood: Etudes: 24edo. 4.38
+Blackwood: Etudes: 24edo. 4.22
-Blackwood: Etudes: 14edo. 2.88
+Blackwood: Etudes: 14edo. 2.35
-Blackwood: Etudes: 20edo. 4
+Blackwood: Etudes: 20edo. 3.75
-Blackwood: Etudes: 19edo. 2.62
+Blackwood: Etudes: 19edo. 2.03
 EDITED 2025.03.21
 meandering
-Blackwood: Etudes. 3.75
+Blackwood: Etudes. 3.44
-Byrnes: Holocene Dream: Holocene. 3.1
+benyamind: Namoic: Chromacro. 3.7
+benyamind: Namoic: Dreamer. 2
+benyamind: Namoic: Hereninging. 3
+benyamind: Namoic: Uradjinn. 3.5
+benyamind: Progression in 16-tone equal temperament. 4.0
+intriguing
+Byrnes: Holocene Dream: Holocene. 2.62 TODO: RECONSIDER
 ish
-Costa: Danse-Etude. 3.75
+Byrnes: Holocene Dream: Home. 2.25
-Costa: Short piece. 2.88
+Byrnes: Holocene Dream: 27EDO Etude. 2.2 TODO: RECONSIDER
+don't love it
-Costa: Arabesque. 4.38
+Byrnes: Holocene Dream: Mesozoic. 3.4
+RERATED 2025.04.13 from 2.3
+byrnesbyrnesbyrnesbyrnesbyrnesbyrnesbyrnesbyrnesbyrnesbyrnesbyrnesbyrnesbyrnesbyrnesbyrnesbyrnesbyrynesbyrnes
+  budjarnlambeth why do you like byrnes so much
+    i don't get it
+      what do you see in this track
+the more i listen to byrnes the more i hear these little cliches that are
+omnipresent within his work
+i don't think i can take it anymore.
+so why a 2.3? one byrnes track is fine. what i'm doing now, which is listening to a bunch of byrnes all at once, is no fun at all.
+Byrnes: Holocene Dream: Out of the Sun. 4
+RERATED 2025.04.13 from 2.5
+Byrnes: 27th Eclipse: 3
+Byrnes: 2227: Chromawaves: 3.4
+Costa: Danse-Etude. 3.44
+Costa: Short piece. 2.35
+Costa: Arabesque. 4.22
 intriguing
-Costa: Enharmonic Study (31edo version). 4.12
+Costa: Enharmonic Study (31edo version). 3.9
 edo
 technically impressive but not fun to listen to
-Costa: Debussy's "Syrinx" arranged for flute quartet. 4.7
+Costa: Debussy's "Syrinx" arranged for flute quartet. 4.62
-Costa: Messaien's "O Sacrum Convivium". 2.88
+Costa: Messaien's "O Sacrum Convivium". 2.35
 Timbre isn't as good as syrinx, piece isn't as interesting, microtonalism isn't as apparent...
-dogwithabome: to have my bones be one with the river. 4
+dogwithabome: to have my bones be one with the river. 3.75
 fascinating short sketch
-dotuXil: Collected Refractions: A Multitude of New Colors. 2.62
+Domin: chair-2-3-11-19.mp3. 3.7
+also fascinating short sketch.
+dotuXil: Collected Refractions: A Multitude of New Colors. 2.03
 the emphasis is clearly more on production than tuning
-dotuXil: Collected Refractions: Odd Harmonic. 2.25
+dotuXil: Collected Refractions: Odd Harmonic. 1.56
 not a fan of the voice
 feels very lacking in variation between consonance in dissonance.
 last few seconds are great
-E8 Heterotic: Glaukos Circuit. 1.25
+E8 Heterotic: Glaukos Circuit. 0.31
+E8 Heterotic: No Threes for You. 1.88
-fesh: It's a long way down... do you want to jump?: VII. and all the harvest shall rot. 4.75
+fesh: It's a long way down... do you want to jump?: VII. and all the harvest shall rot. 4.69
-Groundfault: A New Dusk. 3.5
+Groundfault: A New Dusk. 3.12
 Worse than the sum of its tracks. Hard to listen to in full, and the timbre of the bass isn't great. The composition itself is great though.
-groundfault: A New Dusk: Superior Intermedial. 4.4
+groundfault: A New Dusk: Superior Intermedial. 4.25
+groundfault: A New Dusk: The Lake Reflects a Black Sky. 3.6
+groundfault: A New Dusk: Rail Twinge. 3.2
-Hunt: Equal-Tempered Keyboard: Prelude in 14et. 3.5
+Heathwaite: Flarn Squared in 80edo. 2.3
+It's a perfectly fine piece, which is why I don't want to give it a rating this low. It's just not top fifty percent for me.
+Hunt: Equal-Tempered Keyboard: Prelude in 14et. 3.12
 Jumble: Azure. 5
+Jumble: Hammock Hut. 3.8
+Metaclown 2: Bean's Work (Instrumental). 3.7
 Nuorvala: Violin sonata. 5
 fantastic work
-Osmium: Heartbeat. 4.38
+Osmium: Heartbeat. 4.22
-Serafini: Do Androids Dream of 18ed2?. 3.88
+Serafini: Do Androids Dream of 18ed2?. 3.6
-Sintel: Top Ten most Epic fish of all time. 4.12
+Sintel: Top Ten most Epic fish of all time. 3.9
-too many non-xen movements. Would score a 4.75 if everything was xen.
+too many non-xen movements. Would score a 4.69 if everything was xen.
-Sintel: Diversion in 34. 3
+Sintel: Diversion in 34. 2.5
 A really hard one to give a rating to. Sounds great locally, but a mess globally. I don't hear a coherent macrostructure, even though stylistically it is similar to genres of music that tend to have a coherent macrostructure, so I end up feeling lost.
-Sevish: Horixens: Baobaoshuijiaojiao. 3.8
+Sevish: Horixens: Baobaoshuijiaojiao. 3.5
+Sevish: Sean but not Heard: Marooned at Home. 3.9
+Spiral Garden: Spiral Garden: Aurora. 4.6
+Spiral Garden: Spiral Garden: Heirophony. 4.2
 Tapeworm Saga: Languor Study. 5
-Tapeworm Saga: A quick quintet, music for 5 EWIs in 17edo. 3.12
+Tapeworm Saga: A quick quintet, music for 5 EWIs in 17edo. 2.65
 Production really holding this one back, but I don't love the writing as much as Languor Study either.
-Wrenharmonic: Larger Than The Oceans. 3.75
+vivi mouse: valentine's day. 4.2
+great. not life-changing though
+Wrenharmonic: Larger Than The Oceans. 3.44
-Xotla Music: Rive. 2.75
+Xotla Music: Rive. 2.19
 Byrnes does it better.
-E8 Heterotic: No Threes for You. 2.5
 </pre>
@@ Line 164: / Line 221: @@
 <pre>
 Harrison: From Ancient Worlds. 5
+Venkataramana: Evening Rondo Gonzo. 5
 </pre>
@@ Line 208: / Line 266: @@
 Intense in a way I don't really see in 12edo music.
-Metaclown 2: Bean's Work (Instrumental). 4.3
+vivi mouse: valentine's day. 4.5
+edo
+Generally I haven't liked much of what I've heard in valentine temperament, but I like this a lot, and it happens to feel fitting thematically with it being composed in the February valentine tuning of the month.
+Metaclown 2: Bean's Work (Instrumental). 4.5
 edo
@@ Line 266: / Line 328: @@
 edo subset
-Sevish: Rhythm and Xen: Desert Island Rain. 2.9
+Sevish: Rhythm and Xen: Desert Island Rain. 2.7
 Barbados[9] in 313edo
-Infinitone: "Stranges" --- 53EDO, inspired by Coltrane's Giant Steps. 2.7
+Infinitone: Stranges. 2.5
 edo
-Sevish: Rhythm and Xen: Droplet. 2.6
+Sevish: Rhythm and Xen: Droplet. 2.4
 Orwell[9] in 53edo
-Sintel: Top Ten most Epic fish of all time. 2.4
+Sintel: Top Ten most Epic fish of all time. 2.0
 various
 I listened to it because it was the top ranked thing. It made me feel impatient, but I made sure to listen to at least a couple of parts of every song. I think it's just not really my thing, I prefer music with focus on chordal harmony with accompanying melody. Also, though the production seems good, it makes my ears feel discomfort sometimes (which is nothing to do with whether it sounds good or not); perhaps some high frequencies lurking or something. There are definitely various cool parts in it that I liked though. Hence I feel neutral about it.
@@ Line 283: / Line 345: @@
 <pre>
 Abnormality: Moondust. 2.5
+Abnormality: Scatter Brain. 3
 Abnormality: Stardust. 2.5
 Abnormality: towerjamcalm.mp3. 1
+Abnormality: towerjamfight.mp3. 2
+Aura: Space Tour. 4.5
+Aura: The Forgotten. 4
+Aura: Youthful Fun. 3.5
+The first minute may feel a little sparse but after that it’s a very fun listen.
+Barton: jb_seventeen_pno.mp3. 3
+Barton: what_is_this.mp3. 4
+Battaglia: Comma pump in Hanson/Kleismic temperament, 34-equal. 3
 benyamind: A progression in 31-tone equal temperament. 2.5
@@ Line 325: / Line 404: @@
 Berio: E vò. 1.5
+Bigwood: Nerozene: 22edo. 4
 Blackwood: Etudes: 13edo. 1
@@ Line 423: / Line 504: @@
 Byrnes: Realism: Indefinite Suspension. 4
-Byrnes: Realism: Lacuna. 4.5
 Byrnes: Realism: Melt. 4.5
@@ Line 487: / Line 566: @@
 Couper: Dirge. 2
+Deister: 36edo jam. 4.5
 dotuXil: Collected Refractions: A Multitude of New Colors. 1.5
@@ Line 510: / Line 591: @@
 E8 Heterotic: Glaukos Circuit. 3
-E8 Heterotic: No Threes For You. 1.5
+E8 Heterotic: No Threes for You. 1.5
 fesh: It's a long way down... do you want to jump?: VII. and all the harvest shall rot. 3
-Gamelan Degung: Music from Bali: Gara Gara Cinta. 4
+Francium: Void: Make It Darker. 4
-Gamelan Degung: Music from Bali: Hebat. 3
-Gamelan Degung: Music from Bali: Kapinis. 4
-Gamelan Degung: Music from Bali: Kebaya Bundang. 3.5
-Gamelan Degung: Music from Bali: Kedah Kasaha. 4.5
-Gamelan Degung: Music from Bali: Mojang Sumedang. 3
-Gamelan Degung: Music from Bali: Sabilulungan. 4.5
-Gamelan Degung: Music from Bali: Sangkala. 3
 Greystar: Microtonal Nights: A Frail Path. 4
@@ Line 691: / Line 758: @@
 LΛMPLIGHT: Caftaphata. 4
+Mayone: Circulatione.mp3. 3
 Nørgård: String Quartet No 5. 1
 Nuorvala: Violin sonata. 2
+Secor: 17WTjazz.mp3. 1
 Serafini: Chameleons in the Sun. 4.5
@@ Line 731: / Line 802: @@
 Sevish: Bubble: You Tell Me. 4
+Sevish: Cosmic Playtime. 4
 Sevish: Harmony Hacker: Ask Yourself. 2.5
@@ Line 754: / Line 827: @@
 Sevish: Horixens: Better Left Unanswered. 4.5
-Sevish: Horixens: Come on a Jouney. 3.5
+Sevish: Horixens: Come on a Journey. 3.5
 Sevish: Horixens: Horizons. 4
@@ Line 762: / Line 835: @@
 Sevish: Horixens: Outside. 3.5
-Sevish: Horixens: Septilion Reptilians. 4
+Sevish: Horixens: Septillion Reptilians. 4
 Sevish: Horixens: Streaming. 2.5
@@ Line 860: / Line 933: @@
 Takemitsu: Bryce. 2
-Tapeworm Saga: A quick quintet, music for 4.5 EWIs in 17edo. 1
+Tapeworm Saga: A quick quintet, music for 5 EWIs in 17edo. 1
 Tapeworm Saga: Languor Study. 1
@@ Line 919: / Line 992: @@
 == ArrowHead294 ==
 <pre<includeonly />>
-Brendan Byrnes: Holocene Dream: Home. 4
+Byrnes: Holocene Dream: Home. 4
+Erlich: Tibia. 4
 Sevish: Harmony Hacker: Gleam. 4
@@ Line 927: / Line 1,002: @@
 Sevish: Rhythm and Xen: Droplet. 5
 Honestly, I think this works great in Orwell as is but could also make a great quarter-tone piece if rendered in 24edo, which could help make quarter tones more attractive to the general public.
+</pre>
+== CompactStar ==
+<pre>
+Sevish: Golden Hour: The Mersh Tune. 3.5
+Mersh
 </pre>

User talk:Hkm/Rankings: Difference between revisions