Sagittal notation: Difference between revisions

(One intermediate revision by the same user not shown)

Line 10:

The '''Evo''' flavor (short for "evolutionary", previously called "mixed") uses only single-shaft Sagittal symbols, e.g. {{sagittal| /| }} {{sagittal| \! }} {{sagittal| |) }} {{sagittal| !) }}, alone or in combination with conventional sharps and flats and their doubles. Only the large variant of the double sharp {{sagittal| x }} (U+E47D) is considered to be stylistically-compatible with Sagittal symbols. Evo is much easier to learn, but it results in a greater number of symbols on the sheet, which can give it a more cluttered appearance, particularly with chords, and it may be confusing when two symbols alter the same note in opposite directions.

~~<span id="Evo-SZ"></span>~~ A sub-flavor of Evo is '''Evo-SZ''' (Evo with Stein–Zimmermann). This is where any sagittals that are notating exactly half the alteration of a sharp or flat (most often {{sagittal| /|\ }} {{sagittal| \!/ }}) are replaced by the Stein–Zimmermann semisharp {{sagittal| > }} and narrow reversed flat {{sagittal| < }}, and the corresponding combinations (most often {{sagittal| /|\ }}{{sagittal| # }} and {{sagittal| \!/ }}{{sagittal| b }}) are replaced by {{sagittal| ># }} and {{sagittal| <b }}. The narrow variants of the fractional flats {{sagittal| < }} (U+E284) and {{sagittal| <b }} (U+E285) are preferred because they preserve the Sagittal principle that the visual size of a symbol should indicate the relative size of its alteration and they reduce left-right confusion.

A sub-flavor of Evo is '''Evo-SZ''' (Evo with Stein–Zimmermann). This is where any sagittals that are notating exactly half the alteration of a sharp or flat (most often {{sagittal| /|\ }} {{sagittal| \!/ }}) are replaced by the Stein–Zimmermann semisharp {{sagittal| > }} and narrow reversed flat {{sagittal| < }}, and the corresponding combinations (most often {{sagittal| /|\ }}{{sagittal| # }} and {{sagittal| \!/ }}{{sagittal| b }}) are replaced by {{sagittal| ># }} and {{sagittal| <b }}. The narrow variants of the fractional flats {{sagittal| < }} (U+E284) and {{sagittal| <b }} (U+E285) are preferred because they preserve the Sagittal principle that the visual size of a symbol should indicate the relative size of its alteration and they reduce left-right confusion.

In tempered systems, Evo-SZ {{sagittal|>}} {{sagittal|<}} {{sagittal|>#}} {{sagittal|<b}} accidentals ''may instead'' be distinct from Sagittals like {{sagittal| /|\ }}{{sagittal| \!/ }}, when the apotome can be split in two equal parts as in [[Hemipyth|Hemipythagorean]], as literal half-sharps and half-flats, and there is a distinction between mapped neutral thirds like [[11/9|~11/9]] and [https://en.xen.wiki/w/Sqrt(3/2) hemififths], in particularly fine-grained EDOs like [[270edo|270]] or [[311edo|311]]. There is no need for this in coarser systems like [[24edo|24]], [[31edo|31]] or [[41edo|41]], where the mappings of the hemififth and rational neutral thirds coincide.

=== Revo ===

Line 51:

Line 53:

=== Sharps/Flats ===

Using {{sagittal| # }} and {{sagittal| b }} (or {{sagittal|/||\}} {{sagittal|\!!/}} for Revo flavor) is still ''technically'' Sagittal notation, however, it's just a reskin.

=== Spartan ===

@@ Line 10: / Line 10: @@
 The '''Evo''' flavor (short for "evolutionary", previously called "mixed") uses only single-shaft Sagittal symbols, e.g. {{sagittal| /| }} {{sagittal| \! }} {{sagittal| |) }} {{sagittal| !) }}, alone or in combination with conventional sharps and flats and their doubles. Only the large variant of the double sharp {{sagittal| x }} (U+E47D) is considered to be stylistically-compatible with Sagittal symbols. Evo is much easier to learn, but it results in a greater number of symbols on the sheet, which can give it a more cluttered appearance, particularly with chords, and it may be confusing when two symbols alter the same note in opposite directions.
-<span id="Evo-SZ"></span> A sub-flavor of Evo is '''Evo-SZ''' (Evo with Stein–Zimmermann). This is where any sagittals that are notating exactly half the alteration of a sharp or flat (most often {{sagittal| /|\ }} {{sagittal| \!/ }}) are replaced by the Stein–Zimmermann semisharp {{sagittal| > }} and narrow reversed flat {{sagittal| < }}, and the corresponding combinations (most often {{sagittal| /|\ }}{{sagittal| # }} and {{sagittal| \!/ }}{{sagittal| b }}) are replaced by {{sagittal| ># }} and {{sagittal| <b }}. The narrow variants of the fractional flats {{sagittal| < }} (U+E284) and {{sagittal| <b }} (U+E285) are preferred because they preserve the Sagittal principle that the visual size of a symbol should indicate the relative size of its alteration and they reduce left-right confusion.
+A sub-flavor of Evo is '''Evo-SZ''' (Evo with Stein–Zimmermann). This is where any sagittals that are notating exactly half the alteration of a sharp or flat (most often {{sagittal| /|\ }} {{sagittal| \!/ }}) are replaced by the Stein–Zimmermann semisharp {{sagittal| > }} and narrow reversed flat {{sagittal| < }}, and the corresponding combinations (most often {{sagittal| /|\ }}{{sagittal| # }} and {{sagittal| \!/ }}{{sagittal| b }}) are replaced by {{sagittal| ># }} and {{sagittal| <b }}. The narrow variants of the fractional flats {{sagittal| < }} (U+E284) and {{sagittal| <b }} (U+E285) are preferred because they preserve the Sagittal principle that the visual size of a symbol should indicate the relative size of its alteration and they reduce left-right confusion.
+In tempered systems, Evo-SZ {{sagittal|>}} {{sagittal|<}} {{sagittal|>#}} {{sagittal|<b}} accidentals ''may instead'' be distinct from Sagittals like {{sagittal| /|\ }}{{sagittal| \!/ }}, when the apotome can be split in two equal parts as in [[Hemipyth|Hemipythagorean]], as literal half-sharps and half-flats, and there is a distinction between mapped neutral thirds like [[11/9|~11/9]] and [https://en.xen.wiki/w/Sqrt(3/2) hemififths], in particularly fine-grained EDOs like [[270edo|270]] or [[311edo|311]]. There is no need for this in coarser systems like [[24edo|24]], [[31edo|31]] or [[41edo|41]], where the mappings of the hemififth and rational neutral thirds coincide.
 === Revo ===
@@ Line 51: / Line 53: @@
 === Sharps/Flats ===
 Using {{sagittal| # }} and {{sagittal| b }} (or {{sagittal|/||\}} {{sagittal|\!!/}} for Revo flavor) is still ''technically'' Sagittal notation, however, it's just a reskin.
 === Spartan ===