Major second

From Xenharmonic Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search

A major second (M2) in the diatonic scale is an interval that spans one scale step with the major (wider) quality. It is generated by stacking 2 fifths octave reduced, and depending on the specific tuning, it ranges from 171 to 240 ¢ (1\7 to 1\5). It can be considered the large step of the diatonic scale.

In just intonation, an interval may be classified as a major second if it is reasonably mapped to 1\7 and 4\24 (precisely one step of the diatonic scale and two steps of the chromatic scale). The use of 24edo's 4\24 as the mapping criteria here rather than 12edo's 2\12 better captures the characteristics of many intervals in the 11- and 13-limit.

As a concrete interval region, it is typically near 200 ¢ in size, distinct from the semitone of roughly 100 ¢ and the neutral second of roughly 150 ¢. A rough tuning range for the major second is about 180 to 240 ¢ according to Margo Schulter's theory of interval regions.

This article covers intervals between 160 and 260 ¢. The outer range of this might be too extreme to call "major seconds", but this is done so that one can find what they're looking for easily.

In just intonation

By prime limit

The Pythagorean (3-limit) major second is 9/8, which is 204 cents in size and corresponds to the MOS-based interval category of the diatonic major second. It is generated by stacking two just perfect fifths of 3/2. There is also a Pythagorean diminished third of 65536/59049, which is about 180 cents in size. While called a "third", it is within the range of major seconds.

Other major seconds exist in higher limits, however, for example:

  • The 5-limit ptolemaic major second is a ratio of 10/9, however in 5-limit harmony it is used alongside 9/8. It is about 182 cents.
  • The 7-limit (septimal) supermajor second is a ratio of 8/7, and is about 231 cents.
  • The 11-limit (undecimal) submajor second is a ratio of 11/10, and is about 165 cents.
  • The 13-limit (tridecimal) ultramajor second is a ratio of 15/13, and is about 248 cents, but it might be better analyzed as an inframinor third. Despite that, it is also here for completeness.

By delta

See Delta-N ratio.

Delta-1 Delta-2 Delta-3
8/7 231 ¢ 15/13 248 ¢ 22/19 253 ¢
9/8 204 ¢ 17/15 217 ¢ 23/20 242 ¢
10/9 182 ¢ 19/17 193 ¢ 25/22 221 ¢
11/10 165 ¢ 21/19 173 ¢ 26/23 212 ¢
28/25 196 ¢
29/26 189 ¢
31/28 176 ¢
32/29 170 ¢

In EDOs

The following table lists the best tuning of 10/9, 9/8, and 8/7, as well as other major seconds if present, in various significant EDOs.

EDO 10/9 9/8 8/7 Other major seconds
5 240c
7 171c
12 200c
15 160c 240c
16 * 225c
17 212c
19 189c 253c
22 164c 218c
24 200c 250c
25 192c 240c
26 185c 231c
27 178c 222c
29 166c 207c 248c
31 194c 232c
34 176c 212c 247c
41 176c 205c 234c
53 181c 204c 226c 249c ≈ 15/13

In regular temperaments

The three simplest major second ratios are 10/9, 9/8, and 8/7. The following notable temperaments are generated by them:

Temperaments generated by 8/7

  • Slendric, where a stack of three 8/7s is equated to 3/2
  • Semaphore, where a stack of two 8/7s is equated to 4/3

Temperaments generated by 9/8

Temperaments generated by 10/9

Other major second temperaments

  • Didacus, where the septimal tritone 7/5 is split in three, with 1\3ed7/5 being the generator 28/25 and 2\3ed7/5 being 5/4.
Icon-Todo.png Todo: complete list

In moment-of-symmetry scales

Being a small interval, major seconds generate a number of monosmall and monolarge MOSes.

These tables start from the last monolarge MOS generated by the interval range.

MOSes with more than 12 notes are not included.

Range MOS
150–171 ¢ 1L 6s 7L 1s
171–200 ¢ 1L 5s 6L 1s
200–218 ¢ 1L 4s 5L 1s 6L 5s
218–240 ¢ 5L 6s
240–267 ¢ 1L 3s 4L 1s 5L 4s


VTEInterval regions
Seconds and thirds Comma and diesisSemitoneNeutral secondMajor second • (Interseptimal second-third) • Minor thirdNeutral thirdMajor third
Fourths and fifths (Interseptimal third-fourth) • Perfect fourth • (Semiaugmented fourth) • Tritone • (Semidiminished fifth) • Perfect fifth • (Interseptimal fifth-sixth)
Sixths and sevenths Minor sixthNeutral sixthMajor sixth • (Interseptimal sixth-seventh) • Minor seventhNeutral seventhMajor seventhOctave