Telicity: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 27: | Line 27: | ||
Because F is not a linear function, it does not satisfy any of the conditions above. So even though rounding sometimes gives us better approximations, it doesn't conserve interval interval arithmetic, and conserving interval arithmetic is why we care about RTT in the first place. | Because F is not a linear function, it does not satisfy any of the conditions above. So even though rounding sometimes gives us better approximations, it doesn't conserve interval interval arithmetic, and conserving interval arithmetic is why we care about RTT in the first place. | ||
However, people who care about ''both'' good approximations ''and'' conserving interval arithmetic are seemingly presented with a dilemma- either go with a linear map and risk bad approximations, or go with a non-linear map and risk inconsistent interval arithmetic. This is why telicity is useful- when one is able to work with the section of the EDO's harmonic lattice in which both mapping methods lead to the same result and limit the harmonic lattice to this section through means of '''harmonic lattice resets''' one has the best of both worlds, hence why telicity is defined by equation val(N)⋅monzo(r) = round(N⋅log2(r)). | However, people who care about ''both'' good approximations ''and'' conserving interval arithmetic are seemingly presented with a dilemma- either go with a linear map and risk bad approximations, or go with a non-linear map and risk inconsistent interval arithmetic. This is why telicity is useful- when one is able to work with the section of the EDO's harmonic lattice in which both mapping methods lead to the same result and limit the harmonic lattice to this section through means of the '''harmonic lattice resets''' established especially by forms of telicity involving the [[equave]] one has the best of both worlds, hence why telicity is defined by equation val(N)⋅monzo(r) = round(N⋅log2(r)). | ||
== Telicity | == Integer and Rational Telicity == | ||
[[Harmonics]], and especially primes, are fairly simple as both [[equave]]s and [[generator]]s when it comes to telicity, and since all of these interval ratios are integers, this type of telicity can be referred to specifically as '''integer telicity'''. However, when the equave and or the generator are a combination of primes, things are more complicated, leading to the broader term '''rational telicity''' as a descriptor for this second type of telicity. | |||
== Telicity Type Designations == | == Telicity Type Designations == | ||
| Line 42: | Line 40: | ||
While the telicity of EDOs with, say, 3-2 telicity and only a single circle of fifths, is independent, properly accounting for the same type of telicity in EDOs with multiple circles of fifths is another story, and for that, we need to work with telicity that is '''k-Strong'''. k-Strong telicity is k times as strict as normal telicity, which is to say that for any two generating intervals A and B, A^n * B^m for nonzero integers n,m should by patent val consistently be mapped to the right interval in both N EDO and kN EDO so that the error is less than 50%/k of a step in N EDO, which is to say the error is less than 1\(2kN). Note that this also requires that the mapping for intervals A and B in kN EDO should be the same as the mapping for them in N EDO, and that it requires all the other things needed for telicity by default. Using this, we can see that 12edo is a 2-strong 3-2 telic system and 53edo is a 3-strong 3-2 telic system. | While the telicity of EDOs with, say, 3-2 telicity and only a single circle of fifths, is independent, properly accounting for the same type of telicity in EDOs with multiple circles of fifths is another story, and for that, we need to work with telicity that is '''k-Strong'''. k-Strong telicity is k times as strict as normal telicity, which is to say that for any two generating intervals A and B, A^n * B^m for nonzero integers n,m should by patent val consistently be mapped to the right interval in both N EDO and kN EDO so that the error is less than 50%/k of a step in N EDO, which is to say the error is less than 1\(2kN). Note that this also requires that the mapping for intervals A and B in kN EDO should be the same as the mapping for them in N EDO, and that it requires all the other things needed for telicity by default. Using this, we can see that 12edo is a 2-strong 3-2 telic system and 53edo is a 3-strong 3-2 telic system. | ||
== Telicity on Subgroups == | == Telicity on Subgroups == | ||
| Line 51: | Line 45: | ||
There is a yet weaker - but not unuseful - notion of telicity on subgroups, where every generator can be considered as a node in a graph, and every telic connection can be considered as an edge in that graph. Then the model of the subgroup that the rank one temperament provides is said to have '''connective telicity''' if the graph is connected, meaning every generator in that subgroup can be related to every other generator directly or indirectly through a path of telic connections to other generators. Then, if every one of those telic connections is k-strong, it is said to have '''k-strong connective telicity'''. (Having '''connective telicity''' is defined as having "1-strong connective telicity".) Analogously, a model of a subgroup may have "k-strong connective telicity" except for exactly '''n''' pairs of generators that do not have a k-strong telic connection, but which demonstrate 1-strong connective telicity with respect to the subgroup nonetheless. Then the subgroup demonstrates '''n-weak k-strong connective telicity'''. | There is a yet weaker - but not unuseful - notion of telicity on subgroups, where every generator can be considered as a node in a graph, and every telic connection can be considered as an edge in that graph. Then the model of the subgroup that the rank one temperament provides is said to have '''connective telicity''' if the graph is connected, meaning every generator in that subgroup can be related to every other generator directly or indirectly through a path of telic connections to other generators. Then, if every one of those telic connections is k-strong, it is said to have '''k-strong connective telicity'''. (Having '''connective telicity''' is defined as having "1-strong connective telicity".) Analogously, a model of a subgroup may have "k-strong connective telicity" except for exactly '''n''' pairs of generators that do not have a k-strong telic connection, but which demonstrate 1-strong connective telicity with respect to the subgroup nonetheless. Then the subgroup demonstrates '''n-weak k-strong connective telicity'''. | ||
== Telicity Range and Usable EDO Sizes == | |||
Each telic comma has a numerical range in which it can possibly be telic, that is, a '''telicity range'''. The size of a comma's telicity range is inversely correlated to the size of the comma itself – that is, the smaller the comma in question, the larger the size of that comma's telicity range. The size of a comma's telicity range is evaluated by comparing the size of a given equal temperament's step with the size of the comma in question – if the comma is more than half the size of the equal temperament's step, said equal temperament is outside the comma's telicity range. For example, in EDO systems, [[81/80]] has a telicity range of 27, as 27 is the largest EDO with a step size that is more than twice the size of the comma, while [[Mercator's comma]] has a telicity range of 165, as 165 is the largest EDO with a step size that is more that twice the size of that comma. In addition, the concept of telicity can be used to evaluate the usefulness of EDOs relative to the [http://musictheory.zentral.zone/huntsystem2.html#2 JND] of human pitch perception, and, since an interval smaller than 3.5 cents is unlikely to be noticed by even the most trained listeners, it can be said that the JND has a telicity range of 171, meaning that EDOs that are higher than [[171edo|171]] are not all that suitable for use as musical systems outside of pitch bends. | |||
It should also be noted that while the tempering of a given comma that is larger than half a step in a given equal temperament can sometimes be accomplished to join primes without either prime exceeding the 50% relative error threshold in said equal temperament, the fact remains that the equal temperament in question lies outside the comma's telicity range. Thus, such a phenomenon in relation to telicity is analyzed as being a result of the equal temperament in question tempering out two or more commas that actually do meet the strict criteria requirements, and thus, having two or more forms of the same type of telicity. As an example, 31edo tempers out 81/80, which is larger than half of this EDO's step size, but this can be attributed to 31edo tempering out both the [[Würschmidt comma]] (393216/390625) and the [[Semicomma]] (2109375/2097152), with the former equating an octave-reduced chain of eight [[5/4]] intervals with [[3/2]], and the latter equating an octave-reduced chain of seven 5/4 intervals with [[32/27]], while both commas additionally satisfy the equation for telicity on account of being less than half an EDO-step in size. | |||
== Applications == | == Applications == | ||