Equal-step tuning: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
|||
| Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
When a tuning is called "n-tone equal temperament" (abbreviated n-tET or n-ET), this usually means "n divisions of 2/1, the octave, or some approximation thereof" but it also implies a mindset of [[Regular Temperaments|temperament]]—that is, of a harmony-centric, JI-approximation-based understanding of the scale. If you are wondering how equal divisions of the octave can become associated with temperaments, the page [[EDOs to ETs]] may help clarify. | When a tuning is called "n-tone equal temperament" (abbreviated n-tET or n-ET), this usually means "n divisions of 2/1, the octave, or some approximation thereof" but it also implies a mindset of [[Regular Temperaments|temperament]]—that is, of a harmony-centric, JI-approximation-based understanding of the scale. If you are wondering how equal divisions of the octave can become associated with temperaments, the page [[EDOs to ETs]] may help clarify. | ||
There are many reasons why one might choose to not consider JI approximations when dealing with equal tunings, and thus not treat equal tunings as temperaments. In such case, the less theory-laden term ''EDO''(occasionally written ED2), meaning "equal divisions of the octave" (or "equal divisions of 2/1"), leaves comparison to JI out of the picture, aside from the octave itself (which is assumed to be Just). There are other less standard terms, many in the [http://www.tonalsoft.com/enc/encyclopedia.aspx Tonalsoft Encyclopedia]. More generally, the term ''EDn'' can be used, where n is any harmonic of the harmonic series. For example, the equal-tempered Bohlen-Pierce scale may also be referred to as 13-ED3, for 13 equal divisions of 3/1 (the 3rd harmonic). | There are many reasons why one might choose to not consider JI approximations when dealing with equal tunings, and thus not treat equal tunings as temperaments. In such case, the less theory-laden term ''EDO'' (occasionally written ED2), meaning "equal divisions of the octave" (or "equal divisions of 2/1"), leaves comparison to JI out of the picture, aside from the octave itself (which is assumed to be Just). There are other less standard terms, many in the [http://www.tonalsoft.com/enc/encyclopedia.aspx Tonalsoft Encyclopedia]. More generally, the term ''EDn'' can be used, where n is any harmonic of the harmonic series. For example, the equal-tempered Bohlen-Pierce scale may also be referred to as 13-ED3, for 13 equal divisions of 3/1 (the 3rd harmonic). | ||
'''As the steps are tuned to be equal, equal scales may be taken to close anywhere composers wish them to.''' Barring the convention of closing equal divisions of particular just intervals at those stated just intervals, there are infinite synonymous names for each equal scale. Barring further the large number of names which would be avoided in discourses on comparative modality and tonality, there is still a a great width to the universe of modes and keys which modal and tonal compositional art can access. | '''As the steps are tuned to be equal, equal scales may be taken to close anywhere composers wish them to.''' Barring the convention of closing equal divisions of particular just intervals at those stated just intervals, there are infinite synonymous names for each equal scale. Barring further the large number of names which would be avoided in discourses on comparative modality and tonality, there is still a a great width to the universe of modes and keys which modal and tonal compositional art can access. | ||
| Line 11: | Line 11: | ||
'''As there are infinite intervals, there are infinite equal scales.''' Barring technicalities, there are large quantities of perceivably different equal scales. Seeing such a diverse menagerie at their disposal, some composers choose to combine multiple equal tunings [[ET_surveys|sequentially]] or [[Polymicrotonality|simultaneously]]. | '''As there are infinite intervals, there are infinite equal scales.''' Barring technicalities, there are large quantities of perceivably different equal scales. Seeing such a diverse menagerie at their disposal, some composers choose to combine multiple equal tunings [[ET_surveys|sequentially]] or [[Polymicrotonality|simultaneously]]. | ||
== Simultaneous equal divisions == | ==Simultaneous equal divisions== | ||
What do | What do 12ED2, 19ED3, and 28ED5 all have in common? They're all approximately the same scale. This happens because 12ED2 is an accurate temperament (for its size) that contains relatively close approximations of 3/1 and 5/1. In contrast, 11ED2 does not correspond closely to any equal division of 3/1 or 5/1. | ||
The following plot shows equal divisions of 2/1, 3/1, 5/1, and 7/1, and points out some instances when three or more of them happen to be close together. Note that any equal division of 2/1 is automatically an equal division of 4/1; and if something is simultaneously a good equal division of both 2/1 and 3/1, then it's a good equal division of 6/1 as well. | The following plot shows equal divisions of 2/1, 3/1, 5/1, and 7/1, and points out some instances when three or more of them happen to be close together. Note that any equal division of 2/1 is automatically an equal division of 4/1; and if something is simultaneously a good equal division of both 2/1 and 3/1, then it's a good equal division of 6/1 as well. | ||
| Line 22: | Line 22: | ||
For the mathematically inclined, this kind of diagram is closely related to [[The_Riemann_Zeta_Function_and_Tuning|the Riemann zeta function]]. | For the mathematically inclined, this kind of diagram is closely related to [[The_Riemann_Zeta_Function_and_Tuning|the Riemann zeta function]]. | ||
== Gallery of equal divisions == | ==Gallery of equal divisions== | ||
===[[EdVI through edX|…of sixths through tenths]]=== | ===[[EdVI through edX|…of sixths through tenths]]=== | ||
* [[EdVI|'''<big>…of sixths (e. g. 5/3 and 11/7)</big>''']] | * [[EdVI|'''<big>…of sixths (e. g. 5/3 and 11/7)</big>''']] | ||
| Line 44: | Line 44: | ||
* '''<big>[[EdXIX|…of nineteenths (e. g. 6/1)]]</big>''' | * '''<big>[[EdXIX|…of nineteenths (e. g. 6/1)]]</big>''' | ||
** [[Ed6|'''<big>...of the hexatave (6/1)</big>''']] | ** [[Ed6|'''<big>...of the hexatave (6/1)</big>''']] | ||
* [[Ed7|'''<big>...of the 7th Natural (7/1)</big>''']] | * [[Ed7|'''<big>...of the 7th Natural (7/1)</big>''']] | ||
* [[Ed8|'''<big>...of the Triple Octave (8/1)</big>''']] | * [[Ed8|'''<big>...of the Triple Octave (8/1)</big>''']] | ||
* [[Ed9|'''<big>...of the Double Tritave (9/1)</big>''']] | * [[Ed9|'''<big>...of the Double Tritave (9/1)</big>''']] | ||
* [[Ed10|'''<big>...of the Just Major 24th (10/1)</big>''']] | * [[Ed10|'''<big>...of the Just Major 24th (10/1)</big>''']] | ||
* [[Ed11|'''<big>...of the 11th Natural (11/1)</big>''']] | * [[Ed11|'''<big>...of the 11th Natural (11/1)</big>''']] | ||
| Line 85: | Line 81: | ||
===[[Equal divisions of the whole tone|...of whole tones (e. g. 8/7, 9/8, and 10/9)]]=== | ===[[Equal divisions of the whole tone|...of whole tones (e. g. 8/7, 9/8, and 10/9)]]=== | ||
* '''<big>...of the Septimal Whole Tone (8/7)</big>''' | |||
** 5 - [[5ed8/7|Fifth root of 8/7]] | |||
* '''<big>...of the Pythagorean Whole Tone (9/8)</big>''' | * '''<big>...of the Pythagorean Whole Tone (9/8)</big>''' | ||
** 9 - [[9ed9/8|Ninth root of 9/8]] | ** 9 - [[9ed9/8|Ninth root of 9/8]] | ||
| Line 92: | Line 90: | ||
** 8 - [[Delta scale]] | ** 8 - [[Delta scale]] | ||
== Equal multiplications == | ==Equal multiplications== | ||
=== ...of a given cents value === | === ...of a given cents value === | ||
* [[88cET]] | * [[88cET]] | ||
| Line 116: | Line 114: | ||
** [[22/21s equal temperament]] - multiples of [[22/21]] | ** [[22/21s equal temperament]] - multiples of [[22/21]] | ||
** [[25/24s equal temperament]] - multiples of [[25/24]] | ** [[25/24s equal temperament]] - multiples of [[25/24]] | ||
== See also == | ==See also== | ||
* [[Edo anatomy]] | * [[Edo anatomy]] | ||
* [[Macrotonal edos]] | * [[Macrotonal edos]] | ||
* [[Maximal evenness]] | * [[Maximal evenness]] | ||
* [[Toctave]] | * [[Toctave]] | ||
* [[The Riemann Zeta Function and Tuning]] | * [[The Riemann Zeta Function and Tuning]] | ||
[[Category:Equal-step tuning| ]] <!-- main article --> | |||
[[Category:Tuning]] | [[Category:Tuning]] | ||
[[Category:Temperament]] | [[Category:Temperament]] | ||
Revision as of 17:04, 2 March 2019
In an equal-step tuning, the distance between adjacent steps is of constant size. The size of this single step is given explicitly (e.g. 88 cent equal temperament) or as a fraction of a larger interval (e.g. 13 equal tones per octave). Any interval, rational, Just, or irrational, may be used as the basis for an equal tuning, although divisions of the octave are most common leading to EDO systems. When a just interval is equally divided, it is assumed none of the resulting intervals are just, because if the interval has a rational root it is seen as a division of that root.
When a tuning is called "n-tone equal temperament" (abbreviated n-tET or n-ET), this usually means "n divisions of 2/1, the octave, or some approximation thereof" but it also implies a mindset of temperament—that is, of a harmony-centric, JI-approximation-based understanding of the scale. If you are wondering how equal divisions of the octave can become associated with temperaments, the page EDOs to ETs may help clarify.
There are many reasons why one might choose to not consider JI approximations when dealing with equal tunings, and thus not treat equal tunings as temperaments. In such case, the less theory-laden term EDO (occasionally written ED2), meaning "equal divisions of the octave" (or "equal divisions of 2/1"), leaves comparison to JI out of the picture, aside from the octave itself (which is assumed to be Just). There are other less standard terms, many in the Tonalsoft Encyclopedia. More generally, the term EDn can be used, where n is any harmonic of the harmonic series. For example, the equal-tempered Bohlen-Pierce scale may also be referred to as 13-ED3, for 13 equal divisions of 3/1 (the 3rd harmonic).
As the steps are tuned to be equal, equal scales may be taken to close anywhere composers wish them to. Barring the convention of closing equal divisions of particular just intervals at those stated just intervals, there are infinite synonymous names for each equal scale. Barring further the large number of names which would be avoided in discourses on comparative modality and tonality, there is still a a great width to the universe of modes and keys which modal and tonal compositional art can access.
As there are infinite intervals, there are infinite equal scales. Barring technicalities, there are large quantities of perceivably different equal scales. Seeing such a diverse menagerie at their disposal, some composers choose to combine multiple equal tunings sequentially or simultaneously.
Simultaneous equal divisions
What do 12ED2, 19ED3, and 28ED5 all have in common? They're all approximately the same scale. This happens because 12ED2 is an accurate temperament (for its size) that contains relatively close approximations of 3/1 and 5/1. In contrast, 11ED2 does not correspond closely to any equal division of 3/1 or 5/1.
The following plot shows equal divisions of 2/1, 3/1, 5/1, and 7/1, and points out some instances when three or more of them happen to be close together. Note that any equal division of 2/1 is automatically an equal division of 4/1; and if something is simultaneously a good equal division of both 2/1 and 3/1, then it's a good equal division of 6/1 as well.
(Unlimited resolution version: equal.svg)
For the mathematically inclined, this kind of diagram is closely related to the Riemann zeta function.
Gallery of equal divisions
…of sixths through tenths
by far the most widespread ones
…of elevenths and beyond
- …of elevenths (e. g. 8/3)
- …of twelfths (e. g. 3/1)
- ...of the Tritave/Triple (3/1)
- most famously the BP scale, but lots of others, too
- ...of the Tritave/Triple (3/1)
- …of thirteenths (e. g. 10/3)
- …of fourteenths (e. g. 7/2)
- ...of the Double Octave (4/1)
- …of sixteenths (e. g. 9/2)
- …of seventeenths (e. g. 5/1)
- …of eighteenths (e. g. 11/2)
- …of nineteenths (e. g. 6/1)
- ...of the 7th Natural (7/1)
- ...of the Triple Octave (8/1)
- ...of the Double Tritave (9/1)
- ...of the Just Major 24th (10/1)
- ...of the 11th Natural (11/1)
- ...of the Just Perfect 26th (12/1)
- ...of the 13th Natural (13/1)
...of fifths (e. g. 3/2 and 13/9)
- ...of the Perfect Fifth (3/2)
- most famously Carlos Alpha, Beta and Gamma, but lots of others, too
- ...of the Tridecimal High Tritone (13/9)
- ...of the Septimal High Tritone (10/7)
...of fourths (e. g. 4/3 and 15/11)
- ...of the Perfect Fourth (4/3)
- 3 - Cube Root of 4/3
- 9 - 'Noleta' Scale
- ...of the Septimal Narrow Tritone (7/5)
- ...of the Undecimal Semiaugmented Fourth (15/11)
- ...of the Tridecimal Ultramajor Third (13/10)
...of thirds (e. g. 9/7, 5/4, 11/9, and 6/5)
- ...of the Just Major Third (5/4)
- 2 - Square Root of 5/4
- 3 - Cube Root of 5/4
- 4 - Fourth Root of 5/4
- 5 - Fifth Root of 5/4
- 6 - Sixth Root of 5/4
- 7 - Seventh Root of 5/4
...of whole tones (e. g. 8/7, 9/8, and 10/9)
- ...of the Septimal Whole Tone (8/7)
- ...of the Pythagorean Whole Tone (9/8)
...of semitones (e. g. 15/14, 16/15, and 25/24)
- ...of the Classic Diatonic Semitone (16/15)
- 8 - Delta scale
Equal multiplications
...of a given cents value
...of various whole tones
- ...of true whole tones
- 8/7ths equal temperament - multiples of 8/7
- 9/8ths equal temperament - multiples of 9/8
- 10/9ths equal temperament - multiples of 10/9
- ...of wolf whole tones
- 11/10ths equal temperament - multiples of 11/10
- 12/11ths equal temperament - multiples of 12/11
- 13/12ths equal temperament - multiples of 13/12
...of various semitones
- ...of diatonic semitones
- 14/13ths equal temperament - multiples of 14/13
- 15/14ths equal temperament - multiples of 15/14
- 16/15ths equal temperament - multiples of 16/15
- ...of chromatic semitones
- 21/20s equal temperament - multiples of 21/20
- 22/21s equal temperament - multiples of 22/21
- 25/24s equal temperament - multiples of 25/24