Neji: Difference between revisions

Godtone (talk | contribs)
m Approaches to neji construction: add clarificatory info about a subtlety to do with when a neji is a detemper or not
Godtone (talk | contribs)
Approaches to neji construction: offered alternative to using the proposed/new term "harmodal neji" that fits colloquial usage more closely
Line 33: Line 33:


===== Harmodal nejis =====
===== Harmodal nejis =====
If the target scale has a [[period]] equal to some positive integer harmonic (like the [[octave]], [[tritave]] or [[pentave]]), a fitting name for this type of neji is a "harmodal neji", a contraction of "harmonic modal neji". This period is typically an octave, as that's the most common usecase.
If the target scale has a [[period]] equal to some positive integer harmonic (like the [[octave]], [[tritave]] or [[pentave]]), a fitting name for this type of neji is a "harmodal neji", a contraction of "harmonic modal neji". This period is typically an octave, as that's the most common usecase. '''This term is new, however; it was proposed to resolve an ambiguity in the stand-alone term "neji"''', therefore please see the directly below alternative, which may be preferred for consistency/"backwards-compatibility".
 
===== Nonharmodal nejis =====
An alternative to using the term "harmodal nejis" is to ''assume'' that a "neji" is harmodal ''by default'', and instead specify that a neji is "''nonharmodal''" only when necessary, in order to preserve the colloquial usage of the term "neji". This is consistent with the sentiment that there does not need to be a new term "harmodal neji" while retaining clarity.


=== Building edo nejis ===
=== Building edo nejis ===