Neji: Difference between revisions

BudjarnLambeth (talk | contribs)
m BudjarnLambeth moved page Nejis and nemis to Neji over redirect: Moved back to neji. The future of the page's content is still being discussed on Discord but there appears to be agreement that it should be titled "neji"
Inthar (talk | contribs)
Removed "nemi" and added a section describing approaches to neji construction.
Line 5: Line 5:
| ja =  
| ja =  
}}
}}
A '''neji''' or '''NEJI''' (pronounced /nɛdʒi/ "nedgy"; for "near-equal [[just intonation]]") is a [[circulating temperament]] which approximates an [[Equal-step tuning|equal tuning]] dividing a JI [[equave]] into JI scale steps.
A '''neji''' or '''NEJI''' (pronounced /nɛdʒi/ "nedgy"; for "near-equal/equivalent [[just intonation]]") is a JI scale that approximates a given (usually non-JI) scale by dividing a JI [[equave]] into JI scale steps. A neji that approximates an edo is thus a [[circulating temperament]] for that edo.
 
Due to the influence of Zhea Erose who originated the term, in colloquial usage ''neji'' often specifically refers to a subset of a chosen mode of the [[harmonic series]] used to approximate an edo or another non-JI scale. To express this sense more literally, the following term has been coined: A '''nemi''' or '''NEMI''' (near-equivalent modal intonation) is a scale which approximates some non-JI scale by dividing a JI equave with a subset of a mode of the harmonic series chosen beforehand. The term ''neji'' may informally be used for nemis, e.g. "neji Lydian".
 
Nejis and nemis are both defined via intention rather than (wholly) via mathematical definition. For both nejis and nemis, "near-equal/equivalent" is fuzzy; for nemis, any periodic JI scale is a subset of some (possibly very high) harmonic series segment, making "subset of some harmonic segment" mathematically trivial.
 
== In primodality ==
In [[Zhea Erose]]'s [[primodality]] theory, edo nemis can be used to explore a prime family (see [[primodality]]), while keeping the transposability, scale structures, rank-2 harmonic theory, notation, etc. associated with that edo. (The edo nemi's denominator need not be prime but primes may be preferred for sake of minimizing lower-complexity intervals. Zhea often uses semiprimes ''pq''.) Zhea Erose's theory also deals with modulations between different prime families, and combining different prime families into one scale.


== History ==
== History ==
The concept behind nemi is probably first proposed by [[George Secor]] in 2002<ref>[http://www.anaphoria.com/secor-blarney.html GEORGE SECOR - A BIT O' BLARNEY]</ref>, where he called it a '''quasi-equal rational tuning'''.  
The concept behind nejis is probably first proposed by [[George Secor]] in 2002<ref>[http://www.anaphoria.com/secor-blarney.html GEORGE SECOR - A BIT O' BLARNEY]</ref>, where he called it a '''quasi-equal rational tuning'''.  


The idea has also been suggested by [[Paul Erlich]] and a feature to produce them has existed in [[Scala]] for generating them since some time in the 1990's.
The idea has also been suggested by [[Paul Erlich]] and a feature to produce them has existed in [[Scala]] for generating them since some time in the 1990's.


The term ''neji'' was coined by Zhea Erose. The term ''nemi'' was coined by [[User:Godtone]]; it is intended to be more faithful to the usual sense in which the term ''neji'' came to be used.
The term ''neji'' was coined by Zhea Erose.


== Versus detempering ==
== Approaches to neji construction ==
Nejis are a superset of both [[detempering]] and edo nemis. Unlike detempering, a neji or a nemi need not imply a [[mapping]].  
=== In primodality ===
In [[Zhea Erose]]'s [[primodality]] theory, nejis can be used to explore a prime family (see [[primodality]]), while keeping the transposability, scale structures, rank-2 harmonic theory, notation, etc. associated with that edo. (The neji's denominator need not be prime but primes may be preferred for sake of minimizing lower-complexity intervals. Zhea often uses semiprimes ''pq''.) Zhea Erose's theory also deals with modulations between different prime families, and combining different prime families into one scale.


As noted above, nemis entail a specific process of the rational pitch replacements all being selected from a harmonic series mode that is chosen at will by the scale maker. This is not compulsory for detempered edos or nejis in general.
=== Detempering ===
A more structural, lattice-based approach is [[detempering]]. Detempering entails that the neji has the property of being [[epimorphic]] (obeys a mapping logic under some val) with respect to a temperament for a tempered scale, equal-division or otherwise.


Nejis and nemis are compatible with [[regular temperament theory]] if they are treated as working in the concrete tuning layer of temperaments.
=== Harmodal nejis ===
One might choose a low harmonic series mode and selecg notes therefrom in order to build an edo neji with extra concordance. Such a neji can be described as a "harmodal neji", from "harmonic mode".


== Building edo nemis ==
This distinction is more process-based than formalized, in that the pool of intervals is chosen to be some mode m::2m, before notes are selected from it. This is hecause any JI scale occurs as some (possibly very high) harmonic series segment.
It's possible to create a working edo nemi by simply approximating an edo as closely as possible with selected harmonics. However, it is sometimes preferable to build particular aesthetic choices into a nemi. One such common choice is to focus on a few intervals in the edo being "nemified" which are of particular interest. The root harmonic is then selected to approximate these intervals of interest as well as possible; the remaining harmonics to fill in the rest of the edo are chosen based on their ability to fit well with the existing notes.
=== Building edo nejis ===
It's possible to create a working harmodal edo neji by simply approximating an edo as closely as possible with selected harmonics from a mode. However, it is sometimes preferable to build particular aesthetic choices into such a neji. One such common choice is to focus on a few intervals in the edo being "nejified" which are of particular interest. The root harmonic is then selected to approximate these intervals of interest as well as possible; the remaining harmonics to fill in the rest of the edo are chosen based on their ability to fit well with the existing notes.


== See also ==
== See also ==