Hobbit: Difference between revisions

No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 7: Line 7:
To create a hobbit scale, we need to find the interval of least complexity in the regular temperament corresponding to each step of the equal temperament. The measure of complexity to be used is the "[[Tenney-Euclidean metrics #Octave-equivalent TE seminorm|octave equivalent Tenney-Euclidean seminorm]]", or OETES, here denoted T(x) where x is an interval. The OETES complexity of any comma of the temperament, and also of the octave, is 0, encoding [[Equivalence vs. tempering|the tempering of the commas and octave-equivalence]]. Note that this means that any given pitch class relative to the unison has a corresponding OETES complexity shared between all of its representative intervals, and additionally, that T(x) and T(2/x) are the same, where x and 2/x are octave complements.
To create a hobbit scale, we need to find the interval of least complexity in the regular temperament corresponding to each step of the equal temperament. The measure of complexity to be used is the "[[Tenney-Euclidean metrics #Octave-equivalent TE seminorm|octave equivalent Tenney-Euclidean seminorm]]", or OETES, here denoted T(x) where x is an interval. The OETES complexity of any comma of the temperament, and also of the octave, is 0, encoding [[Equivalence vs. tempering|the tempering of the commas and octave-equivalence]]. Note that this means that any given pitch class relative to the unison has a corresponding OETES complexity shared between all of its representative intervals, and additionally, that T(x) and T(2/x) are the same, where x and 2/x are octave complements.


For each step within the octave in the equal temperament, we choose the simplest interval (by OETES complexity) in the temperament within the octave that maps to the scale step. For an edo with an odd number of notes, this process is unambiguous. However, when an edo is even and thus contains the perfect [[semioctave]], there is an ambiguity, and there are multiple options for the hobbit, differing by the central interval (this is similar to how 12-note Pythagorean tuning has no perfectly symmetrical mode; either the narrow or sharp tritone must be chosen).   
For an edo with an odd number of notes, the selection of notes is unambiguous. However, when an edo is even and thus contains the perfect [[semioctave]], there is an ambiguity, and there are multiple options for the hobbit, differing by the central interval (this is similar to how 12-note Pythagorean tuning has no perfectly symmetrical mode; either the narrow or sharp tritone must be chosen).   


The intervals selected by this process are a [[transversal]] of the scale, and we may now apply the chosen tuning to the monzos in the transversal, obtaining values (in cents or fractional monzos) defining a scale. The monzos in the transversal are defined only modulo the commas of the temperament, but since these are tempered out this does not affect the definition of the scale.
The intervals selected by this process are a [[transversal]] of the scale, and we may now apply the chosen tuning to the monzos in the transversal, obtaining values (in cents or fractional monzos) defining a scale. The monzos in the transversal are defined only modulo the commas of the temperament, but since these are tempered out this does not affect the definition of the scale.