User:Eufalesio/Harmonic Segments Along Fifths: Difference between revisions

Eufalesio (talk | contribs)
Final touches
Eufalesio (talk | contribs)
Ready to delete as it has been published into main space
 
(12 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
Harmonic Segments Along Fifths (HSA5) are a type of [[periodic scale]] devised by [[Eufalesio]], built by taking a specific [[harmonic series]] segment that ends in 4/3 and repeating times 3/2. They are a unique mix of [[tetrachord]]<nowiki/>s and [[overtone scales]] that exhibit [[omnitetrachordality]] to some extent, and a type of [[NEJI]] (Near-equivalent Just Intonation). How to approach them musically is not within the scope of this article.
{{Delete|If main article is to be kept, this is no longer necessary.}}
 
Harmonic Segments Along Fifths (HSAF) [sing. ''a Harmonic Segment along Fifths''] are a type of octave-[[periodic scale]] built by taking a specific [[harmonic series segment]] that ends in 4/3 and repeating times 3/2. They are a unique mix of [[tetrachord]]<nowiki/>s and [[overtone scales]] that exhibit [[omnitetrachordality]] to some extent, and a type of [[NEJI]] (Near-equivalent Just Intonation).


== Definitions ==
== Definitions ==
For a scale to be a HSA5, it must satisfy the following:
For a scale to be a HSAF, it must satisfy the following:


* Its [[period]] is always the octave.
* Its [[period]] is the octave.
* Its prime mode always contains [[4/3]] and 3/2.
* Its prime mode always contains 4/3 and 3/2.
* Its prime mode is built like a harmonic series segment up to 4/3, and that same harmonic segment repeats from 3/2 onwards.
* Its prime mode is built like a harmonic series segment up to 4/3, and that same harmonic segment is repeated transposed by 3/2 until it reaches the octave.
* HSAF 1 is 6:8:9:12 with [[delta signature]] +2,+1,+2. Except for HSAF 1, its delta signature is +2,+2,+2,+2,[…],+3,+3,+3,[…]. If the HSAF is even-indexed, the +3's start right at 3/2. If the HSAF is odd-indexed, at the step right before 3/2.


These scales require the harmonic segment to start with a threeven number and end with that number times 4/3, so HSA5 are a countable set of scales, and thus can be indexed. Because they are formed from harmonic series segments, all except the first are are chiral scales, whose counterparts are built from [[subharmonic series]] segments.
These scales require the harmonic segment to start with a threeven number and end with that number times 4/3, so HSAFs are a countable set of scales, and thus can be indexed.


== Properties ==
== Properties ==
Except the first, the harmonic segments conforming HSA5s up to the 13th are [[strictly proper]] [[constant structure]]<nowiki/>s.


The HSA5s beyond the 3rd will have noticeable gaps between 4/3 and 3/2. An HSA5 is said to need extensions if the smallest step of the harmonic series segment is smaller than (9/8)<sup>2/3</sup> and this can be done two ways:
* Harmonic segments conforming HSAFs up to the 13th* are [[strictly proper]] [[constant structure]]<nowiki/>s.
* HSAF k is a subset of the 6k::12k harmonic segment.
* HSAF k contains harmonics k–2k as a subset.
* Because they are formed from harmonic series segments, they are chiral scales*, whose left-handed counterparts are built from [[subharmonic series]] segments. The left-handed versions are '''not''' HSAFs per se. They are only the chiral version of the HSAF, which you might call a SSAF, for Subharmonic Segment [...].
 
<nowiki>*</nowiki>except the first


* Insert intervals within the subgroup of the harmonic segment (Subgroup-extended HSA5) [seHSA5] so that the step variety is minimized. This is an arbitrary choice that depends on the HSA5.
Simple HSAFs can be visualized as edo or MOS detempers for simple HSAFs, which makes them particularly useful either for NEJI targets or essential tempering.  
* Extend the main harmonic segment beyond 4/3 (Harmonically-extended HSA5) [heHSA5] until the segment between 4/3 and 3/2 has fairly well spaced steps. When the HSA5s is even, this is trivial.


Extensions are fairly arbitrary and not an absolute necessity, so the use of one over the other is not something that is entirely justifiable; it is as much as an artistic choice as the choice of HSA5 itself.
== List of HSAFs 1-8 ==
For every provided HSAF, the [[EFR]] and used segment are written out explicitly. Names in italic are names never seen before on the wiki, declared here for specificity.


== List of HSA5s ==
=== HSAF/SSAF 1 - Pythagorean Trial ===
<code>6:8:9:12</code>. Harmonic segment: '''3:4'''.


=== HSA5 1 - Pythagorean Trial ===
First meaningful HSAF albeit a trivial case, and the only HSAF that is also a [[MOS scale]] ([[2L 1s]]), and thus [[achiral]].
'''3::4'''. First meaningful HSA5 albeit a trivial case, and the only HSA5 that is also a [[MOS scale]] ([[2L 1s]]), and thus [[achiral]].
{| class="wikitable"
{| class="wikitable"
!4/3
!4/3
Line 36: Line 43:
|}
|}


=== HSA5 2 - ''Zontatonic'' ===
=== HSAF 2 - Septimal minor pentatonic ===
'''6::8'''. It is the first usable HSA5, the first prime HSA5, and the only one that is [[Strict variety]] 3 and a [[generator sequence]]. It is naturally a [[5edo]] detemper in the [[2.3.7 subgroup]], or otherwise an [[archy]] detemper, [[2L 3s]] 3|1 scale.
<code>12:14:16:18:21:24</code>. Harmonic segment: '''6::8'''.  
 
First usable HSAF, the first prime HSAF, and the only one that is [[Strict variety]] 3 and a [[generator sequence]].
 
It is naturally a [[5edo]] detemper in the [[2.3.7 subgroup]], and either a semaphore ([[1L 4s]] 2|2) or [[archy]] detemper ([[2L 3s]] 3|1).
{| class="wikitable" data-darkreader-inline-color=""
{| class="wikitable" data-darkreader-inline-color=""
!7/6
!7/6
Line 66: Line 77:
|}
|}


=== HSA5 3 - ''Íegmul'' ===
=== HSAF 3 ===
'''9::12'''. It is the second prime HSA5, and the last one to not need extensions. It is naturally a [[7edo]] detemper in the [[2.3.5.11 subgroup]], or otherwise a [[dicot]]/[[mothra]] detemper, [[3L 4s]] 5|1 #6 scale. (1-indexed).
<code>18:20:22:24:27:30:33:36</code>. Harmonic segment: '''9::12'''.  
 
Second prime HSAF. It is naturally a [[7edo]] detemper in the [[2.3.5.11 subgroup]], and either a [[porcupine]] ([[1L 6s]] 3|3) or [[dicot]]/[[mothra]] detemper ([[3L 4s]] 5|1 #5).  
{| class="wikitable" data-darkreader-inline-color=""
{| class="wikitable" data-darkreader-inline-color=""
!'''10/9'''
!'''10/9'''
Line 120: Line 133:
|}
|}


=== HSA5 4 - ''Ngwóoghe'' ===
=== HSAF 4 ===
'''12::16'''. It is first composite HSA5, containing the 2nd as a subset, and the first one to need extensions. It is naturally a [[10edo]] or detemper in the [[2.3.5.7.13 subgroup]], or otherwise a [[negri]] detemper, [[1L 8s]] 4|4 scale. The only valid heSAH5 is [[17/12]]. Reasonable seHSA5s include 7/5, 13/9, 45/32.
<code>24:26:28:30:32:34:36:39:42:45:48</code>. Harmonic segment: '''12::16'''.
 
First composite HSAF, containing HSAF 2 as a subset. It is naturally a [[10edo]] detemper in the [[2.3.5.7.13 subgroup]], a [[negri]] detemper ([[1L 8s]] 4|4) if you exclude 17/12, and a [[pajarous]] detemper, 2L 8s 6|2 #7 scale.
{| class="wikitable" data-darkreader-inline-color=""
{| class="wikitable" data-darkreader-inline-color=""
! colspan="9" |HSA5 4
! colspan="10" |heHSA5 4
|-
|-
!13/12
!7/6
!5/4
!4/3
!3/2
!13/8
!7/4
!15/8
! rowspan="9" |2
!'''13/12'''
!'''13/12'''
!'''7/6'''
!'''7/6'''
!'''5/4'''
!'''5/4'''
!'''4/3'''
!'''4/3'''
!'''''17/12'''''
!'''17/12'''
!'''3/2'''
!'''3/2'''
!'''13/8'''
!'''13/8'''
Line 149: Line 153:
|<small>15/13</small>
|<small>15/13</small>
|<small>16/13</small>
|<small>16/13</small>
|<small>17/13</small>
|<small>18/13</small>
|<small>18/13</small>
|<small>3/2</small>
|<small>21/13</small>
|<small>45/26</small>
|<small>24/13</small>
|<small>14/13</small>
|<small>15/13</small>
|<small>16/13</small>
|<small>17/13</small>
|<small>''18/13''</small>
|<small>3/2</small>
|<small>3/2</small>
|<small>21/13</small>
|<small>21/13</small>
Line 166: Line 162:
|<small>15/14</small>
|<small>15/14</small>
|<small>8/7</small>
|<small>8/7</small>
|<small>17/14</small>
|<small>9/7</small>
|<small>9/7</small>
|<small>39/28</small>
|<small>39/28</small>
|<small>3/2</small>
|<small>45/28</small>
|<small>12/7</small>
|<small>13/7</small>
|<small>15/14</small>
|<small>8/7</small>
|<small>17/14</small>
|<small>9/7</small>
|<small>''39/28''</small>
|<small>3/2</small>
|<small>3/2</small>
|<small>45/28</small>
|<small>45/28</small>
Line 183: Line 171:
|-
|-
|<small>16/15</small>
|<small>16/15</small>
|<small>17/15</small>
|<small>6/5</small>
|<small>6/5</small>
|<small>13/10</small>
|<small>13/10</small>
|<small>7/5</small>
|<small>7/5</small>
|<small>3/2</small>
|<small>8/5</small>
|<small>26/15</small>
|<small>28/15</small>
|<small>16/15</small>
|<small>17/15</small>
|<small>6/5</small>
|<small>13/10</small>
|<small>''7/5''</small>
|<small>3/2</small>
|<small>3/2</small>
|<small>8/5</small>
|<small>8/5</small>
Line 200: Line 180:
|<small>28/15</small>
|<small>28/15</small>
|-
|-
|<small>17/16</small>
|<small>9/8</small>
|<small>9/8</small>
|<small>39/32</small>
|<small>39/32</small>
|<small>21/16</small>
|<small>21/16</small>
|<small>45/32</small>
|<small>45/32</small>
|<small>3/2</small>
|<small>13/8</small>
|<small>7/4</small>
|<small>15/8</small>
|<small>17/16</small>
|<small>9/8</small>
|<small>39/32</small>
|<small>21/16</small>
|<small>''45/32''</small>
|<small>3/2</small>
|<small>3/2</small>
|<small>13/8</small>
|<small>13/8</small>
Line 218: Line 190:
|<small>15/8</small>
|<small>15/8</small>
|-
|-
|<small>13/12</small>
|<small>7/6</small>
|<small>5/4</small>
|<small>4/3</small>
|<small>13/9</small>
|<small>14/9</small>
|<small>5/3</small>
|<small>16/9</small>
|<small>18/17</small>
|<small>18/17</small>
|<small>39/34</small>
|<small>39/34</small>
|<small>21/17</small>
|<small>21/17</small>
|<small>45/34</small>
|<small>45/34</small>
|<small>''24/17''</small>
|<small>24/17</small>
|<small>26/17</small>
|<small>26/17</small>
|<small>28/17</small>
|<small>28/17</small>
Line 236: Line 200:
|<small>32/17</small>
|<small>32/17</small>
|-
|-
|<small>14/13</small>
|<small>15/13</small>
|<small>16/13</small>
|<small>4/3</small>
|<small>56/39</small>
|<small>20/13</small>
|<small>64/39</small>
|<small>24/13</small>
|<small>13/12</small>
|<small>13/12</small>
|<small>7/6</small>
|<small>7/6</small>
|<small>5/4</small>
|<small>5/4</small>
|<small>4/3</small>
|<small>4/3</small>
|<small>''13/9''</small>
|<small>13/9</small>
|<small>14/9</small>
|<small>14/9</small>
|<small>5/3</small>
|<small>5/3</small>
Line 254: Line 210:
|<small>17/9</small>
|<small>17/9</small>
|-
|-
|<small>15/14</small>
|<small>8/7</small>
|<small>26/21</small>
|<small>4/3</small>
|<small>10/7</small>
|<small>32/21</small>
|<small>12/7</small>
|<small>13/7</small>
|<small>14/13</small>
|<small>14/13</small>
|<small>15/13</small>
|<small>15/13</small>
|<small>16/13</small>
|<small>16/13</small>
|<small>4/3</small>
|<small>4/3</small>
|<small>''56/39''</small>
|<small>56/39</small>
|<small>20/13</small>
|<small>20/13</small>
|<small>64/39</small>
|<small>64/39</small>
Line 272: Line 220:
|<small>24/13</small>
|<small>24/13</small>
|-
|-
|<small>16/15</small>
|<small>52/45</small>
|<small>56/45</small>
|<small>4/3</small>
|<small>64/45</small>
|<small>8/5</small>
|<small>26/15</small>
|<small>28/15</small>
|<small>15/14</small>
|<small>15/14</small>
|<small>8/7</small>
|<small>8/7</small>
|<small>26/21</small>
|<small>26/21</small>
|<small>4/3</small>
|<small>4/3</small>
|<small>''10/7''</small>
|<small>10/7</small>
|<small>32/21</small>
|<small>32/21</small>
|<small>34/21</small>
|<small>34/21</small>
Line 290: Line 230:
|<small>13/7</small>
|<small>13/7</small>
|-
|-
| colspan="9" |
|<small>16/15</small>
|<small>16/15</small>
|<small>52/45</small>
|<small>52/45</small>
|<small>56/45</small>
|<small>56/45</small>
|<small>4/3</small>
|<small>4/3</small>
|<small>''64/45''</small>
|<small>64/45</small>
|<small>68/45</small>
|<small>68/45</small>
|<small>8/5</small>
|<small>8/5</small>
Line 302: Line 241:
|}
|}


=== HSA5 5 ===
=== HSAF 5 ===
'''15::20'''. It is the third prime HSA5, and the first HSA5 not to be a constant structure without extensions. It is naturally a very close [[12edo]] detemper in the [[2.3.5.17.19 subgroup]]. The only valid heSAH5 is with [[7/5]]. A very natural and reasonable seHSA5 is 17/12, which fits almost perfectly inside 4/3 and 3/2, though other usable seHSA5 is 64/45.
<code>30:32:34:36:38:40:42:45:48:51:54:57:60</code>. Harmonic segment: '''12::16'''.
 
'''15::20'''. It is the third prime HSAF. Its extension is naturally a very close [[12edo]] detemper in the [[2.3.5.17.19 subgroup]], and a [[diaschismic]] detemper ([[10L 2s]] 8|2 b4) scale.
{| class="wikitable"
{| class="wikitable"
! colspan="12" |heHSA5 5
|-
|-
!16/15
!16/15
Line 447: Line 387:
|<small>80/57</small>
|<small>80/57</small>
|<small>28/19</small>
|<small>28/19</small>
|<small>30/19</small>
|<small>32/19</small>
|<small>34/19</small>
|<small>36/19</small>
|-
! colspan="12" |seHSA5 5 (17/12)
|-
!16/15
!17/15
!6/5
!19/15
!4/3
!17/12
!3/2
!8/5
!17/10
!9/5
!19/10
! rowspan="12" |2
|-
|<small>17/16</small>
|<small>9/8</small>
|<small>19/16</small>
|<small>5/4</small>
|<small>85/64</small>
|<small>45/32</small>
|<small>3/2</small>
|<small>51/32</small>
|<small>27/16</small>
|<small>57/32</small>
|<small>15/8</small>
|-
|<small>18/17</small>
|<small>19/17</small>
|<small>20/17</small>
|<small>5/4</small>
|<small>45/34</small>
|<small>24/17</small>
|<small>3/2</small>
|<small>27/17</small>
|<small>57/34</small>
|<small>30/17</small>
|<small>32/17</small>
|-
|<small>19/18</small>
|<small>10/9</small>
|<small>85/72</small>
|<small>5/4</small>
|<small>4/3</small>
|<small>17/12</small>
|<small>3/2</small>
|<small>19/12</small>
|<small>5/3</small>
|<small>16/9</small>
|<small>17/9</small>
|-
|<small>20/19</small>
|<small>85/76</small>
|<small>45/38</small>
|<small>24/19</small>
|<small>51/38</small>
|<small>27/19</small>
|<small>3/2</small>
|<small>30/19</small>
|<small>32/19</small>
|<small>34/19</small>
|<small>36/19</small>
|-
|<small>17/16</small>
|<small>9/8</small>
|<small>6/5</small>
|<small>51/40</small>
|<small>27/20</small>
|<small>57/40</small>
|<small>3/2</small>
|<small>8/5</small>
|<small>17/10</small>
|<small>9/5</small>
|<small>19/10</small>
|-
|<small>18/17</small>
|<small>96/85</small>
|<small>6/5</small>
|<small>108/85</small>
|<small>114/85</small>
|<small>24/17</small>
|<small>128/85</small>
|<small>8/5</small>
|<small>144/85</small>
|<small>152/85</small>
|<small>32/17</small>
|-
|<small>16/15</small>
|<small>17/15</small>
|<small>6/5</small>
|<small>19/15</small>
|<small>4/3</small>
|<small>64/45</small>
|<small>68/45</small>
|<small>8/5</small>
|<small>76/45</small>
|<small>16/9</small>
|<small>17/9</small>
|-
|<small>17/16</small>
|<small>9/8</small>
|<small>19/16</small>
|<small>5/4</small>
|<small>4/3</small>
|<small>17/12</small>
|<small>3/2</small>
|<small>19/12</small>
|<small>5/3</small>
|<small>85/48</small>
|<small>15/8</small>
|-
|<small>18/17</small>
|<small>19/17</small>
|<small>20/17</small>
|<small>64/51</small>
|<small>4/3</small>
|<small>24/17</small>
|<small>76/51</small>
|<small>80/51</small>
|<small>5/3</small>
|<small>30/17</small>
|<small>32/17</small>
|-
|<small>19/18</small>
|<small>10/9</small>
|<small>32/27</small>
|<small>34/27</small>
|<small>4/3</small>
|<small>38/27</small>
|<small>40/27</small>
|<small>85/54</small>
|<small>5/3</small>
|<small>16/9</small>
|<small>17/9</small>
|-
|<small>20/19</small>
|<small>64/57</small>
|<small>68/57</small>
|<small>24/19</small>
|<small>4/3</small>
|<small>80/57</small>
|<small>85/57</small>
|<small>30/19</small>
|<small>30/19</small>
|<small>32/19</small>
|<small>32/19</small>
Line 600: Line 393:
|}
|}


=== HSA5 6 ===
=== HSAF 6 ===
'''18::24.''' It is the last HSA5 to be a constant structure without extensions. It is a [[15edo]] detemper in the 2.3.5.7.11.19.23 subgroup.
<code>36:38:40:42:44:46:48:50:52:54:57:60:63:66:69:72</code>. Harmonic segment: '''18::24'''.
 
Last HSAF to be a constant structure, and first HSAF to contain two different (non-1) HSAFs as subsets. It is a [[15edo]] detemper in the 2.3.5.7.11.19.23 subgroup, and [[nautilus]] detemper ([[1L 12s]] 6|6 and [[14L 1s]] 6|8).
{| class="wikitable"
{| class="wikitable"
! colspan="15" |heHSA5 6
|-
|-
!19/18
!19/18
Line 832: Line 626:
|}
|}


=== HSA5 7 ===
=== HSAF 7 ===
'''21::28'''. The fourth prime HSA5. The most reasonable heHSA5 with 29/21 and 10/7 contains 7::14 as a subset. It is naturally a 17edo detemper in the no-17,19-29-limit subgroup. Its chiral version is surprisingly a subharmonic interpolation of HSA5 3.
<code>42:44:46:48:50:52:54:56:58:60:63:66:69:72:75:78:81:84</code>'''.''' Harmonic segment: '''21::28'''.  
 
The fourth prime HSAF. SSAF 7 is surprisingly a subharmonic interpolation of HSAF 3. It is naturally a [[17edo]] detemper in the no-5,17,19,add-25-29-limit subgroup, surfacing as a strange liese extension detemper ([[2L 15s]] 15|1 10b).  
{| class="wikitable"
{| class="wikitable"
! colspan="17" |heHSA5 7
|-
|-
!22/21
!22/21
Line 853: Line 648:
!13/7
!13/7
!27/14
!27/14
| rowspan="17" |2
! rowspan="17" |2
|-
|-
|<small>23/22</small>
|<small>23/22</small>
Line 1,128: Line 923:
|}
|}


=== HSA5 8 ===
=== HSAF 8 ===
'''24::32.''' It contains HSA5 2, HSA5 4 and [[8afdo]] as subsets. As a superset of HSA5 4, it adds many new interesting intervals with odds 9, 11, 15, 21, 25, 29, 31, 35. It is not an easy edo detemper, just a harmonic interpolation of HSA5 4 in the 2.3.5.7.13.29.31 subgroup, with additions of 11 and 17 with the heHSA5.
<code>48:50:52:54:56:58:60:62:64:66:68:70:72:75:78:81:84:87:90:93:96</code>. Harmonic segment: '''24::32.'''
 
It contains HSAF 2 and HSAF 4. As a superset of HSAF 4, it adds many new interesting intervals with odds 9, 11, 15, 21, 25, 29, 31, 35 along its modes. It is also the last HSAF to fit within the [[31-limit]].
 
The raw scale or its extension could be seen as a [[wilsec]] detemper (negri weak extension) [[19L 1s]] 10|9, but it is a very innacurate realization that only [[19edo]] through patent val can faithfully represent (albeit badly as it tempers together 17/12 and 35/24). Thus, it's better seen as just a linear interpolation of HSAF 4 in the 2.3.5.7.11.13.17.29.31 subgroup.
{| class="wikitable"
{| class="wikitable"
! colspan="20" |heHSA5 8
|-
|-
!25/24
!25/24
Line 1,152: Line 950:
!15/8
!15/8
!31/16
!31/16
| rowspan="20" |2
! rowspan="20" |2
|-
|-
|<small>26/25</small>
|<small>26/25</small>
Line 1,535: Line 1,333:
|}
|}


== Beyond HSA5 8 ==
== Beyond HSAF 8 ==
There are infinite HSA5s as stated before, but HSA5s grow increasingly more complex in prime palette and in interval count the more times the fourth is split. As such, we present here only the first 8 HSA5s as their palettes fit within the [[31-limit]].
There are infinite HSAFs as stated before, but HSAFs grow increasingly more complex in prime palette and in interval count the more times the fourth is split. As such, we present here only the first 8 HSAFs as their palettes fit within the 31-limit.