Hobbled scale: Difference between revisions

Pailiaq (talk | contribs)
Pailiaq (talk | contribs)
Line 49: Line 49:
=== Dual Fifth Systems ===
=== Dual Fifth Systems ===
It lends particular well for dual fifth systems, as a hobbled scale will have two different interval types for every scale step, and thus sound less 'wrong' when hearing inconsistency in interval quality.
It lends particular well for dual fifth systems, as a hobbled scale will have two different interval types for every scale step, and thus sound less 'wrong' when hearing inconsistency in interval quality.
== Examples and Discoveries ==
=== 18-EDO Hobbled Lydian ===
18-EDO provides an interesting case study for hobbled scales, particularly with lydian patterns. The scale 3-3-3-2-3-3-1 creates an effectively hobbled lydian where one of the short steps has been reduced. This scale exploits the fact that 18-EDO shares the same wholetone (200¢) as 12-EDO, since both are supersets of 6-EDO.
The first half of this hobbled lydian scale is identical to 12-EDO lydian, preserving the quintessential dreamy wholetone character. However, the second half becomes distinctly alien with a sharp 733¢ fifth, a just 12/7 sixth (933¢), and a smaller leading tone. This creates a scale that starts familiar but ventures into bright, colorful territory that regular lydian cannot access.
This pattern can also be viewed as a hobbled 17-EDO or 19-EDO diatonic, demonstrating how hobbling can bridge between different EDOs and give a useful lens to understand scales.